It feels like there's about a thousand pizza places in Maple Shade, but I had never heard of The Sub Shoppe until fairly recently. I was pleasantly surprised with the quality of the pizza and garlic knots - they were great! The pizza is a nice thin crust, good tasting sauce and cheese, and the prices were very reasonable! read more

Decided to swing by to order a few subs and wings for the NFC and AFC championship games. Arrived around 2pm and didn't place an order over the phone for pick up because I was struggling to find a menu. We ordered a cheese steak with fried onions, an Italian sub, a cheesesteak hoagie, pizza fries, and 20 wings. Everything was ready pretty quickly by the time we ordered. The workers had a great attitude and sense of humor. The wings are breaded and come with sauce on the side. We had traditional Buffalo sauce. The breading is thick but pretty tasty and the leftover wings reheated nicely in the air fryer. The breading on the wings is good enough to eat them dry. The rolls for the subs and cheesesteaks were soft. We very much enjoyed the sandwiches we ordered. The fries were the least enjoyable out of everything, but weren't too bad. The price was reasonable for what we ordered and I was pleased with the decision to order from Sub Shoppe this weekend. read more

See all

Being new to the area, stumbled on this gem. The subs are soooo good. Had the steak sub. For $17.99, it was excellent. And huge 20" !! The wife had a italian sub, which I had to taste, because it looked so good. It didn't disappoint!!! Also got the works 16" pizza. It had the right amount of sauce and the toppings was fresh. The was outstanding. Will definitely be going back! read more

Good food. Friendly management and personnel. They aim to please. Try one of their lunch specials.

When you just had a killer gym session and can't decide between a cheesesteak or Italian hoagie, get both and make them extra big at 2ft long, becoming one of my favorite places in south jersey. Both cheesesteak and hoagie so good read more

The Sub Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

This place is great! In NJ from out of town for a hockey tournament and picked them solely on the basis of good yelp reviews and The Sub Shoppe lived up to them. Terrific cheesesteak hoagies, wraps, club sandwiches, salads. The "rolls" looked so good while I was waiting for our order that I had to try a veggie one and it was also fantastic. They also have the usual pepperoni rolls and unusual chicken and spinach. Twice the size of most of their ilk, good dough and not greasy at all. The place was spotless and I noticed that they also sell Italian cookies and their own hot sauce. I think the Sub Shoppe is an independent and not a chain. Service is very good: a couple of guys carried out trays to the car. Definitely recommend them and in the unlikely event that we make finals we will give their pizza a shot. read more

Sub Shoppe has great prices and a ton of menu options. The food is good and the delivery is fast. The owners are nice and involved in the community; I am happy to give them my business. read more

1st, we love this place. Now, ordered a large cheese pizza at 5:08 PM (can't drive, just got out of hospital). Was told 30 minutes. At 6:04 PM, the driver called to ask where we lived. I told him, and he was in the wrong development and not even close. At 6:08, I called the pizza shop, told them I don't want this pizza as it is cold by now as your driver is not here yet. They made me a new one and said it would be delivered in 30 minutes. At the 42 minute mark, I called and spoke to the owner. He said he will call the driver and call me back. He never called back. But, the second driver called to ask where I lived. Keep in mind, this place has delivered to my place for the past 5 years. They even confirm my address by telling it to me. So, I call again, speak with the owner, and he said I will have it delivered and no charge for you as it is now two hours in. Lo and behold, three hours in and still no pizza. Very disappointing experience from a local pizza restaurant we use all the time. Will we use them again, most likely, but this service deserves the rating given. read more

If you want good sandwiches that aren't overpriced, this is the spot. A nice mom and pop shop with good service. Overall great value for what you get, would comeback again. read more

Since 2019 my family and I have experienced authentic tastes that consistently keep The Sub Shoppe on the menu list at home, and at friends homes. Thank you to The Sun Shoppe. read more

The Sub Shoppe - This is the entrance to The Sub Shoppe, please watch your steps going down. - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

See all

I really enjoy this pizza shop. We order alot from here for work. Pizza, sandwiches, salads and apps have all been great. They make an awesome chicken salad with cranberries and walnuts. I have had it as both a salad and sandwich. Both awesome. The staff is always so nice and helpful. read more

The Sub Shoppe - Margarita pizza is delicious. - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Very rarely does a restaurant surprise me with excellent food and service nowadays when surrounded by mediocrity. This small restaurant in what seems to be an old corner store area surprising serves one of the best pizzas in New Jersey. I often come here for the margarita pizza. read more

Love the white pizza & the Brooklyn pizza... cheese steaks are very good as well. Maple Shade is loaded with pizza places, Sub Shoppe is one of the best read more

This place is delicious. They are friendly, the food is all spot on. The subs are made to order, the pizza by the slice or a whole one. They have amazing garlic knots. Also a pizza twist thing that is kinda rolled. I've tried 3 different kinds. The mozzarella and spinach one is my favorite. This is a regular amazing place. read more

Oh my God, the sub shop excellent excellent food the hoagies, the cheesesteaks the fries everything is awesome on Forklanding Road. You got a try it if you guys like food trying different things. It's a nice little spot next to her ice cream place. It's all the same owner we're just two different names. I can't think of the ice cream name but the sub shop you can't miss it it's like a little hole in the wall but it's a jam the food the people you got a try it that's all I have to say you have to try it for yourself and you won't be disappointment. Thank you, John. read more

Quesadillas. Not having them from Sub Shoppe before, we took a chance and holy wow, it was worth it. Well worth the price, they we're the perfect amount of cheese and chicken and a beautiful golden brown. They are huge, pizza size, and absolutely delicious. Their salsa is awesome. And as usual, great service. They delivered within 15 minutes. Definitely added to our regular orders from Sub Shoppe. read more

The pizza pies are always delicious, and the wings will not disappoint your taste buds. Service is fast, and the price's are reasonable. The Sub Shoppe has made the rotation on our regular takeout nights. read more

I've enjoyed all of my meals from here. The salads are enough for 2 and so delicious, so much so that I don't go to the mall to Salad Works anymore. Plus the prices here are pretty reasonable and the service is great. Next to pricey Pats, this place has the best White Pizza I've ever eaten. This day I ordered a tossed salad with grilled chicken and mozzarella cheese, and as you can see, it was as delicious as it looks. If you're in Maple Shade try them, the garlic bread chicken parm sandwiches are delicious too. read more

The Sub Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

Also fast delivery and delish food. We've ordered a bunch of things and always get a lot of food for a great price. Large menu has something for everyone - it's our go to place. The carne asada pizza was soooo goood ! read more

This has so far been my favorite place to eat Pizza, being originally from New York it's difficult finding pizza that's comparable, I figured because it's just one state over it would be close but I was for years unable to find any comparison, The Sub Shoppe comes the closest. They got good specials, good creations and absolutely amazing pizza, their garlic knots are also the beez-neez. Do yourself a favor and give them a shot. You can order for delivery or pick up, you can also dine-in, it's a nice little cozy spot to eat, everyone is friendly and it seems to be pretty busy but they never keep me waiting. I would recommend highly. read more

go to Italian place in the neighborhood highly recommend the pizza and the stuffed shells. their garlic bread is amazing and comes with entrees and salads read more

I ordered their margarita pie and it's the best margarita pizza I've ever tasted. Great flavor, a little sweet with the sauce but I enjoy that. Spices and ricotta cheese amount was spot on. I'm pretty sure David Portney would rate at least a 7.0! The 5 rating is solely based on that alone. I highly recommend at least trying. Price was good and I picked up so I can't say much about delivery time. Staff was friendly and quick to serve. Next time I'll post a pic but for now I wanted to do the Sub Shoppe a solid. read more

First time here since we lived in the area a long time ago. Pleasantly surprised. Ordered the roast pork roasted peppers and provolone. Excellent sandwich a bit of a mix between barbacoa and Italian chopped pork on the grill. Bread excellent and peppers sweet. Also had a slice of veggie pizza very good. Clean place friendly service. Will be back. read more

I order pizza and wings from here all the time even after I moved out of maple shade. The food here is amazing especially the Brooklyn pizza! The service is fast and they treat you like family. Also, the prices are the most reasonable in the area. I would definitely recommend this to anyone in the area. read more

My favorite pizza shop in Maple Shade! Larger menu than other pizza shops in town. Their hoagies are much better than Montesinis as their rolls are much fresher and tastier. Whenever we have friends and family in town and we order from the Dub Shoppe, they're always blown away by the quality and taste. Their staff is always friendly and takeout orders are always ready when I go to pickup. They often throw in a free 2 liter soda which is a nice touch. read more

First time having it today... came earlier than expected, nice and hot and everything super tasty... found my new go to!

After moving to maple shade and everyone raving about this place I decided to try it. First time got mozzarella sticks and cheesesteaks. Not good. Bread was almost stale and mozzarella sticks weren't melted. Decided to give it another shot and ordered their "famous" wings. Omg the worst. They went soggy and absolutely horrible. So disappointed in this place. read more

UPDATE: Ordered pizza through the sub shoppe through the app Slice. Bacon wasn't an option as a topping but it said to type in anything additional and it will just charge you extra. Knowing they had bacon as an option we typed it in and just assumed they would charge for the topping no big deal. 30 min later they delivered a plain pizza. I called and said I ordered w bacon and they were extremely rude saying well you didn't pay for it. I said it specifically says that you will just charge extra which would have been done. The guy on the phone said he would send me a new pizza but we would have to pay for both. I was like we will just eat the plain it's fine we weren't trying to get anything for free in the first place. They made it sound like we were trying to complain and get free pizza which we would never do. I always tip well and had previously written a 5 star review on here as I am in the service industry as well. Needless to say tonight was pizza night and instead we ordered from Santis instead which was really good read more

I went here to get a cheese steak and a chicken salad hoagie for opening day of the NFL season. I hadn't been in this place in years but it used to be pretty good. The food was good and really reasonably priced. Nice people own the place as well. I'll be back again since it's only 5 minutes from where I live. I ordered using Grubhub and everything was ready and correct by the time I walked in the door. read more

Sub shoppe has been around FOREVER. I ordered delivery off of grubhub a few weeks ago and it was quick and very good food and not expensive some other places in town. Went in and ordered the second time and still it was quick and delicious read more

I used to live in New Jersey when I was a one-year old back in 1974. For years my parents told me about this place. As I was heading down to DC, I decided to look for this place. All I ever heard was how amazing their Italian sub and cheesesteaks were. Boy were my parents right. As for the Italian, it is absolutely amazing, with a pile of Italian meats (including capicola, I think), with some of the best tasting white bread I have ever experienced. Also, they don't overload the veggies, so you get the meat and veggie flavors working together perfectly. But what they really nailed was the amount of salt, pepper, oil and vinegar they put on. Not too much, not too little, but absolutely right. My father told me I needed to try the cheesesteak, and he was right. He said it was the best cheesesteak had ever had (and that was back in 1974). Now I can say that it is the best cheesesteak I have ever had in 2015. It actually taste quite similar to a Jersey Mike's cheesesteak (which was my favorite until I had this one) but the bread at The Sub Shoppe is way better. The ingredients that they use here are work together and have the most amazing taste. So yes, mom and dad, this place tastes just as good as it did 40 years ago. Thanks for tell me about it. Looking forward to going again. read more

PLEASE MAKE MILKSHAKES!! Sub Shoppe is a no brainer. In business since 1960, i was raised on this food. The subs and special sandwiches are always made fresh and the pizza is absolutely perfect especially if you spend a few seconds to express your individual preferences. I love the chicken salad with cranberries and the gigantic baked calzone. The owner Joe has always gone the mile to satisfy my insane preferences such as add the white onion to the steak 30 seconds before taking off the grill and only 15 french fries! The menu is huge and they enjoy a dedicated fan base. I graduated many years ago and its a darn reunion when I go. The one thing that really cemented my loyalty to this restaurant is their youtube video where you see Joe putting more than a pound of Thurman lunch meats on the gigantic whole hoagie. Lastly, i have noticed the ridiculously cheap board specials and website specials and when I asked why so cheap, Joe essentially the economy is bad and it was his way of giving back. read more

See all

We tried a 14.79 scilian pizza from this business for the first time, after driving by many times. Oh boy... I tell you.. I would never go back again. The pizaa isn't that good for the price they are charging. read more

The Sub Shoppe - Nasty.. - Pizza Near Me - Maple Shade, New Jersey

This place has the best food I have ever tasted!!! This is such a hidden little gold mine I tried this place on a wim and I am supper happy I did!!! read more

Pleasantly surprised by every single this on this menu. We order at least once a week and are never disappointed. Delivery is super fast and food is always hot and delicious. Have gotten pizza, wings, panzarottis, chicken salad, and chicken cheese steaks. This our new go-to...AND the people are also nice, which is a bonus. read more

The Sub Shoppe is Our go to spot. They have the best sandwiches in town! We order at least once a week and they are consistently on point. When you call they are professional and there is never an issue. I highly recommend them! Their chicken salad is amazing! read more

Cheese Steaks are the way to go!!! Crinkle French Fries are excellent Slices are good as well. read more

I ordered three sandwiches. One was the house special steak sandwich (half) which has onions, green peppers, pepperoni, and extra cheese along with the steak. The fill on the sandwich was very good and tasted very good. It could have had more pepperoni. The second sandwich was an italian hoagie (half). The flavor was very good, however the fill on this sandwich was a little small. If it had an extra slice of each cold cut and cheese along with more veggies, this sandwich would have been excellent. The third sandwich was the spiced ham and provolone hoagie (half). The flavor was very good, however the fill on this sandwich was also a little small. If it had two extra slices of ham and cheese along with more veggies, this sandwich would have been excellent. We called on Halloween evening and they were extremely busy. The phone line was busy many times and I was disconnected once. Management was very nice. They allowed me to use a voucher for takeout because of limited mobility. I applaud management when they treat customers very well. On the negative, I could not find an up to date menu online anywhere. There were menus but all had out of date prices and were text like menus. The Sub Shoppe needs a pdf of the actual restaurant menu on the website with current prices. I would absolutely order from them again. read more

We just got the Sub Shoppe's Special of two (2) pizzas and a 2 liter soda for $20.99. When my son arrived home, the credit card receipt showed they charged us $23.18. We called the Sub Shoppe and the girl on the telephone said, "Oh, the price of the special went from $19.99 to $20.99, sorry." The NJ State Sales tax (i.e., 6.63%) on $20.99 is $1.39, for a total price of $22.38. The Sub Shoppe charged us an additional 80 cents to use a credit card! Please watch out for this place because they penalize you for using credit card without notifying you! Very unprofessional!!! read more

The cheese steak was good and not many sandwich shops carry zeppolis. It was a good add on! I'll order from here again!