Great service, home made solid food. Had the broccoli cheese soup which had actual non mushy…read morebroccoli florets, and the broth wasn't too thick. Aldi had the Caesar salad with grilled chicken, and house made croutons. The salad was fresh and HUGE. All that for $15! What a nice little gem in this tiny rural town. Go!!!

High quality, fresh, delicious food and always good service. My husband and I love this place and…read morehighly recommend it!

Excellent! Seems of the beaten path, almost past it up. So glad we stopped. Pegs burger was a full…read moremeal...tasty! If you're ever close by do yourself a favor and stop! Stuffed!

Disregard the naysayers from a few years ago. This place is great! Very good food; friendly staff…read more We have been here before and stopped again today on a country ride from our home. We had my mother here a few years before she passed and she remarked "I want to stop here again the next time I come to see you"!

Went here for breakfast on a Saturday morning with my family and was very happily surprised. Great…read morefood, big portions (but I ate everything anyway), and good prices. The food is homecooked and delicious -- diner style food. Eggs, bacon, hashbrowns, omelettes, pancakes, the works! Our server was friendly, told us about the specials of the day, and kept our coffee cups full. There were multiple whole pies for sale in the cooler -- if I wasn't driving all the way back to Florida I would have taken a couple with me. They looked delicious. This is definitely the best place for breakfast in the area.

Makenzie brought us extra Root Beer to top off our floats, a they have Burritos/Wraps which are…read morequite hard to find in Ohio! Been there twice and the food is excellent! Gonna try the Sloppy Joe special for $7.99 next time, and the Bloody Mary Bar!

We were in town for a wedding staying at a local hotel and wanted to eat at a local diner, found…read morethis one it was close and had good ratings. It's in a cute little downtown. Easy to get to and find. Parking is on the street out front. Pretty easy. Menu is breakfast, lunch and dinner. Usual diner fare for all 3. We got the breakfast wrap which is eggs, choice of meat and veggies and cheese. You can pick the veggies. I got all the veggies. And a side of home fries. My partner got the big breakfast BLT with home fries. It took a bit so it's made to order. When it arrived it was hot off the grill. The wrap was grilled and it was melty and good. The home fries were chunky and crispy. Good!! Our server was very nice and attentive. No complaints. The be place is small but it can fit about 45 people. Menu variety is good. Prices aren't bad at all. If in the area it's definitely worth a try.

Amish Country at its best!…read more This is a gem of a restaurant. We found this place thanks to the great reviews on Yelp. We were not familiar with Baltic, Ohio, yet we were so happy we found this place. The staff was so friendly and welcoming, it felt like we were eating in someone's home. Christian, the manager, could have not done anything more to accommodate us. He really went out of his way to enhance our experience. Our waitress, Arlene, had told us she had been there for several years and you could really tell this by her ability to help us through the menu. She wanted to make sure we were completely satisfied. The menu was one like I had never seen before. Everything from a large breakfast selection to Wagyu and Prime steaks. I had the best Ruben sandwich I had ever eaten ( that is saying a lot). We also shared the Wagyu filet with hand cut fries and sweet potato fries. The steak was sautéed with fresh mushrooms and onions. The steak was seasoned to absolute perfection. You have to try this. I have posted pictures of the menu. Don't forget a side order of homemade mac & cheese. Their prices are extremely reasonable considering the quality of the food and the impeccable service. The decor is perfect. Simple yet very pretty. They even have a nice area (living room style) that we hung out in until our table was ready. This Amish restaurant is the "best of the best". I will be back in this area next year and will be sure to make this my go to restaurant. Bravo to the staff and chef, well done.

Frankly, I didn't hate or love it. I just don't see a reason to make a trip there other than a…read morelack of competition. Food = Jalapeño popper dip was good. Pork chop was cooked alright, but definitely needed a sauce to add some flavor as it was bland. Coconut mango rice was sad (my wife is filipino so she knows a bit about rice, mangoes, and coconut). I had the reuben and it was alright. I don't understand why all the steaks and fish are "market price" on the menu. This is not a fancier restaurant that serves wagyu, why can you not figure out how to price half of your meats? Service = Good with no problems. Restaurant = Stylish, Spacious, and Clean.

I came in with 3 others for a late lunch/early dinner one Sunday afternoon. There were only a few…read moreother diners in the dining area, but the bar looked a little busier. Our server was friendly and had our drinks out quickly. I ordered boneless wings in hot garlic and they were definitely hot! They weren't anything special, but exactly what I was expecting. I thought all of the prices on the menu were more than fair. Everyone at the table enjoyed their meals. The inside of the restaurant was recently renovated, we were told, and was open, warm wood tones and basic black metal furniture. The parking lot is located right outside, decently sized, and gravel.

We tried this place because my niece has been wanting to come here. We were not disappointed. The…read moreplace was clean and had a decent amount of seating. The other side has the bar and is just as big as the restaurant. Our waitress, Michelle, was so friendly, answered any questions we had and gave us our food pretty quickly. She made sure we had everything we needed. I started off with their Bosco stick which is a mozzarella stuffed breadstick served with marinara. It had so much cheese and was just really good. The only thing I would change, would be to serve the sauce warm. Then I ordered the beer cheeseburger, which is just a cheeseburger with beer cheese. This burger was so big, cooked really well and the beer cheese was awesome. I didn't get any sides with it, but the others in my party ordered the fries and they were good. My niece ordered the loaded nachos and there were so many, she only ate half of them. Overall, this place was a great choice. For the price, the portions sizes are huge. We will definitely be back!

The staff here is the best we've had in the Ohio Valley. Breakfast and Lunch menu are short and…read moresweet. Food is absolutely perfect. The only problem with this place is that it's not open for dinner. Great prices!

The service is great. The chicken drummers are so good. I would come back if I'm ever in the area…read moreagain.

Best coffee I've ever had, paired with delicious quiche. It's a must stop! The art work and mural…read moreis beautiful!

This was our first trip to Sarah's and definitely will not be our last. As soon as we walked in we…read morewere greeted by an amazingly friendly staff. There aren't a ton of tables but enough to accommodate 20-30 people in total across various tables. The menu was a little intimidating for me as brunch isn't anything I've ever had. But it's basically a breakfast menu and a lunch menu. They also have a nice bakery selection as well. I went with the caprese and a salad. I made a slight mistake and didn't read everything that came on the sandwich. As an avid carnivore I was a little disappointed to find out it was vegetarian, but that was before I tried it. The combination of the creamy mozzarella, tomato and balsamic was fantastic. It was probably one of the best sandwiches I've ever eaten. Im hoping the next time we stop in they aren't out of their salty bread to try with it. My wife tried the turkey, Brie and apple butter sandwich. Her's was my favorite of the two. They lightly toast the sandwich so everything is warm and creamy. The apple butter pairs nicely with the Brie and the smokey turkey. I'd recommend both of our sandwiches but if mine was an 8/10 hers was a 10 for me. I also had their house salad on the side. It wasn't anything extra special but the cranberries were a really nice touch to take it to the next level. If I had even one complaint to make it would be the hours. I'm sure they close at 2 because most people because they're a brunch spot, but with the quality of their food i would eat it for any meal of the day. I can't recommend it enough honestly.

Super satisfied with the quality of my meal. The service was friendly and fast. It's a cozy and…read morecomfortable spot, highly recommend.

The best "real" burger around. Definitely a freshly made burger. Never had a bad meal at The…read moreRestaurant.

The food was amazing; service superb and we got to meet and talk with the owners. It's a small…read morelocally owned place with that welcoming feeling

We had a great lunch at the Mill Street Diner on New Year's Eve. Not much was open in Amish Country…read morethat day so we felt lucky that they were open. They were steadily busy, but the staff was friendly and upbeat. It is in an old building that made you feel you had stepped back in time. Comfortable booths and high ceilings. Very homey feel. The food was hot and flavorful and not very expensive. We'll be back when we are in Sugarcreek again!