Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Tony G’s Pizzeria

    5.0 (11 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Tony G’s Pizzeria Photos

    Business Info

    TONY G’S PIZZERIA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Tony G’s Pizzeria

    Recommended Reviews - Tony G’s Pizzeria

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Pizza slice with wings
    Tanisha B.

    The wings were delicious. They were so big and meaty and the flavours were all great. I had the bbq, honey garlic and hot wings. The pizza was really good but I didn't select the kind so it wasn't my favourite. The service was good. They were really busy. I loved the interior but this location holds a special place in my heart because it used to be My Buddy's (which was the best). I would definitely go back and try one of their different slices.

    Delicious cheese pizza slice
    Stana B.

    I am still gonna call this a hidden gem in Hamilton because unless you're walking down King William or John St, you might miss it! First time here! I came specifically to try a pepperoni slice. I went to the Farmer's Market first and miscalculated... when I arrived at the pizza place around 1:30pm, there was only the 5 cheese pizza left (by slice).... Still wanted to try it for sure!! I love a good cheese slice too!! This one definitely did not disappoint!!! Garlic oil and extra parmigiana was added. Flavour abound! Nice chewy dough, but still crispy. Good balance between the toppings/sauce and dough/crust. I will definitely come back to order a whole pie to share with friends. It's dine-in and take out. Cozy, mom & pop vibes. Probably needs some extra help with the added popularity! Good hospitality with a bit of spice ;)

    Highly recommend checking Tony G's! Everyone was super friendly and the ambiance was nice and cozy. I ordered the blanco pizza and the crust was perfect -- light and airy yet still crispy. I loved the creamy, garlicky white sauce base, and the assortment of cheeses was flavorful without being overpowering or greasy. I had to get a cheese slice for the road and I'd absolutely travel again just to eat here!

    Twinky S.

    We ventured to Hamilton to visit Adventure Village with our children and a friend recommended this pizzeria so we had to give it a go! From the moment we walked in we were greeted and welcomed as if we were part of the family. Charlie told us to take a seat and to help ourselves to the fridge for drinks and that we can settle up with the bill later. He told us it would be a few hours of a wait and luckily it was only an hour as we had three children amongst us. Their reaction after waiting for that long was that it was so worth it! We had a large pizza of half cheese for the children and half it's a Bronx thing for the adults. The cheese slice was so flavourful, warm, stretchy, melty, gooey and oh so beautiful. The sauce was on the sweeter side with a subtle hint of spice. The dough had great char, was extremely thin, crispy on the edge and each bite was full of flavor. The slice itself was greasy however the oil Charlie uses is part of the experience as it adds flavor and depth. Sort of like the ingredients for the Bronx thing. And this pizza is an explosion of flavor. Sautéed rapini, whole milk muzzarell, sweet Italian sausage, hot peppers and hand whipped ricotta. The slice was a perfect mix of sweet, subtle spice and tangy perfection. We will definitely be back to try the other slices!

    See all

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Andrea W.
    24
    13
    66

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mal Y.
    0
    3
    11

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of M H.
    0
    11
    6

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Review Highlights - Tony G’s Pizzeria

    Highly recommend a side of the garlic sauce for dipping.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 2,118 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Flora Hamilton - Pepperoni pizza and garlic chili oil

    Flora Hamilton

    4.8(9 reviews)
    0.7 km

    Incredible flavours and a unique style offered at this little pizzeria…read more "Roman" style pizza is served here, which is similar to a my grandma pie or a thinner, crispier Sicilian. You can taste the quality of the ingredients here, and everything prepared has a real home-made feel to it, as if your Italian friend's Nona just took some pies out of the oven for you guys. It's incredibly delicious, and you won't be able to stop eating it. The biggest standout for me here is their sauce, which has such a strong tomato flavour while still being delicate and balanced. It's honestly one of the best sauces I've ever had. I highly recommend trying their margherita, as it's the best way to try their sauce and dough. With so many great pizza shops in Hamilton, Flora definitely stands out, not only by offering a different style of pizza than the rest but also by focusing on fresh, quality ingredients with a real homemade touch. Highly, highly recommend!

    Hamilton is filled with fantastic local pizza joints, so when I heard that Flora was the *best*…read morepizza in town, I had to check them out. Nestled on a side-street off busy James St N as you travel up the mountain, you'll find Flora on the ground floor of a older residential-looking building. The first thing you'll notice walking inside is actually how small this place is - the pizza ovens and prep area take up most of the space. But there's something incredibly charming about that because you have high hopes that if they dedicate that much space to food prep, it's gotta be good. Happy to report that their pizza lives up to the hype! Pizza is baked in a sheet-pan with a semi-thick crust that's soft yet crispy at the edges. Crust is on the thicker side relative to some Italian restaurants and pizza chains, but the composition of the dough makes it work because it has a bite but not too tough/thick where it gives your mouth a workout. I also loved their fresh tomato sauce. It balanced so well with the cheese and toppings, giving the pizza a nice freshness so that it didn't feel as heavy. My only critique was that I wanted more basil on my pizza (I love me some basil!)

    Photos
    Flora Hamilton - Pepperoni pizza and garlic chili oil

    Pepperoni pizza and garlic chili oil

    Flora Hamilton
    Flora Hamilton - Margherita & pepperoni pizza slices

    See all

    Margherita & pepperoni pizza slices

    Chicago Style Pizza - Chicago special, cosmopolitan, Mediterranean salad

    Chicago Style Pizza

    4.0(159 reviews)
    3.1 km
    $$

    walked in with my boyfriend for my birthday and had a lovely time! service was exceptional as…read morealways: staff are very personable and accommodating. the pizza was so yum!!! we were warned it takes about 30 mins to come out, but we had a delicious caesar salad to share in the meantime. love it here, will be back!

    Once upon a time when I was in Chicago, I fell in love with the infamous deep dish pizza…read more Nostalgia overtook me, and I decided to try this joint in Hamilton that's been there for as long as I could remember. I pre-ordered the Chicago Special over the phone at 4:30 pm with a pickup time of 6:30 pm. That should give them more than enough time to cook the pizza. They told me that a deep dish pizza needs 30 minutes to cook. When I went to pick up the pizza, a staff member told me it's almost ready and asked me to pay. A few minutes later, I heard my name being called. She told me that they made a mistake and served my pizza to a table. I could see she was upset about the error. She was so kind and said they would remake another one for me on the house and that I could also keep the pizza that was for the other table. That, to me, was ultimate customer service along with the repeated apologies. The 2 deep dish pizzas were definitely deep, like the ones i tried in Chicago. They were filled with tomato sauce, so if you love your tomatoes, you would be in heaven. I look forward to my next order.

    Photos
    Chicago Style Pizza
    Chicago Style Pizza
    Chicago Style Pizza

    See all

    Shorty's Pizza - Spicy sausage pizza - 18"

    Shorty's Pizza

    3.8(29 reviews)
    3.7 km

    Each of the two pizzas we tried, Hawaiian and veggie delight were spectacular. Unique sauces just…read morethe right balance of toppings and the crust was delicious. We will definitely be coming back. The people here are extremely friendly. The atmosphere is great A true traditional diner complete with music checkered floors and bar stools. Ambience is charming.

    The one pizza place I will go out of my way for!!! Took my friends here and ordered for pickup…read more Over the phone, they really greeted us with warmth and kindness, even personalized it by repeating my friend's name back to her a few times. We ordered the 18" spicy sausage pizza which is their larger size, and it was enough for 4 of us to have 2 slices each. We all collectively agreed that it fed us contently but because of how good it tasted- we could go for another slice or two each! Theyve also got a handful of dipping sauces available, and we got two garlic dill dips, not too much dill, and paired perfectly with the spicy sausage! Walking up to the pizza shop itself, you could smell the wafts of pizza from around the corner. The restaurant inside has a decent amount of tables if you want to dine-in, though most do takeout. Because we were taking it back to campus to eat it, it wasn't as fresh as we'd hoped for but you could still taste how GOOD IT WAS! Will still be one of my top reco's for hammy food! If you are a fan of the NY style pizza, definitely need to stop by.

    Photos
    Shorty's Pizza - Pepperoni

    Pepperoni

    Shorty's Pizza - NY cheese

    NY cheese

    Shorty's Pizza - Mural at Shorty's Pizza

    See all

    Mural at Shorty's Pizza

    Cowabunga - Garlicky Greens for the win!

    Cowabunga

    4.3(26 reviews)
    0.4 km

    This is seriously some of the best pizza (if not, my favorite) I've ever tried. The slices are…read moreMASSIVE & full of flavor. The 1up is their most popular pizza that sells out as soon as a fresh pie comes out. It's an elevated white pizza featuring flavors of truffle, fior de latte, and honey, and it all works SO well without overpowering each other. The crust is genuinely next level, it's so flaky on the outside and perfectly airy on the inside-- not bland or dense & has a bit of a fermented taste (kind of like sourdough/poolish) Reminded me exactly of how I remember Brooklyn NY pizza tasting when I visited. I also tried their pepperoni which was generously topped and not too greasy. The atmosphere of this restaurant is really artsy and unpretentious, they have some old school arcade games at the back and plenty of market-style seating available for small and large groups. Honestly words can't describe how delicious these pizzas are, it's an experience you definitely need to try yourself. I've never written a review so fast during the 3 years I've been on Yelp and I hope that says a lot. 10/10 spot highly recommend.

    after years of hearing great things and never quite making it in, i came in for a solo birthday…read morelunch and was so happy with the food and service! lots of natural light. really love the open kitchen. i sampled lots on the menu: 1UP fries, caesar salad, 1UP slice, hot honey, and garlic dip (and a pepsi obviously). everything was exceptionally tasty - perfect combos of flavours with the truffle oil. the only thing i would change would be the croutons on the caesar salad, but that is an understandable cost to cut given this is a pizza joint. will be back!

    Photos
    Cowabunga
    Cowabunga
    Cowabunga

    See all

    Plaza Pizza & Wings - Chicken Shawarma Pizza

    Plaza Pizza & Wings

    4.1(17 reviews)
    0.6 km
    $

    This place is the best and open late (until 2am on some days). Get their shawarma pizza or the…read morechicken shawarma wrap. I go here all the time and the folks working there are super sweet.

    Came here after an afternoon at Albion and Tews Falls. I have to admit I was skeptical at first…read morebecause there weren't many photos up, but the reviews were so positive that's we decided to give it a try. This place is more for carry out or delivery, but there are 2 tables, enough for 4 people to sit and eat and plenty of chairs for when you're waiting for your fresh pizza. For the 4 of us, we got the 2x three topping pizzas with the 20 wings and garlic bread special (includes one dipping sauce), which came to $30. I don't remember if they were 2 mediums or larges. The pizza was so fresh, and there's something different (good different) about the sauce base compared to other pizza joints, and it went so well with the garlic dip. We got BBQ wings which were amazing. Honestly all 4 of us agreed that it was probably the best wings we've ever had. The sauce they toss the wings in tastes so good and the chicken is done nicely, not over cooked, dry or super tiny like other pizza places. One of our friends was so impressed that non spicy wings could be soo good! The staff were also really nice and they had coin operated toy vending machines which kept us busy while we waited for our food. We're from Toronto, but we'd definitely take the trip just to come back. Would also like to note that there are no washroom facilities here.

    Photos
    Plaza Pizza & Wings - Medium thin crust 3 topping well done with dip ---  cheese pepperoni bacon

    Medium thin crust 3 topping well done with dip --- cheese pepperoni bacon

    Plaza Pizza & Wings - All that's left

    All that's left

    Plaza Pizza & Wings

    See all

    Tony G’s Pizzeria - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...