The Percy is a restaurant attached to a traditional pub at the bottom Easter Road. Whilst the pub plies a respectable trade, the restaurant side of the operation has always appeared a bit barren. In an attempt to find something that clicks it's been through a couple of reincarnations in the last couple of years, and in it's latest guise it has emerged as a Polish restaurant. Yellow Bench on Leith Walk, another Polish restaurant, is a favourite of mine so I was keen to see how this compares.
When we popped along business was still very quiet, but it was late on a Sunday evening and the current chef has only recently taken on the restaurant so I'll reserve judgement on that for now.
Service was friendly, efficient... and detailed. When waiting for our mains, the waitress gave us regular updates - "your main will be 4 minutes".. "your main will be 2 minutes" etc. At one point I thought this might extend to a second by second countdown in the last minute, which gave us a bit of a giggle.
The food was tasty, and in mighty portions. I had the sour rye soup to start which was a soup made with a rye flour base, boiled egg, and smoked sausage served in a hollowed loaf of bread. Even eating only the lid of the bread, this was a large enough dish to serve as a main rather than starter. I only sampled the the herring in sour cream starter but enjoyed what I tasted.
For main we both went with the beef stew with Polish potato dumplings. When it comes to stew a lot of places can be overtly generous with the gravy and lacking when it comes to the beef. Happy to report that this wasn't the case here as we were served a good ratio of gravy to chunk of tender beef. The dumplings were nice enough, but never something I get too excited about.
So how did it compare to Yellow Bench? For a new arrival it stood it's ground well. If you're looking for hearty portions of Polish home cooking, The Percy will serve you well but the decor and lighting still has one foot remaining in 'old-man pub' territory. If you're on a date I'd head to Yellow Bench as the the food presentation, candle lit tables and general ambience better lends itself to that dining experience. Judging by the number of Polish stores that have popped up in and around Easter Road, there's a large enough audience for both to happily co-exist. read more