I found The Sweet Tooth Fairy searching online for cupcakes to send for our son's birthday, as we are a couple thousand miles away on the East coast. The Sweet Tooth Fairy could not have been any nicer or responsive to our request for lemon cupcakes. They happen to have raspberry lemon cupcakes on the menu this month which have pink raspberry frosting. When I mentioned our son really loves lemon, without hesitation The Sweet Tooth Fairy offered to switch the frosting to lemon based vanilla. The cupcakes were delivered to our son's home on the day/time we requested. I saw a picture of them and they looked fabulous! And we were told they tasted delicious - the frosting was thick and not overly sweet with a luscious lemon flavor throughout the cupcakes :) We are very pleased and will order again :) Thank You Sweet Tooth Fairy! We can see how you won Cupcake Wars! read more

I'm not a cupcake person, and these cupcakes are so good. They're moist, flavorful, unique and not too sweet. Sending a dozen is a perfect gift! The inside of the shop is cute and usually quiet. Don't forget you get a free cupcake on your birthday with your ID! read more

The Sweet Tooth Fairy - Half dozen cupcakes! - Desserts Near Me - Orem, Utah

My favorite cupcake shop! Always recommending this place to my friends. If you want an amazing moist cupcake with a lot of flavor go here. Their frosting is yummy if you are a frosting person. read more

This is a cute little shop and perfect stop after eating dinner at one of the neighboring restaurants. The cookies we tried were all delicious, but unfortunately the service was pretty terrible. Absolutely no engagement from the employee when we walked in and started looking around. I was especially disappointed that the employee waited to mention a specific discount until after we spent a few minutes figured out what we wanted to buy, which prompted another round of rethinking our order. Kind of a sad experience for such a cute place! read more

See all

Cute little shop with a few different options of treats. Cupcakes, cake bites, cookies, lollipops - take your pick! They do have tables where you can enjoy in house, or get a box to go. Many different options and even gluten free options as well. Give it a try! read more

I just freaking love sweets and everything in here looks so good. I went on a Saturday and they had a sign up that said buy one get one free but then when we went to buy it was apparently only after 8PM. Maybe add that to the sign? But either way I got some cake bites and a cookie/brownie that topped off my afternoon quite nicely. I will say that the first lady that came out to help us was SUPER grumpy. To the point that I have my friend one of these looks. But she went back to the back and another girl came out to help and she was really great! read more

Phenomenal customer service! Sweet Tooth Fairy went above and beyond to deliver my sweets to the right location at the right time! I will definitely give them more business! read more

I am not much of a dessert person overall but I do love a good treat here and there. In this specific area, there is all kinds of awesome places to eat so it only makes sense to also have a dessert stop close by. The sweet tooth fairy has a wide variety of options--they have all kinds of cookies and bars to choose from. It was sort of overwhelming if I am being honest. For most people, this is one of those spots where "you can't just choose one". As for the business itself, I really really loved it. I thought the set up was really beautiful and pristine. For a dessert shop, they really do a great job at keeping everything organized and spotless. I loved all the different treats you were able to choose from. They also had other awesome features like gift bags, when you are in a hurry to get a last minute gift or they even make awesome bags for friends during the holidays. As I said, I am not much of a 'sweet' person but I will say, I enjoyed the treats that I bought from The Sweet Tooth Fairy! They were made perfectly and very "instagrammable" ;) read more

What a disappointing appointment! Went here at suggestion of a friend who knows the owners. Having a wedding venue coming up in a few months and never having been to this establishment we were excited to give it a try. Walked in with our soon to be bride and groom and were barely greeted and handed a small tray with 5 basic flavors of cupcakes, cut in fourths, and three VERY TINY sample cups of their frostings with MAYBE a tablespoon of frosting in each container! I stared at it and wondered when everyone else's samples were coming out (!!) but that was it! For 4 people to sample. Speechless. I asked if we were supposed to eat it with our fingers and the baker said "spoons are behind you!" That was it. I asked if they had pictures or a book for us to gather ideas from and she said, "no books or pictures." Ooookaaay. We sat at a little bistro table with 3 chairs and we were left on our own and that was it! It was the coldest unwelcoming I've ever encountered. I guess I shouldn't be surprised anymore at the lack of customer care out there any more but I'm always hopeful! The cakes all tasted like Duncan Heinz. Nothing special at all. I was told when I made the appointment that they had strawberry frosting and caramel frosting and a few others and that we'd be sampling all of those! Which is WHY I booked the appointment. The Almond tablespoon of frosting we were given to divide amongst the four of us tasted like someone had dumped the bottle of extract in it. We all thought it was awful. Should be much more subtle, that much I do know! The cream cheese was blah. The vanilla buttercream was "meh" at best. But in fairness, the consistency was lovely! Seriously, the flavors were underwhelming (with the exception of the overwhelmingly potent almond sample). No one came over to see if we had any questions! They really just didn't care that we were there. Period. No one spoke to the bride or groom. Never asked their names (which were given at the time I made the reservation) and no one gave two cents when we left! I have never stepped foot in a Sweet Tooth Fairy and honestly, after today's experience, not one of us would ever return. I understand we're "nobody" to them. And if I had been warned prior to coming I might have been better prepared? . However, we think our people are pretty special, and we actually DO know good service and good food, and expected a higher caliber of professionalism from all the hype we heard about STF...and basically, just to be treated better. All said and done, we left the bakery bewildered at what just took place. Chalked it up to experience and on to the next! Noth'n at all "sweet" about this place! read more

This place is darllliiinggg!!! Stopped in to grab a quick cupcake for a birthday and ended up leaving with a dozen! Plus some Rice Krispie treats and some other goodies!! Great size and really good flavor on their cupcakes! They have a wide variety of options and I didn't verify, but it seemed as if everything was made fresh! I live in Chicago, so unfortunately I won't be a regular, but anytime I'm in Utah...I will make the effort to get to one of their locations!! read more

The Sweet Tooth Fairy - a display of pastries - Desserts Near Me - Orem, Utah

See all

A very cute bakery with some amazing pastries! They have amazing little gift bags that you can grab and go T are perfect coworker/neighbor/teacher gifts! Their cookies are massive but unique to the basic chip/crumbl variety. Their cupcakes are masterpieces and have been a go to for family parties at my home for years! read more

Delicious treats! Everytime I come to Provo it's a must stop. We love the cake bites especially! After many years of shopping here I'm always amazed by how terrible the customer service is. Time after time I'm greeted by a grumpy college student who is neither helpful or happy, today the employee even told me he thought some of the stuff was "gross"... posting for the employer AGAIN (left the same review a few years ago) to hire better people! You'll sell more and attract more customers! A place like this needs a pleasant and happy salesperson behind the counter. Step it up. read more

First time visiting any of their locations. This place won cupcake wars and I've been to another cupcake shop that has won (Alisha's cupcakes, 10x better!!!). I was hoping for similar amazing cupcakes and they were just okay. We ordered a red velvet and a strawberry shortcake. The red velvet was a nice moist cake. But seriously I could make this easily at home. The cream cheese frosting was nice. The strawberry shortcake was moist to but lacking in flavors. The strawberry frosting on top was way too sweet! And they make you think you are getting a full strawberry on top but it's just half a strawberry. Overall I won't go back. Even my kids didn't like it. My 4 year who loves sweets just as much as I do said it was gross, strawberry shortcake. Not worth eating I had a couple small bites of each and I didn't want it. Nice service. Really cute interior and decorations! read more

See all

The cake bites were super yum but the girl there was not friendly at all. Was just sad because I love the treats there but her attitude literally had me bummed out.... Will not be returning for this reason... read more

What an experience. Was visiting from out of town. Was in town for business and wanted to treat some people to some cupcakes. Ended up going with 6 different flavors and a total of 24 cupcakes. The cupcakes were a hit. Chocolate Chip cookie dough was my favorite. Great Store and Service read more

First time trying their cake bites. They were good, I expected them to have a cakey texture but they were surprisingly really gooey and tasted more like fudge to me. They were really sweet also, I'd argue a little too sweet. I'm really sensitive to sweetness though so maybe that's why. Overall, I'd maybe order them again but if I went back I'd probably get a cupcake because they are so much more aesthetically pleasing! read more

Absolutely darling cupcake shop! The decor is so cute and bright! The cupcakes are pretty good too ;) #lfthx read more

For some reason I keep going back here thinking things will be different. Every time I am wrong. The cupcakes are mediocre and basically everything else is a huge disappointment. The employees always seem bothered to help anyone. Isn't that their job? It's not like I can grab my order myself and ring myself up. If I could I might give them an extra star for not having to deal with the people behind the counters attitudes. I made a request for sugar free cupcakes on a custom order and I was told that is not possible. How do you even win cupcake wars only making passable cupcakes and hardly anything to appeal to a fairly large demographic? I have definitely had better in all areas, service, taste and variety. read more

Everything looks amazing. Some items are, in fact, delicious, but most items are too sweet--like I can feel the sugar-high running through my veins like I just took a hit of sugar. I'm good with splitting a cupcake four ways. The interior is very pretty and photogenic. read more

I've always enjoyed coming here, but I really wish they would offer more vegan options other than just the brownie. The brownie is super delicious though so if you get the chance to try it definitely do! I'd like to see vegan cupcakes or cake bites especially where it's not difficult to make, and I know it would be a hit around here. read more

Dry dry dry!!! I usually dont eat other peoples baked goods cause mibe or so amazing but had to try and i will go back to my rule

So disappointed in the recent purchases. I ordered two orders for Mother's Day when Rachel Parcell endorsed your company. It said it would arrive on Saturday before Mother's Day, both just arrived today. I was okay with it with everything going on with shipping and covid then it arrived and the box was damaged. Along with most of the cookies and pretzels broken and frosting falling off. I was excited for both sets of moms to try your product since I have heard rave reviews. Unfortunately will not be ordering again. read more

I have always loved Sweet Tooth Fairy since I've moved to Utah! So so yummy and they make great flavors, adding new ones with the seasons! My favorites are probably the fairy fetti and the strawberry shortcake! Also! I was super excited to find out that they offer gluten free cupcakes! #lfthx read more

I ordered a cake for my daughters 1st birthday and it turned out so cute!! just like the photo I had sent (even a little cuter) and it tasted really good:) highly recommend! read more

This is such a cute little shop. I took my 3 boys in and they had the time of their lives picking out and eating the cupcakes. Everything in there looked so good. I can't wait to go back and try more! read more

Beautifully done cupcakes that ended up looking better than they tasted. The cupcakes themselves were pretty average while the frosting and toppings were way too sugary for my taste. They didn't have too many flavors left by 4pm when I went so maybe I just got the not so great flavors? The staff was very friendly though, and threw in two free cupcakes which was very nice. I'd like to try different flavors maybe, see if those taste better. read more

Yes, definitely go here. Cupcakes are excellent. I really like their cookies and brownies. They have a great selection. Everything is very fresh. The employees are very nice. My only recommendation is fountain drinks. I highly recommend this business. read more

Cutest and yummiest cupcakes around! They were perfect for the birthday party I was going to. A huge hit! Customer service was great also. read more

The cake bites are OUT OF THIS WORLD. I am not a huge cake fan, but the bites make this place worth visiting. Not crazy about their whole menu, which is why there is only 4 stars. I have tried every flavor and none have disappointed me yet. read more

Cupcakes were dry and kind of small... go to Harmons instead! They have the best cupcakes.

I think this place has good cupcakes but not great. Some of their flavors are pretty simple, but overall it's a good quality. My husband really liked the funfetti one, but I think that's more a reason of nostalgia rather than actual cupcake quality. This is also the most convenient location for me to buy cupcakes so I do end up going here more than some other places, but there are definitely better cupcakes nearby. read more

The Sweet Tooth Fairy - Funfetti, lemon, and somoa - Desserts Near Me - Orem, Utah

We love sweet tooth fairy but if you're going to drastically change your hours you might want to change your online listings to reflect that. Took family from out of town here at 8:15 and double checked Apple maps on your closing time (it says 10 pm) only to get there and find out you changed your closing time to 8 pm. read more

Their cookies are pretty good. I wish not everything was a cream cheese frosting and that they did buttercream frosting on cupcakes! Everything is super super rich. read more

I love this place. Everything is delicious and excellent at satisfying your sweet tooth. My personal favorite is the Nutella cupcake, although I've yet to have a bad flavor. It is a bit pricey, and some items can be a little too sweet, but overall this is one of the best places to get cupcakes around. read more

Love this location. I go out of my way to shop here. It's perfect for all occasions! Great staff, great service, amazing treats! I haven't tried something I didn't like there. Go, now! read more

A great place for a sweet treat. Love the décor and ambiance of the little store front. The gluten free options were small and had I not already has my fill of chocolate cookies I would have tried the cup cakes. So I had to go with the sugar cookie. THIS WAS A GREAT IDEA. The cookie itself was delish. The frosting on top was a great idea, however a little on the sweet side. Well, not that it was too sweet, it's that there was soo much of it. That was OK with me though. I found it a little on the pricy side, especially for the cake bites. But for the occasional treat its with it. read more

I have been here twice now and same thing each time: cupcakes are dry and crumbly, not moist , light, and tasty. Frosting is gloppy and way too sweet. Not a good cupcake! read more

love sweet tooth fairy!! super cute and delicious cupcakes !!!!

I love their cake bites and cookies! Went in the other night for my once a year summer visit and got 6 cake bites. There were only a few flavors out and i said wow i usually see more flavors here and the employee (Lydia) didn't say anything. A few minutes later when i was about to checkout the other employee brought out more flavors and i asked to switch one of mine out, i knew it was inconvenient but again i only go once a year and i look forward to it. Both Lydia and the other employee gave me dirty looks and didn't say anything. It was so rude. I couldn't believe how unhelpful they were. Employer needs to know. read more

Such a cute little shop. I love their cake bites and cookies, they are better than any others I have ever had. I wish it was a little less expensive, but honestly it is worth the price for the quality of the treats, read more