Tonys NY Pizza

service was amazing especially my king luis. he needs a raise right now!!! working day and night…read morelike michael jackson!!

My whole family didn't feel well after eating their wings. Also got home and part of my order was…read moremissing.

Luis from wingstop is amazing

See all

IL Primo Pizza and Wings

3.3(37 reviews)

1.4 mi

First time visiting this establishment, I felt the wings and pizza was very good, full of flavor…read moreand priced very well. The service was excellent, Eric took my order, he was nice, kind, friendly and remembered everyone's name in my party of 30 people!!!! You don't get customer service like that anymore! I would definitely return!! My only complaint was the ac was broken- whew it was hot; but the food was so good it didn't matter.

Not worth saying anything. But it's basic, below average and overpriced considering the portions,…read moreit's one and done for me.

Main entrance order first. No waiters.

See all

Pollos Kiky Rotisserie Chicken

4.3(3 reviews)

1.9 mi

It's a little difficult to find as Waze had us in the back area. It's very close to the Winn…read moreDixie. My suggestion is don't use the kiosk to order. It's not correct for price and in Spanish. We ordered at the counter. I used translate. The plates come with rice and chicken. The beans are in a kettle near the counter. The chicken is rotisserie or a wait for fried. Which is good because means it's fresh cooked. We got the rotisserie. It was good. Flavorful. The rice was pretty plain but good. The beans were good. We upgraded and got the platter with beans, rice and fries. The fries were hot and crunchy. The hit was the plantain. Really good. Wanted more of those. The meal for two was 34$ with tip and soft drinks. A little pricy but it was good. The chicken was not steaming hot and the rice was warm not hot. Maybe because the restaurant was really cold.

I ordered a bunch of salteñas for people at work. They were delivered on-time and shortly after…read morethey opened. 100% would recommend. They were definitely some of the best I've had, and that is saying something because in my experience there is usually a slice of boiled egg and an olive in each, but theirs didn't have that. They were still amazing though. I prefer the spicy chicken.

See all

Chicken dinner

Hooters

2.8(97 reviews)

4.1 mi

My twin sis, mom and I were crazing the hooters wings after visiting the beach so we decided to…read morestop by. I did forget the server's name but she was super sweet. We ordered 50 wings, fries and loaded tater tots. Everything was delicious minus the fries. We asked the server to have the kitchen to remake the fries because it was drenched in salt. The server brings us the fries again and it was still drenched in salt. However, everything else was super delicious.

Always pleasant the girls here a so lovely they really cater to your desires I always have. Great…read morelunches here

Philly Cheesesteak

See all

Pizza Hut

2.9(11 reviews)

1.8 mi

The food tasted like a piece of shit and the workers should've been fired for what they're doingread more

Everything was so fresh. Perfect!!! Wings, hot. Pizza, awesome. Fries. Really good.read more

See all

Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen

1.8(139 reviews)

3.0 mi

I had a lovely experience here with my mother. The manager, Mladen, was a pleasure to talk to and…read moreit was fun learning a bit about his life. The food was great as usual--definitely recommend the red beans & mashed potatoes if you haven't tried them yet. The French fries are also . Don't forget to ask for the blackened ranch! The place was clean and open, which made it feel very comfortable. Thank you!

The food was absolutely disgusting. The chicken tenders were old, tougher than bad beef jerky, and…read moretasted like old dirty oil. Fries were ok. Rice beans and rice were pretty skimpy and the biscuits were bricks. Homeless sleeping in the parking lot. I sympathize with them, but even they could probably find better food than this one. I've been to Popeyes all over the Southeast but never one like this.

Sitting area with electric outlets.

Popeyes Sides

See all

Popeyes Strawberry Biscuits

Charleys Cheesesteaks

3.2(5 reviews)

2.0 mi

Awesome food and good service chicken California and strawberry…read more lemon amazing Nice dining aria

The lady working the register is very sweet. Didn't catch her name but every time I come here she…read moretreats me very well. Food is pretty good too.

See all

Little Caesars Pizza

2.3(12 reviews)

1.9 mi

I ordered pizza through Uber Eats, and the driver arrived with only two pizzas instead of my full…read moreorder. I contacted the Little Caesar's location for assistance, but I was told that they do not handle deliveries and that it was my responsibility to figure out how to get the remaining pizzas. This was extremely disappointing and unhelpful customer service. Based on this experience, I will not be ordering from this location again.

I ordered an extra cheese pizza. What I received is disgusting and not edible it's brown you can't…read moreeven see the cheese. It's going straight into the garbage!

Outside entrance

The "pretzel crust"

See all

Papa Johns Pizza

2.4(35 reviews)

1.8 mi

The driver I get frequently is named Baselais and he is very kind and always makes sure the food is…read moretaken care of. You can tell he's good at his job.

Had placed an order and accidentally put the wrong address because it didn't save. called the store…read moreto update the address and was told that I couldnt and was very rudely talked to. I have been going into and order from this place for a very long time and now I feel disrespected

San Giuseppe Pizza

4.6(170 reviews)

6.7 mi

I've been back two times since my initial visit two weeks ago and continue to be impressed by the…read moreamazing flavors of all their slices. In my last two visits I tried the meat lovers, vodka grandma, supreme, and chicken bacon ranch. The quantity of food (loaded with toppings? is impressive and the vodka pizza was the best vodka pizza I've ever tried, no doubt about it. On top of the amazing flavor, texture, and quality of the pizza, the owner and other workers recognized us and treated us like family. Such an incredible place to relax and enjoy quickly served slices. Beyond friendly and humorous gentlemen working at this establishment who truly seem to love what they do. I'm sure I'll be back again soon!

We heard good things about this restaurant and wanted to stop by. This is a small restaurant, you…read morehave to look to see it between other buildings. Although the restaurant is small, the flavor is big! The menu has a good variety of pizza, calzone, salads and even a few subs. The pizza with the cauliflower crust was interesting and so was the Sicilian, but we decided on the usual pepperoni. This was a great choice, the flavors were balanced and the crust is true New York style, both crusty and chewy. It's one of the best pizza crusts I've found in Naples, IMO New York crusts make the best pizza. Service was fast and the staff is great, it's obvious they make a lot of pizzas here and know their stuff. If you like New York style pizza, this is a place to check out.

See more unrecommended reviews

Two tables joined

16" Cheese Pizza Large

See all

Chicken bacon ranch slice

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

104 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Sam L.

201

132

348

7 months ago

We stumbled upon Tony's NY Pizza in Naples while we were stuck in Florida due to the blizzard back home in the Northeast -- and honestly, it ended up being one of the highlights of our trip. From the moment we walked in, the service was outstanding. They had a fresh pizza ready for us -- half cheese, half pepperoni -- and it was phenomenal. The flavor was spot on, and the crust had that perfect New York-style crunch on the outside while still being soft and satisfying inside. My son really wanted Hawaiian, and they were more than happy to add a section with those toppings on the side and bake it fresh for him. That kind of flexibility and care -- especially when you're traveling with kids -- really stands out. We also ordered the garlic knots -- and wow. Crispy and golden on top, buttery and melt-in-your-mouth soft in the middle. Absolutely addictive. I had the chance to meet Jason, who clearly takes real pride in what he does. You can tell there's genuine passion behind every pie coming out of that oven. And the blonde lady who served us was fantastic -- incredibly kind, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed for a great meal. The hospitality truly elevated the whole experience. If you're a true pizza person, this place is a must-try. David Portnoy needs to get down here. We'll definitely be back next time we're in Naples. read more

Patricia W.

9 months ago

i went here January 7th, 2026, and it was genuinely the best pizza ive ever had trust me, there is an abundance of good pizza in florida (surprisingly) but this place was IMMACULATE. the restaurant itself was extremely clean, roomy, and comfortable. it wasn't hot even with the oven being right there. the lady who brought us our pizza, holly, was extremely kind and sociable, and made sure to interact with us any time she walked past :D the experience was completed with nice pricing, like 15 bucks per person for a SIT-DOWN RESTAURANT. i have never paid that little for a sit down restaurant and you absolutely get much more than you pay for :) the pizza was accurate, with huge slices that held their shape. there was a polite amount of grease that never became bothersome or gross, and instead actually made it taste better and prevented it from being dry (p.s. this is annabelle, the kid who was with troy, i just don't have my own account yet) read more

Juan L.

4 months ago

I'm a commercial pilot for United Airlines, and without a doubt, Tony's Pizza in Radio Rd (Naples, Florida) is one of my favorite spots to visit on my days off. Whether I want a bite to eat before heading to the airport or just have some free time, I always make sure to stop by and enjoy some delicious New York-style pizza. I highly recommend the lunch menu if you're looking for something light and tasty; it's also perfect for enjoying an afternoon pizza with my wife and kids during the summer. But the best part is the service: the cooks and servers make every visit a unique and delicious experience, bringing that authentic New York style right here to paradise in Florida. I've been a VIP customer since Tony's first opened in Florida. To everyone who eats at Tony's--and those who haven't been yet--you have to go and see the quality, service, and food for yourselves; it's always a 5-star experience. read more

Tracy T.

2 months ago

The best Pizza in Naples. We tried Tony's Pizza when they first opened on Radio Rd and we were not impressed. We decided to give it another try and what a difference. Jason and Holly turned the restaurant around, the food is amazing and the service is unbelievable. This location is our new date night place to go. Jason makes the best crust I have ever had. We enjoy chatting with Holly and she makes the visit very personal and is a delight. Excellent food and customer service. Rob & Tracy read more

Hernando S.

21 days ago

I had such a nice experience at Tony's NY Pizza on Radio Rd & Santa Barbara! The pizza was absolutely delicious--fresh, hot, and really tasted like authentic New York pizza. What made the visit even more enjoyable was the wonderful service. Holly and Jason were so kind, friendly, and welcoming. They made me feel very comfortable and truly cared about making sure I had a great experience. I'll definitely be coming back. Great pizza, great people, and great service! Highly recommended! read more

Kenneth M.

8 months ago

Tony's pizza is the best.Jason cooks the great pizza and holly serves it up with a smile.Highly recommend place to eat great pizza and more.Very convenient and quick service.Special orders don't upset them,they welcome them.Fresh and delious every time.Located in the Berkshire shopping center.Italian Ny Pizza.Italian Sub.Pizza by the Slice.Stromboli.You name it.Its the place to be if you are hungry and have a craving for great Italian food. Thank you From Teresa and Ken! read more

Joe P.

6 months ago

Coming from an Italian neighborhood in new England, we love our Pizza, so coming down here to Naples Fl of course I want great pizza. I have tried a number of places and FORGET ABOUT IT. Finding Tony's New York Pizza here at Berkshire commons on Radio Rd, the Pizza is FANTASTIC, and the meals are great also. I never bragged about a place before, but because Tony's so good I don't want anyone else to waist their time or money at any other place. read more

Hilary G.

10 months ago

Hi stopped in for a slice, which I appreciate, been there before always great. Holly and Jason super but today I had a slice of Grandma's pie and it's definitely worth a stop. Specialty sold by slice at lunch, amazing crust ,mozzarella base, then striped with marinara and chz. Sorry don't remember the blend but will definitely get again. Also available, because I asked, in a round pie. Try, especially during lunch hours support local. read more

Andy B.

8 months ago

Ordered delivery while staying at Great Wolf Lodge. We had a mishap and the delivery driver only brought half our order on his first trip. The team from Tony's couldn't have handled it better even though it may not have been their fault. They made sure we got the rest of our order, threw in some free garlic knots (delicious) and most importantly fed the driver since he made a second trip. Food was great. Service was better. read more

Chase S.

4 months ago

Tony's NY Style Pizza is fantastic! The moment we walked in, the smell of fresh pizza and garlic rolls had us hooked. Holly gave us sweet, excellent service. The pizza slices were huge with the perfect amount of cheese. Jason's fresh garlic rolls were crispy, perfectly cooked, and not overloaded with garlic like most places. The whole spot has a great, authentic New York vibe. Highly recommend -- we'll definitely be back! read more

Hurnicane T.

7 months ago

Wow! I am a NY style pizza connoisseur and can tell when deviants try and make it authentic but miss the mark. Tony's NY Pizza at least the one one 7335 Radio Rd made it original and the best ever at an affordable price! Jason and Holly really took care of me and family while waiting for phones next door. Felt like family! read more

Joseph B.

9 months ago

I'm from the other coast and I heard the pizza is a MUST HAVE from the locals I had to try a slice !! It was amazing!! It blew me away!! Sooo damn good!!! The server Holly she is so sweet n kind funny too! Jason makes the best pizza around!! Sooo good next time I'm back this way I'll be back for move thanks Holly n Jason read more

TEE H.

1 year ago

The pizza was delicious and perfectly toasted with great flavor. Our server, Hayley, was incredibly friendly and welcoming, and her hospitality made the experience even better. This place has an inviting atmosphere, and after today, it's definitely where I'll be enjoying my pizzas from now on. Highly recommend! read more

Jaime M.

2 months ago

Really great pizza. Jason and Holly were really great people they treated myself and wife and my daughter like family. I have never come to a place with great customer service like my family and I got like tonys pizza on radio rd. thank you so much Jason and holly. Jaime,gina and Valerie read more

Sarina N.

1 year ago

the food was delicious and the service was great! even though they seem short staffed...Holly was running and doing her best to take care of the swarm of customers both in the kitchen and serving up front. If you ask me...I think she deserves a raise to deal with everything she does! read more

Colin S.

7 months ago

I've Been looking for great NY style pizza in Naples for years & finally found it! Tony's on radio & Santa Barbara is the best pizza town. Not only great selection of different pizza but great homemade garlic knots, meatball parm sandwich on homemade breads etc. Luv it! read more

Carly M.

165

6 months ago

Love love love the single slices--especially when ordered well done. The extra crisp gives it that perfect crunch and truly takes me back to classic New York pizza. So good every time! P.S. Holly is awesome--friendly, welcoming, and makes the experience even better. read more

Wendy B.

18 days ago

The best Tony's of all. My family and kids drive in from Fort Myers and Broward just to eat here -- the flavors and the crust are unbeatable. Everything is always fresh. Holly and Jason are fantastic, and the customer service is truly the best. A win‑win every time. read more

Patty M.

8 months ago

Tony's Pizza is my go to spot for a couple of giant slices of pizza on a Friday night. Holly and Jason are the absolute best duo and definitely make sure you get everything you need, with an extra garlic knot on the side! Definitely gonna keep coming back for more read more

Lourdes C.

7 months ago

Fantastic food! Today I had a slice of their BLT pizza, I love healthy choices and this pizza was both healthy and delicious!! The staff is awesome, I got wonderful service from Holly and Jason! If you are ever in Berkshire Commons I highly recomend Tony's Pizza! read more

Tonys NY Pizza - italian - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Naples, Florida Restaurants near Tonys NY Pizza

BEST of Naples, Florida Coffee near Tonys NY Pizza

BEST of Naples, Florida Pizza near Tonys NY Pizza

BEST of Naples, Florida Dinner near Tonys NY Pizza

BEST of Naples, Florida Things to Do near Tonys NY Pizza

BEST of Naples, Florida Desserts near Tonys NY Pizza

BEST of Naples, Florida Parking near Tonys NY Pizza

BEST of Naples, Florida Cocktail Bars near Tonys NY Pizza

BEST of Naples, Florida Shopping near Tonys NY Pizza

BEST of Naples, Florida Movie Theatre near Tonys NY Pizza

Best of Naples

Things to do in Naples

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Tonys NY Pizza also viewed

San Giuseppe Pizza

4.6

(170 reviews)

Fabio's Pizza

4.4

(123 reviews)

Best pizza in Naples. This little mom and pops is my go to lunch. Service is always great. He's…read morealways happy to see you come in.

The Best Pizza in Naples. Nice Family, Mom and Pop. We go there often. They treat every customer…read morelike family.

Grandpa's Pizza

4.3

(246 reviews)

Unparalleled experience! This is the real deal. It's consistently out of this world. We came back…read moreto try the house special, Grandma's pizza this time and it's EXCELLENT. Thin crust, amazing flavors of garlic tomato and the perfect amount of cheese. You feel like family the moment you walk in the door. I can't believe how friendly they are- it's seriously remarkable. We will certainly be back- again and again!

Disappointed…read more Called ahead because I was 45 minutes away and asked them to time the pizza to be ready at that time. They guy who was on phine said it would be ready in about 45 minutes. When I arrived the man suspiciously announced "perfect timing right out of the oven!" I drove 15 minutes to my destination with the pizza that was "right out of the oven" to find totally overcooked pizza nearly burnt and the cheese had already solidified. Top of pizza totally dry. Crust was dry and overcooked. Two of the worse pizzas I have had in a long time. My family agreed and a sibling actually made fun of the leftover slices the next day. I suspect the pizza boxes were sitting on top of the stove for about 30 minutes and they immediately cooked the pizza as soon as I called. It was not busy this was 4pm and no other orders being cooked and underway. No phones ringing. Just me and my $40 waste of money.

Nunzio's Taste Of Italy

4.1

(235 reviews)

Stopped in for lunch and had a great experience…read more The service was attentive, the food was delicious, and the best part... you don't have to break the bank for a good lunch Definitely loving the lunch specials!

I checked out Yelp reviews to find a good Italian/ Pizzeria in the area. Nunzio's did not…read moredisappoint. They have a large menu, including lunch specials. The food was excellent. I had an Eggplant Stromboli and my husband had a Veal Parmigiana Sub. Delicious! It reminded me of the Italian food from Brooklyn. So good! The service was excellent. We were greeted as soon as we came in and were served fairly quickly. The restaurant is clean and the ambiance is that of a pizzeria in New York. Excellent restaurant!

Peppi's Pizzeria

3.9

(143 reviews)

Great little authentic pizzeria, and Italian restaurant family owned. Pizza is thin crust and crisp…read moresauce is phenomenal and the mussels are some of the best I've ever had.

Best Pizza by far in Naples! Been coming here for many years. It never disappoints. The Cadillac…read morepizza is great

New York Pizza & Pasta - Tamiami

3.5

(544 reviews)

New to the area, living close by. We decided to stop in on a weekday night for dinner. 6 PM in…read moreseason, it was busy, but we were able to get a seat for two. Some of the tables are very close to where patrons walk by, so that was a little awkward. Ambience is nice. Better than we expected. It's deceiving from the outside. Nice decor. Bar looks like a good spot. Started with a regular side salad, which was very good, tried out a small cheese pizza, which was pretty good. Very crunchy with minimal flop. Chicken Alfredo was delicious as was the marsala! Big portions, so I was able to take some home. Our only complaint was the service. They were all over the place. Rolling silverware for the first 5-10 min when we were ready to order pretty quickly was frustrating. We asked for extra plates for the pizza and he said he would get them and then never came back. They seemed a bit understaffed/not assigned to specific tables? Hard to put my finger on it, but would definitely try coming back at a slower time. Also, bread service - even if on menu to purchase, would have been great, especially ordering pasta dishes.

Ate here early Thursday evening. Arrived 5 pm, unfortunately happy hour over then. We sat outside,…read morewhich may have been the problem with not attentive service (we started with a female server but after she was MIA, ordered with a male server who was passing our table). Two glasses of Josh Sauvignon Blanc and two dirty martinis. For entrees, the lady ordered Pappardelle Bolognese, liked it, took some home. I ordered Branzino in white wine sauce with penne, good not great. So, overall this place gets 4 stars, misses the mark for excellence.

Detroit Pizza Joint

4.8

(13 reviews)

Run, don't walk!! (Because they sell out!) Yes, it's in a gas station, yes it's fabulous!! Stop in…read moreand say hi to Chef Todd!! You won't regret it!! Ask for the hidden menu item~ pizza bread!! (Shown!) You'll die for the caramelized onions!

Anyone from MI or from the Detroit area must check this place out! Don't judge a book by its cover…read more-- this hidden gem is truly a piece of home. Anyone not from MI or Detroit and wants to know what real authentic Detroit pizza and coney dogs are like -- this is it! Chef Todd, has certainly mastered his craft and the taste of Detroit. He's a one man band, and makes everything fresh daily, so availability is until it sells out. If have a large order, or just want to reserve pizza dough for dinner that night -- make sure call early and place your order. If not -- don't get mad if you show up late and the selections are slim.

Tin City Slice

4.7

(6 reviews)

As someone born and raised in Naples, this has easily become my favorite spot to get pizza…read moreI get the garlic cheese pizza and it's ALWAY amazing!!!! I love the food the people everything 10/10!!!

A legit NY style pizzeria in the Tin City Waterfront Shops that opened on Independance Day last…read moreyear. Discussed pizza with the owner "Craig the Greek" and ordered a slice of cheese pizza with fresh grated Romano cheese sprinkled on top. While waiting for my slice, I browsed the Italian market that offered chips, sauces, meal additives and even an Italian cookbook and a retro wicker picnic basket. This room was extremely detailed and the customization was a nice addition to the small pizzeria. The slice was removed from the oven had a nice light charred crust and "no flop" whatsoever. The added Romano cheese gave it a Kapowy Bam!!! Would have liked a more garlicky sauce kick, but it was still tasty. The $6.00 price for the average sized slice was the highest I have EVER paid...Maybe all the ingredients are imported, not really sure, but either way, all the employees from the Tin City were raving about this eatery. Tin City Pizza offers a rewards program - buy 6 slices get the 7th free.

Tony's NY Pizza

3.8

(88 reviews)

Tonys is an "authentic " NY-style pizzeria located near "the big Publix" on Marco Island. We…read moreordered a couple of their thin crust Pizzas online to feed a group. The pizzas and salad were ready on time when we got there but they overlooked the pizza

We love Tony's when we need a quick & fast, pick me up. We always ordered the slices to go. They…read morehear them up and then you're good to go. Big slices too! Think Costco size but a little smaller. Inside is nothing special. But don't judge the looks from the pizza. We've only ever had their pizza but they do offer way more on their menu. Service is fast and quick. People are kind. Way less crazy than some other pizza spots in town. Way more casual and laid back!

Palumbo's Pizzeria

3.8

(165 reviews)