The service, the selection of cigars are fantastic! Mike and Tim run fantastic Cigar shops! Couldn't ask for a better owners operators and gentlemen that will get you anything that they can possibly find. read more

I've only been here a couple of times, but the staff is knowledgeable and friendly; willing to answer your questions. They have a different selection than you'll find at Blend or some other cigar shops, so support another locally owned business and find some variety for your humidor! read more

Reviewing this for my husband who is a cigar aficionado. He loved the selection and knowledge of employee that helped him. In fact after smoking a couple we had to go back through Indianapolis to go grab a couple he hasn't been able to get in Kansas. He was really impressed with this store! read more

Cool place. Not a good ventilation system but the guy behind the counter was very helpful. I'm a novice. he took his time answering questions and making recommendations. Only four stars because I've been to other places that I didn't smell like smoke when I left but I recommend. Give it a visit. read more

A three-star rating is Very Good, in my scaling, and this Cigar Box location is exactly that. A cozy shop with a generous selection, I was able to find my Arturo Fuente favorites, and pick up a few others, as well. A convenient location, and friendly staff; it looked like it a good place to sit and smoke one as well. I'll stop by this Cigar Box location if I'm back in the area. read more

I had an unpleasant experience 4 years ago. The new owner reached out to me and asked me to give the shop another shot. Not only am I extremely impressed with the humidor conditions and the meticulous upkeep of the cigars, but the selection was phenomenal for being a relatively small humidor. Two thumbs up! read more

Stopped in for the first time. Pleasantly surprised by small but comfortable and well stocked store. Knowledgeable staff, good broad selection and competitive pricing. Small smoking lounge that I will return to enjoy. read more

I've been coming to the Cigar Box for over a decade. Not only does Tim have a great selection and prices, the clientele are great folks to hang out with, have a smoke and watch a game. Highly recommend you give them a try next time you're buying a stogie. read more

What a selection this place has. They have a very big walk in humidor and several humidor cabinets outside of that. I didnt stay and smoke but they have a comfy looking lounge area as well with big plush chairs and TVs. Im just getting into the hobby, and staff was so helpful, walked into the humidor with me and helped me make a few selections based on my budget and taste. Looking forward to coming back here. read more

The Cigar Box is an amazing shop that really embodies everything a true cigar shop should be. The prices are great, and only beaten by their amazing selection. The store has a very personal feel as there are two owners who seem eager to chat. I would highly recommend The Cigar Box over any of the ritzier shops in Broadripple. My entire experience was incredibly pleasant, and I am making The Cigar Box my go to tobacconists when I'm in Indianapolis. read more

A nice cigar shop to run in and grab a variety of sticks with well over 100 different brands. Small area to enjoy a smoke. I come in about every 2 to 3 weeks and grab some Fuentes, Padron, My Father, Camacho, Romeo Y Julietta and a few others. And if you buy a box, you get 10% off. I have been coming here for over 10 years. How can you go wrong. Give it a try. read more

Delightful cigar shop. Very nice humidor and intimate space for smoking what you buy there or just hanging out. Prices are good.

Excellent, fresh selection and fair prices. I love to stop by when I am driving from Chicago to my parent's house in Geist. Owner is very friendly and even throws in free items every once in awhile. read more

As a regular smoker the selection was ok, and pricing was ok. The lounge itself was small, cluttered and dingy. Ventilation was not the best either. Staff was nice. read more

By far one of the best around. Great smoking area with regular customers. Huge humidor with good prices. A type of cigar for everyone.