Still one of my Hamptons favorites. Classy atmosphere and still feels "under the radar"…read moreconsidering this is a historic venue. Food always has a very fresh farm to table vibe.

One of the worst dining experiences I have ever had…read more My partner became ill and was unable to join me for dinner. We called the restaurant to either move our reservation to another day or cancel it, and were told that only the manager could assist us. However, we were told the manager was unavailable because he was busy speaking with regulars at a table. I asked if we could simply be placed on hold until he was available so we could find a solution. We were told no. Instead, the employee said they would "leave a note" and that someone would call us back if they were able to help. Meanwhile, we were told that if the reservation was canceled, we would be charged a $135 cancellation fee -- despite the fact that we were actively trying to work with the restaurant to either reschedule or resolve the situation. The experience became even more unacceptable when the employee eventually hung up on us and then stopped answering our calls. The restaurant only answered after American Express contacted them on our behalf. To be clear, I have no issue with a restaurant having a cancellation policy. What I have an issue with is the way this situation was handled: being told the manager was "too busy" to speak with us, being refused the simple courtesy of being placed on hold, having our calls screened, and ultimately being hung up on. That is an embarrassing level of customer service for an establishment of this caliber. I genuinely hope someone in management -- above the person working the restaurant that evening -- takes this seriously and addresses this behavior. A cancellation policy is one thing; treating a customer with this level of disrespect is another.

Service, location, space, comfort, and quality are all words that come to mind when I think of my…read morerecent stay at the Mill House Inn. At so many other properties in the US, lost is the art of hospitality - not the case here. I haven't received this level of attentive care and detail at another property in quite some time. Having never been to the Hamptons, I took Mom "out East" during her visit this past weekend. After all, she had been hearing me talk about this little slice of heaven for 10+ years. I was torn between (this property) and the Topping Rose House, but ultimately chose the Mill House based on the slightly lower per-night prices and the fact that I simply love East Hampton. From the moment we arrived at the property, we were treated with genuine care and fabulous service, plus invited to enjoy an array of homemade snacks (plus dog food and treats) and beverages at our disposal. The front desk advised that we make reservations for breakfast the next morning (served between 8:30 and 10:30AM), as the in-house dining room would quickly fill up. Our 600+ square foot room included: kitchenette (mini-fridge stocked with alkaline water and seltzer, microwave, sink, cabinets, utensils/cups/plates/silverware), dining table with four chairs, two large and super comfy sofas, spa robes, a fire place, TV, king-sized bed, shower with two heads, two sinks (one for each of us), a separate whirlpool bathtub, and a doggy bed for my pup. Breakfast at the Inn was quite extensive and generous. The ingredients were locally sourced and prepared with precision. Mom and I had the best weekend and would wholeheartedly recommend the Mill House Inn to anyone! We are very picky women, having traveled extensively, and cannot wait to return to the star of East Hampton (and the rest of the Hamptons, for that matter).

This was our initial experience at the Mill House Inn located in East Hampton. We visited for the…read moreHampton Classic, and the location proved to be extremely convenient. Our accommodation was situated on the third floor, which was ideal, featuring a king-sized bed, a television, and a bathroom equipped with a spacious soaking tub. Each morning, we enjoyed a complimentary breakfast that included eggs, yogurt, fruit, pancakes, coffee, tea, and more. This meal was available in a cozy dining area or could be served in our room. Additionally, there is a small snack area accessible throughout the day. The Inn itself exudes the charm of a bygone era and is well-maintained. The staff consistently demonstrated friendliness and attentiveness. The Inn is conveniently positioned within walking distance to downtown and other attractions. Overall, it was a delightful stay.

This a great place to stay! We stayed here the later part of June and had a fabulous time there…read more The cottage is situated where you can walk to town, to great restaurants, and bars. The owners Jed and Leslie were super nice, very helpful and gave great recommendation for places to eat. The cottage we had was very spacious as there were six in our party. We had 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms that were decorated really nice. The cottage was also stocked with everything you could possibly need. The grounds were also super beautiful with trees, flowers, and a large spacious grass area with different sitting areas where you could sit, relax and have a glass of wine.

Very comfortable hotel with amazing outdoor spaces. The backyard is especially beautiful at sunset,…read morewhere the light is soft and fireflies dance. They offer bikes for exploring, a car service, and complementary snacks throughout the day. I recommend this hotel for all, but especially for families looking for a summer getaway. Boby, the hotel manager, is very kind and accommodating. He went above and beyond to deliver an amazing experience for my family. Be sure to try the desserts from their Balinese chef!

Absolutely loved my stay at The Maidstone! Everything about the hotel is just so cute and quaint,…read morewith a great location and impeccable service. First off, the overall property is gorgeous. It's a beautiful building, with a ton of outdoor space including tables and lounge chairs, and even a hammock + swing in the backyard. The front has plenty of seats as well, and they offer free bikes to take out for guests staying on property. The indoor decor is fabulous - each room is different, from the bar room with a cute fireplace to the millennial pink restaurant, to the eclectic and kitschy lounge next to the bar. I absolutely loved the attention to detail with all of the decor - it all just felt so unique and well put together. They sell cute jewelry in the front as well, and the bar is stocked with alcoholic seltzers, wines and beers, and a collection of cocktails. The room isn't huge, but it is big enough with unique decor in every room. It has a nice bathroom, decent sized closet, plenty of outlets for charging, and a very comfortable bed. Breakfast was included with our state, and it had a good assortment of pastries, bagels, yogurt, and more. The service was excellent from every single staff member I interacted with. I can't wait to come back!

The Maidstone for Thanksgiving dinner was very nice. The service was EXCEPTIONAL. Atmosphere was…read morewarm and welcoming. The soup and pasta were EXCELLENT. Turkey could have been better. Pumpkin cheesecake and carrot cake delicious!

Despite the pandemic, I had a very good experience recently at this hotel. The room was spotlessly…read moreclean, and the bed was very comfy. Extra points for fancy gel pillows that are similar to what I have at home! While there were certain procedures in place for social distancing, I did not have any issues using the amenities when I happened to want to. They also made me feel safe in that they were taking precautions. The pool area was clean and not too busy. They even do a fire pit some evenings where you can roast marshmallows, which was a nice touch. I enjoyed making s'mores in what I thought of as the "backyard" area of the hotel. It is sort of hard to see the turn-in from the road, so don't miss your turn. Other than that, it was pretty much ideal! The location was very handy for spending some time quiet outside at the area beaches and nature preserves.

Lovely stay at the Journey. Cindy was absolutely wonderful as was everyone else we met throughout…read moreour stay. The little breakfast set up in the lobby is perfect. The lobby itself is warm and inviting. Firepit with all the fixings for s'more's was a wonderful touch. Can't wait to come back.

I have stayed here a couple of times when visiting friends the area. The units I've been to were…read moredecent sized for one to two people, with the living area separable from the sleeping area, small kitchenette, two TVs, couch, dining table, outdoor patio. The pool is open in warmer months. The nearest beach is about 5 mins away by car. Pictures attached are of unit 205 (although I booked 201, not sure what happened there). Recommend lunch sandwiches to go from Luigi's across the street.

Dear people on the first floor under room 220. You must be seriously disturbed if you needed to…read morecall in a noise complaint on 3 women over the age of 70 having some laughs BEFORE 8 PM on Mother's Day - followed by two seconds of pulling out a couch bed for someone who is visiting their father at a cemetery on his birthday. You are obviously not connected to anyone local because WE WOULD NEVER! And YOU DID!

Really underrated hotel in EH. The staff is simply fantastic. The front desk ladies made our stay…read moreso enjoyable. Like we made new friends. The rooms are clean and the AC blows cold. Great deals midweek. A fun bar. The Palm is at your fingertips for a quality steak.

Had a lovely Hamptons overnight here. Location is the key. Seriously right in the middle of town…read moreand an easy drive to the beaches. Dark, small "lobby", so the main area could use a facelift but the room was clean and comfortable. Staff was helpful. Beach chairs, umbrellas and towels provided. Perfect for a girls trip.

BEAUTIFUL & OLD WORLD STYLE B&B…read more It's a historic home and I love the fireplaces. Do not expect to be staying in a modern glass hotel. This is not for you. They tend to not bother the guest which is a plus if you value privacy. The breakfast was very nice and homemade by our server. Everything was fresh and of very good quality. The neighborhood is quite beautiful and peaceful. Great weekend getaway.

The Baker House 1650 in East Hampton is just an amazing bed and breakfast experience. It's an old…read morehouse from 1600's with all the old world charm. If you want to have a massage or the private pool make an appointment and reserve your private time. The rooms are quite beautiful and offer a lot of charm and all the necessities. They offer delicious breakfast each morning, The staff is extremely friendly and helpful.

Staying for our 7 th season and it just gets better each time, both hotel and restaurant…read more Manager Julian makes sure that everything about your stay and dining experience is 5 star. Servers William and Michael are very professional and friendly. Chef Micky (Jamaica Mon), is excellent and accommodating. Housekeeping team are efficient and helpful. Bartenders(25+ years), mix great drinks and are accommodating. Thank you Julian and owner Suzie F., for keeping this institution, an iconic gem‍

Went for breakfast as a visitor. Called in advance to make a reservation and was told that I could…read moreif I wanted. When I arrived I found the outdoor space and inside empty. We sat at around 10:30am and was told the kitchen is closing and we must order immediately. I had to call our 3rd diner who had to order over the phone despite walking in by the time the call was done. The food was good, service intermittent and when a friend spotted us off the street and joined we asked if there was anything we could order. The staff were negative but ultimately we purchased a cup of coffee it was brought in a to-go cup. Not quite the standard you would expect. Then we were brought a bill and told we had to leave as lunch was being set up - despite no one sitting outside or inside. Perhaps it would have been better to have offered for us to sit inside to finish our breakfast but that was that. Summary food good, attitude far less so. Probably my first and likely last American hotel breakfast.

Baron's Cove is not your average motel -- it's an upscale Hamptons hideaway with serious style. The…read morerooms are comfortable with a classic nautical flair, and the whole property strikes that rare balance between laid-back and luxurious. Breakfast here is a standout -- fresh, thoughtful, and served with a view if you're lucky. But what really elevates the stay is the service: warm, polished, and genuinely attentive from start to finish. It's definitely a motel to see and be seen -- the kind of place where you'll spot stylish weekenders lounging by the fire pit or sipping cocktails on the deck. One star off just to keep expectations grounded, but it's absolutely a place worth returning to.

We absolutely loved our first time stay at Barons Cove. We can in the off season November but the…read moreplace seemed very busy with guests. We stayed two nights in a dog friendly room, which was spacious and clean - no previous smell of a dog at all! They had a dog bed and treats with bowls waiting for her. It was so cute! We visited the restaurant and our food was great. Service was quick and helpful with the menu as well. They had the fire place on which was so nice. We went to the bar/lounge afterwards and had a few drinks by that fireplace. So nice and relaxing. Staff was always welcoming and all drinks and food were good. Room was clean, spacious and comfortable. That's all you can ask for! My only complaint was when we were checking out I wanted to make sure our bill was correct and wanted to speak with someone. With Sunday brunch going on upstairs there was no one at the front desk for almost 15 minutes. During the time I was waiting two other people came behind me to wait as well. The front desk person who came back was quick and friendly to get us checked out but for the price I would think someone would be there at all times? We can't wait to come back to Barons Cove soon!!