I loved my first visit to The Pizzeria in Smithtown! I brought my nephew for our lunch date on a Saturday afternoon. The ambiance inside is bright, clean, and welcoming. From start to finish, the service was excellent. Our waitress was super friendly and sweet, especially when my nephew decided he didn't want to share a pizza with me (how rude). She laughed with me and quickly brought him his own cheese slice, which made him happy! We started with drinks. My nephew had apple juice, and I got the Montauk Wave Chaser on tap. For starters, we went with the mozzarella sticks. They were perfectly crispy on the outside, with gooey cheese inside, and a side of marinara. A classic done right. I tried their bruschetta slice, which I think I could eat a slice of this everyday. The crust had a hint of balsamic baked in, topped with fresh bruschetta, creamy burrata, basil, and a balsamic glaze drizzle. So good. We decided to go with the Aunt Danielle. The personal pizza was 16", perfect for sharing. Topped with vodka sauce, pepperoni, stracciatella cheese, fresh basil, and a perfect swirl of hot honey over the top. The hot honey was the star of the show here. The spicy pepperoni mixed with the hot honey, mmmm mm. I will definitely be back. This place is a Smithtown gem! Highly recommended for families or anyone who loves great pizza with a twist. I can't wait to try their wraps that you could see through the window counter. read more

See all

Stopped by for a quick slice for lunch. The ambiance is light and roomy inside and the service is friendly. The plain cheese slice was just ok, I've had much better tasting slices. We tried the regular garlic knots and buffalo knots. Not much flavor to them and they were small at 70 cents each but they were soft and fresh. The tri-fecta with was decent with a nice thin olive oil crust. read more

See all

I recently gave The Pizzeria a 4 star review. I would like to upgrade my review to a 5. Went for lunch and as promised tried the slices of Pizza. Tried a chicken with bacon and white sauce. Also had a hot honey with pepperoni and sausage. Both of these were outstanding. Had more than enough to eat read more

The Pizzeria of Smithtown - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Amazing atmosphere. Nice bar and seating area. Very good and interesting specialty pies. Service is always pleasant and accommodating. Plenty of parking. read more

I have been back a couple of times for pizza takeout...this time we decided to eat in. We started with the calamari and it was very good. Then we ordered the "Pizzeria Chicken" Its breaded chicken cutlets topped with arugula, tomato & fresh mozzarella with a balsamic glaze It's a standard dish at most Italian restaurants. This was one of the best we had! To end the meal we had to have the cannolis which comes from Whisk bakery. They are amazing! Service was great! read more

Hot honey Sicilian slice was incredible. Thanks for hooking it up guys. Will make sure to stop off here everytime I'm in the area

Amazing Pizza, staff are super kind in explaining what every single slice is and heating it up. And the restaurant is clean and new! They will be cashless soon though. For the Pizza, all the different slices are so good and the bottom is always crunchy, the garlic knots are pretty good alone and with the sauce as well. I recommend their burrata slice! read more

I just bought a pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage . They need to put some sausage on it. Just a few crumbles. Like a dusting of sausage. No chunks at all. Not impressed at all. very small portion. read more

The Pizzeria of Smithtown - Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

We absolutely love The Pizzeria. We've gotten take out as well as dined in and we've always been happy with everything we've gotten. We love the speciality slices. Their salad slice is awesome and the house dressing you could drink with a straw. I love the pizzeria chicken entre and "The Hero". Their eggplant is awesome. All great things to say. Their drinks are also amazing. read more

This is a upscale pizza restaurant. The menu has just the right amount of Italian classics. The pizza is on point along with there wings ! Don't skip on the calzone made baked or fried (old school) the only way IMHO the chicken parm is also a hit with vodka sauce and ricotta . We always try and sit at the bar where Luke the bartender provides 5 star service and 5 star drinks (makes a killer espresso martini)! Seating in the dinning area is first come first serve with plenty of seating and great service! Only good things to say go enjoy! I think they have a Sunday special (take out I believe) check them out you won't be disappointed. read more

See all

This branch of The Pizzeria just opened in Smithtown. The restaurant looks beautiful and there is a bar that opens to be al fresco. I didn't dine in but simply ordered two slices to go. I didn't have them heated up because I was bringing them home to share. The white slice was delicious but the margherita wasn't that great. I didn't care for the crust. Lastly I thought the slices were pricey. $11.96 for them both. I'll probably go back to try their pasta and skip the pizza. read more

The Pizzeria of Smithtown - Margherita and white slice - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Awesome specialty slices. The Aunt Danielle and the Uncle Benny are family favorites. Went here for dinner last Sunday and it was very good and the service is friendly! read more

This place is really good if you eat there.Its rooms clean and modern . The staff are all great. My issue is every time we order food some may be hot and others items are freezing. This is now third time. Thought maybe first two times was a fluke. We just ordered again and pizza is actually freezing as if it was never heated up. Of course can allow that in drive home won't be piping hot but this is crazy. I think they just don't account for temperature when putting orders together and will get pizza ready and then everything else. Idk read more

The food is delicious. One of the best I've had around here- the girl that picks up the phone (not all the girls) not so friendly , I never understand how kids who have a customer service job don't know how to smile, say hello and goodbye. Restaurants should teach that. Otherwise yum!! read more

Amazing Pizza....hands down one of the best pizza places I've ever visited. I ordered the white pie without the truffle oil. The Sicilian, and a plain round pie for a family gathering we had yesterday. All were delicious and miraculously maintained their structural integrity and quality after being in the boxes for 2 hours and a gentle reheat! Amazing....can't wait to come back and try some of the other offerings as everything from pasta to sandwiches looked amazingly delicious. Staff was tremendous and very accommodating!! Don't miss this spot! read more

Just terrible in every way. Poor food quality and the worst service. As in they took the order but never even fulfilled it. Never again

I'm shocked the person who made my sandwich was OK with this presentation. I ordered the Primiano hero, it comes with soppressata and prosciutto. I'm not saying mine didn't come with those meats. But the tiny specs of meat they chopped in here is borderline disrespectful. It's essentially a Romain hero. With the pictures I provided I challenge you to disagree with me. I'm excited about this new spot. It's a beautiful place, friendly staff, good atmosphere. But please, you can't be serious with this hero. read more

The Pizzeria of Smithtown - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

See all

Much better. Luke is a good bartender and attentive. Food is always good. Really have the best pizza. Service comes down to who you have which is why we only come on certain nights. read more

Luke makes amazing margs, taste phenomenally exquisitely deliciously great. Buffalo chicken slice read more

Great Customer Service! Had an issue the other night with my order, that was my own fault, and the staff was beyond willing to help with a smile. They took great care of me. Love the food and pizza! My favorite is the Uncle Benny Pie!!! read more

Great food and service. Dine in food is very good. I would give it 5 stars but the regular pizza is fair.

First time trying The Pizzeria and I was impressed. I tried the chicken caesar wrap and it was amazing. Instead of a wrap it seems they use the pizza dough which was absolutely delicious. The garlic knots are perfect size and all the slices we tried were great! read more

Picking up an uber eats order for delivery. Order running late, im impatient cause I have other customers food to deliver. Some kid from behind the countwr tells me that I can cancel the order and that too bad theyre busy. Exvuse me ? I can cancel? Well maybe you shouldnt take too many orders if you cant handle them ... you entitled, livin home with mommy and daddy little peon. read more

Excellent Smithtown Eatery!!! Great attentive staff ambiance and Best Pizza in Smithtown!!! read more

The Pizzeria of Smithtown - Grilled Chicken Pizzeria Delicious!!! - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Such a cute place! When we arrived there was a wait, so we ordered drinks at the bar. The bartender was very nice, and attentive. Once we got a table, we ordered the calamari app which was delicious, very large rings and very tender. We also had the stuffed clams and they were whole clams, and the sauce was very tasty. For dinner we ordered the Tri-fecta pie, best pizza I've had in a while! It's olive oil crust, so different and tasty. We had no room for dessert, but will definitely be going back! read more

This past Saturday my wife and I had dinner at The Pizzeria of Smithtown. I was under the impression that this was just a fancy pizza place, but was I mistaken. We sat down to have dinner and I was extremely pleased. The server was warm and welcoming. We started with the whipped ricotta with honey and lemon zest. This was a light and delectable starter. My wife had vodka chicken with statichella and I had chicken parm in vodka sauce. Instead of pasta we had Caesar salads. The portions were huge and tasty. Unfortunately we had no room for dessert. Tonight we did takeout. Eggplant parm with rigatoni in vodka sauce. Once again this did not disappoint. We will definitely be making this a regular stop for us. read more

Delicious food every time we had been there. The shrimp pasta dish is my favorite. Nicest staff

Stopped in for some pizza and a drink, and this place absolutely delivered! The food was fantastic. The atmosphere had a great vibe. A special shoutout to the bartender--super friendly, attentive, and made some great drink recommendations. The service really made the experience even better. Highly recommend this spot if you're looking for great food, great drinks, and even better service! read more

Just tried it and got delivery. The Margarita pizza was delicious! It had a nice crunchy crust and excellent flavor with the sauce. Definitely worth a try if you are in the area. read more

The food here is great! I love the vodka slice and I get a plain personal pie and both things always come out warm and delicious!:) The service is great too! The only reason the service is a little delayed is when it's packed. The ambiance is so cozy! During Christmas it is so cute! read more

This place looks so different than previous establishment!! In my opinion for the better!!! Place brings a little of that city vibe and Babylon village feel! Loved the place and the young folks working the counter are rocking it! Place is clean well maintained and food is delicious! I will take my next company outing to this place!!! Great experience! ++++ read more

Great staff friendly service. Pizza was good . Best buffalo and best white slice I've had. The wings are breaded sauce was avg . I will go back ! The place is new and clean . read more

Leaving another review because it's one of my favorite restaurants of smithtown. Food never disappoints read more

The Pizzeria of Smithtown - Beggars' purses, Caesar salad, and chicken parm - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

Randomly came here on a Sunday afternoon. We ordered two slices and sat at the bar. We had the caprese slice and eggplant with arugula. Both were fantastic. The caprese was... chef's kiss! We also tried the buffalo garlic knots which were amazing! Drinks by Luke at the bar were 10/10. We had an espresso martini, cucumber martini from the menu, Sicilian, and margarita. Every single drink was perfection. He was very efficient and attentive. One of the best bartenders I've ever met. Love the open air bar and just overall vibe. Will most definitely be back! read more

The Pizzeria of Smithtown - Espresso martini and cucumber martini - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

The plain slices were great, the meatball Barada was incredible. The best I've ever had. The restaurant is very clean and a service was top-notch. Definitely go out of my way to get a slice of pizza here. read more

I had been to the locations at the mall and in Bay Shore before, so was so happy when this opened in Smithtown. The pizza is some of the best on the island. Love all the speciality slices! read more

The Pizzeria of Smithtown - Meatball Burrata pie - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I ordered chicken parm dinner, stuffed clams, calamari. The chicken parm needed more sauce. The salad was excellent with their dog. The calamari got soggy on the way home with the plastic cover. The clams were terrible!!! They were tasteless and were sitting in an orange oilly liquid. I do NOT recommend this place!!!! read more

Love burt pizza and what i love more is asking for a wrap and being told no substitutions because the wraps are all made in the morning read more

The Pizzeria of Smithtown - Pizza Near Me - Smithtown, New York

I really like the atmosphere and the pizza is above average. The service is always very good.

This is a new place thats around the corner, so we went to check it out. My wife and I were there for a few slices and drinks. Even though it wasnt a true complete bar, it was great. Luke was the bartender, and honestly, I would go back just for him. I saw people walk in and shout his name happy to see him as well as him remembering other people's names as they walked in. He makes a great old fashioned, and my wife loved her little Sicilian. We got the buratta app, and 2 personal pies. If you're a self proclaimed pizza snob like me, I'd ask for the pies a touch well done. Overall we had a really fun time. Casual, but upscale enough for a date night. We will definitely be back. read more