Oh the places you'll go! I'm sitting here on vacation drinking my coffee early morning in my tank…read moretop I got for $3 from the Toggery. This place is the best! We came here on a sleepy Saturday afternoon and hit the jackpot because they were having a sidewalk sale with very nice prices. I walked away with Talbots, Athleta, Rock and Republic, Free People on clearance and splurged on a Lululemon sweatshirt for full price (still under $40 so no complaints there). Not only are the prices great but this store will make any organized persons heart sing! Amazing organization and flow of the store, kudos Toggery! I will be making another trip here next time in the Broadripple area.

I found some designer jeans here for $50 that usually sell for about $200, and they are my favorite…read morego-to jeans, so that's cool. At first, I was a little disappointed in The Toggery because it seemed like the clothes were just a half step up from a regular Goodwill, but then I found the jeans, and now I'm not so sure. I think it all depends on when you shop, and what you're looking for. If you're looking for unusual vintage gems, you probably won't find that here. If you're looking for regional-trendy clothing ... you will probably find that here. I visited on a Saturday afternoon, and the racks seemed a little picked-through, but I think that's because this place is popular and so the racks probably were indeed picked through. They buy clothing during the weekdays, so if you want to find the good stuff, you should probably visit during the week, I'm thinking. The clothing is arranged very nicely, and everything is super organized and clean. They have dressing rooms available that you can just walk into (you don't have to flag down someone!), and they also have sale items that are pretty good. Like most consignment shops, they don't accept returns or exchanges, so make sure you're happy with your items before you purchase!

I liked this shop. I found plenty of fun clothes to check out. There were home decor items and…read morefurniture as well. It was a good sized store and I found plenty of items I liked. The prices were on the high side but they did have some items on sale. They had a big wall of designer purses behind the counters where you pay. They had jewelry also in the cases where you pay. I found some cute Betsey Johnson cat earrings that I purchased. There were a lot of unique items especially in the furniture they had. Make sure and bring a shopping bag as they are bagless. They had a lot of designer fashions and had the higher end items separated in their own section. They had a separate room also for the shoes. I am sure I will stop again when I am up in Carmel.

After my last review, the owner reached out to me to correct the situation. Originally I wanted to…read moregive Amanda's Exchange 5 stars until the shoe situation happened. Given the customer service, how beautiful the shop is and the wide variety of clothes they have at various price points - I've updated my review! I did really love the other items I bought. The owner reaching out and making the situation better really has left a lasting impression and I'm so grateful. You've definitely won me over as a regular customer.

I have always loved this vintage shop, I will say as the years go by it seems as though the items…read moreare not as much vintage as they are "gently used" I mean I guess anyone can find beauty in anything... it's still nostalgic & I now go with my daughter! I always make a B-line for the pins because I collect them & they have a huge selection that are nicely priced.

I LOVE THIS SHOP!!! The best vintage clothes-budget friendly and very people friendly-such a cool…read morevibe. Every time I go I leave with treasures and when I wear them, I always get compliments This is my new fav!

Fresh, dressed like a million bucks. This could be you if you visit Naptown Thrift. This vintage…read moreclothing store is situated in a questionable shopping center just outside of the SoBro neighborhood of Indianapolis, in one of those areas where if you blink, you might pass it. But when you find it, you'll see that these cats have a lotta good stuff. Mostly, you will find streetwear and novelty t-shirts and accessories at Naptown Thrift. Shirts run the gamut from band t-shirts, Mickey Mouse, sports, hobbies and other things. Have you been looking for a shirt that says, "It's five o'clock somewhere?" Do you need a hoodie that shows your undying love for Dayton Beach? Or maybe a ball cap with a black Labrador Retriever on it? This is the place for you. Speaking of ball caps, you'll also find lots of hats and caps, Indiana artwork for sale, posters, denim (both shorts and long pants), jackets and lots more. This thrift store skews toward the adult male, which is fine by me. I feel like we need more good vintage stores for the dudes around here. Dudes need places to find sick threads. Naptown Thrift is a great place to find such sick threads and wearable treasures.

I was out thrifting with my husband, when we ran across this shop east of Broad Ripple in a little…read morestrip mall. The shop, filled with secondhand logo wear, is amazingly neat and organized. The proprietor was friendly and engaging. He even suggested a few other nearby shops for us to check out. Several walls were filled with vintage local sport art. Colorful team hats hung from the ceiling. This is definitely a man cave dream shop. Racks were filled with vintage logo jackets, tee shirts and other sports wear. The place is really interesting. I didn't buy anything as I was really looking for houseware and I don't have a man cave. Parking is plentiful in the strip mall lot.

Clothing prices are equal to Goodwill, but unlike Goodwill, they do offer discounts. Each day of…read morethe week is a different discount type. Active military and first responders get 30% off every day. They have 1 fitting room and sell a few snacks and drinks. The place is pretty big, but parking lot is small. Staff is very friendly. 1st Sat of each month entire store is 50% off, no exceptions. DVDs =$1, books = $1 or less, most jewelry = $3 or less.

I was in there on 03/11/2026 I mentioned how their prices are out of control. The store supervisor…read morecame out and said if I didn't like it I could go to Goodwill and I said I know where Goodwill is. She continue to badger me grab the vacuum bags out of my hand and then grab the cart out of my hand and told me to get out I said I'll would like to make a donation to the homeless because she kept mentioning how the money goes to the homeless. I never felt so belittled in my life. I googled it but I'm not sure if it's right but it says it's battery if someone grabs something out of your hand so if that's true she shouldn't have grab the bags and the cart. As far as the homeless go if it wasn't a man I would have invited him into my house on them very extreme cold days we had but I'm a single woman that lives by myself. Where was that store supervisors time or money when it was really needed??

Been to this location on two separate occasions and on BOTH visits, when I thought I'd found a…read more"BACKYARD BARGIN," the woman manager decided to DOUBLE the items listed sticker price AT THE REGISTER because she thought they were priced too low. I'm no lawyer, but I believe that falls under false advertising! Honestly, the price isn't even the problem here. The issue is this poor management! I'd pay triple for an item I wanted if it was originally priced as such. But to change sticker prices mid-transaction because you think you can get more out of it is bad salesmanship! Moral of this story... time to get some new leadership at this location!

Stumbled upon this place cruising around Anderson and it's a gem! Tons of high quality antique…read morecollectables and randomness. Had some cool oil lanterns that hung on the wall for 3 bucks but I missed out. If you love findings treasures at flea markets and such then check them out.

Thanks to fellow Yelper, Richard P., I found this little thrift store, which is in the basement of…read moreSt. Paul's Episcopal Church. The thrift store is opened to the public and sells mostly clothes (women's, men's and children's ) and shoes, with also a bit of vintage jewelry and women's accessories. I like rummaging through thrift stores and looking for unique vintage items. The volunteer staff is super friendly and helpful. Changing rooms are available to try on clothing. The small shop is well organized. Prices are very reasonable and proceeds benefit the food pantry. Jewelry was marked half price during my visit. I found a stunning artisan necklace, which I regret not buying. The shop is located behind the church and there is plenty of parking. The shop maintains the same hours as the adjacent food pantry, so the hours vary.

I was fortunate to be able to catch the soft opening of Second Treasures, a thrift store opening up…read moreon a part-time schedule as part of Second Presbyterian Church's missions program. Second Treasures will be open about 10 hours a week with a particularly focus on supporting the needs of its Washington Township neighbors. It's patterned after the church's popular Bazaar and Clothing Sale and will support the work of the church's Women's Ministry. A good majority of the items are donated by church members and will be staffed by volunteers from the church. It's located at the North end of Second's Mission Suite (outside the Northside Food Pantry). The thrift store is opening to the public on Tuesday, April 23rd, and will be open on Tuesdays (12-3pm), Wednesdays (3:30-6:30pm), and Saturdays (9:30am-12:30pm). I was pleased with the items available and the prices at which they were marked. Clothing, of course, is quite popular here and there are items for men, women, children, etc. While you won't mistake this non-profit, church-based thrift store for one of the behemoths in terms of selection, this is a really cool idea for a great cause. Today's soft opening/open house was a great chance to get a feel for everything to be offered and how it all will work. Cash and credit cards are accepted. In terms of accessibility, there's plenty of accessible parking and doorways are pretty decent. This is on the first floor and accessibility should not be an issue. 5-stars might be a tad generous given the simplicity of the project, however, I'm always a fan of true non-profit, mission-based efforts and I'm anxious to see this one grow and truly support the Washington Township area.

Very nice antique shop. Lots to look at on the first level and upstairs. Decent prices on stuff…read more Totally worth a stop if in the area.

Was fun to shop here. Staff VERY NICE and HELPFUL, even calling a vendor to ask her about a piece…read moreI wanted to bu and texting me the answer later that evening.