Cancel

Open app

Search

Papa Johns Pizza

2.5 (10 reviews)
Closed • 10:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

Order Papa Johns Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Papa Johns Pizza Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Papa Johns Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of D C.
0
1
0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Sam G.
0
110
14

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Ordered pizza with super chocolatey brownie. Brownie was cut oddly but it's all good, it's delicious. Thanks guys, keep up the good work!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Papa Johns Pizza

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 1,216 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Bambino’s Pizza - NEW BAMBINOS MENUS

Bambino’s Pizza

4.1(35 reviews)
6.6 mi

Went with some friends to try out this spot. Under new ownership and serving Italian and Asian…read morecuisine. Seems like an odd combo, but it works! The owner brought us out water bottles for everyone in the group. She then brought us some shrimp appetizers and some lumpia while we looked at the menu. The lumpia were packed with flavor and the sauces were so good. I opted for a sausage roll. The roll was hot and crisp on the outside with warm, gooey cheese. Served with a very tasty red sauce. Others at the table got Bourbon chicken, General Chicken, Baked Zita, Baked Spaghetti, & dumplings. Everyone was very pleased with their meals & very happy with the serving sizes. After all of the appetizers most of us took home some food! Staff was great and friendly. They were very patient with our questions and you can tell are committed to good food and good service. Can't wait to go back!

I work near here on the weekends and have wanted to try them. Great little family place. Not much…read moreroom to eat in. I called ahead and paid over the phone. Walked in at appointed time and received piping hot order on time. Could not decide what to get so this was only for 3 people but we will have leftovers for days. Garlic parm wings are perfection. Sausage roll tasty-real Italian sausage. Chicago firm pizza was unique and just as described to me on the phone. Edges are buttery and crisp. Sauce is authentic. That is all I tasted tonight. Will update when I eat lasagna and pepperoni meatball pizza later but check out all that cheese!

Photos
Bambino’s Pizza - NEW BAMBINOS MENUS

NEW BAMBINOS MENUS

Bambino’s Pizza - So yummy

So yummy

Bambino’s Pizza - Slices

See all

Slices

Benito's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Benito's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.1(61 reviews)
7.6 mi
•$$

I love this place! It has great service and the food is delicious 10/10 definitely coming again…read more I recommend the pizzas and for takeout they are cheaper

Whenever I'm in Fleming Island and am craving Italian-American red sauce joint type food I come…read morehere. I've been to Benito's lunch buffet a bunch of times when out there before and this is definitely the place. It's very good and enjoyable. The atmosphere is very middle-of-the-road comfy, not too fancy yet not at all divey. Place is immaculate and the staff are all very friendly and chill. The buffet's not ginormous but there's a lot of variety on it, something for everybody and the food, without exception is all tasty (see pix). The eggplant parm was good with lots of eggplant flavor, though pretty saucy. The sauce is nice though with a good balance between sweet and tangy. First time I went they had eggplant rollatini. They were great! Haven't seen them back since though, sadly. The saucy lasagna was also tasty with a nice presence of both meat and ricotta. The chicken Regina was unusual and mouth-worthy in a novel way. It's like chicken Francese with prosciutto, onions and mushrooms! The pizza was standard good and extremely edible. I don't like pepperoni pizza so I stuck with the cheese. Once when I went, they had veggie pizza. That was REALLY good! Wish they'd bring it back. I don't want to drone on and on so I'll let the LABELED pix speak for themselves. You should definitely go here when in the area at lunchtime for the great buffet, 11AM-2PM.

Photos
Benito's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pano photo of the inside of the restaurant

Pano photo of the inside of the restaurant

Benito's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Benito's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

See all

Valentina’s Italian Bistro

Valentina’s Italian Bistro

4.5(196 reviews)
7.0 mi
•$$
Full bar
Large group friendly

This restaurant is a hidden gem for comfort Italian food. Openly, I was a bit skeptical due to the…read morelocation, but I am glad that I tried this place, I will definitely be back. I visited on Friday 9/25 and the restaurant was packed which is a good sign. Luckily I had a reservation. I do recommend a reservation if you visit on a weekend, as this place seems to get busy. For drink I had the Capo Zafferano (cabernet), the wines are affordable here which I believe is a must for any Italian restaurant. For starters we ordered the calamari and the arancini. The calamari was crispy, and I enjoyed that mainly because some restaurants serve it soggy. It being crispy showed me that it's cooked to order. Additionally the arancini was unique for me. I never seen one with beef and risotto inside of it. It was a moist beef and was all around flavorful. I would absolutely order both of those appetizers again. The entrée I tried was a classic chicken parmesan. A lot can go wrong with a chicken parmesan, but this place had a nice hearty portion served with rigatoni. You can swap for a different pasta if you like. The red sauce was flavorful and comforting, and the chicken was a big 7 oz portion. It was the perfect entrée after experiencing a long day at work. For dessert our table ordered a cannoli and a tiramisu. The cannoli was most special to me because it had a cinnamon flavored filling, not too strong, but yet present. I am a fan of cinnamon so I may be biased here. I typically do not like cannolis, but I enjoyed this one thoroughly. The tiramisu was also satisfying. Both desserts were not overly sweet, which I appreciated. My opinion on this place is all around positive, I enjoyed the meal, and the service. It's a great spot for fulfilling a comfort Italian food craving. Nothing makes me happier than a hearty portion of chicken parmesan and some wine. It's hard to critique anything here, but if you forced me to critique one thing it would be that bread service was not free. However, in my opinion the dishes are reasonably priced, so I can live with going without bread, especially when the appetizers themselves were so good. In its class I rate Valentina's a 10/10. I was completely satisfied eating here, and these days I feel some restaurants try too hard, and fail to deliver. For me Valentina's delivered. I typically include pictures of my meals, but this one was so good that I had no time to take any! Again, 10/10.

I've been to Italy, so I was honestly surprised to find my favorite lasagna right here at home. The…read morelasagna there had this light, fresh quality that I'd never been able to find anywhere else in America...until now. This one had that same light, refreshing feel but with even more flavor. It was hard to explain what I meant to my husband until he tried it and he ended up liking my lasagna more than the calzone he ordered! You can tell they make everything from scratch. We also got spaghetti and meatballs to go, and the sauce tasted so fresh. The cannoli was incredible. I used to make cannoli at a bakery years ago, and theirs had the smoothest, creamiest filling I've ever had. The staff was wonderful, and the owner treated us like an old friend. It's a modest size restaurant with good seating but limited parking,and it's always busy for a good reason. We'll definitely be back!

Photos
Valentina’s Italian Bistro
Valentina’s Italian Bistro
Valentina’s Italian Bistro

See all

Aspendos Italian Cuisine - 10" Veggie Pizza

Aspendos Italian Cuisine

4.3(64 reviews)
9.7 mi•Westside

When I helped my daughter and her family moved to the Middleburg area last July, we were looking…read morefor someplace for dinner on our first night in her new home. We decided on Aspendos and, wow, were we glad we did! Every dish was delicious. As a result, while spending the Christmas holidays with my daughter, I made sure we went to Aspendos and again on my third visit a few weeks ago. While I have fallen in love with their Penne alla Vodka, I have sampled other dishes and found them to be very good, as well (my daughter's go-to is their pesto pasta dish). This is a small operation, run by three members of the same family. If you have a large group you will need to wait awhile for your food, but it's worth the wait. We have some good Italian restaurants where I live in California, but I wish we had Aspendos here!

Ordered a pizza for carry-out from this small local pizza place in the Oakleaf area after reading…read morethe positive reviews. The adventure started when I called and after 4 rings was greeted with the following convo with an unknown male employee: Business: Hello Me: is this Aspenedo's? Business: Yes Me: are you taking orders? Business: yes Me: can I place and order? Business: yes Me: can I have a 16 inch Hawaiian pizza ads Banana peppers Business: yes Me: can you tell me when to pick it up? Business: 35 minutes Me: how much will I owe? Business: $34 I sent my 17 year old son to pick up the food and he called me upon arrival stating that they did not have my pizza. I then had to call the business again to find my pizza which they had but could not find bc they did not associate it with me or my phone number. My son brought the pizza home and it was good but not $34 good. The pizza tasted smoky from the bacon and ham. The sauce was light and tomatoey but the crust could not hold under the weight of the toppings. My son also advised that his experience with the staff at the restaurant was similar to mine on the phone. Love to support local businesses but I don't think we will be back.

Photos
Aspendos Italian Cuisine
Aspendos Italian Cuisine
Aspendos Italian Cuisine - Meatball well seasoned!

See all

Meatball well seasoned!

Papa Johns Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...