Famously one of the worst music venues in North Jersey. The guys who run the place are alright, they're really about the music but honestly don't run the venue that well. The Meatlocker is a stinky basement in Montclair formerly known as 8 Park Underground. I really can't complain about the appearance of the space because it is a DIY venue and was in no way designed to be a performance space. So when I say there's a dangerous pole directly in front of the stage that people often get injured on when more aggressive bands play, it is in no way subtracting from my rating. The worst thing about this venue is easily their bathrooms and sound system. Seriously, now that this place is charging $10 a show, the least you can do is proper restroom maintenance. If there's a show I really wanna go to, I just won't eat that day so I don't have to deal with that. As for the sound system, the venue typically only mikes vocalists. This would be totally fine if they still didn't manage to make it sound like complete poo. A decent P.A system for vocals only costs usually less than $400. I know that's a lot of money for a DIY venue but once again, considering that they're now charging $10 a show...yeaaa. I like most of the staff here as people except one of them is really annoying. The last time I saw a show here I left at 1:00am in the morning because I had work early the next morning. As I tried to leave, I was basically bullied by the same staff member mentioned in another review who hounds you for a donation. There was two more bands playing who travelled all the way from Canada. Guess what, it's not my fault that YOU decided to put the band who travelled the farthest at the worst possible time slot. I apologize to that band, because I really would like to have seen them, but the venue staff should also apologize to them. As mentioned in another review, there are multiple rooms close together in that filthy basement where sometimes there will be a band practicing while there is a show going on. There have been a few instances where the show going on was so bad that I actually went to go watch another band practice that was much better. I don't think this is a bad thing about the venue because it feels like a hub for music performance and creation. The best thing about the venue is that anything goes. Practically any style of performance is acceptable here including those that could potentially harm people in the audience. On multiple occasions I've seen grown men here playing completely exposed. That's punk.
Overall the Meatlocker is an OKAY DIY venue. I believe a good d.i.y venue should be raw, but also friendly. The Meatlocker is definitely raw, but it is definitely NOT friendly. That being said, if you're a band starting up in North Jersey, you HAVE to play here. It's not only a rite of passage, but it is necessary for any local credibility in the music scene. I think the best possible solution for the Meatlocker to both increase friendliness and their profitability would be to charge a true donation, not the "suggested" $10. Shows should not be free, but people should pay what they can and what they think is fair. It just isn't worth it to pay $10 for a bunch of locals, especially when they wouldn't even want to charge that much.
Final sidenote: I once booked my band and several others here and insisted that I did all the promotion and fee collection at the door. I also made tickets that I could sell in advance to secure attendance. These tickets were $5, that's what I thought the show was worth, and it was also $5 at the door. Believe or not, it was actually the most profitable show we had played there and walked out with over $150 even after paying the venue.
Edit: People have been messaging me complaining about my review so let me clarify. I love the Meatlocker in all of it's crappy glory, I just don't think they should be charging a $10 donation when the word "donation" implies a voluntary exchange. read more