food is excellent, Tony's a great guy, service is always good, reminds me very much of the small family-owned Italian restaurants I grew up with in South Jersey read more

I went to Tony's Pizza restaurant with my husband on September 12, 2026. I made the mistake of ordering the spaghetti and meatballs instead of pizza. The sauce was completely tasteless and they only gave me 2 and a half tiny meatballs. The meatballs were cut in half, so there were 5 extremely small pieces. What a way to save a buck. the spaghetti was broken in pieces. Any real Italian knows that you don't break the spaghetti when you cook it. The sauce tasted like Ragu. I was incredibly disappointed. read more

Very happy with our visits here pizza is excellent ! Restaurant clean and happy staff. Their entrees are excellent. We enjoy their meatball and eggplant parm sandwiches give it a try. In silo mall Middleburg. Great Chinese restaurant in that mall also. Hidden gems read more

We ordered a small white pizza and a small pepperoni with black olives! The white pizza is a MUST! Crush is airy, crunchy, and garlicy We called in the order and it was ready in the given time frame! read more

Tony’s Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza & White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Florida

Excellent food and service at a good price! The family members that work there are friendly and make you feel at home. Great ambiance and very clean. read more

I love my pizza big,cheesy and greasy!! And the service is amazing as well. And the prices are also gratifying read more

Great pizza! Great vibes! Love the employees! Great place to hangout by yourself or with friends!

This at first caught my eye because i've only seen good reviews... Until i tried it. This pizza was flavorless, had a watery taste to it. I didn't get anything special, just a regular pepperoni pizza. I have to say by far this is the first time i didn't like pizza. This was worse than Dominoes. read more

love this place, always great food and quick service. Food tastes fresh and comes out hot

Best sauce in Jacksonville area. Oh so good ‼ Thats Italian and Sicilian at its best.

Just had the best pizza from here. Friendly fast service! Will definitely be back for more pizza.

We tried Toney's for the first time. I'm an 80 yr old disabled veteran and my wife in her middle 70's is from the Philly area. I had a spaghetti dinner and order my wife a Cheese Steak and we also order a pizza to go. When my wife asked for ketchup for her Cheese steak the waitress said, we don't have ketchup and my wife told her she can't eat the sandwich without ketchup and the waitress asked would you like to exchange it for something my wife said no. The cook was nice and offered us tomato sauce and my wife said no thank you cause I only eat this with ketchup. When we went to pay, the lady said, why didn't you turn it back into the kitchen and I said, isn't that what the waitress does? My wife and I both tasted the sandwich and it was ok for me but I didn't know what a cheese steak tastes like. When the lady looked at our table and said, you ate 1/2 I said no! We both had a taste and the lady said well we will charge you 1/2. The cook, a very nice man said take it home and put ketchup on it and told his wife not to charge us. My wife was so embarrassed as the onlookers made her feel like we were trying to get something for nothing, that was not a good feeling at all especially since we not only ordered dinner and a pizza to go. I felt that they treated us very badly just because my wife couldn't eat the sandwich. What a way to treat two elderly people. We mostly stay home and decided to go out for dinner and this is what we experienced my wife was horrified and embarrassed. read more

Unpretentious family run, friendly and GREAT food at very affordable prices. If you like NY style pizza this is the place for you. They also have a full menu of traditional Italian dishes. read more

The food excellent! The service amazing! The ambiance a comfortable and casual Love my new pizza joint. Reminds me of being up north to grab a couple of slices. Which they do... sell by the slice that is. read more

We had the Sicilian! Great pizza! Tony is from NY, so Tony knows pizza! Try this great place. We plan on returning to try other menu items. You won't be disappointed! read more

Nice small business. Food has always been good, and they are willing to customize the order. My wife loves the stuffed Manicotti, and they are always willing to make it with their Alfredo sauce instead of the marinara. The Stromboli fills the pizza pan, and we always enjoy the garlic knots. read more

Tony’s Pizza - Half of the Stromboli we ordered. - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Florida

See all

Another tasty night! Service was great. Cheese sticks were a disappointment but their pizza makes up for it. read more

See all

Pizza was very great! Service was good. Timing was perfect. They accommodated our last minute large order without hesitation.

What an awesome little place! Great service, super clean and food was hot and came out quickly! read more

See all

Second time here. Had meatball sub for lunch. Excellent. Great sub and great price. Service was wonderful as well. Service with a smile. read more

Tony’s Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Florida

First visit to this truly hidden gem, as it is hidden in a strip mall on 220. Clean and friendly when you walk in, with a very full menu of the usual suspects. Pizza, Calzone, pasta, subs and salads. Had the 18" Meat Lover and it was very good, almost too much topping. It is definitely NY style pie and the crust was almost to Wood Fire quality and thin and crispy. Center was a bit soggy, but it was from the loaded amount of meat and not cheap cheese or greasy meat! Good job read more

Tony’s Pizza - 18" Meat lover - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Florida

The hours on apple map say they close at 10, but when I called for a pick up order at 8:40, they let me know they actually close at 9. I said nvm I didn't want to place an order & do that to them, but they said it was no problem. When showing up, I found out I called the wrong number somehow & they did not mind making me my order. I showed up at 9 & left with my fresh, hot order no later than 9:15. Needless to say, I will only be getting pizza from here from now on read more

Tony’s Pizza - Baked lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Florida

See all

Amazing everything! We got the chicken parm dinner and a calzone. The quality of the food was too notch. You can tell it's homemade and they get high quality chicken and cheese. I'm a little high maintenance when it comes to my chicken but this was great. Pricing was super reasonable and we left with a ton of leftovers. Comfortable, clean dining area. The owners/ staff are wonderful. Support local!! P.S. delicious ice cream place a few doors down! read more

The pizza was really good. The pizza was perfectly cooked on the crust but the middle felt not cooked enough. The atmosphere was very cute, it was like an old times shop. It had music in the background. read more

Tony’s Pizza - Cheese and little bit of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Florida

Called in an order and was quoted 20-25 minutes, it was ready at the 15 minute mark when I walked in. Pizza smelled absolutely heavenly on the ride home, everything was delicious! read more

See all

We ordered a large pizza. It seemed like it was taken out of the oven, had more cheese sprinkled on it, and then not re-baked. It was covered in semi-melted, odd textured, mozzarella cheese. I wouldn't go back. read more

The food is amazing, the attitude of the employees is not. We ordered 2 large pepperoni and cheese pizza to be delivered. They arrived - no pepperoni. I called Back and was told too bad, we only charged you cheese. They did not care, offer to remake, give a credit. Nothing. It's too bad because when it's right - it's good but it's really 50/50 read more

Great food and service! It's our favorite pizza place in Middleburg! Highly recommended.

I havent been out in a while, so my wife and i decided to try a new pizza place closer to home. The place is very clean and i love the decor. We started with the garlic knots. They were great with lots of garlic on them. We had the super supreme pizza for dinner. It was a good size pizza 18". And it was loaded with toppings. It is a very thin crust but very flavor-able . All in all we were happy with this place and will be back. read more

Tony’s Pizza - a half eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Florida

Tony's is great! We have eaten here a few times and the pizzas are really good. They have great lasagna. Good calzones as well. You should also try the garlic knots! read more

See all

Awesome supreme Stromboli, good garlic knots, friendly service, fair pricing, cute place in general.

Perfect place to be on a rainy day (sunny day too)! As soon as I opened the door to go into the restaurant, I was met with delicious smelling aromas of pizza sauce, garlic, and pasta. There were four of us - I had the grilled chicken salad with balsamic vinegar salad dressing and garlic bread, one had the spaghetti and garlic bread lunch special (large tasty portion of spaghetti and she ate it all). The other two had the two slice pizza lunch special with each one's choice of toppings. Lunch special prices very good. Everyone enjoyed their meals and left with full bellies, stating all would be coming back again. Want to try either the lasagna and chicken parmigiana. Til next time! read more

Pizza was great! I got supreme and it didn't disappoint! A nice balance of toppings and cheese. Service was great and appropriately timed considering how busy they are. I will visit again! read more

I think I could eat pizza everyday. I have tried many around jacksonville based on recommendations and the myriad of "Top 10... Top 5" etc. but I keep coming back here as the best crust, sauce and cheese. All three are equally important. Tony doesn't get the hype since he is not in a cute or trendy area, but if you want good pizza he is worth the trip. read more

Mom said the spaghetti sauce was just like hers! There's no better compliment! Thanks everyone at Tony's!

In town for a 50k trail race and wanted pizza for my pre-race meal. Daughter yelped and found Tony's Pizza. What a find. Young lady who waited on us was very attentive and helpful. She recommended the garlic bread with mozzarella and it was . Mozzarella sticks were great along with pizza. Tony was there and he is very interactive with customers which was fun! Will be back when in town. 5 for Tony and 5for daughter for recommendation. read more

I called to place a order since the online doesn't place orders. I ordered a small supreme with Alfredo sauce in place of her mariana, a greek salad, and moterella sticks. I was told 25-30 minutes, so I waited in the parking lot. Never called me ro tell me it was done. Apparently it been done alot sooner than 25-30 minutes cause I waited exactly that. Walked in and no one was at the front area but I heard talking from the back. So I called out for a few minutes waiting saying hello, no one heard me or walked up front. So then I walked around and seen some workers and said hello again, finally a man walked to the front and asked what I ordered and I told him and he went looking and found my sticks in a bag, and found the pizza under 2 others, I asked him if it was a supreme with white sauce and doesn't show me but looks at it, says something I didn't understand. He then started talking to me about my puppers I was holding and I said, she was gonna be eating the meat off the pizza, he opens up the box and takes a pepperoni off with his fingers, trys to feed Queenie, she declines it, then goes and gets a cold pepperoni and trys to feed it to her, she declines it, hands it to me to feed her, she doesn't want it. And a woman walked up and was looking for the rest of my order, she found my salad in a bag. I paid $30 for the meal. Not to bad, but its just me and pup eating it, so kinda high. I was referred to go there by a sweet lady I met walking. She raved how good the food was and the service. I don't get the receipt which I was not happy about since I put those in my fetch app. I didn't ask for one cause the man kept talking to me and got me off track. I still added a tip. And I look at the food when I get in car and the sticks are cold and cheese not melted pulling apart like I was hoping they would be. Just like the frozen kind. Disappointed, the pizza was not the supreme it mentioned. No sausage for Queenie. She wouldn't eat their pepperoni for some reason. So she didn't get anything out of it. The pizza is room temperature. And the salad was not a Greek salad. Had iceberg lettuce which I hate and never eat, not to mention a small portion for a hefty price. So the experience was not a good one. I mean who touches a customers food and without permission. I really should have walked out and left not paying or taking that food with me. Won't be back! read more

Tony’s Pizza - Greek salad that wasn't a greek salad. Not good either. - Pizza Near Me - Middleburg, Florida

See all

I love their pizza!!! We live a little outside their delivery zone, and I am so glad they still deliver to us!

I am giving this 1 star because out of everything at least the staff was pleasant. The food was HORRIBLE! I had the chicken parmigiana and the chicken was one of those frozen hockey picks that you buy in the freezer section of the grocery store. There was no flavor or seasoning at all. My husband got a calzone and it had no flavor either and the ham and pepperoni was the cheap nasty stuff. Also the soft drinks were $3.00 and you have to pay $1.00 for refills! I don't know who is giving this place 4 & 5 stars but I would give it 1/2 of a star. Save your money and go somewhere better. read more

This is our number one favorite pizza place in the area. The sauce is really flavorful and yummy. They deliver. They have good options if you're not feeling pizza. But we always are at Tony's! Definitely recommend. Wayyyyy better than the chain restaurant pizza we would normally get. read more