Service was beyond horrendous! Had to ask several times for refills and every time we needed something the server was nowhere to be found for what felt like an eternity. Prolly 4/5 minutes in reality. When you're waiting to eat your food it feels like forever lol. It was a late Sunday afternoon and not busy either. The food was good but nothing worth what we paid! $145 w-tip plus some astronomical service fee for using a card instead of cash. If you want the luxury of accepting cards, you should be responsible for the fees. I'm over going places that charge me just to pay them. Either be a cash only establishment or don't charge fees for using cards! Bloody Mary was fire though! Atmosphere is cute and aesthetically pleasing but just really not worth the price. I think this might be one of the most overrated restaurants in the area. But there's not many seafood choices so I guess do with this review what you will! Be warned slow service and take cash. read more

Best chicken tenders. Nice and thin. Fast service. Nice staff. Great outdoor atmosphere. 10/10 read more

The Tin Fish - Chicken Tenders & Onion Rings - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Wish I could have known about this place but the drinks and food was wonderful. I had the lemon drop,wings, fried perch, and walleye. read more

The Tin Fish - Wings - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

See all

This morning we had brunch at Tin Fish in Newburgh. We've been there several times for dinner, but never realized they have a separate brunch menu for Sunday brunch (10:00 am - 2:00 pm). We were pleased to see that for brunch they have table service, rather than their usual order at the counter then they bring it to your table service. The menu had many things we wanted to try, but we finally decided on the crab cake benedict and the seafood pizza. The crab cake benedict was a split English muffin with each half topped with a crab cake, poached egg, and hollandaise. Everything about it was perfect. It's hard to find places that perfectly poach eggs - even most breakfast places around here don't often get it right. Tin Fish does! The crab cakes were very good and the hollandaise was as luscious and tangy as you want it to be. The seafood pizza was also delicious. I was surprised that it came with macaroni and cheese (the menu just says freshly crafted side, so maybe it changes), but I never mind getting unexpected pasta The pizza was very cheesy and had a generous amount seafood. I highly recommend squeezing the lemon slice that comes with it over the pizza. If I'm being picky, I felt the pizza could have benefitted from a touch of sherry in the sauce and maybe some capers or a drizzle of balsamic glaze as a bit of contrast to the very rich pizza toppings. But it was quite good as served and I had no trouble eating almost all of it - it's also a generous portion. Everything was delicious and we can't wait to go back and try more of the menu. In fact, we were sad that they don't offer that menu aside from brunch. They honestly could open another restaurant with just that menu and probably do very well. This post was made in connection with a Toast promotion. read more

See all

Food was great. The atmosphere is inviting and very spacious. The staff was amazing. small business locally owned. Just a great place to relax and have good meal and conversation. read more

What a great find! The fish and chips were fantastic, lightly breaded white fish with just the right crisp. I swapped the fries for onion rings, and it was the perfect choice. They're made in-house and perfectly crispy without being overly breaded. Service was friendly, food came out quickly, and the portions were just right for a weekday lunch. read more

This was an excellent find! The fish and chips are fantastic! Lightly breaded and fries white fish with the perfect layer of breading. I subbed onion rings for fries and that was a perfect fit! Onion rings are made in house and perfectly crispy as well without the excess breading. The service was friendly and the food was delivered quickly as well. Perfect portions for a weekday lunch! Highly recommended! read more

The Tin Fish - Oyster bar - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

We have been going to the Tin Fish for several years. The food has always been good. One of our favorite memories is taking our grandson since he was a baby and watching him enjoy a meal. read more

I have been here quite a few times now and every time it never disappoints. I've had fish tacos from one coast to the other and the tacos at Tim Fish are as good or better than any I've had! Well worth a visit if you haven't been! Service is always top notch as well! read more

Excellent food! The decor is so beautiful. I love the sea salt wall. The lemonade is yummy and the service outstanding

One of my favorite restaurants in Newburgh/Evansville. The outside patio is the best around during the summer. The food quality is very consistent. Employees are always so kind and helpful. My 5 year old loves this place which makes it a family favorite read more

This place is about the best place for seafood in the area. I like the tacos and calamari. The food quality is pretty consistent. The only thing I don't like is the way you order. You order at the counter. So, on a Saturday night if you have someone who's slow in ordering, the line can quickly back up to the door. They need to work on that. Food is good and outside seating is nice if it's a nice evening. read more

The Tin Fish - Trout - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

See all

Delicious food, the ladies were super nice and helpful and the restaurant was well kept. Would highly recommend! read more

The Tin Fish - Fried Calamari - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

See all

Food was really good! Service was great and they also have a great beer selection! Nice layout with plenty of seating. I'll definitely be back read more

Great food, great ambiance and outstanding service! We had my mom's birthday dinner here and they were very accommodating. Highly recommend!

I don't go to Newburgh very often, but this was a pretty cool place for all things seafood! You order up at front and the servers will bring the food to you when it's ready. I ordered the fish sandwich platter, which comes with waffle fries and cole slaw sides. The sandwich itself was very tasty, but the ratio of fish to bread could be better. The bread fell apart pretty quickly, which made the sandwich a little hard to eat at times. Regardless of that, I really did enjoy this restaurant! Staff was very friendly and the ambiance of the location was nice too. Definitely will be back to try more of the menu in the future! read more

The Tin Fish - Fish sandwich platter. Comes with waffle fries and cole slaw as part of the platter - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Brunch! Beautiful sunny March day to sit on patio and enjoy the new DELICIOUS Sunday brunch menu at Tin Fish. We stopped in with our dog after a long walk at Friedman Park and it was just delicious. We sampled the House herbed biscuits accompanied with a trio of honey butter, habanero jam and Bonne Maman preserves --the 3 large biscuits -served in a basket were warm and the trio a nice assortment to enjoy on them. We needed twice the amount of jam and preserves to spread on the biscuits and hope they add a bit more next time. We also had the New Yorker biscuit sandwich --which featured a tasty homemade sausage and town butter sage gravy -- But -the brunch showstopper was the Croque Madame! Not only a beautiful presentation --but the flavor profile was everything you could want in a memorable brunch dish. Sourdough covered in perfectly melted and broiled Swiss, ham and bechamel with a sunny egg on top. We will be back next Sunday for an order of 2 of the Croque Madames. read more

See all

We stopped at this restaurant during our trip out to the Midwest. They were a life-saver, as we needed a good solid dinner without having to pay too much or spend too much time waiting for our meal. Our order included the calamari appetizer, and Walleye, Orange Roughy, and Tilapia platters. The food was superior- fresh, tasty, and splendidly hit the spot. We were all satisfied with how delicious the meal was, and how accommodating the staff was in preparing our meal and having it ready right before they closed. So far, 5 Stars, right? The downside of this wonderful establishment is that the menu seems to be limited in its selection of sides- you pretty much have a choice of fried sides or a salad. I thought being in the Heartland, they would at least offer potatoes, or vegetable medley or a serving of corn. Additionally, I had my meal and part of an appetizer, and a drink, and still didn't feel quite full. Portions were not small, but they weren't large either. I would eat here again and again if I lived in this area, but it would be nice if they had a larger and more diverse menu with expanded sides, and maybe slightly less fried plates. Again, five stars for service and quality of food. Four stars overall. We'll hopefully be back some day! read more

For spending $300 plus on dinner and having to go to a counter to order your food and drinks?! It's an over rated long John silvers. Everything about this place is over rated. Atmosphere and service. Zero stars. Pathetic. Had to go to the counter to order. My brother from out of town from California had to deliver our drinks. There will be NO TIP. RIDICULOUS and NOT WORTH THE MONEY. We will NOT be back. read more

Like to go there on Sunday after church for fish tacos. Outstanding! Also, a good fish sandwich. Very attentive waitresses that circle the dining area to help. Will always come back. read more

Best shrimp & grits in town! Best fruit cup! New clam quiche is great. Needs hotter coffee. My favorite place for Sunday brunch. read more

Good food and service. Consistently prepared the same. Staff always friendly Great carry out service and nice dine in.

Really great place for gang stalking. Farbest turkey, so you know it's high quality from the most respected company. read more

The Tin Fish - the outside of a car dealership - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

We love tin fish. They have the best crew and the food is always cooked fresh. The brunch is a different menu with a lot of variety. The croque madam is my favorite!! read more

The food was so good that we recommended the Tin Fish to the guy that sold us our new phones. Definitely a come back spot. Can't wait to try more items. read more

See all

Was there for lunch. It's a very casual atmosphere. You order at the counter. Service was very friendly and checked on us several times. Our food was good. read more

Love Tin Fish. I love their new location on Sharon Rd and the way they've used the space. It's beautiful. Staff is always absolutely fantastic. It's nice to order at the counter as soon as you arrive, so you're not waiting to be greeted and served drinks and then apps and then get to order dinner. My only complaint is that while I love, love, LOVE that they've added cauliflower as an option to their entrees, there aren't a lot of options for vegetarians besides sides. The cauliflower is great, and very appreciated, but my family could eat Tin Fish every night and Mom can only eat so much cauliflower! read more

The food and service was excellent! The stuffed mushrooms are amazing. Hubby got the fish and shrimp, and both were very good! The broccoli was the perfect consistency and tasty! The waffle fries taste better than Chic-fil-aVery good, would recommend. read more

Clean, well taken care of, friendly staff...Veteran Supporting! Great food. Was very pleased with everything here. Will come again for sure! read more

Food was great. Loved the atmosphere. I had the fish and chips. Serving was large. Outdoor seating is really nice.

We come here every time we are in town visiting family. Amazing fish and chips and fish tacos.

We had the grilled trout and scallops which were cooked to perfection and so delicious! Would highly recommend this place. They serve alcohol too! read more

The Tin Fish - We went early to avoid a crowd. - Seafood Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

See all

Wow! Food was phenomenal and everyone was very friendly and accommodating with our 3 young kiddos (5, 3, and 1 year old).

Stopped in for brunch on Sunday because we've had other things here and really enjoyed them. We had the shrimp and grits and the crab cake Benedict. Just a heads up, the descriptions are woefully brief and incomplete in the menu. The shrimp and grits is somewhat New Orleans style with mushrooms in a rue and four large shrimp. No peppers, chives, gravy or heat of any kind. Also, it was $14 for a small bowl. The crab cakes had good flavor but are more Maryland style and not lump crab cakes. Won't be coming back for brunch, but maybe some mahi tacos later. read more

Gotta love Tin Fish! Been coming here since it opened with my friends and family and it's always amazing. The food is always delicious and the place is always clean. I admit that I miss the old location because of the nostalgia but the newer one has a beautiful modern look that you can't go wrong with. I highly recommend this place, and will continue to bring my friends and family here when the opportunity arises. read more

Great seafood and service is perfect. Bar staff make a great simple cocktail and willing to learn/try on things they don't know. Good casual stop for dinner. read more

Awesome decor and big upgrade from old location. Food was fabulous. Loved the vibe. Family friendly atmosphere. Will be back for sure.

Went there to try it out. The restaurant was nicely set up, the staff was polite and nice. The food came out quick and tasted good . Just not happy with what little food we got for the amount that was paid. Misleading description of what was ordered. Not saying we won't go back. Just may be a long while. read more

Excellent food, my walleye was cooked perfect. The service was outstanding! Definitely worth the drive from Evansville to Newburgh.

Went here about a month ago. I had the fish and crab cakes my wife not being a seafood lover had the chicken. Both were tasty and hot. Our only complaint is standing in a line that was about 20 deep to place your food order. Then go stand in another line if you want a bar drink. There seemed to be plenty of help they bring the food to your table and come back plenty. read more