Such a great find! We came here in search of Ny style pizza in Hamilton and this is up there with…read morethe best of the best! First thing to know is it is cash only but there's an ATM onsite with a very low fee of $1 to use it (this fee could be $5 and people would pay so this was quite the deal). This pizza is everything you want in a good slice, greasy in the best way, good amount of flop and structure, crispy airy charred crust and of course the cup'n'char pepps are mint. Highly recommend a side of the garlic sauce for dipping. Plenty of seating inside, public parking lot across from it and extremely clean washrooms. Staff was incredibly friendly and helpful & cost was super reasonable for the size of the pizzas. Worth the drive to the hammer!

So worth the drive to come check this place out. Authentic pizza fantastic flavors definitely…read morecoming back again. Friendly staff very welcoming. Lots of seating. Loved the whole experience

walked in with my boyfriend for my birthday and had a lovely time! service was exceptional as…read morealways: staff are very personable and accommodating. the pizza was so yum!!! we were warned it takes about 30 mins to come out, but we had a delicious caesar salad to share in the meantime. love it here, will be back!

Small stuffed pizza with no self respect toppings was good, with tasty toppings, lots of cheese & a…read morerich sauce. It takes at least half an hour to cook so if you're getting it for takeout, call in ahead of time.

This place opened only two months ago and it was already busy with walk-ins. The staff were very…read morepleasant and greeted everyone with a smile. I ordered onion rings, chicken wings, and a small pizza. The onion rings were very crispy and light. The chicken wings themselves were small compared to places like red rocket, but otherwise they were very tender, and the sauce was spot on. The toppings on the pizza were very fresh and still had that crunch, even though they've been through the oven. The gluten-free crust was, well typical gluten-free crust but the pizza was very enjoyable for sure. The location is on the corner of upper Wentworth and Brucedale. There is only street parking but there's plenty available. It is takeout only, there is no dine in. The inside is very clean and well organized. I found the prices to be very reasonable and very highly recommend it!!!

Each of the two pizzas we tried, Hawaiian and veggie delight were spectacular. Unique sauces just…read morethe right balance of toppings and the crust was delicious. We will definitely be coming back. The people here are extremely friendly. The atmosphere is great A true traditional diner complete with music checkered floors and bar stools. Ambience is charming.

The one pizza place I will go out of my way for!!! Took my friends here and ordered for pickup…read more Over the phone, they really greeted us with warmth and kindness, even personalized it by repeating my friend's name back to her a few times. We ordered the 18" spicy sausage pizza which is their larger size, and it was enough for 4 of us to have 2 slices each. We all collectively agreed that it fed us contently but because of how good it tasted- we could go for another slice or two each! Theyve also got a handful of dipping sauces available, and we got two garlic dill dips, not too much dill, and paired perfectly with the spicy sausage! Walking up to the pizza shop itself, you could smell the wafts of pizza from around the corner. The restaurant inside has a decent amount of tables if you want to dine-in, though most do takeout. Because we were taking it back to campus to eat it, it wasn't as fresh as we'd hoped for but you could still taste how GOOD IT WAS! Will still be one of my top reco's for hammy food! If you are a fan of the NY style pizza, definitely need to stop by.

I heard this place won an award for the best cheese slice so of course I had to visit. I ordered…read moretheir pepperoni plus which comes with pepperoni, jalepenos, and hot honey. This pizza blew me away! They make their own sourdough crust which was delicious, I think sourdough pizza was what I was missing in my life! I'm a huge fan of a sweet & salty combo so the hot honey was amazing great touch that elevated the whole pizza.

This is seriously some of the best pizza (if not, my favorite) I've ever tried. The slices are…read moreMASSIVE & full of flavor. The 1up is their most popular pizza that sells out as soon as a fresh pie comes out. It's an elevated white pizza featuring flavors of truffle, fior de latte, and honey, and it all works SO well without overpowering each other. The crust is genuinely next level, it's so flaky on the outside and perfectly airy on the inside-- not bland or dense & has a bit of a fermented taste (kind of like sourdough/poolish) Reminded me exactly of how I remember Brooklyn NY pizza tasting when I visited. I also tried their pepperoni which was generously topped and not too greasy. The atmosphere of this restaurant is really artsy and unpretentious, they have some old school arcade games at the back and plenty of market-style seating available for small and large groups. Honestly words can't describe how delicious these pizzas are, it's an experience you definitely need to try yourself. I've never written a review so fast during the 3 years I've been on Yelp and I hope that says a lot. 10/10 spot highly recommend.

Very tasty pizza. Lots of cheese; delicious crust (I haven't eaten the crust since this pizza!);…read moreand tasty (non-Heinz) garlic sauce. Recommendation: Order the pepperoni on top of the cheese so it's not soggy - see last photo

This is my first time here…read more Ordered a large pizza with sausage, half pineapple and half ham. Was over charged for 3 toppings after paying; employee argued with me but did give me the change back after it was explained to him. Waited for the pizza and checked when I got back to my car - no pineapple, magically ended up with pepperoni? Did not want to wait for a new pizza, so I asked for the owners phone number. Employee in the store said he didn't have it (lol why lie?) The cherry on top was when I found a hair in a slice of pizza. See photo

Consistently excellent pizza, a nice, sweet flavourful sauce, a well baked crust, just right, good…read moreamount of cheese, nice topping selection, fresh, delicious, everything a pizza should be. Good prices too. And I agree with the other reviewer, very friendly staff. They do accept credit cards as well.

I shall begin with my first impression with the employees. The person who brought the pizza was…read moreblasting very loud Arabic music and was very unprofessional. He also gave me the look of disgust as I was paying for the food. Secondly, the pizza had arrived very cold and had a lot of burnt pepperoni on it, although it was burnt it still tasted decently good. My experience with Marios pizza has always been complicated, sometimes making great pizza and sometimes making horrible pizzas. Just because I had a horrible experience with this place , You should just give this place a try and see for yourself.