Really wanted sandwiches and decided to try the Pickled Pepper. It's a little hard to see from the road because the signs are small, however we were still able to find it. The woman who took our order was very kind and patient as we looked over the menu. The Pickled Pepper offers a great variety of sandwiches, wraps, salads, pita bread pizzas, and rotate their soups and pasta salads. I was really excited to see they serve sourdough and focaccia breads. We each got the Aussie Chicken (which is served on focaccia bread) and the street corn pasta salad. Everything tasted fresh and the garlic cheesy spread added nice flavor to the sandwich. I saw they also offer a few breakfast options during the week, so maybe we'll try a breakfast wrap or bagel sandwich next. read more

The Pickled Pepper - Aussie Chicken and street corn pasta salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Just had a simple soup and 1/2 sandwich. Dropped in, as I'd never heard of them and was intrigued. Very nice and helpful staff. Super fast. No seating. Just grab and go on weekdays. Designed best for pre-orders, but walk-in was fine at 3pm. Corned beef and Cabbage soup was just lovely! Excited to add this to my lunch rotation. read more

Had the blt...very basic & was not very good at all. Maybe I ordered the wrong thing but it is a deli...was hopeful for a new lunch spot but this one missed. read more

Service was great! Small little cafe with outdoor seating. I ordered the soup of the day which is coconut curry vegetable soup in a cup, it's a little bit watery for my taste but it's okay. I've ordered the Aussie chicken sandwich and it was omg so delicious. The focaccia bread was crispy and soft on the inside. Definitely worth it. read more

See all

Great food. AMAZING STAFF! This hidden gem is something to talk about. Good deli sandwiches with a bit of flare. The staff is amazing. They are helpful and chatty. They can help you modify your orders to match your dietary needs etc. just a warm and inviting place. Small, so grab it to go, but so worth it. My mouth is watering all over again just thinking about. read more

The Pickled Pepper - Mac salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Omg the portion is huge! It is so delicious! I was looking for something different to eat and I am so happy that I stopped by read more

The Pickled Pepper - French dip. It is huge.... Delicious! - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

I was looking for a place to eat and felt like getting a sandwich. This place was not easy to find as it looks like it is tucked away under an office building of some sort. It can be missed pretty easily. Once you get inside, there is a significant amount of parking. The service is friendly and they have several good looking options for sandwiches. I ordered the Aussie chicken based off of what others have ordered before. I would have to say this place is a little pricey for sandwiches. Each sandwich ranges from $13-$17. The Aussie chicken came with focaccia bread, lettuce, tomatoes, chicken, bacon. It had a nice sweet taste with some saltines from the bacon. The chicken and bacon went well together. Overall, I think this is a pretty solid place to get sandwiches. I would try the Aussie chicken. read more

Great service. Interesting sandwich options! Would love the staff to offer add ons to spice up each sandwich offering to taste.

Love the weekly specials that change. Always a good sandwich selection, pasta salads, salads and soups.

I wrote an initial review years ago about this place that was five stars, and it was delicious. I don't know what's happened. Change owners new management something like that. However, after speaking with management, we were able to work out an agreement so they were very helpful and polite, and I'd like to change my rating. read more

While traveling we stopped here because we could sit on the patio with our dog. We were pleasantly surprised at the many options available for lunch. We ordered a Thai Peanut Chicken wrap from the May specials menu and a Turkey Basil panini. Both were delicious! Would definitely return here in the future should we be in the area. read more

The sandwich was made exactly the way I asked. It was nice and fresh with the perfect amount of condiments. Very friendly staff and served in a timely manner. It's a small place tucked into a big building. Very clean and well lit. Definitely recommend. read more

Really great food. Subs are fantastic and the red bull drinks are tasty. I was a little put off that it was in the court house building, but it was worth it. I will definitely be back to try other things like their homemade soup which sounds amazing. read more

I've been sleeping on this sandwich spot for far too long. The sandwiches and the pasta salads are so good. The price is worth it. The staff is always nice to me. I have no pictures because I just wanted to eat tbh. lol read more

If you've ever been pregnant, you know that sandwiches/subs just HIT DIFFERENT. Not sure of the reason, but sandwiches have been a huge craving of mine through all three of my pregnancies. I was wanting an Italian sandwich one day and wanted to try somewhere new, so I ordered delivery from The Pickled Pepper. They have a great assortment of options. Paninis, subs, toasted subs, a "famous" french dip, and more lunch options too. Be sure to check out their website, because they run daily specials! I got the toasted Italian sub along with a side of their daily special, a creamy Italian pasta salad. The sub comes with Black Forest Ham, Genoa Salami, Provolone Cheese, Black Olives, Sweet Onion, Pepperoncinis, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo. Drizzled with their own Homemade Italian Dressing (copied from website). I nixed the tomatoes (not a fan) but everything else great. The sandwich was soooo good and satisfied my craving instantly! Loved the italian dressing on it, too. The creamy Italian pasta salad was decent, but nothing to write home about. I wish it had more of a zing to it, because it was just a really light flavor. Loved the fresh veggies in it though - the texture was nice and it made it really refreshing. Definitely a good find! I'll for sure order from here again when a sandwich craving strikes. read more

The Pickled Pepper - Toasted Italian Sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

This place was mid. We ordered the club sub and the turkey & artichoke on focaccia. It was okay, but nothing really stood out, and there wasn't much sauce on it. It probably would've been a lot better with more sauce. Probably wouldn't go out of my way to come back. read more

I have ate here twice and both times the food was very good. The cafe does not have anywhere to sit inside as it is a small little space inside of an office building so if it is nice outside, its fine as you can sit outside at little picnic tables but if it is not nice, you will have to take it to go. There is a very expansive menu for such a small space, however. The portion sizes are really nice sizes and the prices are reasonable for the portion and quality of food. The staff are all very kind and efficient. Fantastic little lunch spot! read more

The Aussie sandwich at Pickled Pepper was incredible! Perfectly chopped grilled chicken with bacon, cheese, fresh veggies, a hint of honey mustard and a delicious garlic sauce. A must-try! PapaFoodie read more

The Pickled Pepper - Aussie Chicken Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

The Pickled Pepper has very simple, healthful, and yet comforting and filling food that you can somehow tell has a lot of care put into it! Much prefer this place to any Panera Bread or Starbucks lunches. My go-to is the turkey basil panini, which stays crispy even when ordered with delivery. read more

The Pickled Pepper - (One bite of) the basil turkey panini - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Food was ok. My husband and I got a panini and the bread was perfectly toasted but very flavorless. It could use some sea salt or herbs or something to help. My husband got the chicken salad panini and it was very bland besides the overpowering taste of garlic, which was pretty much all you could taste. He found almost an entire clove of raw garlic in his panini. Beware vampires of PNW... lol I got the spicy Italian panini and it was good. But again, the bread could use some salt or herbs or something. I couldn't finish the sandwich though because I found a hair in the bread... so that was our first time eating there and it will be our last. read more

Food is always great, and the people there are very kind. Have never been disappointed when I've come here. The place is in a small, cozy little nook, and the prices are pretty good! Make sure you try the Aussie chicken on focaccia! read more

Tried it for the first time based on an acquaintance's recommendation, who eats in this area often (it was her first in the list of places). I ordered the roast beef Schmity lunch special.. and didn't realize until the second half that I had the wrong sandwich, but this one was delicious.. the sauce/condiments was so tasty! I don't know what this is called but can recommend this sandwich! There isn't really seating inside, it's a small shop where you order and step out. read more

The Pickled Pepper - Mystery tasty turkey, Swiss?, tomato, chicken, sandwich panini with tasty sauce - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

This might be long but here goes.... I would give The Pickled Pepper 10 stars if I could! Before today I had never been there but heard amazing things from so many people and wanted so badly to try it. They have pretty limited hours and I don't work close enough to go there on a 30 minute lunch break. So I saw they do delivery through Door Dash. I was so excited and had planned all week on not bringing a lunch on Friday (today) and getting food delivered. Then I get a notification that my order has been delivered but it shows a picture of someone else's driveway. I work at a school and gave detailed instructions on how to get it to me. I called The Pickled Pepper and explained this. Katie answered and was very apologetic ( even though it wasn't her fault) and she contacted door dash. Door dash was a nightmare, they called me several times and told me it would be re-delivered and then the last time told me they could not process the re-delivery and I would need to call customer service. I'm not happy with door dash at all but Katie called back as well, several times, checking in on what door dash was telling me. The final time she called, she told me she was going to personally come deliver it to me. She went way out of her way to do this and I am so appreciative of her. And then the food... omg, it was amazing! I ordered a cowboy pasta salad and a turkey basil panini. I was a little worried about ordering a warm sandwich that would be delivered 20ish minutes after being warmed. It was delicious and I shared some with my co-worker and she agreed. They also included a cookie that I didn't order, I'm assuming for my troubles. They went way above and beyond for me and I can't say enough good things about them. Pickled Pepper customer for life!!!!! read more

Saw good reviews and wanted to try this deli out, unfortunately, it wasn't worth the trip. $16 for a salad in which it was only half eaten as the lettuce just looked expired and I spent more time picking out the old pieces. I stopped by about 25 mins before close so perhaps that had something to do with it, but just an assumption. Service was fine and quick, but the quality of the food was the majority of this review. read more

The Pickled Pepper - Chicken Caesar salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

See all

When I say I was shocked by the quality of this place... I WAS SHOCKED. Had a random sandwich craving postpartum and ordered from this place on DoorDash... WOW!!!!! I ordered two more times in the next two weeks and I usually only order in once a month! I had a lunch special (turkey pesto, at the time) with a chocolate chip cookie and I'm actually salivating even writing about it now. EXTREMELY delicious food with great value. You can taste the quality and effort in your food. We will be lifelong customers! read more

The spicy Italian panning was neither spicy and barely Italian. Hardly any sandwich spread. Just a ton of very smoked roast beef in the middle of 2 pieces of bread read more

Delish! Sando was tremendous! Absolutely loved it, nice and fresh solid toppings. Great service.

This place is not easy to find, but it's worth it. I ordered the special...toasted focaccia tomato mozzarella sandwich. It was piled high with arugula and lots of tomatoes. It was the best sandwich I have had in a very long time! It was so good! Vegetarian options are slim. There is no place to sit, it's all strictly to go. They had lots of drink options which looked really good, although I didn't try any. read more

This place is delicious!!! Sooo many options! It's my bday so I got the French dip and added cheese. Sooo good! read more

See all

I have ordered lunch 2x now. First time I got the Turkey Basil Panini and Street Corn Pasta salad. Wow, the flavors were phenomenal. The food was so fresh and delicious. I had to order again. The second time I got the Turkey Artichoke Panini, and again I was blown away by the flavor! I didn't get the pasta salad again, because it wasn't available. I would have though, it was definitely worth reordering. The Pickled Pepper knows how to do lunch. I believe them when they say they love lunch. The sandwiches are really incredible. You have to give the Pickled Pepper a try. read more

Food is fresh and great. Service was fast. Suggestion: warm the gluten free wraps 30 seconds. They don't fall apart as much.

Always incredible. My mom and my boyfriend love when I ask if they want anything from Pickled Pepper cause it's always so delicious. Everyone in there is super sweet and gets my order out quick! Best sandwiches around. I always get the turkey artichoke focaccia with their garlic parmesan aioli instead of plain mayo and it slaps. It comes warm and the cheese is melty. Simple yet so so tasty. If you ever have the time during the week to stop by I highly recommend Pickled Pepper!!! It will brighten your day! :) read more

The Pickled Pepper - Turkey & Artichoke - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

First time visit and I am very impressed. We ordered to go and food was packaged well and incredibly delicious!! Highly recommend. read more

The Pickled Pepper - Club - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Incredible service. Awesome quality tasty food! Really small space with only outside seating. Dedicated people producing the best whole food recipes for their community. read more

Some of the best sandwiches and service. The ladies working in the small deli were helpful when ordering for the first time and just overall kind. I took my friend out for her birthday lunch and loved the sandwiches. We also got some pasta salad and Redbull mixers. Outside seating with umbrellas, but odd location. It's connected to a county building and parking was a little odd, but overall great place to eat and would be back if I'm in the area again! read more

Great sandwiches, just terrific! The staff was friendly. My 3 sandwich order was called in and was ready when they said, fast service. I will be back, often read more

This review is based off of the first and only time I've gotten something from The Pickled Pepper. My husband got two sandwiches while I had my hair done down the street. He got the Aussie (no tomato) for me, and the grilled chicken panini for him. The service was very friendly, and the ambiance was chill, clean, easy going. A nice little place for lunch. I was worried that these would be very mediocre, but they absolutely were not. The focaccia bread on the Aussie was delicious and the perfect texture, the garlic spread is incredible, chicken was great, everything was great. My husband loved his panini, same feelings about his, as I felt about mine. Best sandwich I've had in a long time. So flavorful and great chewy and perfect bread, delicious cheese. Love. I can't wait to go back and get another one! read more

The Pickled Pepper - The Aussie (no tomato) - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Love this place! Delicious sandwiches and great service. The ladies are so nice! Can't recommend enough.

Didn't care for the chicken seemed like it was out of a can... not my speed but you should try it for yourself.

Was in town for an appointment. I used Yelp to help me find a great lunch restaurant to pick up food from before I headed home. The Pickled Pepper has fantastic reviews. I ordered online through their website and headed straight to the restaurant. I didn't realize they were a little tiny place inside of courthouse. It was still really easy access and great parking. I failed to notice that I was given a time to pick up my food, and that time was like an hour away so they were not ready for me. However, the girls made my lunch right away since I knew I was there which was super nice of them. I ordered the turkey artichoke sandwich and then be BLTC sandwich. The BLTC see was amazing so good. The extra bite of their cheese spread was perfect. My husband enjoyed his turkey artichoke Panini. I also ordered some pasta salad, which was homemade and delicious. I would highly recommend this little place for a great sandwich, soup or pasta salad. read more

The Pickled Pepper - Turkey & Artichoke - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington