I've purchased two sets of Nokian Tires for my Jeep and Subaru - awesome tires in the snow/rain/dry road conditions. The guys here are first rate - no bs add-ons like every other tire shop. After the big snowstorm, my car was vibrating/shaking when I hit speeds of 35+. Stopped in to ask them if they could help - they told me the cause was ice/snow trapped in the wheel well and to simply get a car wash. If only all car issues were remedied by a car wash! Their honesty and dedication to customer satisfaction is unparalleled. If you're not buying your tires here, you are missing out! read more

Had a tire that kept going low. Took the car to The Tire Store and was in and out in less than 30 minutes. They found a nail in the tire. Plugged and fixed. The best thing...No Charge!!! read more

Today was the second time that I've bought tires from these guys and left with the tire sensors IMMEDIATELY not working properly and then I have to pay to replace them. I won't be going back there. This hasn't happened anywhere else read more

Great prices and Mike recommended a much quieter tire than what my Bronco came with. Love the new Falken tires and great prices and most friendly tires store around! Highly recommend!!! read more

I have used The Tire Store for about 8 years. Always friendly, excellent service and reasonable prices. There is no reason to go anywhere else! read more

even if you're not close by it's worth traveling to The Tire Store I walked in without an appointment they took me immediately, got me out quickly and their prices are very reasonable. on top of all that, they are the most customer oriented cordial guys.. Support a local business!!. Dump the big box stores. These guys have your back. I can't imagine any better service read more

Wonderful 1st time experience! Saved big time and got a cash discount! I be back. No hidden costs only discounts...loved it read more

When our car had a flat tire on the way to the beach and the spare tire was flat, we got a tow to the Tire Store! It is open on a Saturday which we learned many car places in the area are closed on the weekends. The staff was kind, quick and professional! We were back on the road in no time! I highly recommend them and wish we lived closer so we could use them again. read more

Tire Store - Tires Near Me - East Lyme, Connecticut

Consistently great. They mounted and balanced tires for me. They told me I had an additional steering issues and suggested I get those fixed before getting an alignment. At this point in my life I'd drive 2 to 3 times as far just to go here. Good honest shop. I got my wife's tires here a few months back, good price. read more

I had a bad day. I got a flat on the way to work. I was stressing about being able to get to the tire store before it closed at 5pm, as I get out of work shortly before then. I rolled up with my donut at 4:55pm, 5 minutes before closing and was greeted with a smile. The tire store went the extra mile. They stayed late. They plugged my tire and didn't try to upsell me. Then put my spare tire back into the very complex alcove and gave me a tee shirt to cheer me up. I went to check out, and the guy said it was on the house. I was just about in tears. I highly recommend the tire store. I will never go anywhere else. read more

If you live in southeastern ct I don't think there is a better alternative. Fast, competent, cost effective and friendly. Mike is fantastic.

Great store, they work very quickly and staff is super responsive. They take walk-ins for tire patches, and I didn't even have to pay since I got the tires at the store. The only thing I will say is you should call ahead if you're planning to get your tires rotated or especially to get new tires, because I believe they don't take walk-ins for that. But for quick service on your tires I would 100% recommend. read more

Excellent! They were helpful, friendly and responsive. They patched my new tire after a big fat nail snuck into one of my tires. I was patched up, good as new, and ready to go in less than 10 minutes. These guys saved my morning! read more

Great place Good prices and excellent work It's been over a month and car drives really well read more

Tire Store - Love these tires - Tires Near Me - East Lyme, Connecticut

When the cats away the mice will play took over 2 hours and only 2 other customers around. I had a scheduled appointment and that obviously didn't help me either. If the owner isn't around stay away. read more

Blew my tire out yesterday and got it replaced within the hour today. Knowledgeable and reliable people.

Excellent customer service and friendly staff. In and out with 2 tires installed 15 min at most. Never going to town fair tire again.

Great place to go for tires, fast and cheaper than everyone else in the area, I'd recommend stopping here first to exchange prices and appointment availability, worth the time to save a little read more

Purchased 4 new tires along with an alignment. Noticed a new scratch on the bumper that was dismissed as "could not have happened here". Been a customer for several years. They lost my trust - not a customer anymore. read more

good price on tires, but for me that's as good as it gets. They put new tires on my truck. I picked the truck up and never looked at the wheels on the passenger side. I get home and one of the center caps is missing. I went back the next day and was told it was gone when I brought it in. Sorry- no it was not. These wheels are Dodge Motor sport limited production, no longer available. Thanks Guys. I'm sure their service is normally good and this was a one off situation, but the way it was handled it -with denial- was poor. read more

I have been going here for years but NO MORE! They are in too big of a hurry. They strip lug nuts and to top it off I had to go to the dealership to get the replacement. ( I think they broke it they should replace it) Yesterday was the final straw. I bought a set of four truck tires but the one required so much weight to balance it is ridiculous. It clearly is a defective tire and they refuse to fix it. This may come to legal action. Having been in the tire biz before I know this much weight is absurd. I won't be back!!!! Fast, Yes they are fast. So fast they break stuff and do unsatisfactory work. Well, I posted this to find out that Yelp really does not want to post negative reviews no matter how true if they don't really know anything about me the customer. I get it. However, I would not have taken time out of my life to write it had I not had such a bad experience. read more

Tire Store - No new tire should need this much weight - Tires Near Me - East Lyme, Connecticut

I got 2 flat tires and went over first thing not realizing they are appointment only now but they got me right in and patched the tires at no charge. What could've been overwhelming was a really nice surprise and we will be back for our next set of tires! Thank you to everyone there! read more

I recently had a set of tires mounted on Pontiac honeycomb wheels, which have a removable center cap. The tire store removed the center caps when they balanced the wheels and irreparably damaged 3 of the four caps. When I noticed the damage 20 minutes after picking the tires up and getting ready to reinstall the caps I called the tire store. The gentleman who answered the phone eventually apologized for the damage but also stated that I should not have brought the wheels in with the caps installed. They had no interest in replacing the parts they had damaged, so now I'm out $163.69 for a replacement set. The tires look like the were mounted and installed correctly; at least there is a small silver lining. read more

Thank you to Mike and his staff at the Tire Store. This is the only place that I have done business with for my tires since 2009. Sadly, I was hit by a drunk driver in 2019 and my garage put tires on from another place. My garage is the best, but I have had nothing but problems with these tires since they went on. I have NEVER had any problems with any tires that I got from the Tire Store. Last night I found a screw in my tire the night before I had to go to Yale New Haven. I went fist thing to the Tire Store and they took care of me in no time at all, AND they can fix the issue with the tires even though they weren't purchased there for a fair price. Honestly, if you are going anywhere but the tire store, you're making a mistake. THEY ARE THE BEST!!! read more

I've purchased tires her for years now and have always had a great experience. Friendly service and good prices. Thank you Tire Store. Theresa read more

Are you kidding me? I called the day before to make an appointment for a car alignment. They don't make appointments until they begin to put snow tires on. Okay makes sense, no big deal. I tell the man on the phone I would be in tomorrow (Wednesday) for the alignment. I get there, long line, again not a big deal. The women a few spots ahead of me was going over the paper work with the desk clerk. I hear him say very clearly that her car needed an alignment so they took care of it. I wait few more minutes and its my turn. I kindly tell the man I needed an alignment. He then proceeds to tell me to come back tomorrow because his "alignment guy" doesn't work today. SO how was the lady before me able to get her car taken care of, then I'm told to come back tomorrow? I was kind of in shock... didn't bother to question the guy. Maybe he thought I was too young and blonde to notice? I could understand if I didnt make an appointment but they don't allow you to. Also why didn't the guy on the phone when I called the day before tell me the "alignment guy" would not be in the next day. GIANT waste of time. Will definitely not be coming back. Went to TFT in New London and was in and out within 35 minutes without issue. read more

I had an appointment, and still waited OVER AN HOUR for 15 minutes worth of service. I've been coming here for over 3 years and will never come back. Would rather pay more to go somewhere that honors appointment times, not accommodating multiple walk-ins... read more

I strongly anyone who needs tires to go to The Tire Store in East Lyme. We were told at Midas that we needed a new tire, quoted $180. I called the tire store, quoted $145 (and they offer military discount), we get there and they said we didn't even need a new tire. THEN as if it could get any better.... THEY DIDN'T CHARGE FOR FIXING IT! Amazing. Highly recommend, great company, and HONEST. We will be going to them for all our tire needs while stationed here in CT. read more

These guys always give us a great deal, never oversell, and keep our family's cars safe and road ready. They're fast and convenient and also very professional knowledgeable. read more

These guys are great. No matter how busy they are they are always polite and professional. Classic local business. With all due respect to the larger stores this is the reason you support a local businessman. read more

These guys were great! Fair prices and wonderful service, I will continue to come here for tires in the future.

Reasonably priced tires, awful service. Brought my car in to have tires done and they lost a lug nut cover. Worker came back with one that was a different color entirely and asked if it would work. After losing a customers item a business should offer to reimburse them for it. The worker simply turned his back and went back to work. Great place to go to if you want a job done. Horrible to go to if you want the job done correctly. Snubbing a repeat customer is never a good idea. read more

They put tires on my truck . After driving the truck it was shaking so much on the highway. I pulled over at a gas station only to realized that almost all the lugs nuts to my passenger side tire were gone except one which was barely hanging on . I had to tow it to a shop. I called them to explain but they were not helpful. It could have been a bad day for me had I not pulled over at the gas station. The guys work so fast and overlook other stuff, My lug nuts were never tightened right and I am lucky to live to give this review. Please take your time and do the job right. read more

I won't go anywhere else! Quick, efficient, honest and trustworthy. I recommend to anyone and everyone. Support your local business!

My husband got a flat tire and I brought the tire here to see if they could fix it. It was already almost 5pm when they close, but when I called before hand the guy said he would wait for me to come. I got there and they came and took the tire out of the bed of the truck, checked it, filled it back up, and then came and put it back on the truck. When I asked about payment the guy told me there was no charge. I couldn't believe how nice and helpful they were even though it was my first time there. This is definitely my new tire store. Everyone was friendly and willing to help. I highly recommend this place! read more

Went there on a friend's recommendation. Quoted over the phone, left rear wheels (rear) since I had run flats. Picked them up the next morning, went back with car for install of other wheels and front end alignment. Great people and quick and even charged me less than what was quoted. read more

Ive been going to the tire store for years. They go above and beyond every time I've needed them. HIGHLY RECOMMEND

The guys at The Tire Store were WONDERFUL! I discovered a screw in my tire at 4:30 on the Friday of a holiday weekend. I called and they said to come right over. They fixed it with a simile. They were well oiled machine, very efficient! Within ten minutes I was on my way again. Thank you! I will definitely be back. They are the best! read more

I absolutely love coming here to do buisness with these guys. Fast, friendly, and efficient! I highly recommend them to anyone and do so by word of mouth all the time. I will happily continue to bring my cars here for many many years. read more