I'm not sure how I haven't reviewed the storefront before so I'm going to change that. I've bought the 2 packs ($5.50) to include with holiday gift exchanges but generally I buy them as a treat for myself. Each Buckeye is a minimum of two bites. My favorite stuffed flavor is puppy chow. Last night I tried key lime. The sour citrus definitely shone. The choices are clearly labeled. They have a rewards program which will net you two wax paper covered regular Buckeyes. The service is always excellent. They are game for small talk about the flavors, the business, weather, etc. even though I'm sure they've heard it all before. It's a small space but don't be discouraged if there's a line. It usually goes fast. read more

The Buckeye Lady - Red velvet and everything but the bagel flavors. - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Delicious!!! 10/10 recommend, this place was amazing! So many fun and fresh buckeye flavors, we absolutely loved trying all the different buckeyes and they were so tasty! read more

The Buckeye Lady - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I love the buckeye lady and all of their different flavors! I usually get them at the farmers market but I like the convenience of them having a store front now. They even have pup friendly buckeyes for your doggies! read more

See all

Amazing! The Buckeye Lady catered our wedding reception desserts, and they were so good! Honestly, our guests could not have had better things to say about how delciious and unique the buckeyes were. The service was great and everything was done super well. We loved all of the different flavors, but our favorites were toffee, puppy chow, and the samoa buckeyes. We are obsessed now. read more

The Buckeyes are very delicious and there are a lot of fun additions and different flavors. You can buy the Buckeyes individually or in different packs suck as 2,6,12 or more. When I go in I'm immediately greeted and served and everyone is very nice and accommodating. There are two vegan buckeye options which I love because I'm vegan and most sweet or chocolate shops don't offer any vegan options. I will say the buckeyes are a bit pricey. I got a 2 pack for $5.75 ,I think the 2 pack is $5.50 for regular buckeyes but $5.75 for vegan ones. I think the price is worth it if you want to try though especially because they are a small business and offer a unique take on the original buckeyes. If you are craving buckets or a sweet and don't feel like making a whole homemade batch of buckeyes it's nice to just pick up some fun flavors and support a local business in the process! read more

While their traditional buckeyes are delicious, what really sets The Buckeye Lady apart are their Stuffed Buckeyes. So many amazing flavors and even things you may not think would go great with peanut butter suddenly do. Great for gifting or just as a little treat for yourself. They also have Buckeye making workshops and my work team had a wonderful time with Alicia and her team! read more

The Buckeye Lady - After the Buckeye making workshop - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We met the Buckeye Lady at the Worthington Farmers Market. Not only is she super nice but she makes delicious buckeyes! They are better than the ones that can be purchased in stores locally. I will be back for more Buckeyes! read more

The Buckeye Lady - Enjoying buckeyes. His first ever buckeye! - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We've been spoiled by The Buckeye Lady carts showing up at farmers markets around town and getting our fix that way, but we finally made our way into the cute little storefront they now have! I wanted to share the goodness with some friends and family and opted to pick up the tailgate dozen to share - it was a nice collection featuring six traditional buckeyes with scarlet and gray sprinkles and six puppy chow buckeyes. They were much enjoyed! Little Yelper couldn't resist getting some cheesecake buckeyes for home, which were a huge winner and will definitely be a variety we will be getting again. read more

Pros: Delicious, varied options 2 for $5 for traditional You can order online and pick up later Clean cute store Easy parking Cons: Would love to see them branch out to other Buckeye items and decor Prices are a bit high; not sure if they are still donating a portion to canine organizations? Pro tip: Support local - these are a fantastic treat for yourself or a gift for someone else! read more

The Buckeye Lady - Storefront - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

So good! Got the Oreo and toffee buckeyes. I am in town for a couple more days and plan on going back to bring some home.

Went to Buckeye Lady on a whim for a sweet treat after dinner and we were not disappointed!! The best buckeyes! Traditional buckeyes and also creative specialty buckeyes. We will be back! read more

Went here for my sons birthday treats. They have a wide variety of buckeyes and we went HAM. The service was great. The person working was very kind and helpful to a first timer. It had a steady stream of people coming in and getting treats. The store was nice and clean seemed like a really nice place to grab desserts and enjoy them at home. It didn't seem like the type of place where you would buy your treat and enjoy in the building. read more

See all

A welcoming shop that had the nicest young lady there to assist us. She offered great information on the selections for today. The buckeyes are flavorful. They offer gluten free and vegan too. read more

The Buckeye Lady - Six pack is one option. - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Holy moly, these buckeyes are incredible! I originally bought one box of the Traditional and Cookies & Cream to share with my coworkers, but after tasting them, I simply had to buy more. My favorite so far is the Thick Mint. Each buckeye has chunks of thin mint cookies inside. The crunch of the mint plus the crunch of the refrigerated chocolate coating is spectacular. New flavors are added every so often too! What I love most about this business is the story behind how it started. Do yourself a favor and read "Our Story" on the website. Even if you aren't a huge buckeye fan, you can always just donate to the animal shelters listed. What's not to love? 10000/10! I am now a loyal customer who will buy plenty more in the future! read more

See all

Super clean and organized location in Clintonville. I came right before the holidays and they had an amazing selection of seasonal flavors. (Don't miss out on the Gingerbread buckeyes when they're available!) I usually visit their cart when it's at farmers markets and festivals, but their store front is a convenient way to get my fix at any time. They also do catering trays if you have an event. read more

The Buckeye Lady - a variety of desserts on display - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This Little buckeye shop is super cute and easy to locate. They have multiple flavors of buckeyes with different toppings and all looked really good! I got puppy chow & cold brew flavored. The service was very nice and quick, however we were the only ones there. But pricing is a little much in my eyes 2 for 5.50$. 6 for 10$ and more. It was a sweet little treat for the afternoon. I read more

The Buckeye Lady - Puppy chow buckeye - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

These are amazing. Crunchy chocolate, super creamy peanut butter, and some really interesting variations. I'm excited to try more options - I got the traditional, hazelnut cream, toffee and bourbon this time. Ordering was fast and easy, and they took care of a problem (completely my fault) quickly and smoothly. read more

The Buckeye Lady - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I was surprised that a peanut butter chocolate Buckeye can stuffed. I tried the Red Velvet that had piece of red velvet cake and cookies & cream mixed into the peanut butter. I was very happy that I tried it and enjoyed it. I will trying the Traditional Buckeye and other flavored Buckeyes. read more

The Buckeye Lady - The Buckeye Lady container - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I love this place! I haven't been to their new location (I used to get them from the coffee shop they were at). These are so fun and they always taste great. I would get these for clients and they were always a hit because of the unique flavors and sprinkles. It seems like there's at least 20 different flavors available, but my personal favorite was the bourbon cheesecake from when they paired up with The Cheesecake Girl. I've been wanting to try the puppy chow because it looks amazing. Everyone should check this place out! read more

The Buckeye Lady - Red velvet, Oreo, sprinkles, original, plus others - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Super friendly service, and very interesting and yummy stuffed buckeye options. Even got a huge one for Easter.

so I get to help helpless doggies and I get buckeyes? sign me up because this is literally the best thing since "I'm helping doggies" because I can get me some hand rolled buckeyes while doing a good thing :-) I was initially kinda bummed that I couldn't just go in the cooler at BBK&C and snag some deliciousness but I guess ordering online works pretty well too since it was less than a week from buy to eat. I got me two dozen of these mailed to the house and they are so good - one box is in the freezer and the other box is already mostly in me. smooth creamy peanutty butter with a thin band of chocolates around to make it easier to pick up. yea! fun times for all when topping them with fruits or jams of cookies or whatever is convenient and not icky on or under peanut butters. savor the moment but try not to get too emotionally involved, they're just treats. if you're going to get all swoony go get yerself a shelter doggie and some dog-safe treats from here :-) read more

See all

I'm not sure if I mentioned it before, but I FLUFFIN LIVE FOR PEANUT BUTTER!! It's basically part of my DNA, requiring consumption in some form or another. I'm pretty sure buckeyes are an official "Approved Carrier," right... I am 100 percent in love with Bucks For Pups mission: a potion of the money of every sale goes toward an animal organization that's helping to foster, rehab, home, etc. animals around. Now that's a cause I can totally get behind!! S/O for the ease of ordering online and pick-up @ Basic Biscuits, Coffee & Kindness! There's plenty of free street parking being on the not yet overpopulated part of Goodale Ave. I'm not too adventurous when it comes to buckeyes - especially when they're homemade (brownie points for BFP!). For my 12-pack, I picked Traditional, Traditional topped with Cadbury Mini Eggs and three Crunchy. Me, I'm all about the peanut butter-to-chocolate ratio - I prefer the former to shine thru. Happy to report my tastebuds are IN LOVE with these sweet spherical delicious delights!! Great smooth peanut butter flavor, of which is the star of the show! The amount of chocolate is slim in comparison, and that's just how I roll, baby! I am SUPER glad I finally got to try BFP, and it will definitely be my go-to for gifts for family/friends and, well, if I'm in need of a lil pick me up!! read more

The Buckeye Lady - Traditional, Traditional with A Cadbury Egg, and Crunchy!! (4/8/2021) - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I ordered a dozen crunchy buckeyes over the weekend for pick up at Basic Biscuits. There was a warning about a high demand turnaround time, but I actually got an email on Monday that they would be ready on Tuesday. They were in the shop pick up fridge early Tuesday morning! The best buckeyes I've ever had...seriously. I will def order more and can't wait to try the white chocolate, and the butterscotch. read more

Thank goodness for the April challenge with Yelp or I would have never tried Bucks for Confections. I ordered the traditional buckeyes and they were so yummy. My dog was confused at first and I reminded her the label said for human consumption only. Speaking of dogs, a portion of the proceeds here go to rescues. Which is why I widely support this place. I will definitely be back here to try the other buckeye confections made here. read more

We tried these the first time at coffee fest. Who knew Buckeyes could be stuffed!? They are over the top amazing definitely a new level achieved . The Buckeye Lady has an amazing product that represents Columbus OH perfectly. Make sure to try them you will not regret it. read more

These buckeyes are out of this world! Unexpected flavor combinations that will keep you going back for more! They are the perfect special little treat to share with family, friends, work colleague, caregivers.... anyone! I'm always looking for an excuse to go back here LOL! The last time I was there I got to meet Alicia, The Buckeye Lady herself, and she expressed such gratitude for my support. I'm a customer for life! read more

The Buckeye Lady - Beautiful variety! - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

These are the BEST buckeyes in Columbus without a doubt. The staff is very sweet and part of the money goes to a great cause.

Omg.....a must try! The Buckeye Lady has a the nose amazing stuffed buckeyes...so many flavors and season ones as well! My first introduction was her collab with The Cheesecake Girl....cream cheese stuffed buckeyes....they are amazing! She has a website and is on IG, check her out asap! read more

The Buckeye Lady - Cream cheese stuffed buckeyes! - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This was a seamless process from order to pickup. I ordered online and chose a variety pack because I couldn't decide on one flavor! I got white chocolate, traditional, bourbon, and Nutella, all top notch choices with that familiar sweetness of a buckeye and interesting flavor choices. I couldn't come actually get my buckeyes until several days later because the hours didn't work with my schedule, but when I got there, I'd paid online and my buckeyes were in a cooler ready for me to pick up and walk out the door. It's an added bonus that the proceeds benefit animals. Would absolutely shop here again! read more

The Buckeye Lady - Desserts Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Amazing assortment of Buckeye flavors. Great service too! Will definitely try it again!

Was looking for a real buckeye. Couldn't find any went to several candy stores in the area. One candy store recommended the buckeye lady. I am so so so glad I stopped by. I have no words. They are worth every $ dollar!!! PERIOD!! read more

These Buckeyes are absolutely to die for! I got the Cinnamon Toast Crunch and puppy chow. Now I wanna try the rest.

Seriously the BEST buckeyes you will ever have in your life! I've had many, and none compare to these. The best part? Your money is helping all the local pooches. This is a locally run business that has so much heart and hard work in it. Don't hesitate to try it! read more