I've been going to the Tire Place for years. Originally for routine oil changes and my yearly…read morestate inspections, and now for all my car related stuff, and I've always had a great experience. Cathy is incredibly honest, trustworthy, and goes above and beyond for her customers. As a woman, I've definitely felt taken advantage of by other mechanics in the past, so finding someone I can truly trust means a lot to me. I recently had a strange issue with my car where the check engine light kept staying on. Cathy's team did multiple checks, over multiple days, and eventually solved the problem for me, at an incredibly reasonable price. What I appreciate most is that I never feel like I'm being scammed or pushed into unnecessary repairs. I genuinely trust Cathy and her team with my car, and that is not something I take lightly. She is honest, reliable, and clearly cares about doing the right thing for her customers. I highly recommend this place, especially if you're looking for a mechanic you can actually trust.

Cathy and her team were very helpful. I told them what was going on with the car, and they checked…read moreeverything and rotated my tires. It was actually a good experience and I will be coming back

Very good service. Friendly and reasonably priced. No job to small, anything you need they will…read morehelp you.

These guys were great. Reasonably priced and very friendly for an emergency tire change. Quick…read moreresponse. I couldn't be happier with their service.

I visited this location today as i was reffered and unfortunately, my experience was highly…read moreunprofessional. Upon entry I spoke with a representative named Rishi who was very dismissive and unwilling to assist me, he was very dismissive and rude As a first time customer, I expected better communication and basic courtesy. I hope the management takes this feedback seriously, as I cannot recommend this business based on this experience.

I came in, without an appointment to get my tires checked out for uneven roll and put wheel locks…read moreon.But, after Isaiah test drove and after checking my vehicle on the lift for warn shocks and warped tires, I was assured I was safe. I appreciate honesty, caring service and prompt service. By the they have great lift equipment. I recommend this neighborhood location.

Good fast service friendly people, amazing prices and deals. Got a plug done for the low. Happy…read moreHonda, happy life :3

Very convenient if you having an issue with your tire at anytime of the day. However pay cash…read morebecause they told me if I had paid credit I'd be taxed. Which I'm fine with however when they said "taxed" they meant that they were going to include their own tip to the total.

Came in to get my wheels balanced while taking the knots off the car he ruined all of them on both…read moreside claiming that its toyota car problem when I go to other shops and everything seems to be fine. Then has the audacity to tell me that all of them had to be changed even though the condition I brought my car in was better then I left

Always the best service very quick efficient , these guys play no games they get to it.read more

Very accurate and fast service! Best tire shop out there. They're very helpful and professional,…read moreand price ranges are very reasonable, and they are very nice people! They have the ability to plug a tire without even using a lift/jack, they are very experienced in tire work. Also have a large variety of used and new tires! (Ask for Brandon or Bobby)5+stars!

From the owner: sell new &used tires and rims also do flat fixread more

Great experience at Whiteys once again. Got 4 tires put on my truck yesterday. Ordered the day…read morebefore delivered next day. Called me as soon as they arrived and once I got there multiple gentlemen did their thing removing the old, balancing and installing the new ones like a seasoned pit crew. Everyone was super friendly and professional. Whenever I need tires it's automatic where I'm going. Whiteys always does the right thing. Thank you guys.

I'm clearly living such a charmed life! I Just came off the…read moreJ train in Brooklyn from an all day training in lower Manhattan. I could tell that I had a flat tire. And there was also a not very angry note in my windshield (in both Spanish and English) telling me that I had parked all day partially blocking a long residential parking driveway. Get this: no ticket, no problem with the car. And I was 4-5 blocks from Whitey's tire service. Enormous tire place (on BOTH Sides of Atlantic Avenue). AND When I slowly rolled up, three guys were waiting there chitchatting and directed me inside. I jokingly got out of the car and said, "I just need an oil change." Then I found the boss and told him don't bother changing the flat, sell me 4 new tires. They are putting them on for $520 total. Nice, right? Highly recommend this place

Atlantic Tire shop was able to help me get on my way after getting a flat tire on the highway…read more Appreciated the quick and effective service.

By all outside appearances, the curb side appeal won't grab your attention, but when hobbling on…read morethree working wheels down Atlantic, the appeal is tremendous. The hubcap adorned entrance you just know were once part of a cars rim that shot off upon the Ho Che Min NYC roadways. Once my car was up, upon the dual floorjacks and the tire was pulled, the intruder was found, pulled out and plugged up. What a great bargain for all of the work that is required to get me rolling again.

I needed one run-flat tire and had already gone to two different locations with no luck. When I…read morecame to Cross Island Tire, they told me they had one available for $100 which was great. I was actually prepared to buy four tires since I couldn't find just one used run-flat anywhere else. The service was awesome, quick, easy, and the guys were really nice. The location is a little tricky to get out of, but getting in wasn't a problem. Overall, I have no complaints and would definitely go back if I needed to.

Went to get a tire mounted and the rest of my wheels balanced on my Mustang. Very nice and friendly…read morepeople , did a great job

I got a flat tire and had a brand-new spare in my trunk. The worker took off my flat and said he…read morewould swap it with the spare, but instead he took my new tire into the shop, damaged it, and then told me it was no good. This place is a scam. He originally said it would cost $20, so I sent him $23 on Zelle, and then afterward he claimed he said $30. He was dishonest, left me with a flat tire, and then refused to even put air in it.

I went last Saturday 11/1/2025 and this people screw me , charge me $120 dollars for 19 inch used…read moretires, that is the most expensive used tire I pay in my life. Please don't go there never.