Got stuck with the whole LIRR thing. So, headed downstairs and looked for a place quench my thirst…read moreand found Fibbers. Excellent. A fantastic pub, just what I needed. People were great, bartender awesome. We need more of these spots to be publicly posted. Well... Maybe keep it as a great secret?

New-ish to the area (recently singje, moved here during pandemic). I've been trying different…read moreplaces, can be weird as a single remake. Came here with a friend; super chill and def coming back. Bartender was a lady that said she usually only filled in behind the bar. Think seeks an owner, guy next us said she was. Anyway. Good service; friendly but not in your face. Super affordable (heads up NO food, Cash only but they have an atm machine). Good jukebox and the regulars are funny and welcoming . Bathroom small but clean. I might be a new regular, I'd be ok coming here alone!!! I liked the decor; Irish pub with authentic stuff from Ireland not cheesy and looks to have a leaning towards the lads iykyk

On Thursday (04.02.26) it was a random date night! Which are the best :)! Also, it's been a while…read moresince I've been here. For the appetizer, we ordered Philly Cheesesteak Rolls with cheese sauce and it was deliciousssssss!!!! For our main course we got a Bourbon Bacon Burger (added egg) with truffle fries and the Carne Asada Tacos. The burger and truffle fries was so flavorable, can't wait to have that again! To be honest, there was something missing in the carne asada so it tasted okay. Not only did we enjoy ourselves, but there was also a sip and paint with Bluemoon the same day we were there. That was a pretty cool little event! First time doing one! The hostess Gwen gave us two Bluemoon glasses and we painted them while we ate. I can definitely say I'm no artist but I tried my best lol! So definitely want to come back and try other dishes!

December 2025. I attended a Christmas party here in mid…read moreDecember. It included open bar and quite a few appetizers. The food was decent and the staff was pretty attentive. I've never gone just to sit down and have a meal.......but I probably will when in the area. I saw a bunch of people ordering different variations of burgers......and I must say, they looked quite scrumptious.

Small bar tucked on a side street. Tuesday nights they have a nice friendly karaoke show…read more The beer tender serves up a nice personal pizza and a few other things. I had the pizza and a couple of soft drinks (since I was driving). It's a nice time with some nice local Malverne folks.

Local pub. What a…read moregreat little local pub in Malverne. We hit this place while I was visiting the area as my sister and her dude are regulars here. The building is sort of wedge-shaped and there is usually live music set up in the corner, which was the case the night we were there. Definitely a lot of regulars here and the bartenders are just great- very personable and make decent drinks. Walk in, sit down and they treat you just as well as a regular. My kind of service. The place is well lit and clean and the bathrooms are pleasantly nice. All in all a solid place to meet friends and just chill Parking lot behind the building or the street.

I came here over the summer while visiting friends on the Island and am only now getting around to…read morewriting this. I ordered salmon and sweet potato fries, which you can skip, the salmon was a little over cooked and nothing to write home about. The boyfriend loved his burger, I think it came with caramelized onions and maybe blue or goat cheese. The apple pie with ice cream was on point. But forget all that. The thing that I still think about, the thing I tell people in the city about, is the epic, gigantic, fried appetizer sampler platter. You know when you see something that was just meant for you? Like someone made this with me in mind. I was so happy. You get like 6 mozzarella sticks, fried onion rings, fried zucchini sticks, and fried calamari. It comes with a white sauce I completely ignored- our waitress was extremely patient as I ordered not one, or two, but three sides of marinara, the third they finally brought out in a gravy boat like I had tried to convince them to do in the first place :P It's just so big and happy! The platter can easily fill three hungry people with large appetites, especially if you're also getting full entrees. I'm just a sucker for these samplers when they're done well, and this was excellent. Nicely seasoned batter that always adhered to the food it encased, the insides were not lava, they did not fall apart. The oil they used was fresh, the calamari tender. Is there a food challenge where I can try to eat one of these solo in a certain amount of time? If not there should be!

Nice atmosphere in this old fashioned bar restaurant, If…read moreyou come just to have a few drinks, this place is for you, but as far the food goes, look somewhere else.

Great local restaurant located in our town. The staff is amazing. The food is really good. The…read moreprices are reasonable.

My boyfriend and I came to Connolly Pub & Restaurant in Malverne tonight, May 6th, looking forward…read moreto a nice dinner together. We had been holding onto the gift certificate since September and finally got the chance to use it after a really rough few months, so we were genuinely excited for a relaxing night out. The food and atmosphere were alright, but unfortunately the experience at the end completely ruined the night for us. There was a misunderstanding with the gift certificate payment, and we honestly thought the tip had already been taken from the remaining balance when the check was processed. As we were walking back to our car, the waitress there (forget her name- only blonde, older, waitress there on a Wednesday night) suddenly came chasing after us in the parking lot. She ran to the door of the restaurant we just walked out of and yelled out to us "is there a reason you didn't leave me a tip?!?!" We were completely caught off guard and honestly embarrassed. We thought she had taken it off the gift certificate already (so I asked if there was a receipt of how much was left but I guess she just wrote it on the certificate and we didn't realize.) we still thought she took it off already. However, this was extremely embarrassing and could've been handled calmly as it was a misunderstanding. Very unprofessional and rude. Also our first experience here-- will definitely not be back. Also-- we were already at the car so my boyfriend proceeded to take out all the cash he had on him and gave her that tip-- she scuffed and didn't say thank you and just took the cash and went back inside! Absolutely horrible experience!

Great food, great vibes. Love the atmosphere and service. I been here 3 times and have no…read morecomplaints. Respect goes to the owner of this establishment for nailing everything. The staff is absolutely incredible. Sassi is wonderful. She was my waitress 2 out of the 3 times I've been here and she couldn't be more sweet.

I have written here before regarding Prime 39 as I do like to support local businesses…read more I have been here for happy hour, after work drinks with co-workers and late night happy hour. I can't give 5 stars as the dining we struggle with .. Service is up and down. Both occasions felt the same. For Prime 39, I categorized the place as a restaurtant that happens to provide fine dining, but has an upscale feel. The music selection is really good here and the selection feeds into the upscale feeling with a good mix of R&B. We arrived promptly for our reservation but noted that it took a while to seat us, even though the dining room was empty. I do appreciate the dividers as they give you some privacy when sitting next to another group. The wait was uncomfortably long, which made us wonder if we should change our reservation to sit at the bar. We ordered drinks and water, but it took a while for the drinks to make their way to the table. The place wasn't that busy, but it did make us want to rush our order in for appetizers and entrees. Drinks were watery... As in sitting too long stir up the ice and keep stirring. The food had some winners. We enjoyed our entrees of Branzino, Burger, Cajun Shrimp Pasta as well as our appetizers which included lamb chops and Calamari. We also had a mini-chicken and waffles appetizer... Really good. I haven't seen this before and glad I tried it. Although we did enjoy the entrees, we left the drinks. From my experience I would suggest visiting the bar but I would place an order to go.

Cool bar and i like the age restriction. They had dark and stormies but no mint for mojitos. Before…read morei went outside for a cigarette and ordered another drink, i asked the bartender if he was closing soon (it was around 10-11) he said no. When i came back in he was windexing the bar down and practically sprayed my drink. Why tell me youre staying and then pull that? Overall its ok if youre by the railroad but even with the age restriction it was quite loud and rowdy when their sponsored softball team came in... confusing vibe

Great Place. Always have a fun time there. Bartenders are…read morealways friendly. It has a very comfortable feel to it.

Tried giving this place another shot - instant fail I've…read morenever been served cold wings before tonight. Wings literally tasted like they were microwaved. My sons chicken fingers had no flavor whatsoever. When I noticed him not eating I tried the chicken- tasted like a plain non-seasoned breast with breadcrumbs. I felt terrible. We asked for modelo- no we don't have Blue moon? - nope Shock top? - nope Really??? I gave two stars because the service was on point. And they did try their best to help. However, after tonight I will never spend my money

This place still has some cheap drinks , frankly service and nice atmosphere as well. I'd come back…read moreand haven't tried the food but it did look good .

I came here for St Patrick's Day on an absolutely whim as I simply wanted to find a neary Irish…read morePub. It doesn't get closer than this to my place so I jogged over and walked right in. It was loud, slightly unruly, and some patrons were friendly while others were a bit out there, all things you'd come to expect at a bar on St Patrick's Day. Once my date and I spotted an open table, we quickly snagged it. After grabbing a few beers and putting in an order of onion rings, to my surprise I ran into an old friend who I haven't seen in years! It was great to catch up with him while we people watched.. and watched.. and watched. When the onion rings came out, I was pleasantly surprised just how darn good they were! They were perfectly battered, crispy, and clearly used some thickly cut onions (which IMHO, is one of the keys to a great onion ring). One of my favorite parts of the evening was when I put on my favorite Biggie song on the jukebox. I quietly enjoyed watching half of the room nod their heads and vibe to it while the other half looked around wondering who the h*ck put the song on. On the way out, I met the owner and must say, he was a super nice and friendly guy. Thanks for a fun evening!

Great place to stop in for a burger and a beer or a cocktail. Food is always great. A local pub…read morewhat else could you ask for!!