We were inadvertently stuck in Florida after a huge blizzard cancelled our flights twice. We decided to make lemonade out of lemons and used the opportunity to explore the other side of Florida. This pizza place was a short distance from Great Wolf Lodge's. It was an hour before closing and there in front of us was a piping hot half pepperoni and half cheese pizza. It just seemed like the strs aligned for us to walk in. Our kids yelled out for a cheese and Hawaiian pizza while we were deciding. The staff happily accommodated us by having a couple slices with ham and pineapple then reheated it in the oven. Jason thoughtfully asked and then proceeded to make the slices smaller for the kids. We also ordered a large Caesar salad with chicken and garlic knots. As my 8 year old described the garlic knots were amazing- perfectly crispy on the top while nice and fluffy inside. The pizza was perfectly thin and crispy but still had a nice chew. Honestly everything just hit the spot after a long couple of days figuring out what to do with our plans. I was do excited about the pizza that I forgot to take a picture before we dove in. Definitely worth checking out. We are based in New England and have had our fair share of pizza in Boston and NYC. This pizza was definitely up there with pizzas in the northeast. The staff were so friendly(I think they were Holly and Jason). Both were accommodating to us and to our kids. There is plenty of parking and it is about a 15 mins drive from Great Wolf Lodge. read more

Tonys NY Pizza - Large Caesar Salad - Italian Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

We stumbled upon Tony's NY Pizza in Naples while we were stuck in Florida due to the blizzard back home in the Northeast -- and honestly, it ended up being one of the highlights of our trip. From the moment we walked in, the service was outstanding. They had a fresh pizza ready for us -- half cheese, half pepperoni -- and it was phenomenal. The flavor was spot on, and the crust had that perfect New York-style crunch on the outside while still being soft and satisfying inside. My son really wanted Hawaiian, and they were more than happy to add a section with those toppings on the side and bake it fresh for him. That kind of flexibility and care -- especially when you're traveling with kids -- really stands out. We also ordered the garlic knots -- and wow. Crispy and golden on top, buttery and melt-in-your-mouth soft in the middle. Absolutely addictive. I had the chance to meet Jason, who clearly takes real pride in what he does. You can tell there's genuine passion behind every pie coming out of that oven. And the blonde lady who served us was fantastic -- incredibly kind, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed for a great meal. The hospitality truly elevated the whole experience. If you're a true pizza person, this place is a must-try. David Portnoy needs to get down here. We'll definitely be back next time we're in Naples. read more

Ordered delivery while staying at Great Wolf Lodge. We had a mishap and the delivery driver only brought half our order on his first trip. The team from Tony's couldn't have handled it better even though it may not have been their fault. They made sure we got the rest of our order, threw in some free garlic knots (delicious) and most importantly fed the driver since he made a second trip. Food was great. Service was better. read more

Tony's NY Style Pizza is fantastic! The moment we walked in, the smell of fresh pizza and garlic rolls had us hooked. Holly gave us sweet, excellent service. The pizza slices were huge with the perfect amount of cheese. Jason's fresh garlic rolls were crispy, perfectly cooked, and not overloaded with garlic like most places. The whole spot has a great, authentic New York vibe. Highly recommend -- we'll definitely be back! read more

My favorite pizza in Naples. Period. The crust was nice and crisp and the sauce was perfect. I took off a star for the service. Staff was a little salty. read more

Amazing pizza and service! Finally REAL NY pizza! Many varieties and love pizza by the slice. read more

Ordered online tonight. Normally our go to pizza when we are at our Naples house. Pizza was good as usual. Service was below par. I understand things happen, but I don't appreciate being lied to about my order. When I arrived, one pizza was ready. The cashier seemed confused as he verified my order. He told me it would be another 10 minutes. When I asked if it was still in the oven, I was told yes. I then watch the pizza guy make my pizza and put it in the oven. No sorry or any offer on the screw up. Lost my business for the rest of the season read more

Good pizza. Female order taker horrible. Had to leave before my order was taken. Ive been a customer for a yeat. Disgraceful service. There are plenty of good pizza places. Terrible service kills a business. Avoid... read more

Great pizzas and lunch special for busy days. Would recommend. Thanks to the team today as I'm posting this!

I have been to 3-4 pizza places in Naples, none of which I would call good much less great. Last week I went to Tony's on Radio in a Publix shopping center. It was very good. The crust was very good, the topping were good and they put a more than fair amount of the toppings on the pizza. It was not greasy and when you picked up a slice it doesn't fall apart. I have tried buying a slice or an entire pie. They both were excellent. So if you like Pizza and you're over near Santa Barbara and Radio give Tony's Pizza a try. It's right next to 5 Guys. I think you will like. read more

We are down from Orlando for a lacrosse tournament and t and went out of our way to try Tonys. Wow was it worth the trip. Maria and Eddie were so friendly and nice. And the pizza....cooked to perfection, nice and crispy just the way we like it. We tried all kinds of slices and had their garlic knots. Highly highly recommend stopping here for some great slices. Order them crispy! read more

The bbq pizza was so dry and nasty . I was so disappointed. Usually the pizza is good! read more

Tonys NY Pizza - It was just so dry and nasty. I was so disappointed because their regular cheese pizza is good. - Italian Near Me - Naples, Florida

We recently moved from Ft Myers to Naples. Discovered Tonys NY Pizza here in Naples. We were happy to find Tony's in Naples because the pizza and other menu items are exactly the same as the Fort Myers Tony. Tony's in Fort Myers opened over a decade ago , located in the Forum near Colonial. A booming business. Tony's in Naples is in the Berkshire shopping center, on Santa Barbara... If you love New York pizza this is the best place! Delicious pizza , subs and salads ! Casual dining and easy take out. read more

Stopped in for pizza, had a plain cheese pie and garlic knots. Everything was delicious. Very good New York style pizza. I would highly recommend read more

Have Lived in Naples for 10 years and was so happy to wander in to the Tony's on Radio Rd. If you like NY-style, it was great. Place was clean, friendly staff. Hats off to Zoe! If I ever were to open a business, she'd be my first call! read more

This is a new piece of joint in the area. We tried it, but it was no different than all the other sub pizza joints. We are from Connecticut and that's where they have real pizza especially in New Haven. read more

We cannot say enough good things about this place. They are so friendly and the food is a high-quality. My personal favorite is the Italian sub but the pizzas are to die for too! Our new favorite corner pizza shop. read more

Best pizza in the area. The dough is excellent . Nice and crispy, true NY style . The lady at counter was very nice too. read more

Dough, sauce, cheese together make a pizza but not necessarily a true NY pizza. The woman at the counter was super friendly and the inside looked really nice and clean. read more

Great Italian NY pizza consistently every time. Always friendly and price is reasonable!!!

great pizza I'm from NY so I know good pizza and this is an authentic place Jason makes the best pizza Holly is hot