Love this pub. Everything about it is great, but what makes it special is it's service. Staff are extremely knowledgeable on the menu and what to try based on your preferences. From Smokey flights to your average scotch, this place has it all. Food is also delicious. A simple but effective menu, this place is doing everything right. read more

Best Guinness in town is another accolade amongst a very long list. Their patio out back is also right up there with the best, street dining for those who can't get a patio seat in summer. read more

Amazing. First time here and this is as authentic as it gets. Will definitely be back again and again and again Edit: have been several times now and continue to be exceptionally pleased with each visit. The food is fantastic, the beer and Irn Bru cold, and the service is unparalleled. Looking forward to my next visits. read more

See all

Best Scottish pub in Toronto. Dave and Donna are amazing. Great spot for tastings and their whisky selection is fantastic. If you're in the area it doesn't disappoint. 5/5 * read more

Came here on a Thursday evening. Their patio is big and is split into 2 parts, covered and uncovered. Decent beer selection, huge Scotch whiskey selection. They even do scotch flights! We had their taster platter and the scotch egg was amazing! Also ordered their mac & cheese and butter chicken. If you like Mac & cheese, you'll love this one. Wow! The butter chicken was good too! Our server was quick and attentive​. To end, great food and great service! read more

Donna, Meg and the rest of the staff are amazing! The food will transport you back to Scotland! I highly recommend the sticky toffee pudding. They have the best whisky collections in the city, along with a caring and knowledgeable staff. I also love the fact that they have Tennants on tap! Highly recommend this place!! read more

Came here yesterday for date night. The standing rating already speaks for itself. what a great dining experience. Food- we each ordered an entree since we came here after a snack and drink down the street. I got the Mac and cheese and my SO got the steak pie w frites. My Mac and cheese was amazingly creamy, very flavourful and cheesy, great crust on top, and the portion was very large. I have a bit of a love affair for Mac and cheese (maybe because growing up it wasn't something we ever are but I digress...) and this gooey rendition w cherry tomatoes was wonderful. The SO got a steak pie which is essentially bites of steak in a Guinness sauce covered w a puff pastry and fries on the side. He loved it, and I was immediately transported back to Scotland when I tried it. We were both very happy w our dishes. They were under $18 to boot as well so we can't go wrong here. The prices are very reasonable. We ended off w a deep fried mars bar - enter Homer Simpson drool sound - melt in your mouth, sweet and rich. Great to share. Drinks- I ordered the Whisky caeser and I was pretty happy with it. I've never had a drink like it that's for sure. Essentially whiskey, clamato and horseradish, no salt rim or any toppings tho. The whiskey was incredibly peaty and it came thru with each sip of the drink. It's not my Favorite Caesar in the city but it was good and i would i give them points for the inventive combo. Service- wonderful. The place was PACKED. We managed to get a table within 2 mins tho and the waitress was just on point. She checked on us, was prompt in everything we asked for, asked if we wanted more drinks etc. most importantly she was really friendly and was really good at her job. What I described above is apparently too much to do sometimes in some too cool for school joints. Resto- great lighting, very romantic. Vibe was friendly and just a place full of great ppl. Comfortable and perfectly warm durig these cold months. Not pretentious at all. Dark wood features and a beautiful well stocked bar. There's a tv on in the corner as well showing replays of the Olympics. We were happy to pay for that meal as it so worthwhile and the service was so nice. In the summers their patio is one of the best on the city IMHO (see pic) read more

The Caledonian - Steak pie and frites. - Pubs Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

My first trip the Caledonian was a bit of a mixed bag, and if Yelp had a 3.5 star rating, I'd be inclined to lean towards it. However, I'm going to have to settle on a 3 star. Ok on to the details..... Our group showed up at the Caledonian later in the evening for a night-cap and was told that on Thursday's the bar has last call at 1am. With a statutory holiday looming on the next day, a few fellow Yelpers piped up to say, "Even on Holy Thursday!?' Yes...apparently even on Holy Thursday. Considering the bar was fairly full with patrons looking to unwind (get drunk) without the worry of an early morning the next day it certainly came as a bit of a surprise, and I'm sure the Caledonian missed out on a boatload of extra revenue. On the bright side, the waitress was more then understanding and let us nurse our beers until 2 am. (Disclaimer: After writing that last sentence, I adjusted the Yelp rating to a 4. Must give credit, where credit is due.) The atmosphere and feel of the Caledonian is great and while I can't speak for the food they offer, they've got a great patio out back that smells like rich, new MDF board (Disclaimer 2: I once worked at a woodworking factory. When you head out back, look up under the awning. That my friend is MDF board...and yes it was brand spanking new on my visit). If the weather had of been a few degrees warmer I'm sure our group would have enjoyed our beers a little more. I can easily see this patio being a big hit come summer time and hopefully the scent of new MDF has subsided. I'm looking forward to my next trek to the Caledonian this summer to enjoy a nice cold beer on the patio......I just hope that last call on the weekends is 2am! read more

OMG. That doesn't even begin to describe this place. Donna served us and couldn't of had a better experience. Food was hot, fresh and fast. The price was amazing considering the location. This place was picked right out of Scotland and put here for us Canadians to enjoy. 5/5. Will be back soon. read more

The Caledonian - Steak pot pie - Pubs Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

We love this local restaurant! Wonderful atmosphere and very welcoming owner. This time around we tried the burger, fish and chips and curry. Great burger bun, nice patty and fresh lettuce, onion and tomato. Thin-cut fries well cooked. Fish batter is lovely - light in texture, airy and a really big serving of fish. Butter chicken was well executed - good flavour and the right hint of spice. Service is very attentive and pleasant. Great selection of beer and - it goes without saying - Scotch! Wait for food was long, but such is life. read more

The Caledonian only got better on my repeat visit. A confluence of elements created the perfect meal - cozy dimly-lit dark wood interior, gorgeous bar, quiet chatter, amazing owner, delicious food, wonderful beer selection. It's the perfect place for a casual date night (if you enjoy your date). The service was also top-notch, and not for nothing, but the servers and the owner were all running themselves silly to provide their guests with the best experience in the most unpretentious manner. The owner is a no-nonsense but delightful and warm woman who darts around the place like a pistol, clearing plates and spouting out wonderful things in a Scottish accent, such as "Of course we've got room for you! Jump on in there!" This, my friends, is what you want from a front-of-the-house manager. Straightforward and charming, she made the experience go from good to great. My husband swore that she'd go zipping across the room on a horse just like the main character in Brave at any moment, gorgeous wild red hair flying behind her! The selection of Innis and Gunn here is fabulous - they have the original, the oak aged and a seasonal. In my opinion, go with the oak aged. It goes perfectly with just about anything! We got the Taste of Scotland appetizer...something right up my alley. Fried haggis, sausage rolls and a Scotch egg. Beautifully plated and a wonderful mix of textures - squishy, crunchy, salty, moist. Just the right amount to warm two people up with a couple pints of beer. As we usually do, we split an entree as well, this time being the steak pie with a side order of neeps. Mmm, mashed turnips - a favorite of mine from childhood that I haven't had in ages! The steak in the pie was fork-tender and the crust was homemade too. It was a nice little portion and, after our starter and beers, just the right amount of food. Of course this left room for dessert. We got the fried Mars bar. Every time I have this dish, I'm amazed by how good something so simple can taste -- that melted chocolate and carmel, covered with the crispy batter and a little dollop of ice cream is the perfect way to finish off the night! The crowd at the Caledonian is mostly people in their late-20s to mid-50s. It's couples and groups catching up, it's not a place to go on a girls' night or a guys' night to pull someone of the opposite sex. Once you've found them at another bar, though, this is the perfect place to get to know your date better without killing your bank account. This isn't to say that the place wouldn't be perfect for groups to do organized whiskey tastings. Looks perfect for that! A favorite that we will certainly return to as much as we can in Toronto, the Caledonian conjures warm and happy memories just as I write this review. We'll be back! read more

It is a very warm and welcoming place. Donna, the owner made a point to come over and introduce herself, and dropped by from time to time to ensure all was well. I noticed that everyone who came through the door had the same treatment. The servers too, were all very warm and personable. I felt very settled the whole night The food was excellent. I started with a Scotch egg. I love Scotch eggs, and have few places to have them and this was as good as my Scottish neighbor used to make in Oshawa a lifetime ago. Teena and I both had fish and chips which were great. I loved the lightly battered fish, the chips and the greens which came with it. I love the beer selection. They have a good draught selection but if you are looking for true Scottish beer, it comes in bottle form. Many great and unusual choices. Their motto on the website is "Come for the food, stay for the drink, return for the friends you've made." As Teena and I left, Donna the owner, on a very busy night, made sure to call out to tell us to have a good night and thanks for coming. Thanks Donna......and yes we'll be back! read more

The warm and inviting atmosphere at this brand new Scottish pub is a whisky lover dream. Plus, it's the only place in the city where I've ever seen haggis on the menu... I'm still working up to trying the haggis but I'll report back once I do. This bar might just breathe some new life into this strip of College Street that was previously home to not much more than several vacant shop fronts and the less than stellar Black Knight. read more

Great Food, Wonderful Service, Incredible atmosphere on the lovely patio, and the best of all-- Outstanding value that would please any Scot! (and I'm half Scottish, so I can say this!) We began with a bottle of Pinot Grigio that was an applaudable $30. It reeked of nothing but white peach, but for a summer's eve on a patio, this is not just allowed but welcomed! We had the Scottish platter that consisted of Haggis fritters, sausage rolls and a scotch egg cut in half to share. YUM! Is there anything more delicious with a drink than a Scotch Egg? I think not. And to continue our 'No Vegetables Allowed' menu, we had fish and chips and the mac n Cheese. Fish was a crispy and generous portion of haddock with lots of chips, but they were very brown and over cooked. I forgive because everything else was so great. Mac N Cheese---some of the best I've had and not made at home myself. They snuck a couple of cherry tomatoes in there, and they were a surprisingly delicious contrast to the cheesy decadence of the dish, itself. Patio was nicely decorated without being pretentious, and the crowd was a mix of 30 somethings and a few old-timers. It's not a rowdy pub for the young 'uns. Our server was the cutest and sweetest Glaswegian lass and we very much appreciated her witty anecdotes as much as her attentive and timely service. Our bill was just under $85 for all the aforementioned goodies. This place is a winner or all fronts and I plan on coming back!! read more

We went for my birthday with a large group of various ages. The food is excellent, I especially liked the beer battered kosher pickles. The whiskey menu is wonderous and had many scotches from distilleries I had not even heard of. Which were great drams. The service was excellent, even putting up with my high maintenance family that is picky to no end. I can not recommend a better pub for Scottish food and great scotch. read more

When you think of an Scottish pub, I think most people would think of a somewhat divey, low key spot with a wooden interior with a great chance or reeking of beer, with fried food galore and a clientele that's there with one purpose - to get drunk. While there's still plenty of fried food on the menu (hey, that's the Scottish way afterall!) Caledonian was a nice break from that stereotype, it's an "upscale" Scottish pub which focuses on a good selection of whiskey, and traditional Scottish food. A dark interior and a clean and upscale ambiance, it's a place you'd find people in suits meeting after work. Scottish eggs ($7 for one egg) were nice, though the fried out shell was a bit soft for my liking. If there are two of you, you should opt for the sampling platter ($16) which comes with a Scottish egg, 2 sausage rolls and 2 haggis fritters. The curry fries ($8) were alright. Fries were a bit soggier than my liking, even the ones that weren't drenched in curry sauce. The haggis ($16) was done right - a good big slice of haggis sitting on top of a bed of mash, and slathered in gravy. It has a pretty distinctive taste, with the lamb and tons of peppercorn. If you haven't had haggis, I'd give it a try - don't hate me if you don't like peppercorn though, you've been warned! And also be warned, it's really, really, really heavy! Fish and chips ($15) looked ok, a heaping portion of fries with one piece of fish. The steak pie ($14) was pretty good, but nothing special. The mash it came with was great though. They also have a good selection of whiskey, with flights for tasting (0.5 oz pours in each flight) that range from $12 or so up to $50. A single drink will set you back about $8. Also a decent selection of beer, and yes, Guinness is definitely on tap :) read more

Why should you go to The Caledonian? I'll give you 4 Reasons: -Tennent's on tap -Haggis, Neeps & Tatties -Scottish Steak Pie -Sticky Toffee Pudding All are excellent!! The pub also feels very authentic , with great service and had a nice back patio. read more

It's been a couple of weeks since we went to The Caledonian, but I felt I should share my thoughts. I was there with Patty H (her review is also here) and was eager to let my new friends in Toronto sample some of the Scottish foods I had been ranting on about ! Firstly, I would say the atmosphere and décor was very similar to a number of Scottish Pubs back home... there was also a good selection of Scottish booze based beverages, but sadly no Irn Bru :( We ordered quite a selection from the menu, and let everybody dig in. The food was served in pretty good portions. My penny pinching Scottish upbringing made me think you didn't quite get all you paid for with some of the portions, especially the Scotch Egg. Unfortunately I felt the Haggis lacked a little authenticity. It wasn't as spicy as I would have expected and I would have preferred a loser texture too. I have never been served a slice of haggis, unless its then been fried and served on the side of dish or on a roll. The gravy, was also unexpected. White turnip, rather than brightly coloured neeps? I guess it had been toned down for the Toronto market , and they did what they could with the ingredients to hand ? All in all, it felt like a wee spot of Scotland in Toronto and it was an enjoyable brunch. read more

Excellent atmosphere, the best service I've had in ages, and a fantastic fish and chips - where the large filets are lightly battered and delicious - where the fries laying under the filet aren't starchy, over-oiled, and soggy. Crisp and light, flavourful. The Scotch Egg is delightful, crispy and rich - finish it with the creamy bread pudding and wash it all down with a Caledonian pint. The haggis was more than I'd expected in terms of texture and presentation. Dreamy. read more

I consider myself to be very lucky that this is my local - how can you go wrong with that many delicious beers (the Elderberry & Heather ones are my favourite, so far) and such an amazing (and reasonably priced) assortment of single malt scotch? The food is significantly better than your average pub food - in particular the scotch egg, which cannot be adequately described due to it being That Good, and the steak pie, which is perfect winter food. I like that it's unpretentious and casual, too, possibly because it's aimed at a slightly older crowd than other bars in the area. read more

Wow, found this place on Yelp, and we were in the neighbourhood looking for a yummy place to grab a pint and a bite to eat. When we walked in the door we thought it was going to be impossible to get a seat, because the place was jam-packed! One of the waitresses quickly made her way over to us to greet us, and let us know that a table was about to free up, so we only had to wait about 4-5 minutes to get a table. It was worth the wait. It's a traditional Scottish-style pub, and a really cool place. The tables are packed in a slightly too close to one another, making it a bit tricky to get in and out of your seat, but I guess that means a few extra tables and makes it so that more people can get in to enjoy the place. They maintain a bar which stocks mostly imported beers and alcohols, which a feature scotch, which one of my friends opted for. Magners and Keith's ciders were the only ones available, but the waitress assured me that Magner's is great with lots of ice, which it was. The menu is someone limited in it's selections, but it seems that they stick to what they know, and what they do well. The food was delicious. I opted for some sort of a beef pie with a light and flaky toping and mashed red-skinned potatoes. The pie was light, not thickened and packed full of gravy, with a hearty mix of tasty veggies and deliciously tender beef. Yum! One of my friends ordered a salad off of the appetizer menu, which she enjoyed, and the other opted for the mac and cheese, which she liked. I tasted the mac and cheese and thought it could've used a bit more S&P, but otherwise it was tasty. Food prices were very reasonable.... it worked out to be about $20-25 per person for an entrée and an alcoholic beverage. Not bad. Overall, it the place had an upscale, cozy feel for a traditional pub. Very enjoyable. The music wasn't too loud, which was nice... we could actually talk to each other. read more

After a game of ball hockey, my team and I decided to grab dinner to celebrate another successful season and with our experience with Indie Ale House in our last season outing, most of us had high hopes coming to The Caledonian for a Scottish dinner after an intense game. Unfortunately, this place around the area was quite disappointing given it had positive reviews on yelp. First of all, if you had been reading my reviews, you will know lighting is very important for me. I dislike dim places because it makes me very sleepy and energy draining when I'm supposed to enjoy a meal especially at night! (maybe it would be considered as romantic if i was actually on a date). Lighting is terrible here, it's so dim I can actually fall asleep. Second, the ventilation was terrible, no AC at all on a day that is 25 degrees outside, our party had to move closer to the patio to actually feel a little breeze. Third, the service was not great, server was not very attentive, wasn't polite either and didn't smile much, But consider they only had two waitress that night, I guess I shouldn't expect great service. Actually, I blame it on the dim lighting/atmosphere as I believe it must have took a toll on the waitress mentally as well as the night went on. Fourth, the food was not impressive at all. I ordered the Scottish Steak Pie hoping it would be decent because this is a Scottish restaurant afterall and the pie was terrible. Sauce was not flavorful at all, the steak was very chunky and rough and the potato didn't taste good. The only positive I have for this restaurant and deserves the 1 star I am giving is because when I asked for a recommendation on a light beer, the waitress recommended the Innis & Gunn Lager and I really enjoyed it. Overall, if you are on a date and/or you are into whisky, with their wide selections of whisky, you will find one that is for you. read more

See all

This is one of the best spots in the city to grab a drink and quality pub grub in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Donna and her staff are extremely knowledgeable about scotch and treat everyone as equals, from experts to novices. And I know because I had my first Islay here. Go ahead and ask your questions, they'll bend over backwards to find what your looking for and educate you in the process. I've always had great experiences learning about new scotches here. Assuming you can get a seat, the back patio in the summertime is also a not so hidden gem. I also enjoy the niche beer list focused on scottish imports like Innis and Gun and Tennents. Rounding out this bar is the simple but quality food menu. I think I've tried almost everything from the butter chicken to the haggis and I've never been disappointed. The only item that I found closer to average was the burger but the fish & chips was the best I've had in the city. Overall, you can expect good food that's not going to break your wallet. I can't comment on authenticity because I haven't been to Scotland but friends of Scottish decent seem to enjoy the roast beef and bread pudding, Scottish egg, and the haggis even though I understand it's not served in its most traditional form. My only knock is that the prices of certain scotches that can get quite high so I've had some bills creep up there after some tastings. But that's really a product of the LCBO system more than anything else so I'm not going to hold it against the Caley.. Overall, fantastic place! Please don't change a thing. read more

I've gone a few times for drinks, tried the food for the first time yesterday. I had the 4 cheese baked mac & cheese. It was incredibly rich with roasted garlic and grape tomatoes mixed in, and pretty much put me in a food coma. My partner had the steak pie. Pie crust was light and flaky, meat was tender, fries came with a side of curry sauce. But lets face it, you're here for the Scotch. And if you're not sure about Scotch, this is a great place to learn. Extensive Scotch menu ranging from the affordable 10 year olds to some very expensive, premium 25 year olds, and everything in between. If you're indecisive or still learning, there are some interesting flights at the back of the menu that again range from an accessible try ($19 or so), to the super premium ($100 or so). If you're not sure, just ask the staff. Not a Scotch drinker? Shame on you. (Although I think I was the only woman sipping Scotch last night.) There is a short but creative cocktail list focused on more mature offerings with quality Scotch, instead of bar rail sludge. Beer list is succinct and focuses primarily on Scottish offerings, including draft Innis & Gunn (yum!) and Tennants stout. Back patio is huge in the summer. There's also a "keyholder" system, where you can leave a premium bottle of Scotch with them and drink it whenever you come. Keyholders include the likes of Ron Sexsmith. We come here whenever the dude wants to be spoiled with Scotch options he cannot get or afford at the LCBO. Our waitress gave us a free deep fried Mars bar on the house, since my partner was celebrating his birthday. Or maybe it's cause we racked up a $200 tab? Whatever, it was a really nice touch. Someone actually busted out bagpipes while we were waiting at the bar for our table, and played a few songs. Wide range of clients. We're youngish (late 20s, early 30s), we saw some patrons younger than us, and some old enough to be our distinguished grandparents. read more

I think it's an amazing little pub for the area and central Toronto as a whole! I ordered the Steak Pie and it was delicious. Rather than getting an overly greasy, massive portion of junk, the dish was impressive. Perfectly cooked green beans was a pleasant surprise for a pub! The owner Donna, was really friendly and genuine, constantly checking in on us. Great beer and whisky selection, cozy understated (not tacky) decor... great little spot on College west! Had a great time, definitely going back. ps: there's an area in the back for a patio.. can't wait for warm weather to enjoy this outdoor pub space! read more

I'm all about atmosphere and this place has it: friendly, inviting, comfortable, it's like I was stepping into someone's house. It's all Donna's doing. She's the proprietor of this establishment and once you step inside her bar, you're in her home. She will make sure that you're having a great experience. In fact, all of her staff offer the same level of customer service. My first introduction to the Caledonian was on a Wednesday night and the bar was pretty busy for a weekday. Near the patio, a group of men and women of various ages were singing Scottish folk songs. This group meets once a month and if you happen to be there on the same night, it's such a beautiful thing to see and hear. I've been in love with the Caledonian ever since. In terms of libation, the Caledonian doesn't fail at this. Their beer and whiskey lists is good. They have 10 draft beers, including KLB Raspberry wheat beer. But it might be worth your while to try one of the bottled imported beers from Scotland. My favourite is Alba Scots Pine Ale, which is a popular choice. Their impressive scotch and whiskey menu includes Oban, Macallan, and all of the Glens you can think of. Their menu is traditional Scottish fare but I've only had three of their items: Fish and chips made with a light beer batter; curry and chips; and my favourite, the Taste of Scotland platter. This platter is best to share with a friend and it includes a Scotch egg, Scottish oat cakes, apple smoked Scottish cheddar and haggis balls. Mmm, haggis... If the idea of eating stuffed sheep's stomach doesn't scream "yummy" in your head, then try a haggis ball. They're small and you can always share it with friend. It's not as gross as you think and it doesn't look anything like the food you would stab on Robbie Burns' Day. So, go ahead. Try it. === Woot! Woot! My 200th post! read more

I was a regular customer from the day it opened and for many years later. Staff and owner are kind and friendly. Walked in what ever day of the week and had a great experience. Unfortunately my last few visits have not been enjoyable. You can't get in without a reservation. More smaller tables have been crammed to seat more people. Food and alcohol portions are smaller and more expensive. Newer staff are less friendly and less knowledgeable, which made for unpleasant visits. Now there is also corporate sponsorship, which, like many parades and events, takes away from the personal feel and enjoyment. I'm all for businesses being successful and growing but it comes at a cost. The cost for me and my friends are to find another place to call home. Very sad to have to move on. read more

Came here during the winter for a drink and the place was totally packed. We were shocked by the crowd and intrigued by the menu, so we came back to try the food. We sat out in the lovely half-covered back patio. Ordered the burger, steak pie, and mac and cheese. Everyone really liked their food - the fries were great, and the pastry on the steak pie was perfectly flaky. I'd say it was pub food done simply and done well. The food isn't a high concept interpretation of traditional pub food, a trend that has become recently popular, although the modest prices reflect that. Three people with five drinks ended up being $100 after the tip. What makes The Caledonian really stand out is the service. Our waitress was easy-going, friendly, and attentive, and the owner checked on us and chatted briefly as we were leaving. read more

This is the BEST BRITISH PUB in Toronto. First off, the owner and host, Donna, is lovely and always makes everyone feel at home. When she's at the venue, it's like having a meal at your best friend's house. Secondly, Donna is Scottish, so this is an authentic British-run pub. Not some cookie-cutter corporate chain *cough* Firkin *cough*. The food - both starters and main are excellent. And it's excellent EVERY TIME I go there. My favourite is the Taste of Scotland - a starter that has sausage rolls, Scotch egg and mini haggis. Superb. The Caledonian has an excellent whisky selection. If you're new to whisky and not sure where to start, do yourself a favour and try a Glenmorangie (it has an orange label). It's like making out with Amy Pond from Dr. Who. I would highly recommend The Caledonian to British people as it captures the best of a real British pub. And I'd also recommend it to everyone else as it's a place with great food and atmosphere. read more

Came here for a birthday tasting of scotch bit was surprised by the quality of the food. Every single item be ordered was fabulous. We had The scotch egg and the curry fries to start. The curry had an incredible depth of flavor and the fries were perfectly cooked. The scotch egg had a great texture and the outer layer of sausage was no Jimmy deans . For the mains we had the Mac n cheese the butter chicken and the scotch pie. Finished with deep fried mars bar. Check this place out. read more

The Caledonian - Z - Pubs Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

It's good... It's ok. On a crazy night service is lacklustre and you feel like an underprivileged guardian who has not received a social assistance in weeks- in regards to being acknowledged by your server. Pickle shots are fun and I would encourage trying them if one has not before. I have heard only excellent things about The Caledonians whiskey tastings, but on a regular night: drinks, service and food are mediocre in comparison to the other options of the area. read more

It you want proper Scottish food from a proper scottish lass i highly recommend 'The Calendonia' We ordered the Steak Special and the Hagis. The Steak was tender, cooked perfectly, with a delicious peppercorn sauce. The grilled veggies were a nice touch. Now, i had the Hagis....and it was absolutely amazing. Now those who may be nervous about idea of hagis i suggest that you give it a shot, you will not regret it. It was so flavourful and moist, it was better then my memory of Scotland a few years ago. Great place, great food, and remember...try the hagis ;) read more

If this was solely based on going out and having a drink, I would totally give it a 5. But we've got other things to consider! Atmosphere: loved it! So adorable and cozy and warm. The owner was on the floor seating us. She was so kind and friendly and so Scottish! Very authentic. Service: unfortunately we got the new girl. As much as she was sweet, she screwed up really bad...over and over and over again. It was rough. They comped 1 appetizer which I didn't think was enough considering the scope of the bad service. Hopefully she gets better! It was a busy night. Food: the food was ok. Nothing super impressive. The fried pickles were good. The butter chicken was ok. Steak pie was pretty good. The Mac n cheese wasn't quite as awesome as it sounded. So the food wasn't mind blowing. Drinks: my hubby got the rob Roy. That is a stiiiiiiff drink but he liked it. Not a huge beer selection but enough. They are in fact known for their whiskey selection. Overall, I would go back for a drink, snacks and the lovely atmosphere. read more

The food was alright, I'd say even pretty good. Tried the steak pie with a side of haggis. The haggis was actually pretty good. Good beer selection, though I'm surprised they didn't grace guiness....How can a pub like this not have guiness? The server was so bloody rude that it ruins the whole experience though. Who doesn't say sorry when they spill and splash something over their guests. And who demands for, instead of apologizing and asking if it's ok to pay with credit because they ran out of change... And she didn't even tell us it was last call. So when we tried to order dessert all she says is the kitchen's already closed. Don't ruin your nice bar with such bad service...... read more

Atmosphere is right. Busy, at times loud. Excellent single malt inventory and the staff knows what they are. I asked if they had a Balvenie Caribbean Cask, the Lass replied, instantly, "Of course the 14 year old!" Food was top notch. The Mrs loved the Steak and Ale Pie, I had the Haggis stack with neeps and tatties. (fresh caught that day). Best haggis I have tasted this side of the pond... not quite up to Stornoway or MacSweens. I would like a little more spice and a little more of that dark organy flavor. But as it is, it will more likely suit North American tastes. We shared the Ardbeg house smoked salmon.... awesome and very unique with texture halfway between cold smoked and hot roasted. The peaty-ness of the Ardbeg came through very subtle and pleasantly. Try it it is a don't miss. read more

I will start off by saying I may be biased as I am Scottish, but whenever I feel homesick I head here! I know of no other bar which has such a fine variety of Scotch, serves Vodka and Irn Bru and has a haggis burger on the menu. (For those of you who have never heard of/tried Irn Bru - it is a bright orange Scottish soda/pop that has the most indescribable flavor, you either love it or hate it...I love it!) My advice before going here is to book as I have never seen the place empty. Owned by a Scottish expat called Donna (who is a true salt of the earth West Coast Scottish person!) it has a super friendly relaxed atmosphere. On my first visit I was greeted with a hug and welcomed in to the bar. Do try the following - haggis fritters (if you only want to brave a mouthful of this beautiful food), the fish and chips (fries), the haggis, neeps and tatties (turnip and mashed potato) and if your waistline permits the deep fried mars bar. Most items on the menu have a recommended whiskey pairing...and do try, especially with the haggis. The food has always been lovely, I have been here on several occasions. In fact a group of friends and I went here on Christmas Eve, I honestly felt like I was home. I cannot say enough how inviting and fantastic this place is! Warning - most Scottish cuisine should be eaten with a group of friends, preferably trained in CPR as undoubtedly someone will need resuscitated! read more

Great selection of whisky (Scotch), and whiskey (all others) as well, great selection of brews on tap, accompanied by good food. 'nuff said. read more

What a great place to eat and hang out. First time here and I was shocked at how good the food it. The portions are a good size but the flavour was incredible. There was a few of us so we could try a few different dishes. Our server was fabulous!! She was so mice and helped us pick out things to try which included the drinks we had. I was so comfortable there. You have to try this place!!! You will not be disappointed!!! read more

Fine dining food quality in a intimate pub setting. Best Scotch egg ever had. Haggis on par with what I had in Scotland. Love the Scotch selection. Must try for anyone looking for that authentic Scottish experience! read more

Amazing service and delicious meal! Recommend for a nice evening out and great Scottish drinks.