I grew up on the Southside of Chicago and there was a great pizza on every other block. The area had thin crust, pizza with a sweet sauce, lots of Wisconsin cheese and sweet sausage. This pizza is the very closest I've come to the pizza I grew up on that is still in existence 40 years later. I didn't like having to pay a fee to use my debit card. Had I known I'd have brought cash. Nothing posted indicating there was an up charge for using my card. Despite the good pizza that left a bad taste. Prices are high and being up charged is not ok. read more

Food tasted amazing and the service was also great everything met my expectations and beyond

Excellent pizza. They're generous with toppings and the sauce has a sweetness that I love. You can get pizza from 10 to 26 inch diameter in 2 inch increments and the cheese and toppings go all the way to the outer edge of the pie. There's no 2 inches of dry crust all the way around the pizza like other places. read more

See all

Not a fan of the pizza. Very greasy so much so that couldn't taste much else. Order large sausage pizza, fries, and 4 piece garlic cheese bread for delivery and it was $27. Fries and cheese bread were ok. Overall not recommended for price or flavor read more

I just went back and forth with the man that answered the phone! This business was highly recommended by the front desk at Holiday Inn Express on Ford St. I asked him nicely if they deliver ...he said yes! Then I told him the address and the gps said 4miles from the hotel. He tried to convince me that there was no Holiday Inn and bc I'm sure he saw my number on the caller id he felt like I didn't know what I was talking about. I repeated again where I was and also the color flyer they have. He put me on hold for a long time and didn't apologize. Then said ok I can but it will be an hour and 30mins. I told him no thank you. He really went off of my voice and the number on the phone. He didn't want to help and I didn't want any problems with my food nor give him money. Funny part of the reviews sad the customer service sucks but the pizza is good. Well I agree with the horrid service. read more

They are fantastic. Southern Italian pizza with a lot more cheese. Loads of cheese! They are a great value, especially the largest pizza that they make. We fed 10 hungry people and had leftovers all for about $25 (one topping-sausage.) I'll be telling my friends in Napoli, Italy about this place! read more

Those complaining about the customer service need to get over themselves. They should go to Little Italy in New York to realize that it's all about the food. The service is simply the transaction of exchanging cash for some of the best pizza in this region. For the style of pizza, I'd put it up against anything you can get anywhere. As for those who don't like the pizza itself, I'd say it's most likely a situation where what has passed for a good pie around here has tainted their pallets. Or... a situation where they like a different style all together. But if you like a good New York style pizza with a nice rich combination of cheese and sauce on a crust that compliments the whole package, then Tony & Maria's Pizza is truly a gem to patronize. People in this area should consider themselves lucky to have access to such high quality pizza. Both Beloit and Janesville are better places to live because of them. read more

Delicious pizza! Great quality every time. Tasty crust, lots of toppings. We're from Kentucky and every time we visit family in Beloit, Tony & Maria's is a must. read more

Your restaurant was recommended to us by the desk clerk at our hotel, who had. I personal experience, but had heard good things. So glad she was working! We had the meat lover's and it was fantastic! Plenty of toppings and didn't skimp on the cheese. One of the better pizzas I've had in quite a while. Highly recommended! read more

This pizza I order for the first time this past Friday, The pizza was very greasy and nasty as hell,I could have wipe my but with the pizza and it would have tasted better, never again,I rather eat pizza made in Janesville city sewer system then order from them again! read more

I want to give them more than 3 stars, I really do but the service I experience stops me. As far as the pizza goes - best I've had in Beloit no complaints at all. However I've constantly had bad service. My family frequently uses their delivery service and while ordering over the phone I feel very rushed and like the person taking my order is being very rude. They also never tell me the price of my order unless I ask, this isn't a huge deal I suppose but it would still be nice to be given my total before I pay like most businesses. My final issues is that my delivery drivers always seem shady. I don't know what it is about the many different drivers we've had but I've never felt comfortable with any of them read more

Epic pizza, The sauce has a touch of sweetness, just like it came out of an Italian nonas kitchen! Very flavorful. Love tbis pizza!

Absolutely love this place! I'm a pizza guy! Pizza all day every day, we get their biggest pizza all the time, and it's to die for! The sauce ratio with the cheese, is perfect! Greasy, but I love greasy pizza! I can eat at least a quarter of the pizza and I get full! Always great for left overs! Warm or cold! And yes, I eat cold pizza, depends on who it is, and this place is good left overs cold! read more

We have ordered from Tony and Maria's previously for over 20 years and enjoyed their pizza. We ordered a standard pizza (what they call "The Works" ) for delivery. They did not quote a price when ordered. After two hours it arrived with a $43.00 price tag! I declined delivery. I called the restaurant to ensure that the order was correct and they informed me that it was. No pizza is worth that. read more

They are so rude on the phone. The pizza was ok, not great, but I just can't get by the customer service. Won't be going back. This was my 3rd try. read more

Their pizza is fantastic. Been here over 5 times and have never been dissatisfied. Their staff is fantastic. They are very interested in you and go the extra mile to make sure you have a great experience. I will keep coming back here for both the quality of food and service!!!! HIDDEN GEM!!!!!!! read more

This is s personal favorite of ours. The pizza sauce is to die for. We get Tony's pizza nearly every week, cuz it's consistently great. They do not skimp on quality or toppings. No matter how busy they can be, they do find a way of conversing while working. Worth the drive if you are 30 minutes away!. Cant speak highly enough of these guys. read more

We love the pizza. Very good Italian style pizza. Great crust and cheese with an old world flavor. We moved out of town, but every time we visit family we try and get back to Tony and Maria's read more

I am a new customer and called after spending 25 minutes trying to get Little Caesers to even answer their phone. These people were polite friendly and very helpful, haven't tried the pizza yet but bet its fantastic! read more

This has always been my favorite pizza place. I have been going here for years and never have I had a bad experience. For those that come from out of town you must try and I guaranteed you will not be disappointed. read more

I have to say I was really excited about having pizza from Tony and Maria's to start the New Year (2014)!! A friend suggested the pizza this last month, and it was good the last time we had it!! Unfortunately, I was unpleased to find out they couldn't deliver 4.6 miles away because "the roads were too bad, and we won't go that far..." It shouldn't have surprised me one bit, but it was annoying to hear for the 1st of the year. We live in Wisconsin, news flash it snows. Duh, the roads are bad, if we didn't want bad roads we should live in California. Instead, now we have to drive if we want pizza!! Note to self and others, don't order pizza when it snows you have to drive to pick it up. I am not recommending this place for delivery, although the pizza is decent. read more

I love pizza and Tony & Maria's has the best bar none! Everything I come up from Texas I come by to eat.

The pizza was good, especially if you're a fan of mountains of cheese. The toppings were delicious and the crust was good. I found it a bit pricey for what you get however. Delivery was faster than I expected, which was nice. I still don't understand the need to cut a round pizza into tiny square pieces. read more