This is a takeout/delivery only restaurant, so keep that in mind…read more I love their pizza! So far my favorite is the Supreme. A great balance of fresh toppings, with flavors that complement each other, and a generous amount of smooth, creamy mozzarella! The restaurant is under new management, and the menu has been expanded. I'm looking forward to trying their great variety! The new owner is friendly and very accommodating. I like my thin crust pizza with a pie cut instead of squares. I experienced problems with the payout system and my card, which I hope he gets straightened out, but he did tell me I could order online, have the food delivered, and still pay the driver at the door (they carry card readers). That would save me the hassle of having to go pick up my orders in order to pay in the store. He said I could also order on the phone and pay that way. I look forward to visiting my friend's house up in Rockford more often so I can explore their diverse and ambitious new menu!

Been ordering for almost 2 years now.. started out really great and then one time I ordered and…read morenever got my food delivered and restaurant didn't answer phone ... took a long break.. just ordered again last weekend and food seemed different ... less cheese and different quality and mozzarella sticks were weird and hard .. too much inconsistency ... parting ways

I'm picky when it comes to Italian restaurants; disheartened by so many that put little effort into…read moretheir sauces and use of fake cheese (fake cheese?!!). Lasagna is first on my list of things to try at a new (to me) place. This place ended my search for fantastic lasagna in Rockford~this is The One! The sauce is fantastic, tastes like several cheeses and it's baked right in the aluminum to-go container. And it's huge! Delish AND very reasonable priced! SCORE! I'm also picky about house salads. So many places don't give a crap~they tear up iceberg lettuce (ugh... Zero appeal in my book, not to mention zero nutritional-value), throw on some unripened tomatoes and carrots. But when you open the Primo's salad container, ciao bella! The colors instantly delight! Beautiful, fresh garden greens, scrumptious ripened tomatoes that taste like they were just picked, and whatever else is in there, it's going to be enjoyed, even if by itself! Next, the pizza test. This, from a male companion, who is also a self-described pizza critic, won him over and I, too, thought it was very good! Again with the sauce and cheese~Primo!! Thanks Primo's! I'm so glad I moved to your neighborhood!!

The pizza was packed with toppings! My mom and I were enjoying drinks at Rural on Tap and decided…read moreto pop next door for a pizza. We got a veggie and were given a number to wait for. About 20 minutes later, it arrived hot and delicious right at the bar! Every slice was loaded with fresh toppings and they definitely don't skimp. I loved that they delivered it straight to us. Primos is a small, charming pizza spot and placing our order was super easy. The staff was quick and friendly, and the pizza was amazing. We will absolutely be back, and I can't wait to try the margarita next!

June 2026 Quick stop…read morewhile passing through the area. We were able to call ahead and order the STUFFED PIZZA, made our own: Italian sausage, onion, and mushroom. The Italian salad was good, simple ingredients, the DRESSING is amazing! Waitress was very kind and actually used to be a dental assistant like me lol. Delightful family owned restaurant, clean, and friendly vibes.

First time going last Saturday night. Had the stuffed pizza, amazing and spot on. Had the Italian…read morefamily salad with John's dressing-stellar. Service was excellent and the big guy John, stopped by to check on us which I love when the proprietor stops out to check on his clients. Says he really cares about your experience. Can't wait to go back and try extra thin pizza and their pastas. Nice job!!!

Pizza is always really good grew up eating from here. Really miss the ability to sit down and eat…read morein the restaurant

If you want some authentic Italian tasting pizza, this is it ! Yeah it's cheese because my family…read moredoesn't eat pork and the kids just love cheese so this is our usual. When I say everything is good, down to the sauce, the dough, the cheese! It's perfect ! It's not easy to find good pizza now days & I'm super picky about red sauce ! But this is it ! They are super quick I call in my order and it's always ready when they say ! Quick in & out pick up service just how I like it ! Check it out you won't be disappointed!

This is a long overdue review for their catering service. We Catered from them for my…read moremother-in-law's memorial service. After reviewing several different options, including Olive Garden, we selected Sam's. We were very, very happy with the food they provided! We did the option with salad, chicken, Italian beef and mostaccioli. The quality of the food was excellent, and the amount of food they gave us was huge! You know how sometimes you buy food and the service portions seem incorrect? Like a frozen pizza serving a family of four? No issues like that here! We would absolutely use them again

Killer value, pretty good food!…read more For $14.99 you get soup or salad, your choice of meat sauce pasta, and a dessert !! Meat sauce had a good flavor, on the tart side rather than the sweet side. Noodles were close to al dente maybe a little past. Salad was fresh, good creamy balsamic dressing Spumoni ice cream was pretty good too. Service was good and friendly. The only thing that wasn't that great was the bread. Nice typical Italian interior. Will be back!

I have been coming here for 40 years and it still taste as remarkable as it was when I was 5…read more Every A I got a Gulotta's pizza and he made a bunch of pizzas for me.. My analysis is 9.9.... 10 on the crust, it is made with a special recipe with sweet dough that has a solid crunch all around 10 on the sauce, the keystone of the pizza... tastes as fresh as can be, to include the fact he does not skinch on the sauce, which also has a sweet taste - 9.9 on the cheese, he makes his own blend that completely makes the pizza In the end, I have had pizza all over the world . This is my favorite pizza in the area a, from that, the county And outside the country ! I compare Every pizza to this one it would be Bert's Best pizza in all Rockford hands I would love to see @davePortnoy try this mine is a 9.9z!!

Gullotta's is a little walk in/take out pizza joint(cash only). I've driven past it a million…read moretimes. We tried it a few weeks ago for the first time and my husband and son swear that this is the best pizza in town!! We went back again last night and had the same results! First time I had the Italian beef and it was flavorful and juicy but the bread... it was crusty and flaky on the outside and fluffy yet dense on the inside. The absolute perfect bread for a juicy sandwich. We also had the lasagna(which I believe is only available on the weekends) and it was fantastic as well. His Grandma's sauce is splendid('Mamma Gulotta's' sold at Woodman's). To top it all off, Nick Gulotta; the owner, chef, order taker, carry out worker(he does it all himself!!!), is just about the nicest person I have ever met. I know some very kind/caring people, but Nick takes the cake. I just can't believe how long it's taken us to try it but am so glad we finally did! Thank you, Nick!! We will keep on coming back as long as you're willing to make us pizza!!

Benny is fantastic! Clean place with exceptional Italian dishes. Daily specials a wonderful bar…read moreand gaming room.

We all know that Benny's Pizza is outstanding. I didn't know until a few months ago how absolutely…read moreamazing Cimino's ribs are! I had actually eaten at a steakhouse in Rockford last week, and ordered the ribs, and I have to admit, Bennys BLEW them away!! Oh, and Benny's were half the price Just a side note for those who may not know, when I say "Benny", I'm talking about "Cimino's" in Durand

New very friendly owners with same (plus a few new) great food…read more Not only friendly, hard working and always present - taking care of their customers. We have become regulars and are treated like family.

After decades of loving Nunzios, we were very disappointed for the first time when we ordered pizza…read moreunder the new management. My lifelong favorite pizza has the sweetest sauce , nothing at all like the pizza I love. I'm sad to say goodbye but it's time to try some of the other wonderful local Italian pizza restaurants.