Awesome service, chocolate peanut butter fudge is extremely disappointing lacking almost any peanut butter read more

The Fudgery - Candy Stores Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

The store was small. Great that they make all the fudge. No cross contamination with nuts, my boss is allergic! But 3 pieces of fudge was almost $50!!!!! Very yummy, but very expensive! read more

I don't really like fudge but the lady at the fudge shop was nice and offered free samples. I went upstairs and ordered their ice cream. It was good and they give you a ton with one scoop in a cup. Definitely a solid ice cream shop and I would go there again. The 2 ladies working there were nice as well and let you try any ice cream you wanted before ordering. read more

The Fudgery - a person holding a cup of ice cream - Candy Stores Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

6/26/20 "Follow your nose, it always knows." Well the sweet smell of sugar, chocolate, vanilla and brown sugar are an unbeatable, extremely tempting and unhealthy treat hips, butt, thighs and blood pressure will thank you for...no it won't...., but oh so good. Even with a mask on, the nose can still smell the smell of brown sugar. I love it. The smell draws you in and your other body senses kick in. I saw many things that look nice, my mind did not get tempted until I saw the traditional New Orleans pralines. Had to buy two of these bad boys. The combination of these with sparkling water or just plan water is delicious. One of the managers there wanted to sell me a more than two. I told him if he can eat as many of these things as possible, I would buy just as many. He didn't go for that. His diabetes would won't allow such a thing. Neither would mine. A few bites and I saved the rest for several other days. Just finished mine today. This place is very cool, but very tempting. I do like the signs of the owner of this business doing cover shots of different movies or books. We will most likely be back. Good times great food, even if it is bad for you. read more

See all

The scent of chocolate was intoxicating at the Fudgery! I wanted to buy some fudge, but sadly they only sell fudge by the slice (pretty hefty portions). I would have liked to have purchased several flavors in smaller pieces. I wanted to try them all! It was a hot day outside so I couldn't justify buying big slices just to have them melt in the heat. Who can eat that big slab of fudge at one time? Some of you may be able to, but I just wanted a few bites... my sweet tooth left feeling salty. read more

The Fudgery - The fudge - Candy Stores Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

See all

Nice fudge place. You can see them making it. Price is per pound. Carry some candied treats and cookies as well.

Great fudge, even greater service! Must visit! Had the best fudge ever! If you come here, must try the cookies and cream, tastes just like the ice cream! read more

No! Fudge is so yummy but this fudge was sadly not. It was super hard and taste old. It taste like they added something weird to it which took away from the flavor. Peanut butter didn't even taste like peanut butter. Super sad. We tried 4 flavors peanut butter, cookies and cream, Carmel chocolate and sugar free. All terrible. A WASTE of $40 dollars. read more

Bottom Line: Great annual advertisements, good fudge and central location but a bit pricey. What The Fudgery does better than most businesses in OBX is advertising. Their front page add in the Sunny Day never disappoints. Not only is the add entertaining, but it's also enticing. Enticing enough that when I find myself at the Jockey's Ridge Crossing shopping center I feel compelled to poke my head in to see what kind of fudge they are finishing on the marble table tops. Watching fudge be cooled and formed into loafs is oddly intriguing and before you know it, you find yourself in line for a 1/2 lb. slice of fudge. This is another case where I think the adversing, this time being part of the fudge making process, really works. As for the taste of the fudge, it's good. Not the best I have had but definitely good enough for me to eat more. Unfortunately, you do have to be very committed to fudge here because the smallest piece they sell is 1/2 lb. which is a lot for me. At other places you can get much smaller pieces and it's easier to get a variety that way. The Fudgery is located at the Jockey's Ridge Crossing shopping center between the bypass and beach road at MP 12.5. The fudge store is located in the central part of the shopping center next to Kitty Hawk Kites. read more

The Fudgery - A view, albeit not a good one, of The Fudgery. - Candy Stores Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

It was buy 3 get 1 free. Flavor of the month was birthday cake - my favorite. When I say it was the best fudge I've ever had - it was the absolute best. If in the area you won't want to miss out on The Fudgery. read more

Not the widest selection, but of course everything is delicious. (It's fudge! Even the shittiest fudge in the world is still going to be tasty.) One cool thing -- you can see them actually preparing the fudge on the marble tables. And if you buy 2 pounds, you get 1 pound of vanilla for free. Or if you buy 3 pounds, you get a 4th pound of any flavor for free. read more

See all

Super awesome place with awesome management! I was not expecting to make any purchases but the friendly staff and samples quickly changed my mind. We ended up walking out with 2lbs thanks to a nice man working. Hope COVID isn't hurting this friendly store and that they will be around OBX for a while! read more

You can smell the confectionary delights before reaching the door. It smells delicious. The service here was very fast and friendly. The fudge was very good. It even lasts 2 weeks at room temperature as long as it's place in an airtight container. I would definately return. read more

The Fudgery - Candy Stores Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

See all

The Fudgery has the best fudge I've ever had. In fact, after having this fudge no other fudge compares. My personal favorite is the Vanilla, but all of the flavors are divine! Don't forget to grab a Sunny Day magazine for a free 1/2 lb of fudge with the purchas of 1 lb. SO DELICIOUS! Also, it's a fun place for families to visit if you can catch them making the fudge they will give you free samples. The have giant slabs of marble where they shape the fudge, it's fun to watch and so good when it's fresh! read more

We have been coming to the fudgery for over 20 years. It has become a staple in our list of "what do you want to do today". We usually go at least twice and every time we swear we will only get one slice, we usually come out with two. However, there have been times when we have made it out with 4! read more

See all

We were already in the shopping center so we checked this shop out. Free samples of fudge to try led me to get a half pound of the chocolate peanut butter. Then we got told of the deal - buy one more half pound and you get a free half pound of vanilla fudge. Boy, were we goners. Boyfriend had been wanting the vanilla all along so we got the cookies and cream fudge too. A big reason why we got the fudge is that we were assured it would not melt. Important to us since we were driving back home. Well what they said is true, it did not melt and tasted just as good as we tried when we had it as our late night dessert. A bit pricey, but worth it for how good it is! read more

Again, just like the Fudge Company, limited selection. In addition, this company gives the smallest samples...to the point where you can hardly taste anything to determine if you like it or not to buy some. Nah, just head on over to Cold Stone Creamery for some real good treats. read more

I went in here yesterday and the girl that helped me was so awesome! She was so friendly (and funny!). You can sample the fudge ... The birthday cake flavor is AMAZING. read more

Charged me double! When I questioned it, I got an unintelligible reply and she took my card. Be very careful when you go there and maybe get fudge somewhere else. read more

The Fudgery - Candy Stores Near Me - Nags Head, North Carolina

Yummy fudge!!!! The counter lady was very nice when we asked to try a bunch of their fudge. They gave us 2 free 1/2 lb slices of fudge after buying four 1/2 lb slices. It was pretty good! My fav is the maple nut!! We also got a box of candied pecans. It wasn't very good. but the fudge was worth it! read more

Fudge was ok....I'm not a fudge connoisseur though. It taste like a spoonful of sugar. They tell you slice weighs about half a pound, but on my receipt they were over a pound. So if you like fudge and plan to buy a lot, this is the place. They give you a free slice of the vanilla if you buy multiple slices. Which now I know why, it's horrible. I actually threw it out. But if you're just looking for a snack, go grab it somewhere else, they only sell per slice. read more

We had to visit after we saw the Star Trek themed ads in the booklet in our hotel room! The Fudgery didn't disappoint! I love that we were able to watch them making the fudge; it was interesting to see and showed the fudge was pretty fresh! Buy 2 lbs, get one free! Several flavor choices as well! Yummy yum! read more

There were flies inside the display case. Landing all over the chocolate. What more to say? DISGUSTING.