Each of the two pizzas we tried, Hawaiian and veggie delight were spectacular. Unique sauces just the right balance of toppings and the crust was delicious. We will definitely be coming back. The people here are extremely friendly. The atmosphere is great A true traditional diner complete with music checkered floors and bar stools. Ambience is charming. read more

The one pizza place I will go out of my way for!!! Took my friends here and ordered for pickup. Over the phone, they really greeted us with warmth and kindness, even personalized it by repeating my friend's name back to her a few times. We ordered the 18" spicy sausage pizza which is their larger size, and it was enough for 4 of us to have 2 slices each. We all collectively agreed that it fed us contently but because of how good it tasted- we could go for another slice or two each! Theyve also got a handful of dipping sauces available, and we got two garlic dill dips, not too much dill, and paired perfectly with the spicy sausage! Walking up to the pizza shop itself, you could smell the wafts of pizza from around the corner. The restaurant inside has a decent amount of tables if you want to dine-in, though most do takeout. Because we were taking it back to campus to eat it, it wasn't as fresh as we'd hoped for but you could still taste how GOOD IT WAS! Will still be one of my top reco's for hammy food! If you are a fan of the NY style pizza, definitely need to stop by. read more

Shorty's Pizza - Spicy sausage pizza - 18" - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

Ordered the margherita pizza, which is usually pretty good, but the one I received this evening should not have left the store. It was extremely thin, very dry, and had little little sauce. Called Shorty's to ask for either a replacement pizza or a refund, I was told they were too busy to do anything about it and to email the manager. So no pizza dinner for me this evening, and I will think twice before ordering from Shorty's again. read more

The pizza here was excellent! We tried the NY cheese, and even though you could tell from the look and taste that it had been sitting out for a while, it was still a heck of a slice. The cheese blend was a little saltier but in a good way, and they had a nice herb blend on top which made for a good punch of flavor. Cook on the pizza was nice, and the crust had good crunch. Definitely would come back! read more

Shorty's Pizza - NY cheese - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

I popped in here with some friends after a long bike ride, service was excellent and fast. Pizza was also excellent, i had the meat-lovers slice and a pepperoni slice, the pizza was well made, perfectly baked, sauce was tasty, cheese fresh, the toppings were plentiful and also Delicious, i really enjoyed this pizza, definitely above average quality, i'd definitely eat here again. read more

This is the best pizza I've had in a very very long! The sesame seeds on the crust were such a treat! We Had the white pizza and it was fantastic!! So so so good! read more

One of the best pizza spots around Hamilton area. Good pies.. little salty but on the good side!

Been visiting Shorty's whenever I'm in the Hamilton area. Great pizza with a cracker-like crust and sesame seeds on top. They have the pepperoni which cups up which is always a plus in my book. Lots of patio seating for the summer in the back. Nice spot to grab a quick bite if you're in the area read more

Shorty's Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

Best pizza joint in Hamilton. Atmosphere: 8.5 out of 10 Food: 8.8 out of 10 Pizza was cooked perfect! Cleanliness: 9.5 out of 10 Staff: 9.7 out of 10 Asked some questions about merchandise and they were able to answer perfectly. Overall: Nothing bad to say about this place read more

Shorty's Pizza - Perfect about of heat on these pizzas. - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

Best pizza I've ever had in Canada. When my wife suggested we stop for pizza after our sons hockey tournament, I was a little nervous based on the pizza I've had in Canada in the past, but this stuff was different. It was delicious. We had a cheese and pep, and a bacon/mushroom with hot honey. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed. read more

Now THIS is what I'm talking about. Shorty's is the sort of pizzeria you might have expected to see featured in an episode of No Reservations or Parts Unknown. It feels like the kind of unassuming, small, and out-of-the-way spot that Anthony Bourdain would have taken the time to check out. The pizza is fantastic, and probably the only place I will drive significantly out of my way for when craving a pizza. I recommend the Spicy Deluxe! read more

I was told that it was the best in town by so called self proclaimed experts. The pizza was dry and the dough tasted like cardboard. I will never return ever! read more

On May 12, 2024, I placed an order for an 18" pepperoni and additional mushroom pizza. I am not sure who was working the pizza table, however the pizza base can be best described as paper-thin. Additionally, the pizza lacked enough mushrooms, and the ones that were there were placed strategically in the center. While a light crust is usually acceptable, for a pizza that costs $30 or more, it really should not be so thin that the slice bends from the middle to the end. read more

My husband and I drive from London, Ontario just to get this pizza! We've been to NYC several times and this is the closest thing to it we've had in Canada! read more

Do 10 Things and Do Them Well. Unexpected 'Bistro Style' Pizza Parlor. Modest menu. Modest setting. 10 creative Pizza types to choose from. Working my way through the menu. Tonight Bacon and Mushroom. Done crispy with Onions. Flavor was sweet, a tiny bit of heat with a very thin well made crust. Service was immediate and neighborly. #Recommend read more

Shorty's Pizza - Shorty's Pizza Menu Do 10 Things and Do them Well! - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

See all

Best pizza in town. We're so happy that this is in the neighbourhood now! NYC style pizza with fresh ingredients, perfect thin crust, fantastic toppings. We've ordered slices and full pizzas to go. The classic cheese/pepperoni slices are great and a nice size. Just tried the white pizza the other day (mozz/ricotta/arugula) and it was SO good. The owners seem super nice too. You can call ahead for pick up and the wait is only normally about 10 minutes. Hot tip: get the garlic dill dip. read more

Best pizza in Hamilton, hands down. I love pizza. Shorty's is the new gold standard. Most of the others just don't measure up and shouldn't be in the top ten. read more

Decor is old pizzeria style. Rapini and sausage pizza had sesame seeds and honey on it. Crust was thin and crunchy. Pizza was ok nothing amazing and more expensive that the local spots in Hamilton. Probably won't go back. read more

I was really looking forward to trying this joint because I've heard the pizza is pretty good. Unfortunately my experiences was quite opposite! For one, this place is is a really sketchy part of town, which makes it really unappealing to go to. The decor is old looking, it's really hot inside, and it just feels greasy in there. Now on to the customer service. When my husband and I walked in, we were basically ignored until I walked closer to the counter and asked if we order there or sit down and order, the one girl told me to just hold on a minute. This was fine - then I waited until another girl who was trying to take an order on the phone and couldn't get it right, was down. Once the computer was free, the 2nd girl tried to take our order. I say tried because it seemed like she couldn't hear a word we were saying and I had to repeat myself every time I said anything. We ordered Nodini (like little garlic knots) and a small sausage and rapini pizza. She asked a bunch of times what kind of pizza, how many Nodini, and if we were staying in or taking out - I told her multiple times...staying in, small pizza, 12 Nodini. Also ordered a bottle or water and my husband ordered a beer. We paid and sat down. After a few minutes the 2nd girl came over and asked again if we wanted our pizza in a box to take out or on a tray, again I said we were staying in. She went away, and the other girl came over and asked again to clarify if we were staying in - I said yes (for the 10th time!) After another 10 mins or so, while they were cutting our pizza they brought over our drinks and apologized (I guess because they should have brought them way sooner). Then the 2nd girl brought our pizza over. Then she brought over only 6 Nodini is a take out box. I looked back at the menu and then my bill and realized she only charged me for 6 Nodini but we ordered 12, I was fine with this because I just wanted to eat - but really they need to listen! Our pizza was mediocre at best, the crust was so thin but it still wasn't even cut thru all the way for slices. The rapini was just shoved on top and not even cut small so it was easy to bite. I asked for cutlery and they brought over a plastic fork and knife - ummmm how am I supposed to cut anything with plastic!? Useless. We looked over into the "kitchen" area and my husband noticed they just use cheap billy bee honey for the pizza topping - it would be nice to support local, no? The sauce was flavourless and watery, really quite boring. Crust was slightly burnt and too crispy, and random sesame seeds thrown on. They tasted fine I just don't think it was necessary. The Nodini were not bad, but my husband thought they just tasted like Pillsbury croissant rolls with garlic and spices. LOL. No one ever checked on us, asked how our food was, or really ever said another word to us after they brought our food to the table. Customer service is a huge flop for the place! I wanted to like Shorty's but unfortunately it didn't add up at all for us. Bad service left a terrible taste in my mouth and so did the food. read more

Best NY style takeout pizza in Hamilton, period. Their pizza is unique, super tasty, and huge slices. The garlic dill sauce alone is a reason to visit. You have to try it! read more

Shorty's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza & garlic dill sauce - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

THE. BEST. PIZZA. IN. HAMILTON! It's embarrassing how often my boyfriend and I eat Shorty's. Thin crust, big flavour! I love the classic margarita but you can't go wrong with any Za. Try out the Kale Caesar as a side dish. You can order on Skip The Dishes or dine in- they serve beer and wine! read more

Unique, thats the first thing i gotta say. The Roni Cups were great and the sesame seed crust was interesting and was good. The sauce was on the plainer side and it was a little light on the cheese but i will go back and eat there again. It is an experience that i would recommend to anyone that likes pizza. read more

I had ordered pizza and wine for pick up and when I arrived to pick up there was a discrepancy in the price his online menu was different from his in store menu, when I asked him to match the price of his online menu the owner was rude told me I'm trying to screw his business and if I didn't like it to leave the order and go elsewhere I can sell the pizza you ordered ! So that's exactly what I did I went elsewhere and will never return. read more

Really disappointed in my first order with you guys. You guys copy the order down wrong, I call to see if this can be fixed and the best you can do is 10% off the original, and correct pie??? Plus I get attitude from the college student working your front desk because SHE somehow messed up writing down the correct order? What kind of customer service is that?? What a waste of time and money. read more

I've had a lot of pizza in my day, and Shorty's is by far the best pizza in Hamilton. Friendly staff and delicious pizza. I can't recommend their pizza enough! read more

If you like NY style pizza this is the place. Super good dough and fresh toppings. A very welcome addition to the neighborhood and a nice departure from the "2 for 1 large pizza and wings" places that dominate this city. My only complaint is it is maybe a touch overpriced (especially the beer) but its not an unreasonable price point. I've been in every few days since they opened. read more

Great quality pizza and ingredients, great roomy atmosphere to sit and enjoy a slice or a whole pie with someone. Nodini are excellent too. I wouldn't just call it NYC pizza, it's NYC pizza with quality ingredients. read more

Love the pizza. We have ordered 3x recently. Best pizza in Crown Point. Only giving 4 stars because the salad is disappoint. $6 for a Caesar salad that barely serves one. Skip the salad. read more

They do not advertise that they put sesame seeds, a known allergen, on their pizzas. Nor will they refund us, or remake us a pizza we can eat. We've wasted $60 on two pizzas that we cannot eat and they refuse to remedy the situation. read more