Our new hometown pizzeria! This is a little joint that is very underrated! It is a classic old school NY pizzeria! And I mean classic. The inside has kind of a 90's vibe to it. I do not believe that it has been updated inside since then, but it does not feel dated! It is always on the dark side every time that I go. Staff is always super friendly and very welcoming! I have gone here a few times and it is definitely the best pizza in the area. If you go earlier in the day around lunch time, their display case is filled with a ton of varieties, from the typical Chicken Bacon Ranch to Buffalo Chicken, as well as tortellini Alfredo slices and Vodka Chicken Parm. I am also a massive fan of their pepperoni garlic nots, and their massive garlic sticks! Other great items are their bruschetta and their salads. I was not a fan of their burger, it was a frozen hockey puck. But since this a Pizzeria not a burger joint, I do not hold it against them. All in all, great location! Great food, great ambiance, great staff, great food, great selection, great everything! Highly recommend! read more

See all

We have been going to Red Star for longer than I can remember and we love their Sicilian pizzas especially, the Works and their Verde varieties. That have been a staple in our dining experience! I cannot say enough good things about them - the food, service and dining room are wonderful! read more

I have heard good things about this spot and finally got to check it out. The place was hopping with little wait staff, but the service was excellent and fast! Our large group ordered something from just about every part of the menu, and everyone was happy with their food. My chicken Caesar wrap was filled with grilled chicken ..not those frozen grilled pieces you often find...and was perfect! The fries were spot on crispy and hot. The prices are reasonable. I will be back for another visit read more

Holy canoli!! The antipasto salad is incredible. Get the large to share with someone. I suggest the creamy Italian dressing. It's delicious, fresh and enough tuna to mix throughout the salad. It's perfect for salad lovers like me. read more

Consistently great pizza and Italian food. Good service with attentive staff. Will make menu adjustments if requested.

Best pizza in this area. Nice people here. Cheesesteaks do not disappoint. Just ordered takeout today, in fact.

Always great food and good service and have been going there for years. During Covid they seem to have made changes to ingredients of lesser quality. This was due to supply issues. Adjustments were made and food is back to their high quality. The restaurant is clean and well maintained. Has two spacious dining areas. Their pizza is one of the best in the area. Food portions are large. read more

This is the third time you've gotten my order wrong. I didn't comment the 1st 2 but this is number 3. Why take my order if you're just going to make sandwiches the way you feel like it. Today tomatoes and onion on my cheese steak when I specifically said none. Good food but Jesus this is making me it want to order here any more... read more

Awesome Sicilian Pie. Recommend !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I have been trying the lunch specials which are delicious! Chicken marsala was very tender chicken, delicious sauce and loved the fresh rolls. Highly recommend their lunch specials. Chicken parmigiana lunch special is also wonderful read more

Red Star Pizza - Chicken parmigiana and penne pasta lunch special - Pizza Near Me - Southampton, New Jersey

See all

They whipped up three DELICIOUS---meaty--pizza steaks-with all the works for us for a Father's Day treat!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Sandwiches were great and we really enjoyed them. Highly recommend!!!! read more

We really enjoy Red Star Pizza. It is the closest pizza place to our home and luckily in the top two in our opinion in the entire area, I definitely would recommend them. There large subs are huge and feed three people while their pizza is delicious as well. read more

Been a Red Star fan for over 25 years and the pizza is still good, but not like years past. They used to have great hoagies and cheese steaks but not anymore. They cut back on the amount of meats for both and raised their prices. Last hoagie I got was mostly lettuce, haven't been back since. Sad because Red Star used to so good and our go to place was every Friday night. read more

Love the food, cleanliness and the owners...love the garlic knots and the cheese fries are great.

Can someone say Friday Pizza night!? Our now go to spot almost every-every Friday. We love pizza but can't take too much carbs. So, we ask for thin crust and the folks make it just right to accommodate for a good soft and crispy crust without compromising all the cheese and toppings. Our Red Star adults favorites; chicken parmigiana pizza and pizza primavera. Then of course for those hungry nights, the meat lovers pizza. To top it off for the kids, their favorite white pie made just right. Every time it's just right! read more

Red Star Pizza - 1/2 meat lovers 1/2 primavera - Pizza Near Me - Southampton, New Jersey

See all

The best in Southampton. After getting a sloppy delivery from the pizzeria on the other side of town, we tried Red Star. The sauce is really different, not bitter a little sweet in fact. My husband and I have lived in Tabernacle 30+ years and have just discovered this great restaurant. I think "slice" will deliver too!! ***** read more

Reason why I'm saying maybe it's because red lion in the pizza is not amazing know that place is made for the pizza I'm gonna say that burger is the best dish their their pizza it is way too cheesy for me not a lot of tomatoes for I like to on the pizza under the cheese what do you eat and then like there's some tomato sauce because I like that there's literally no tomato sauce not the best place for you if you like pizza or are you thinking about ordering that I recommend the burger there with a solid that's all read more

Doesn't look like much from the side of the road but the best wings in the area. Good cheese steaks and generous portions.

We were driving around, hunger kicked in, and this place happened to be less than a mile away. We stopped right outside of the restaurant and there was an elderly man walking to his car carrying a pizza so we asked how the pizza is. He replied, best in town. We called and ordered a large cheese pizza for the kids, Saporito for me, and husband got the Chicken Marsala. What a disappointment. I'm giving it 2 stars because the pizza wasn't too bad. I'm all for supporting small businesses, but if the service isn't there, you must know. I must say, I've never had such water down, tasteless pasta in my life. The Saporito, I believe, was about $15. Not worth it. I don't live near that area so I know for a fact I won't be going back there again. But we paid 40 something dollars for tasteless food and some mediocre pizza. read more

Red Star Pizza - Saporito - Pizza Near Me - Southampton, New Jersey

See all

I love Red Star SO MUCH! The nicest staff and the BEST food!! I often have, and highly recommend, the cheese steak hoagie -- YUM! but my go to is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza!! (see attached BEFORE blue cheese added!!!) OMG this is a little slice of Sicily right here in NJ!! See you soon RSP!!! Simply the best--go and enjoy!!! read more

Red Star Pizza - Buffalo Chicken (before Blue Cheese) YUM!!!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Southampton, New Jersey

See all

Pizza is awesome and the prices are about what they are everywhere. Usually just pick up and go but the short interaction I have with the staff has always been pleasant. read more

Come here often and loved it but...tonight we called in a pick up order, they even read back our name on the caller ID. Said it would be an hour+...ok, it's Friday. Get there, no order. Nothing. Waited over an hour, kids are waiting and hungry and nothing. Oh, we can put you at the front...yeah, another 30 minutes. Can't rate food when you get any! Time for a new place. read more

Best Pizza around. Even my son who lives in South Philly says they have the best pizza. Also great cheese steaks and hoagies! And indoor dining for complete meals. I only gave it 4 stars because they don't deliver!!! Which is becoming an issue for us older folk! And in 20 years we haven't missed many Friday pizzas! read more

The staff are great!! Best pizza in the area and would highly recommend stopping by and trying it out. It's a very safe and kid-friendly business and the owner makes sure to provide the best experience while there. Pasta dinners are also very delicious and would highly recommend trying this place out!! read more

Easily one of the best pizza places in town! I've been coming to this place for the last 20 years, and I can say that I've tried *almost* every single item on the menu from the pizza, breadsticks, pizza fries, cheese fries, to the baked ziti, eggplant parm, and the list goes on. Never disappoints me and the owner + staff are super awesome and treat everyone like a friend! Definitely a go to spot! read more

I stopped in this afternoon for slices because my mom said it was good. I think it's the best pizza on the route 70 corridor between cherry hill and Southampton. The sauce was perfect and tasted like it was made with fresh tomatoes. The best part is the crust was thin. Many places in south jersey claim to make NY style pizza but the crust is too thick. This place hit it on the nose. Oh, and it was like 6 bucks for two slices with a big bottle of water. read more

I wish Red Star delivered. I would order them over the other local places every time. Everything is so good!!! Their breadsticks are to die for! read more

This is a wonderful, affordable family grill n pizza shoppe. Every entree' and varied pizza are made fresh with quality ingredients. I live in Leisuretown now but I have been a regular over 20 years! I recommend the Pizza with the Works and the grilled burgers are to die for. Oh! The salads and dressings are great. Everything is good. I saw the Who guitarist Larry Mills there! He signed my menu. Wow! He has really curly hair. Try u will like! read more

I've been going to Riviera for 7 years...This is our new pizza place. The pizza is superior. My kids all agree it is delicious!! read more

Red Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Southampton, New Jersey

This is hands down my favorite pizza place in the world, at any given time you can walk in there and Vito always says hi to everyone he possibly can. I might be a little partial to this place because I've been coming to red star for over 30 years and they've never disappointed me, if there's ever anything wrong they are always real quick to fix it and make you a satisfied customer. The staff is always so nice as well, they always stay right on top of your drinks and bring the food out as quickly as they possibly can. I've been all over the US and I always come back to Vito's for my pizza he always knows what he's doing. The prices are also very affordable, go ahead and order a large cheesesteak and let me know if you can finish it in one sitting cause they are huge there's always leftovers for the next day. read more

excellent food, great service, place is always busy but in and out quickly for takeouts !! i

Their pizza is usually so good and it still is but recently it's been making me feel ill after one slice but none the less it's still really good read more

Great friendly service. Great price for the quantity and quality. My family has been ordering from them for years.

You're looking for pizza in Southampton, and this is where you're going to get it. You know it, they know it. Sure, you could go to Riviera, but we both know it's not as good, and you gotta deal with street parking in Vincentown. The staff knows you don't have other options, too. Don't expect any of that hoity toity politeness you get in your fancy city restaurants. They've completely forgotten to cook my take out order TWICE, and the blonde who works the register most of the times I've gone in here hasn't once offered me one of those fake customer service apologies. Just "It'll be a while" and pay me. So yeah, reviews don't matter because you're in the middle of the woods and you want to eat, but expect them to sort of openly resent being bothered. read more

Very good pizza. When eating inside and not just ordering pizza, they can take long to serve you your food and for the waiters to come take your order, but all of the food is great. read more

I have lived in Medford Lakes for a few years now and am from north NJ. folks here seem to like Riviera. I tried that and really wanted to like it based on how much everyone else likes it. but the crust is consistently too doughy, no crunch. and the taste is flat. Red Star is the best pizza in the area, hands down. put Riv to shame, really. Ive had a lot of pizza. worked in NYC for 2 years, lived in Baltimore, rhode island, so I've tried many different types of pizza. and of course tastes vary. but Red Star--the sauce has that zing, that sweet zing that makes it hard to stop eating. my 2nd favorite in the area is la bella and they deliver so we have their pizza a lot. la bella makes a stuffed chicken parm pizza that is awesome. read more

I've been going to Red Star Pizza for a few months. The last few times I've gone there the girl at the front desk would see me as the next customer but would ask the customer behind me if they needed help. The 1st couple of times I excused because it was crowded. But every time after is UNEXCEPTABLE! It seems its on purpose because I'm African American and not too many of us live in the Southampton community. I feel the young lady's main focuse is on receiving a tip and not service. It's a shame cause I really like Red Star 's pizza. UNFORNUTATELY I will not be returning. Red Star pizza will continue to loose a lot more customers if that young lady at the front desk don't learn the true meaning of customer service. read more

The food has always been great - been going here since they opened about 20 years ago. To the fella who complained about the staff being.."little silly girls with their tits and asses hanging out." I say that's even more reason to eat in! Seriously? Great food AND eye candy! That's a winner for me!!! read more

Delicious food at great prices! Just wished they delivered.

Great pizza and atmosphere & staff is great but I wish they would start delivering. Have been going there for 5 + years. Def 5 stars