I think they have the best pizza. I ordered a few slices one was the florentine and other a veggie something. The lady at the counter was a doll. Excellent customer service is hard to come by. I was thoroughly impressed!! So sweet! Completed the experience when I heard her conversing with the chef in Italian. The pizza was crisp and perfect in every way. I'll definitely be back. I'll be back for a slice anytime I'm in Dunedin. Thanks so much! read more

tasty Italian Pizza. very consistent quality, good ingredients and they always deliver to you expectations.

The pizza was not good at all the half of the pizza was uncooked and did not have a lot of flavor and took 25 minutes even though there were just 5 people in there .I went to another tony pizza place but it was the same. Totally not going ever again just Domino's pizza place. read more

Pizza was great as well as the price Small seating area but pizza was 10/10. Sold by slice or whole pie.

As a New Yorker who loves pizza I am impressed. Enjoyed the slices very much. No cheap ingredients read more

Busy, busy, busy- but we'll worth the wait! Always a family favorite when walking around downtown. We love supporting a family owned local business!! read more

Great pizza, friendly service , and very very fast . We highly recommend , we had the meat lovers

We love Tony's in Dunedin! This is our go to pizza place when we also have a lot of family over or in town! Always hot and fresh!

We came to Dunedin for a day trip from Safety Harbor. Being a transplanted New Yorker, I saw a sign for NY style pizza and had to try. I am always skeptical of NY style pizza outside of NY but I was impressed. I had a Sicilian slice which is more rare to find outside of NY. The crust is light and airy but crispy on the bottom, the way a Sicilian should be. The sauce and cheese are on point and brought back memories of my childhood. Excellent! read more

Excellent gluten free pizza. I order extra garlic and well done crust and they don't disappoint.

Here's the deal wood oven ,27toppings Buffalo motzeralla marazino tomatoes Yes they all have their place Tony's has nice of these Tony's has what us almost impossible to find outside of nyny Walk in grab a fresh slice Reheated to perfection correct crust cheese and sauce Perfetto Can't wait to go back read more

Placed an order Nov 1st for pickup to be paid in cash, which it was and now today Nov 4th there is a charge for it on my credit card. And thus ends my relationship with Tony's and ordering through Yelp. read more

The key here is to stay the hell away from the joint when the bars are closing because it's a shitshow! During regular daytime hours, this place is calm and mild-mannered in comparison to the rambunctious and raucous 2-3 AM crowd. So if you enjoy good NY style pizzer and wanna enjoy it in peace, then heed my word. Tony's serves us proper slices from a yuuuge 18" pie, the way it outta be. Nothing worse than these so-called NY style pizzerias out here serving slices from 16" pies. That shit is wack, son. Enough on that though. My favorite feature is that they use Grande cheese, which for the one or two Yelp stalkers I have know, is very important. How do I know? Because places who use Grande do not conceal the brand of their cheese. They mount a big-ass Grande Cheese 100 Percenter plaque on their wall for folks like me, who recognize the real shit. Downsides to Tony's? The don't deliver and they bake their pizzas on screens. totally not necessary with Baker's Pride ovens. read more

See all

I was hoping to find a great local pizza spot. The pizza was just "OK". Nothing special. I ordered a slice. It wasn't freshly made to order. The seasoning was lacking and the ratio of sauce and cheese were disappointing. I will try again because it's a local spot and others seem to like it. The customer service could be better. When we go out to enjoy a bite, we hope for a welcoming smile at least. read more

Basic pizza joint but excellent pizza. Lived in NY for over 38 years so had a lot of good pies in my years. In general FL pizza is at best mediocre. Tony's is one of the few exceptions. As good as NY pizza. Many claim that but very few deliver. read more

Being from Brooklyn NY ... Land of the Best Pizza in the world ... Tony's Pizza is truly amongst the Best Top 3 Brooklyn Pizza slices ever ... and imagine that, it's right here in Dunedin. PS: HIGHLY recommend the Eggplant Parmigiana Panini. AWESOME !!! Thank you Tony's Pizza. read more

I must admit, I wasn't expecting much when I walked in. My wife and I purchased six slices. Meat lovers, white sauce, and veggi slices. All were very good! It's a great location with pizza by the slice or you can order a pizza. We will definitely return. Well done! read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

This place makes a really delicious pie! Good char, very crispy and flavorful sauce. The ratios were on point. Surprised to see it rated 6.5 on the Slice App...I'd go solid 7.4...keep up the great work Tony!! read more

Long wait - 45 minutes for a large cheese pizza. Pizza was thin but not much flavor. Green tossed salad was $7.95 (for 2) but only came with one container of salad dressing. Will not return. read more

we went here for dinner and it sucks to say that it wasn't up to our expectations, we were expecting true NY style pizza. the wings were heavily breaded which made it a little uncomfy to munch on. we also ordered the mozzarella sticks which weren't good at all, which sucks cause they're kinda hard to mess up! the marinara sauce was very thin in consistency and didn't taste very great. and the pizza wasn't very good either, the pepperoni tasted more like a perfume, and there wasn't very much sauce to match the cheese and dough ratio of the pizza. hopefully this can help ppl looking for pizza and wings for the night! read more

I ordered pizza from here last night. When I went in to pay for and pick up my pies the young lady at the counter asked me if I had already paid. I said no, to which she replied "sorry it was just shift change so I wasn't sure". Another customer jokingly commented that I should have said I already paid and gotten a free pizza. I said that I was just being honest. I then paid $39.14 for my pizza by credit card. Today I get a phone call from an extremely rude man who said he was calling from Tony's pizza and that I had picked up my pies with out paying. I relayed the story of the night before to him. He proceeded to tell me that I didn't owe $39 but $42 and that I wouldn't be getting so defensive if I had actually paid for it. I asked to speak to the owner who was apparently standing there during this conversation. And finally said it must be a miss understanding. Well to make sure there is no misunderstanding on my part I will post a pic of the receipt at the end of this post. Also he then tried to tell me that I ordered the same exact order today and not yesterday and that it was a man who called. Well, sir... 1. It's not my fault if your employees do not know how much to charge the customer, I don't work there, how am I supposed to know what I owe. I pay what the clerk tells me to pay. 2. Umm, yes, I am getting defensive, you just called and accused me of stealing and did not accept my story that I paid even after I told you that I have the receipt to prove it. 3. How as a business owner do you think it is ok to ever call a client and accuse them of anything. 4. As a business owner how could you stand next to your employee and allow him to speak to a client in such an unprofessional manner. 5. The number I called from and that they called me back in is my cell and I can assure you no one else called from it and ordered the same order the very next day and then proceeded not to pay. So you either have a problem with your system or a problem with your staff being completely incompetent. Again NOT the customers problem. From just glancing at other reviews I can see that this is a on going occurrence at this place. As I am not the only one having been accused of stealing something that they did not. Maybe you should take a long hard look the people you employee so you don't loose anymore customers. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

A step above most places of this genre. I'm from the NYC metro area, and this pie is quite at home on my palate. I ordered two slices of the meatlover's which was fresh out if the oven. Mangia! read more

Good pizza in a prime location for an after drinking fix. I want to give a 3.5 star but since that's not an option... I like the pizza, I really do, but I just like other pizza places better. Nothing wrong here though - a good heart slice from the oven is hard to beat, and super fast to boot! Always good service and friendly banter while we wait. read more

Located in Downtown Dunedin. Walked the main drag. Came back to Tony's in order to get a quick bite. Pizza was very good. It's a small joint. Not much seating. But we did manage to find a seat for 4 in the back. Service was very friendly. read more

Really disappointed tonight! The woman took forever to wait on us. Then when I gave her my card, she said was declined (it most definitely wasn't). She then asked for another form of payment. My husband gave her his card and it magically worked. The same thing happened to the woman behind us. Maybe instead of announcing to the whole restaurant that my card was declined, she should check on the register! Also, our pizza was given to us way ahead of the rest of our to go order. Not interested in coming back! read more

Pretty good white pizza. I recommend it if you're looking for a "lighter" on the stomach pizza.

I live in Tampa now but I will still drive to Dunedin to get Tony's. When you get a whole pie it's super fresh.

Just bought a house in Dunedin. I'm originally from Long Island. Gave Tony's a shot even though the overall rating on Yelp wasn't an excellent one. I got home and loved it. Nice thin crispy crust. Tasty pie. I'm always searching for a great slice resembling NY pizza and I'm happy. Then I look further on Yelp and see that these negative reviews are mainly from people with issues with customer service. I could give a rat's booty about that. I didn't go to charm school either. I'm a truck driver not a ballerina. It's a very busy pizza place, people. They have to pound out the food. I'll be back quite a bit. Thanks. read more

Tiny storefront pizzeria with classic NY style pizza. Prices are super reasonable and this place can't be beat for a quick bite. You can sit in the window and people watch tpurists. Thileir white pizza is sauce less and has ricotta and mozzarella. I like a cheese slice best but would order a white again too. read more

Tony's Pizza - White pizza with ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

We are locals and Tony's is our go-to place. Whether it's a late night slice on the way home from Dunedin bars or a whole pizza for a quick easy dinner, Tony's is reliable, delicious, and valuable. It's somehow always crispy and fresh every time, even upon delivery. Could t recommend Tony's enough! read more

Nice little place. Good pizza & nice choice & selection. Got 5 slices to go & they were ready in under 5 minutes.

Very friendly staff and pizza was great! Was my first time here and they were really friendly especially with their regulars! You don't get this kind of customer service anymore where in from :( read more

Meh. Didn't expect much, wasn't bad wasn't great. The salad was very good sized and the pizza was ok. Not much to say, good people that work there and a cozy little place that also sells pizza by the slices. read more

A few months back I was pretty disappointed to miss out on the Yelp event at Tony's. Well, I just so happened to be in Dunedin a couple weeks ago walking around with family. It was their first time in the area and we had been touring the Tampa Bay area all morning and early afternoon. Needless to say, it was time for some grub. Knowing that there were dozens of places to choose from in the area, I of course went to Yelp. Lo and behold Tony's was just a block away from where we were! No brainer - we dropped in. They had several pizzas on display for those that want to simply drop by and grab a slice. For my group of three, we were interested in one of their small pies that we could split. The workers there were friendly and got right to making our pizza. We grabbed a seat in the back away from the busyness of the front counter. About 15 minutes later our piping hot New York style pizza was at our table ready to be devoured. Overall, the pizza was really dang good. It the perfect combination of cheese, sauce and pepperoni. Naturally, there was a good amount of grease as well thanks to latter. They had parm, hot pepper flakes and Italian seasoning tableside to accompany the 'za. I think most remarkable and noteworthy about the pizza is how each individual slice held up thanks to the sturdy crust. It was tender yet not floppy nor overbaked, allowing for the perfect fold for those more seasoned NY style pizza connoisseurs. For those spending the day in Dunedin, Tony's really is an excellent option to grab some quality pizza without having to sacrifice a large chunk of your day in the FL sunshine. read more

Awesome pizza, Vodka sauce, has gluten free, friendly staff, plenty of parking. Best part, they have great desserts including Zeppoles. Highly recommend! read more

Came here for a quick dinner after getting into town late and this being one of the few places open late. Ordered cheese slices and mozzarella fries. The woman working the front desk was super friendly! The pizza was really good, not greasy. The fries weren't hand cut but they were cooked to order and tasted good to us! Would definitely go back! read more

Annoying loud Shakira Latin music playing. Pizza was flat, hard crust, overcooked. Salad had brown wilted spot. Atmosphere old. read more

They crushed it. Absolutely solid slice of pizza. Fresh tasting ingredient and the crust was so crispy. I haven't had crust like that before and it was a very pleasant surprise. read more

Stopped in for two slices while a big event was going on in downtown. A slice of Pepperoni and a slice of cheese with a bottle of water to go. Service was quick and with in minutes of placing our order two hot and delicious pizza slices were ready. I have to say again, the service at Tony's was super fast even though downtown was packed by the time we ordered. Prime time lunch crowd was gathering tempted by the smell of garlic, melted mozzarella cheese and dough. We took our slices to-go and walked down the street. Stopping at some park benches, we sat down to enjoy our slices of pizza. If I could eat pizza every day, it would be Tony's pizza. They serve their pizza thin crust New York style and we wouldn't have it any other way! Fast and friendly service with awesome New York style pizza, Tony's is the best pizza joint in Dunedin without a doubt! read more

A little slice of heaven in the sister city of Scottish capital Edinburgh. In Dunedin north of Clearwater FL on an evening drive my wife and I ran into this town on out way to Honeymoon Island. Tony's is the perfect slice of NY style pizza with salads that are out of this world. STOP BY TONYS if you're ever anywhere around Tampa Clearwater. read more