All the favorable reviews must be from family and friends. Just like someone else mentioned, order a whole cheesesteak and ask for onions on half. They try to charge you for 2 halves. Want paper plates or parmigiana cheese on take out? They charge you for that to. If you order something and you don't mention the size (because they don't ask), they give you the largest. And if you complain and say your not paying for larger and you don't want it . Then you get threatened by the scumbag owner and his dirtbags that work there. There are plenty of good pizza joints around here. This place is sub par and the staff sucks . Any chance they can rob you of a few bucks they will. Amazed that they are still in business. Hope the douchebag owner gets what he deserves = Bankruptcy!! Crook !! read more

Won't ever go back. Bunch of lowlives run this place. Forget ever making another dollar of my hard earned money! I go in and am with a coworker on a break from work looking to get a whole cheesesteak. Peppers and onions on one half. Scumbag at the counter refuses and tells me he is charging me for two halves. I told him that was ridiculous and he tried playing some BS game. What's next? I want a large pizza half sausage half pepperoni am I going to be told no I have to buy two small pies?? Forget you. Pizza was horrible anyway. Way too much oregano read more

Saw that this place has been open for a few weeks and decided to try it. I am very picky about pizza and have always complained about not being able to find a good pizza in the area. Well....I am very pleased to say that this is the best pizza (Grandma's Pie) I have eaten since I was a kid! It was that good! I highly recommend this place and I hope they continue to produce food of this quality. read more

Soo, there's so many reasons why I gave this place one star. My chicken parm was frozen in the middle and the sauce bland as fuck. Also the dude behind the counter, he said his name was austin. From what I heard his names Austin thatcher and he was a complete unprofessional imbecile. Anything you do, just go to fucking dominos rather than go here read more

Ordered a Pie last week. 5-27-12 it was a Joey Sppecial. Ab sa freakin' unbelieveable! BEST pie I (we) have eaten in years soooooooooo glad they came to Lacey. Hot. Lots of toppings, NOT greasey as others are or too garlicy. Just PRIMO I'm ordering another tonite 6-2-12 just to make sure it wasn't a fluke. Fred a Guy who Knows Pie! read more

This is NOT the Joey Tomato's located in Point Pleasant Beach. This is a COPYCAT Joey Tomatos that has stolen the logo, name, image and has even tried to duplicate recipes! The one and only Joey Tomatos is located in Point Pleasant Beach NJ on the Jenkinsons Boardwalk read more

Joey Tomato's is awesome. High quality ingredients, good prices, and consistently delicious food no matter what you order. Staff is also very down to earth and friendly. Definitely check out the grandma's pie as other reviewers have suggested. read more

One of the best pizza restaurants I've ever had family run pizzeria very clean sanitary. I just think that this is the place you need to go.

The absolute worst customer service. I would be understanding if it were the help but from the owner! I will never go back!!

Order from here for dinner delivery approx 2 times a month and never been disappointed! The juicy joey burger rocks!

really really good pizza!!! i love there grandma pie and italian hot dog pizza! cheese steaks are great too!

Very dissatisfied. I could only assume the good reviews are from the staff.. I won't be going back.

The Brushetta Pizza is out of this world!! Friendly staff! Love this new place!!! GREAT

I love their Grandma Pie!!! Our Wednesday night dinner choice!!!

not great food, horrible delivery people.

Good pizza and wings.