food is great! lots of fish in the rolls, and ingredients seem fresh. staff were so friendly and nice! the bathrooms are clean. definitely recommend this place--pricing is great. read more

Tokyo Sushi - Maki Combo - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Wow! What a hidden gem. From the street it doesn't look like much but it's a lovely atmosphere but we chose outside seating because of the lovely weather. Our bento boxes were delicious!! I'll look for an excuse to return! read more

This was a surprising find in the area. Ambience: the restaurant looks like a little house from the outside, so it may be easy to miss, but the inside is quaint and cozy. Outdoor seating is nice on a warm evening. Service: prompt and friendly. Nothing fancy, but just fine. Food: we all liked our food. We had a variety of sushi, sashimi, and sides. Again, nothing fancy, but solid sushi if you're in the area. We would come back for sure. read more

See all

Great sushi! Great prices. No complaints. Staff was very friendly. I'll definitely be back read more

Tokyo Sushi - Philadelphia Roll Sweet Potato Tempura Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Three of us shared an appetizer and a platter of sashimi for 2. The app, Crispy Rice Spicy Tuna, was just okay. The sashimi was good but didn't blow us away. I liked the sushi rolls I got on an earlier visit much better. A good value with excellent service and a homey environment. read more

Great food and prices! Huge selection of vegetarian rolls. The best selection in town!

The food was amazing! Cute restaurant & the wait staff was very friendly & service was quick. I highly recommend this place & if I'm in Madison again I will definitely go here for dinner! read more

I got the shrimp yaki udon which was good! A bit overpriced in my opinion. I would recommend this place but my friend got food poisoning from the spicy combo. I tried some of hers and felt fine so take that as you will! read more

Tokyo Sushi - Shrimp Shrimp yaki udon and spicy combo - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Don't let the outside of this place fool you. This restaurant is in a house that looks run down on the outside, but it is super cool and clean on the inside. The teriyaki chicken and shrimp had a good flavor without being too sweet. The chicken was a little too tough but the shrimp were cooked right, along with the veggies. read more

Tokyo Sushi - Teriyaki Chicken and Shrimp - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

I usually find a sushi place when traveling and found this place. It's in a converted house, so parking is a little challenging. The fish was good, sushi selections were plenty. Staff checked in frequently and kept my iced green tea filled and plates cleared. Being in a house, it was cozy, the booths were comfortable and clean. A lake view would have been cool, but can't have it all! read more

Excellent service and sushi. It's in a converted home in a neighborhood. Really cute atmosphere.

Cute little place nestled away in what looks like a home. Great food and a great price too. The waiters and waitresses were friendly and quick with our food. Definitely recommend! read more

Stopped in on a Saturday night for a late dinner before a comedy show. This restaurant is in a converted house and has a nice atmosphere. I found street parking right out front. The sushi is 5 stars: excellent quality. And extremely reasonably priced. The service was 3 stars. Not particularly friendly (didn't check on me once after I ordered, didn't offer water, etc) Another server noticed I hadn't been checked on and took over/was much more attentive but also had other tables. Maybe I caught my server on a bad night, it happens. I'd still go back, the sushi was excellent, I'd just maybe do carry-out next time. read more

Tokyo Sushi - Tri Color Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

If I could rate this a 4.5 I would. It was very good. I may have finally found my go-to sushi place in town. I tried some nearer to our house but for a variety of reasons they just did not do it for me. After checking reviews we decided to try this place on a weeknight. We got there relatively early and we were glad we did because all of the booths quickly filled up by 6pm. The decor was light and modern. Our order was taken quickly and the food came out fast. I got a beer and three cooked sushi rolls. The spicy California roll was good but not really spicy, a smoked salmon roll was also good but the cream cheese was almost too much, and the tempura shrimp roll was excellent. My wife got the vegetable bento box and really liked it a lot. One of the big plusses was that the prices were very reasonable - a rarity these days. We will return. read more

Tokyo Sushi - Beverage menu - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

I had lunch from here on a weekday. The place was not busy. I went for the lunch special with 3 sushi rolls. It came with miso soup. Spicy salmon was my favorite sushi followed by shrimp tempura. California roll was ok. I noticed others ordering all sushi starting with the word "spicy". I think that is the right strategy. All their spicy shushis should be the best ones. I wish I knew this before. read more

Tokyo Sushi - Lunch special - shrimp tempura, spicy salmon, California roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Hands down best sushi in Madison! This restaurant is super cute and located in an old house on Willy street. Tons of seating indoor and outdoors and it's always spotless. Street parking is fairly easy to find in the area as well. Their vegetarian sushi is seriously my favorite and is always so so delicious. Staff are super sweet and attentive and I'm just constantly dreaming about eating at this place again read more

Tokyo Sushi - Sweet Potato Tempura Roll, Vegetable Rainbow Roll, Asparagus Tempura Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

This is a solid 3.5 star restaurant located in what used to be a home. I ordered the sushi deluxe, Toro sushi, some hot sake and green tea cream. The ice cream was really good but probably, a pre packaged kind and not fresh made. The reason for the 3 stars is the quality of fish. Although, prices are reasonable, it does reflect in the quality. Nothing was bad or it didn't smell fishy, it just wasn't high quality of salmon, tuna, yellowtail or snapper. The toro too missed the mark and it wasn't your melt in the mouth goodness. Unfortunately, this would be a hard pass for me in the future. read more

We loved our Alaskan rolls today. Great quality tuna, salmon, and red snapper nigiri and sashimi. It's a cute place with comfortable booths and our waiter was attentive. read more

The best sushi in Madison and such a great price! Super friendly staff always as well. Great place to go to!

Fun place, good atmosphere, intriguing food. My first time to a real sushi place - I was impressed. Food was fresh and very tasty. Menu was straightforward with a reasonable number of choices. We stuffed ourselves with the cooked sushi items - too many to name. I did like the spicy salmon, shrimp tempura and California rolls. Prices were modest and service was fast. Would return to broaden our experience. Highly recommend without any reservations. read more

Everything is amazing！We All Enjoyed it!The service is friendly and sushi tastes so fresh.We got volcano Roll ,crazy dragon roll and New York roll.We love it!Definitely will recommend it to everyone who loves sushi!. read more

Cute little restaurant. Went on a Thursday for lunch early afternoon. Seated in the bar area. Had their lunch special - California roll with two pieces each of tuna and salmon sushi. I also ordered their gyoza which was fried not pan fried. Arrived hot and had a good flavor. The roll and sushi were very good. Service was fast and efficient. read more

Tokyo Sushi - Lunch special - rainbow roll and tuna/salmon sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

We were able to reserve a table of 8 to have dinner with the family. Cute little place that we stumbled upon. Ordered the love boat for all of us to share. My husband and I got the full moon roll, chicken & beef habachi, seaweed salad and age tofu. All were delicious. The rolls didn't have a lot of rice which I like! The habachi came in a hot plate - sizzling hot! The love boat was perfect for all of us to share. The server was nice and service was fast. read more

See all

Is it house or a superb sushi place? The answer is yes. Housed in a literal house Tokyo Sushi is as homey as I could expect a sushi place to be. The staff was so kind and diligent and since we came at 2:30 on a Sunday, we were basically Home Alone! This place is great value for great quality. The sushi was superb! Wonderfully fresh and filling. I came on my birthday and was very kindly gifted me this fried cheesecake which was so delicious! This'll be a new go to sushi place for me. TLDR: It's cozy and it's sushi. read more

See all

Food - authentic, well made, lots of flavor. Raw sushi rolls have fresh fish, clean. Cooked sushi rolls also excellent. Here is everything we had and couldn't recommend more: - shrimp yakisoba - queen roll - miso soup - black pearl roll (too much mayo for my taste) - gordon ocean roll - alaskan roll (best I've had w/the most avocado) - eel roll - salmon fried rice (salmon cooked perfectly) - dessert: fried cheesecake - very good! Ambiance: Very homey and cozy. I was a bit shocked when we came upon the restaurant because it looks like a house. They get a lot of business so expect to wait if you don't have a reservation. Seats could be more comfortable. Booth seats pretty shallow. Bathrooms were clean. Service: Understaffed it seemed but they tried the best they could. Very kind and thoughtful. read more

Tokyo Sushi - Top: Queen Roll Middle: eel roll Bottom: Alaskan Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

I've eaten here twice and both times the food was delicious. The service was great, and the restaurant is quite small, yet cozy. Definitely not great for big parties. It looks like they have a nice patio for the warmer months. Great location as well, but plan on street parking, like most of Willy St. I wouldn't say the portions are huge, but the food is really good! read more

I don't like deducting a star for a great food place but the wait time was very long on being acknowledged, order taken, and food brought out. I realize good help is very hard to find, but it looked like only one waitress for the entire restaurant. Almost an hour from being seated until the food arrived. Despite that the decor is cute, intimate, and good lighting. The food pricing is very fair, below market I feel. The sushi itself was very fresh and incredible! Lots of options to pick from on the menu as well. Parking available on the street, can be a bit difficult and you may need to park a block away but nothing too crazy. I would definitely come back here in the future! read more

See all

Went here after a recommendation on a Madison food group based on the quality of the fish, and it didn't disappoint. Excellent rolls especially for the price. The staff is also very friendly! It's been empty every time we go to get carry out, which I don't understand because it's very good and cute. Highly recommend! read more

Tokyo Sushi - Tsunami Roll, tuna avocado, tuna roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Best sushi in Madison! Love this repurposed home on Willy Street. The sushi rolls are like a piece of artwork! Very cool spot to watch the chefs create their delicious food. Chefs kiss Very friendly people, sleek decor, clean bathrooms & decent street parking. read more

Amazing place! Would recommend for a date night or even take out. Staff were very friendly and attending to all customers. Great quality food at an unbeatable price. read more

Tokyo Sushi - Chicken Teriyaki Bento Box Dinner Dragon Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Visited Tokyo Sushi Friday night at 8 pm. The venue was packed at the time, but I had made a reservation in advance (definitely do it for the weekends/Friday). I ordered the tuna, salmon, and a specialty sushi roll along with beef yaki soba. The tuna and salmon rolls were filled with fish and they tasted fresh. The specialty roll had a lot of unique flavor and was also tasted good. The rolls came out within 10 minutes of ordering which was really nice. The beef yaki soba was very flavorful and the steak that was used was very delicious. The yaki soba noodles were a bit thinner than expected and pretty oily, but they tasted good nonetheless. Overall, would recommend to anyone who is looking for sushi at a reasonable price! read more

Tokyo Sushi - Beef Yaki Soba - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Excellent experience dining in at Tokyo Sushi! Every roll we have had so far has been delicious, we decided to order the Tokyo Love Boat and try a variety of sushi and sashimi. Beautiful presentation and fresh flavors. The staff is super friendly and attentive, bringing us more wasabi and waters when we ran out. We like it spicy! For the reasonable prices, great quality, and nice service, this is my absolute favorite sushi spot in Madison. read more

Tokyo Sushi - Tokyo Love Boat - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

First of all, I started to take pictures of the menu to help the people of the Internet out because Tokyo Sushi doesn't have a website or any way to view the menu. I soon began to regret my decision as flipping the pages started to seem endless. My biggest pet peeve in restaurants is a giant menu. There is no way a restaurant can commit to a giant menu and do it well. So, when it came time to order, the server was incredibly confused and had to reference the menu when I said my order. My order came with soup or salad, which by the way, the menu says "soup AND salad" but it was scribbled out with a black pen. The menu is black. Anyway, the server neglected to ask if I wanted soup or salad. Then I had to ask for it to be brought to me. Another iffy encounter: my SO ordered sake. The server took the order and left. Minutes later, comes back and asks to see his ID. And then looks very confused afterwards. But he brought the sake eventually. The decor is also questionable. They have pendant lamps placed so low that you can't see the person across from you. OKAY, anyway, if you don't read any of that, read this. I ordered a sushi bar entree - I've already forgotten what it is called. It was 8 pieces of sushi and a Godzilla roll. As soon as I picked up the sushi (not the Godzilla roll), it completely fell apart! The rice just crumbled. All I was holding with my chopsticks was the fish. I tried to use my hand, but that was also unsuccessful. Yeah, so I think if you're going to pay these prices for sushi, you're better off at Muramoto or RED. Sushi rice integrity is subpar. read more

See all

Great little place. Solid sushi and good service. A bit tight in space but it works.

will definitely be back! The value for the price is incredible. My boyfriend and I both loved our food, it was delicious and as described. I tried his grilled teriyaki salmon and it was incredible, it was soft and tender but had a perfect crunch to it from the grill. Sushi was great, the rice was a good consistency and the veggies in the veggie roll were crunchy and yummy. The service was great too! Very attentive and refilled our waters a few times, took our plates pretty quickly, and checked to make sure everything was good. Very friendly staff. Plus they had this cute outdoor seating that I will try next time I go. Some things to note- they said they are still working on getting their liquor license, so we couldn't order alcohol. Also, sounded like due to Covid they've been having trouble getting some of their food shipments in, (we got veggie dumplings and they were different than they're old kind) but the staff were super friendly, helpful, and upfront about everything. All in all, cute inside, great service, delicious food, and great prices. Highly recommend. read more

See all

I suggest not going there on weekends, as the kitchen prepares food very quickly ，but the sushi food is not only slow and unpalatable ,but the steward attitude is also poor .It is suggested to increase the number of service personnel to improve the quality of service. However, there is a good restaurant called (SUSHI LOVE）which is cheap and delicious ！ read more

Had an excellent meal on the patio. Service was good, prompt and not intrusive. The waiter didn't have a great handle on the menu, but that was t an issue at all. The patio could use better tables as the umbrella was directly between two sitting at the table, and there were ants everywhere, so I would stick to the inside. The fish quality was super, and the speed of execution with great flourishes on the dishes was to be applauded. The hot house sake was very tasty and a great deal for the price, I would recommend and sake lovers give it a try. read more

Tokyo Sushi - Sushi - chirashi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

The most amazing food and incredible customer service for unbeatable prices! And the fact that you walk into a house and suddenly it's this beautiful seating area! We sat at the sushi bar and I absolutely will be back! Best Anniversary Dinner read more

Tokyo Sushi - Tiger Roll Alaskan Roll Sweet Potato Tempura Roll Super Tokyo Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Extremely cute resturant! We went here for dinner and the place is basically a house transformed into a resturant which is really cool. All the servers were very friendly. The downstairs area was very crowded so we were seated upstairs. Very nice decor and everything was extremely clean. The sushi was very good and you could tell the fish was high quality and fresh. Only recommendation I would make is maybe turning up the volume of the music upstairs. There were three other couples upstairs with us and it was so quiet that we could hear every word of each conversation. Perhaps a little louder music upstairs may help! read more

See all

Sushi is not delicious, the quality is average, especially salmon is very bad, and there will be symptoms of vomiting and diarrhea. The service attitude is bad, the buffet service mode, the service is colorful, there is no penny, no thank you, I feel disappointed, I don't want to go to this place again! read more