I recently stayed 5 nights at the Eldridge and one at the Springhill. Here is a comparison:
STAFF:
Superb at both places. Nothing bad to say about either.
CHECK-IN/OUT:
It seemed impossible to check into the Eldridge before 4:00. The Springhill let me in at 2:00. Checkout was 11:00 for both. Check in and out were flawless at both.
DESIGN:
The Eldridge is a faux historic hotel: It was built in 1925, but only the first floor has very much original, and that's confined to the floors, some ceilings downstairs, the walls descending into the basement, etc. I like the generous use of wood, but none of it is original. It's all designed to "look" old, which is what I mean by "faux historic."
The Springhill was built as an outlet mall in the 1980s. The center of the failed mall was converted to the hotel in the late 1990s. It was remodeled in 2011 with a 50's-modern retro look I enjoyed. It is due for remodeling in 2016.
AMENITIES:
Both have exercise rooms; the Springhill has a pool, which I did not try.
CLIENTELE:
The Springhill seems to attract more business people during the week, and more families on the weekend. The Eldridge seems to attract more couples, "girls on the town" types and people "looking for a good time," at least after Wednesday.
FOOD:
The Ten restaurant in the Eldridge has a variety of good breakfast items for $3-$5; with free coffee from the lobby, it is hard to spend $10 on breakfast. At the Springhill, there is a free "standard" eggs-waffles-oatmeal, hotel breakfast, with good coffee.
There is also a bar at the Eldridge: Low-key sports atmosphere. Drinks aren't too overpriced.
There is no restaurant or bar at the Springhill, but it is very easy to walk to about 150 of them within 1/2 mi. Suggestions: The Free State Brewery. 715. La Parilla. Check reviews.
ROOMS:
Room 506 at the Eldridge, a King room, is reported to be haunted by Col. Eldridge. I also had a King room ($139 weekdays, $169 weekends), but no haunting. Due to the age/design of the hotel, it was somewhat smallish; it has two rooms, with two leather chairs, but there is no couch like at the Springhill. Springhill seemed slightly more spacious. MORE importantly, the Springhill had a dresser. I will unpack completely if I am staying more than one night. In the Eldridge, I had to keep my suitcase out and open on the stand. There was room in the room for a dresser.
BED/PILLOWS:
The King bed at Eldridge was a little soft and bouncy; I'm glad my wife wasn't on the other side, or I would have felt her every move. The bed at the Springhill was firmer. The pillows at the Eldridge were very thick and full and I therefore declined to use them. The Springhill offers a variety of pillows on the bed, from thin and firm to big and fluffy; take your pick. (Why don't more hotels do this?)
EXTRA TOUCH:
The Springhill room had a clock radio in which an Iphone 3 or 4 would play and charge, and an audio in cord for playing music from any other device. It also featured a "sleep machine" white noise generator. (The Eldridge room also had a white noise generator.)
BATH/SHOWER:
Due to the age of the hotel, it can easily take 15 min. of wasting water for the hot water to come on. Seriously; they warn you about it in their in-room documents. My first day there, I didn't know better and settled for a lukewarm shower that just got me angrier by the minute. Next day, I learned that you want to take a shower between 7 and 9 when everyone else is. Shower water pressure was average at the Eldridge, good at the Springhill.
TV:
Two 42" HDTV's per room at the Eldridge; just one at the Springhill. But they only play standard def! If you want HD, you'll need to go to the bar, which has several HDTVs playing various games. The TV's at the Eldridge (and the Springhill) have HDMI ports, so you can use an HDMI cable to project your laptop onto the screen and watch Netflix in HD. (Tip: I bought a "Miracast Dongle DLNA Airplay WiFi Display Receiver Dongle HDMI 1080P Media Share" on Ebay for $20 which allows you to project whatever's on your phone, tablet, or modern laptop screen onto the TV. Netflix, anyone?)
WIFI:
Wifi at the Eldridge was super-speedy. I got 15Mbps down during the middle of the day, 10 at night. At the Springhill, it averaged 2.5-3.0 Mbps.
NOISE:
I thought the walls at both places were pretty thin; I could hear conversations in the adjacent rooms. Many people complain about the train noise at the Springhill. I found the noise of the slamming doors, loud talking in the halls and people yelling outside after the bar closes at the Eldridge to be more distracting than the trains. (The Eldridge gets louder each night; Thursday-Saturday is a little bit too much of a party atmosphere.) I sleep with earplugs in, and those types of sounds seem to make it through them more than train horns. In addition, the in-room HVAC system at the Eldridge was noisy when it came on (it was winter, and it came on a lot). [Rest of review on TripAdvisor.com] read more