Timothy Jay Sweets is a wonderful place to go. It's a wonderful guy that learned his crafts from his mother and he went to culinary school and he makes gluten-free stuff. He makes cake, pops cakes, cupcakes, devil dogs, all different stuff. Great atmosphere great ambience clean great customer service. if I could give it 50 stars out of 50, I would. read more

What a great bakery. I stopped in here on my way out of town and enjoyed some of the most delicious cupcakes ever!! Timothy is an amazing person (and baker)......he truly is an ace at what he does. read more

We stopped by here to grab some pastries for our guests. It looks like a small family run business, which is confirmed on their website. I liked their about section, and a few excerpts follow: I love to provide baked goods and help make your day a little sweeter! With cupcakes, cookies, whoopie pies, cake balls, cheesecakes and more; you are sure to discover something sweet that puts a bounce in your step. I love baking so much that I even received a Baking Award when I graduated High School. I started baking desserts and custom cakes here and there for my friends and family for fun. Realizing how much fun it was to bring joy to someone by adding a bit of sparkle to their celebration was rewarding to say the least. I realized I wanted to share my talents with everyone and open a bakery! Hard work and passion for turning flour, sugar, and eggs into something beautiful is what really bakes my cakes! We bake the world a better place, one treat at a time. Their display case looked really appetizing, and the pastries did not disappoint. Their whoopie pies really deserve a "Whoopie - these are great"! Their pistachio and chocolate fudge cookies were excellent. And I'd suggest trying Boston Cream Cupcake too! They were all wearing masks, and masks are mandatory for patrons. Customer service was excellent. Order your custom cakes in advance as they can get busy. If you're in this area, we can strongly recommend. It's a sweet place! read more

Timothy Jay Sweets - Tasty treats! - Bakeries Near Me - Millbury, Massachusetts

See all

My friend and I recently stopped at this shop on a whim. What a great gem!! We were trying to decide which of the beautiful treats we wanted to try so we asked the owner Timothy Jay about the fillings and he was more than happy to give us a detailed description of each one!!! Timothy Jay is delightful, we ended up talking about all sorts of things with him and he had us laughing. I picked a white chocolate raspberry cupcake for my mom and husband and a triple chocolate for myself. My cupcake was chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and real chocolate sprinkles (not the candy sprinkles you usually get...these will actually melt if you were to hold them in your hands)on top. It was amazing... I'm usually not a big frosting lover, but that ganache was perfect. I also had one of his peanut butter cookies that he makes using his moms recipe and that was also delicious. We will definitely be returning to try some of his seasonal flavors (he has St Patrick's cupcakes now). Thank you Timothy!!! read more

See all

The best bakery! Everything is delicious, the owner is so kind and friendly. Highly recommend!!

Stopped by this little bakery to get cupcakes for my wife's birthday. It was great! The owner helped me immediately, answered all my questions and was really cool. I got a variety if cupcakes and treats and my wife loves them! I already clicked "5 stars", but beleive me, absolutely worth a visit. read more

Timothy's provided outstanding empathetic service when I was forced to cancel last minute (after the order was completed) due to a death in my family. Timothy was gracious and immediately said 'do not worry about anything, I will credit your card.' The bakery was highly recommended by so many for the quality, you can now add 6 star service to those recommendations. read more

The owner was expeditious in returning my call, answering all of my inquiries about a potential birthday cake order for. Then I Picked up my cake to find that the flowers that I requested were not present on the cake & it looked lot it was decorated but a 5th grader! It only got worse from there. I got home ready to enjoy my cake only to cut into it and have the knife resisting my knife at each layer (there were multiple layers of lemon filling) because of the hard crust that was on each cake pans contents, having the resistance on the knife exceeding that necessary to cut ANY of my other ANNUAL birthday cakes for the last 54 years! Now on to actually attempting to choke down the most dense piece of cake I've eaten in my entire life. It brought Christmas fruitcake to mind in its density. The buttercream frosting was thin & essentially tasteless despite allegedly being vanilla flavored, but dry and crumbled and cracked when cut. This was by far the worst cake I've had in my entire life! My sister went with me when I picked up the cake and purchased a cupcake, and the Baker told her about allowing it to reach room temperature before eating it. And some story about people having complained about them being cold. She did as directed and told me it was still disgusting and dry. My cake also was extremely dry despite being dense and flavorless. STAY AWAY FROM THIS BAKER OR YOU'LL BE WASTING YOUR MONEY. I SPENT NEARLY $50 FOR AN INEDIBLE CAKE! Note: Because of this experience. I am going to learn how to make my own birthday cake. Exactly the way I've been having it for the last 54 years. It's sad that I have to make my own birthday cake. Because a bakery has made such a terrible cake that you don't even wanna trust to other bakeries any longer. read more

Cupcakes were awful bought a couple for my grandson's bday hard not fresh and literally the weirdest frosting ever . Nasty and the frosting got hard like lard. For almost 8 bucks for 2 cupcakes I thought it would have been alot better. Ended up making boxed cupcakes with my own homemade frosting the owner was very nice but I was so disappointed they were not even fresh read more

The staff are wonderful very tasty I love their devil dogs and the peanut butter cookies make my drive from webster to Millbury worth the trip Also the cupcakes are delicious Go you will not be disappointed read more

This is my personal opinion. Your experience may vary. A recent visit has renewed my suspicion that highway robbery still exists and is alive and well in Millbury. I am also firmly convinced New Englanders have no idea as to quality food unless its deep fried if the previous reviews are to be believed. I sampled their hocus pocus, chocolate boston cream, and cookies and cream cupcakes and have just one word to describe the experience. GARBAGE! Heres a few more in case that didnt resonate. DISGUSTING! DISAPPOINTING! MY KINGDOM FOR AN ENTENMANNS! First, the icing is nasty, it has the consistency of and finishes on the palate, lips, teeth and tongue like it was made from lard. Not something I would expect from a $3.75 cupcake. Second, the cake itself was dense NOT fluffy, again a characteristic shared with lard baked goods. Not something I would expect from a $3.75 cupcake. Lastly, the cupcake was the size of a normal store bought product possibly a tiny bit smaller but hey lets give them the benefit of bad lighting. Not something I would expect from a $3.75 cupcake. In summation. These cupcakes are not tasty, not visually appealing and quite frankly an insult to real cupcakes. I have no issue with paying $3.75 for a decadent treat and had I known what awaited me I would have hi tailed it to dunkin donuts down the street. At least you know what youre getting and no one is going to mug you at the register. Figuratively of course. It is my opinion that you should pass this one by at warp speed. read more

Where to begin? Well, I was desperate to order a custom cake since the place I normally go to cancelled my order last minute, so I reached out to Timothy. He was gracious and kind enough to do my cake, and even did some of his own research to make sure my custom cake came out exactly as I wanted. Also, the pricing was very reasonable, especially considering the last minute custom order. Walking in, even with a N95 on, I was greeted with the most delicious smell. Everything was clean, and obviously there were markers to help guide customers in and out while abiding by social distancing guidelines. Timothy greeted me and then brought me back to see the cake. Holy Toledo, this man is a true artist. Aside from being one of the kindest people I've ever met (and I've met A LOT of people), he oozes passion for his craft. I've been to other cafes or bakeries multiple times a week for years and treated like a stranger, and yet in my first encounter with Timothy he made me feel welcomed. The cake was delicious. It was everything and more that I had hoped for. I truly believe this place can be successful, but it's going to take our local community to help it along throughout all the current restrictions. So, please go give this place a try, you won't be disappointed. read more

I'm really hoping this place becomes the next Millbury gem. Cupcakes, cookies, edible cookie dough and custom cake orders. The owners are friendly and fun and the place reflects their character. Looking forward to many future desserts from here. The chocolate covered strawberry cupcake was de-lish!!!!! read more

Timothy Jay Sweets - Smores, chocolate strawberry, triple chocolate, cheesecake with buttercream frosting, Oreo, peanut butter heaven - Bakeries Near Me - Millbury, Massachusetts

We wanted to try a new place for cupcakes and a small business. Unfortunately this store did not live up to expectations. We ordered 6 cupcakes and 3 cookies. The cupcakes were hard and stale and definitely not made the same day. The frosting reflected this as well. Same with the cookies. My 9 y/o poked at it and said he wouldn't eat it, which never happens. We will not be back. read more

Ordered custom cookies for my husband's 30th bday and sent him pictures of what I was looking for. He made suggestions to coloring and such, and the cookies turned out great! Also the best price around by far and I did some shopping around. Everyone at the party loved them! Can't wait to have him design my baby's smash cake for his first bday! read more

Love engaging with the staff . We placed a HUGE order for our baby shower recently everything looked very nice but the dessert were very dry. It was quite disappointing spending over $400.00 and it was very blah. I try to support local business but we won't be back for future party needs read more

Super polite owners. My daughter dropped her cupcakes as she got into the car. The owner gave us two new ones, free of charge. Not only are their cupcakes delicious but the customer service is just as satisfying. read more

The most delicious cupcakes I have had in a very long time! Seriously, these cupcakes are what I imagined the cupcakes taste like on Cupcake Wars on The Food Network. EVERY SINGLE CUPCAKE!! From the silky smooth, light and flavorful frosting to the soft moist cake. If you are a fan of cupcakes, you MUST try Timothy Jays! read more

Worth stopping at. The cupcakes were great and the person who took our order was welcoming and helpful with the food allergy questions I had. read more

Today was my first time here. The cookies are big & soft/chewy, which was great! Many other bakeries I have visited do not have soft cookies, so I was pleasantly surprised. I look forward to going back! read more

Simply amazing cupcakes! I bought 1/2 dozen and regret not getting a full dozen! Will definitely be going back for more. Everything looked amazing and smelled even better. read more

I ordered a cake for my wife's birthday, and it was delicious. The cake was an extremely moist gingerbread cake, the buttercream frosting was outstanding. I loved that the frosting was not overpoweringly sweet, it perfectly paired with the gingerbread cake. read more

Today we got a cake from Timothy Jay Sweets for my dad's birthday and it came out SO good! Not only did they make a beautiful cake but it tasted so good that even those of us who are not typically into cake loved it. We will definitely come here again and highly recommend their services! read more

Love this little shop, everything is wonderful and yummy, great service too, not only looks beautiful but tastes good too

Perfection & delicious! Moist cake, perfect texture and amazing icing. Probably the best carrot cake on the east coast! A cake straight out of magazine and the taste can't be beat. The desserts will bring a hum to your belly and a smile on your face. Don't wait for a special event to eat cake! Everyday is cake day! read more

Wonderful little gem of a bakery. Very fortunate to have this in Millbury, especially during the time of coronavirus. Everything I've tried is amazing but I would especially recommend the pistachio cupcake and the funfetti whoopie. If the virus is getting you down, go to Timothy Jay's for a pick me up read more

Could not have been happier with the service and the product provided by Timothy Jay Sweets! We requested a custom cake and it was delicious and decorated just as we requested. They were wonderful and so friendly to deal with! Will definitely go back! read more

Simply amazing! I ordered a custom cake for a co-worker's birthday, not only did it look great, it was probably the best cake I've ever eaten! And this sentiment was shared by everyone who tried it! Will be back to 'sample' many more items! read more

Simply outstanding. Excellent quality. Friendly service. Perfect location. Whether in need of something special for a party or just a midday pick-me-up, this shop is perfect. read more

Finally made it in today with all the construction!! Location is spotlessly clean and smells so so delicious!! They have a big variety of yummy goodies . They even have their homemade devil dogs . Everything was delicately delicious, can't wait to return. Oh, and the owner? Wonderful and such a sweetheart!! read more

YES! I love this place. Everything was incredible- I think my brother and I tried one of almost everything. We had trouble deciding our favorites because they were all so good. read more

As someone who likes to bake, I can tell when others are good bakers. This place is so good! They know what they are doing. Everything I've tried is so so delicious and the staff is super friendly. Highly recommend! I think this is better than a well known bakery business in Massachusetts that has been around for years. read more

I grew up on devil dogs and OMG, their devil dog is fantastic! Cupcakes also yummy, service great!

Awesome little bakery. We stopped in here after driving by a few times and I'm so glad we did. The owner was super friendly and they had a lot of appealing options. We got a couple of cupcakes and a couple whoopie pies. So far I have tried the pistachio cupcake and it was delicious! I would highly recommend stopping in here for some delicious desserts - now is the time to support these awesome small businesses! read more

We tried a cupcake and a chocolate chip cookies sandwich. Many times, the frosting on such items to be so sweet as to make me pucker up-not this time! The frosting was perfectly sweet, smooth, and deliciously creamy! We will be going back! read more