Food was not great...slightly better than McD's. Burgers and fries were incredibly greasy and to be honest, we expected better quality for the price - $50 for three people (3 burgers and two fries - no drinks). Service was quick, very much like McD's. Can't recommend this place at all and we won't be going back, but we know they have a faithful following. read more

I ordered this on DoorDash and picked it up! I got "The Pope" and "Religious Hypocrite" and fresh cut fries. Out of all the burger places I've had in Hamilton, this one might be my least favourite. (My fav spot is Delirious) The portobello mushroom had cheese "gushing" out of it (which was delicious) The main thing I didn't enjoy was the buns that they used. It just tasted like the buns McDonald's use and it started getting a bit soggy (but that might be because I waited till I got him to eat it) Personally for my burger, the religious hypocrite I wouldn't go back to get it here. But if you like big burgers, The Pope was much more delicious! read more

The Burger's Priest - a burger and french fries - Burgers Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

See all

The food is great, a little on the greasy side for some of the burgers but I definitely would go back again and again. Service - was good Ambiance - is good as well. Just an overall good burger place to go. Never go away empty or displeased read more

Love all their Burgers but Vatican Burger is a must. They are juicy and cooked to perfection.

Thought I would give them a try and was definitely not expecting to taste a burger that tasted as well as it did. Will definitely be back!

TL;DR: Overpriced for the serving size, and the quality isn't good enough to counterbalance that. Go to HAMBRGR instead. Hung over from a work party, I was in very serious need of greasy, meaty deliciousness. Having been to Burger Priest once many moons ago (think, back when it opened moons ago), I remembered that their quality was pretty good, and they were conveniently available via Skip the Dishes. So, off I ordered. Seeing that if you spent $20 total for your order, delivery was free, I decided to "splurge" and get their Blue Steel ($11), a poutine ($8), and a cookie ($1.50). Now, to understand the degree of my disappointment, you may need some context. Context One: When I order from HAMBRGR (the Ottawa Street location) I can only finish half my burger and a handful of fries before tapping out. Context Two: When ordering from the COOP, their beef poutine is TWO meals for me. Context Three: If I opt for Wendy's, a Double and small fries makes me uncomfortably full. So, when my food arrived... I was beyond disappointed with the serving size. The burger was literally thinner than the width of my pointer finger. It was decent in terms of juiciness, and there was an okay amount of blue cheese on it...but I've seen thicker burgers in PC's $13 8-pack at Fortino's. The poutine gravy was decently flavoured, but the fries were over-salted and the sizing was basically a side-order. So, suffice it to say, I won't be ordering from them again. read more

The Burger's Priest - Blue Steel Burger....As thin as thin can be - Burgers Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

See all

Amazing burgers at this spot. Nice milkshakes too. The service was nice they have a partially open kitchen where you can kind of see the cooks do their thing. Other than that the store looks great and you won't regret grabbing something off the menu! read more

I've been to BP's before, so I knew what to expect walking in, but my friend was going to be experiencing this meal for the first time. I ordered the Option (panko fried cheese-stuffed portobello mushrooms), one of my faves that I hadn't ordered in quite some time. It was just as amazing as I remembered! My friend got the cheeseburger, and he remarked afterwards that it was one of the best burgers he's had. We both were going bananas for the French fries too...they are so good, and you get a huge serving of them...yessss! They also seemed to fix the one minor complaint that I've had going to BP - the wait! They had a sign saying that you wouldn't wait longer than 12 mins for your lunch, and they adhered to it. It was such a great experience bringing a friend somewhere for the first time that you've raved about for ages and have it actually deliver! Thanks BP. You never disappoint! read more

Good food, great service, cashier went extra mile by giving great suggestions so we can try the best burgers on the menu! Hint, try the double low priest with smokes! Will definitely bring my family back for more! read more

Ordered this because I was close by and saw the good reviews.. they must've been fake. Saltiest food that has ever met my taste buds. Awful and would never recommend. Makes McDonald's look gourmet (Got one of the double cheese burgers, didn't even get the fries I ordered but I don't think I want to see how salty those are) read more

Tried the California burger (or something like that) which the buns were fried in butter and as tempting as it might sound it was the worst choice I have made in my entire life!! ;-) It was greasy and soggy and my sandwich was falling apart after the first bite. The chilli fries weren't any better either in terms of soggy-ness! Chocolate milkshake was the best part. The service and the (religious?!! Or whatever was the idea) concept didn't really give me a pleasant vibe. read more

See all

I had to stop and try the famous Big Mac burger called the high priest. I have to admit it was pretty good the the first time I tried it. This burger was just like a Big Mac but much larger and made with actual real beef! The only issue here is the consistency is just not there yet. Multiple visits which meant multiple experiences with the same food item. This place is a hit or miss on a delicious meal. read more

The Burger's Priest - The High Priest Burger - Burgers Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

This was our first time trying the Burger's Priest. We had no idea what to expect, but were very happy with our experience. The burgers were fresh, and the bacon on my Double Bacon Cheeseburger was crunchy, a great contrast to the messy goodness of the two juicy 4oz patties - exactly how it should be! It dosn't come in a huge bun like some other places, so it looks smaller, but it is quite filling. Our fries were hot and crisp and not over seasoned. The service was friendly and our food came out in good time. We will definitely be back. read more

This place is alright but not great. Peters denial was ok. It consists of southern fried chicken smothered with corn and gravy on a fresh bun. The chicken was cooked well and a little spicy but I found the bun couldn't hold up to the gravy and the heat of the food so basically it fell apart and was messy. Good thing I ate in the restaurant, if I had opted to take it home the bun wouldn't have made it. The Red Sea is a burger smothered in chili on a fresh bun. My b/f had no complaints except again the bun was just too soft. It should be a crusty more substantial bun for these messy sandwiches. We shared a side of fries and gravy. I really liked the fries with a little salt and ketchup whereas he said they were ok but needed more salt and gravy. Not sure if we would go back. Our meals mentioned above with 2 cans of pop was around $25. read more

Burger Priest is innovatively profanely religious. This place is honestly all contradiction. The menu is extensive ranging from chill fries to hot dogs to burgers to desserts to floats & milkshakes. I loved the cookies here - reminds me of the sugar cookies from elementary school bake sales. "What's Right" The chill fries were meh - chili was a little too bland. The burger was salty????? I'm not sure if that's what they're going for but if it's salt overload then they got it right. BUT I'd like to be back to try other things on the menu. read more

This is probably my favorite spot to get burgers in Hamilton now. I haven't been to The Burger's Priest until today, and it changed my life. My tastebuds were tingling the whole time while chowing down on my juicy burger. Service was great didn't take a very long time for them to bring out our orders. read more

Love getting the secret menu cheese burger here! Great quality food that never disappoints and the fries are delicious too! Definitely a favourite spot for me to grab lunch. read more

Had the California burger ..was good but small and greasy. Loved the fries. Didn't care for the vanilla old fashioned milkshake..more like a milk mousse. Very expensive in my opinion for what you get. 2 burgers, 1 order of fries and 2 shakes was $33- wouldn't go out of my way to go here again. read more

The best burger in Hamilton/Burlington hands down. The burgers are top quality freshly ground meat, cooked correctly, always thick and juicy, dripping with flavour. I like them with only cheese. My husband always gets one with lots of toppings and he is equally impressed. Burger's Priest is a little pricey, but completely worth it. These burgers are SO much better than the other two places in Hamilton that people often claim to be the best; Hambrgr - totally over-rated. The hamburg there was dry and tasteless. And the other one I hear all the time is "Five Guys" - but again, the "Five Guys" burgers are dry and overcooked. read more

The Burger's Priest - Burgers Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

Great burgers, nice selection to choose from with enough options and secret menu items to keep you coming back. It's a nice problem to have to have difficulty choosing. I opted for the Vatican City and the Riggs & Murtaugh shake and wasn't disappointed. read more

The Burger's Priest - Vatican City and Riggs & Murtaugh shake. And yes...that is grilled cheese for the buns. - Burgers Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

I have tried the California burger with the gluten free bun. It is a present surprise that the Burger's Priest serve gluten free bun and it is a good one especially after I settled for beef patty wrapped in a piece of lettuce. The beef patty is fresh and made to order which set a very high bar for "fast food" burger. The only con for me is the fries are pretty greasy. I will definitely go back to try the shakes! :) read more

Great burgers and burger style creations! Burgers and buns so fresh they put their competition and the run-of-the-mill burger chains to shame. I've tried the Red Sea, Peter's Denial, the Option and the Jarge-style burger with smoke (from the secret menu). The Red Sea is a burger with a thick, meaty chili, my favourite to date. Peter's denial is a breaded chicken breast served on a bun with cream corn and gravy, a great choice for those days when you want to change it up a bit. The Option is a vegetarian patty, unlike any other vegetarian patty I've ever had, a "custom blend of cheesy goodness sandwiched between two roasted portabello mushrooms, breaded and deep fried then placed on a bun with your choice of toppings" - finally a vegetarian option that carnivores can enjoy! The Jarge-style - mustard grilled patties with fried onion - very juicy with a taste all its own. Don't forget to order "smoke" which are deep-fried jalapeno rings if you want to spice things up. All said, they make great burgers! read more

We have eaten here many time, last night my husband had food poisoning after eating hamburger and fries. I sat on the side where I could see them make food, the gentleman that handled money at the cash, was the same person putting lettuce on the burgers without gloves and wiping his hands on his jeans after. Will not be back and will be intouch with the Ontario Health Inspection Agency. read more

We ordered from here through skip the dishes. It was the first time trying the burgers & fries there. The food arrived at a decent time but I was disappointed at the burger size the bun and the fries. It taste like Harveys. Don't get me wrong I enjoy a good Harveys burger now and then but this was supposed to be a more high end burger with a pice that goes with it so it was disappointing. The shakes were average also just like Harveys. read more

Was out of chicken, and said they hadnt grinded any beef so we had to wait over 20 min for them to do so so they could make burger. All ketchup bottles were empty as well. Poorly organized location. They said they had seasoning salt but werent allowed to give to us for some reason meanwhile weve gotten it at other locations. Then when our burgers came out the burger tasted funny and the meat was chewy and elastic and we couldnt chew it. They refunded our meal thankfully and we showed them the meat. We love burger preist but this location was TERRIBLE. read more

My first time there. Good for a burger only place. Far better than McDonald's or Burger King, but I expected more. The burger was yummy but the bun was regular, nothing special. I did like that it didn't overwhelm the patty though. They messed up my order too which I thought the never did. read more

There's minimal seating and you'll probably smell like burger after you're done but this burger is just the best burger to ever come near my mouth. It's just unparalleled. Everything from the bacon cheese burger to the blue cheese burger is fucking superb. I love this place. The burgers are so good I wouldn't even care if the staff or the place were shit (they're not, they're absolutely fine). But woah that burger. read more

I had the option - deep fried cheese stuffed Portobello burger - and oh my goodness it was mind blowing!!!! So so tasty! The cheese just oozed out - I couldn't believe the amount of cheese they managed to stuff in there! I'm looking forward to trying some of the milkshakes! read more

I had the Vatican with Stern fries my buddy had the 4 Horseman on June 26th. One of the best burgers I have ever had.

Decent burger, nice tasting, not very hefty it's definitely for loading up on the options. For celiacs or gluten free, the buns are delicious, they take the matter seriously, the fryers and gravy are gluten free so yes there's fries and gravy!! And they truly are delicious. If you are gluten free and dairy free, there are zero burger options besides the basics but hey, fries and gravy right?! You know what I'm talking about. read more

Nailed it. The Bacon Double Cheeseburger sets the bar pretty high. Easily the best burger I have had in a long time.

Always great. Fries are great as well. Reminds me of a real , old school , Montreal burger. Friendly staff.

Burger was good, not great. Thought it was expensive. $30 tax in for 2 burgers. Did not have prices on the menu. That price did not include fries, just 2 burgers. 1 was huge, but the second was small. read more

Newly opened, first time ever eating at the burger's priest and I have to say it was amazing! All the ingredients and especially the meat patty were all freshly prepared and made on the spot. Super juicy and delicious. A bit pricey, but definitely worth it. Will come back for sure. read more

The Burger's Priest - I ordered the classic cheeseburger. Absolutely divine. - Burgers Near Me - Hamilton, Ontario

Great food. Great service. Try Peters Denial, it's a very unexpected delicious sandwich. My husband loves the burgers. I personally find them a wee too greasy for my liking. The fresh cut fries are delish! Happy this resto migrated west. read more

Confusion at the cash register with the girl trying to do a bunch of milkshakes and take my order. Very rushed service, she was very busy with other things. Burger toppings order was wrong on delivery. Got the "What's Right" combo. Huge order of chili cheese fries, a meal in itself. Very good as I like a mild chili, might disappoint some. Burger (with some ordered toppings missing) was surprisingly salty, almost overpoweringly so. Double patty, smaller than a 5 Guys burger. Very greasy, which I like, but I could understand how it might put some people off. I thought it was a nice size and quite tasty. I'd try them again. I wouldn't get the combo unless I was sharing the chili cheese fries. The experience is priced a bit on the high side. read more

its 'OK' There is a lot more hype around this place than the burger warrants. The cost is far too high for what you actually get. When I pay $60 for my husband & I to eat; I'd expect more than a single pickle slice and one single ring of onion as a topping. The meat was BLAND, likely because of the severe lack of toppings (I asked for fully dressed less tomato - it was still dry and tasteless) Fries were plentiful, but undercooked & mushy. We ate in the restaurant. It was not surprisingly devoid of customers. I got the ice cream sandwich & the cookies were stale. The $5 Riggs shake - also not worth it. There are FAR too many burger places out there that offer better burgers at a reasonable price for me to give this any more than 2 stars. read more

Thought we would try this burger place tonight as we heard some good things. On first impression the decor is really stark. There was a large mouse trap located to the left of the front door. Eek!! I ordered the Priest burger and my daughter ordered a cheeseburger. The server told us they would be ready in 7 mins. Hmm. I thought the burgers were made to order?? Wonder how they get them cooked so fast. We took our meals to go. My burger was very greasy and lacked Amy remarkable flavour. No seasoning at all. The cheese was processed cheese slices. The pickles were like McDonald's pickles. No tomato in sight. We were very disappointed. We have been to other privately owned and managed burger restaurants in Hamilton that were much better for taste and price. We won't be returning to burgers priest. read more