My family and I tried this ice cream shop for the first time since it was very close to the house we stayed at for the week. I love that there are rentals there but that they also have an ice cream window. Tons of flavors to choose from, and even a few vegan options, which I love! There was a line when we got there but we were in and out in about 10 minutes. My dad got moose tracks, I got the vegan "oatmazing" chocolate chunk, and my mom got vanilla peanut butter. My ice cream was so good, I love oatmilk ice cream. I saw a sign by the window saying to be patient because it's a lot of teenagers first jobs, which I appreciated. Working in foodservice is tough, especially in a touristy beach town where people are so entitled to quick service. I recommend you come here and give people grace if things aren't as fast as you'd like. Again, we were in and out in 10 minutes with a line. We would absolutely come here again to try more yummy flavors and recommend that you do the same if you are near Holgate! read more

The Boardwalk - Oatmazing chocolate chunk - Bike Rentals Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Lovely family-owned shop w amazing ice cream. Detailed breakdown below: **Service, 5/5** All very sweet and handle the long lines well! Despite the rush, we only stood in line for a few minutes and our orders were out in a few minutes too. **Decor & cleanliness, 5/5** Adorable shop but has limited seating. **Price & portion, 5/5** About $4.50 for a single scoop, but the scoops are huge. **Taste of the food, 5/5** - Single scoop cookie jar ($4.50), 5/5: Vanilla ice cream with fudge and brownie pieces -- delicious. - Soft serve nachos ($6.50 for a small and $8.50 for a large), 5/5: Great way to use up broken cones! Basically a soft serve sundae but with the bonus of crispy cones. read more

See all

The ice cream selection is mediocre and our server was extremely rude. They got my order wrong and insisted that I pay for two ice cream orders to remedy their mistake. Could have been handled in a much more professional manner. Never going back. I also want my 20% tip back. read more

The Boardwalk - Bland coffee ive cream milkshake. - Bike Rentals Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Service was horrible and you could tell some lack of experience. Ordered an expensive milk shake and the kid filled it up 70% of the way. Others in our group got very small portions too. Waiting on their porch at night getting mosquito bites was not fun. Won't be going back! BEN AND JERRY'S in town is 1000X BETTER!!! read more

Wow! S'mores pop tart ice cream sandwich with twist soft serve was amazing! Cookie Monster shake was magnificent! Outdoor window to order, quickly moved through the line. Friendly service, phenomenal ice cream! read more

The Boardwalk - S'mores pop tart ice cream sandwich - Bike Rentals Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

They serve jerseys own Artic ice cream! Love the Elvis favor (choc, pb, banana). If you are local no need to go anywhere else it's the same product as Barry's. Staff is friendly too. If you need to rent bikes or surf board, kayaks they do that also. read more

The lady with the black elbow guard was not kind. She was very rude to my friends and I. She made rude comments such as "Do you have any money? We said no and she replies with of course you don't." The lady working the cashier was very nice and helpful. The inside looked nice but the lady ruined our experience. Thank you and PLEASE BE better. read more

I don't love ice cream. Not because I don't love ice cream, but because I have sensitive teeth and nothing damn works to desensitize them. Eh, you know what the Stones said about what a drag it is getting old and all that. Whatevs, as the kids maybe still say! So the Boardwalk has good enough ice cream that I will fight through the pain to eat it. The spouse has literally been talking about the Nutter Butter for the past week, and I really don't remember the last time she talked about ice cream for more than a few minutes past its consumption other than to say, "Eh. That wasn't worth it." The Boardwalk's stuff is totally worth it. Plus, if your kid breaks their boogie board on your first day at the beach you can grab one while you're slurping down a monstrously huge "single" scoop. read more

Super friendly place that we visit almost daily when we're in LBI. Offers both soft serve and hard scooped ice cream in a bunch of flavors and available toppings. Also has a general store selection of beach merchandise (pails, shovels, etc) along with their rentals. We've never rented bikes from them but have rented umbrellas and chairs which are reasonably priced for those who don't want to lug their own from home. ~ DJReda read more

A wonderful LBI family owned and operated business. Great ice cream Great service We buy some of their rental bikes at the end of each season - just very nice people and nice place read more

We visited here again, on our yearly pilgrimage to LBI. Went for ice cream and shakes three out of four nights we stayed. Wow, do these young kids who work there, work really hard, and are so nice and service oriented. They have a great group working there. It was so very busy every night. The ice cream here is great! Will continue to return! read more

Every time I visit LBI this is the place I always go to for a little treat. No matter where I am I always make time to walk ride or drive down here, luckily I was walking distance and visited there everyday! Ice cream is so creamy and milkshakes are tasty. The decor is so cute and I love how you can rent bikes too! I recommend this to everyone who comes down to LBI. read more

This ice cream place is amazing. I come here every time i'm in lbi. The chocolate chip cookie ice cream is amazing and the bike rentals are easy and the bikes are super nice. read more

The staff was amazing! I ordered the wrong flavor for my daughter - my fault, not theirs. They offered to switch it out for correct flavor without my asking. They made a very happy customer out of my daughter and me. Highly recommend for the service and the great flavors! read more

I recently rented some bikes here. I wanted to return them early, and when I stopped by to ask if I could receive a partial refund if I did, I was told yes. So I changed up my plans for the night to include returning the bikes, but when I came back the owner told me I wasn't eligible for a refund. I explained to her that her employee had already promised me a refund, and the employee herself admitted to the owner that she told me I would get a refund. I asked her to please honor what I was told. She said no. She was EXTREMELY rude and I will NEVER return to this store. Horrible custormer service. read more

This is our favorite ice cream on LBI. There are endless flavor options. The smores and cookie dough flavors were amazing. We loved the hot fudge topping that was really warm. The waffle bowls were tantamount to a tantalizing yumacious treat. The staff were nice. We highly recommend the boardwalk for ice cream. read more

One star is being kind. I ordered and paid for myself, wife, and daughter. We stood there with masks on as we ordered and waited for our order An older gentleman working behind the scenes was not wearing a mask. He scrambled to put it on when my daughter (who has extreme anxiety issues) let us know he wasn't wearing one. We had to leave immediately and throw away the ice cream about 10 seconds later. I went back to kindly ask for a refund, but he started yelling at me about not giving me a refund. Completely rude. He continued to tell me how he was 6ft apart from everyone, and it was only for a minute or two. Guess what--it only takes 1 second to spread germs during this pandemic. If you require everyone to wear a mask, there should be no exceptions. Even the teenager working the register agreed with me that it wasn't safe. If you want to take off your mask, go outside and away from people, but not in front of employees or customers. Needless to say, I will never visit this establishment again. Consider this your warning. Very high disapproval from me. read more

Fast and pleasant service. Ice cream is great. They have dairy free options which is a plus. I Would go back again and recommend it.

Most wonderful, unique, creative ice cream shop / bike rental on LBI. They have great inventory too- beach toys, umbrellas, beach chairs, swim accessories, and more. Absolutely love this store, it's adorable inside or fun to eat on the deck on a hot summer night. Staff is super friendly. A "must"! read more

When on a weekend trip in Beach Haven 2 summers ago I couldn't get enough of their ice cream, more specifically the "Jersey Shore" flavor. I couldn't wait to return during this trip, being just a short walk away from the hotel. This time I was sorely disappointed. The ice cream was too cold, to the point where it was hurting my mouth. It was also too thick and nearly flavorless. read more

This place is tremendous. Great flavors. Incredibly friendly & accommodating staff. Very kid friendly. Ridiculously great prices. Plus they have an ice cream hullabaloo called The Blotation Device. read more

We often rent bikes (and sometimes "rent" ice cream) here during our summer visits. This is locally owned and I like that they really try to make sure that you get what you need so you come back again. The prices are reasonable, and I have ever had a problem with the bikes we have rented. They also have a lot of other beach needs, but the ice cream is a highlight! read more

Great Mom & Pop place for home made Ice Cream. Large menu selection and large portions. Great for a quick stop and you can rent a bike to burn the calories off. read more

Super friendly place. Great ice cream. Love making it a ritual to ride here just for that special treat.

An outstanding experience. Ice Cream was delicious and service was great. Got there at closing time but they stayed open and kept us company until we were finished. Will return again before we head home read more

Delicious Ice Cream! They are super helpful. The helped us with our flat bicycle tire that I rented somewhere else for free!

Whenever visiting LBI this is my favorite ice cream place to hit. Very customer is important to every employee. They make sure everything is just right. The only reason I didn't give a 5 star rating was because of the wait they had inside and outside they were slow to get to us and slow with the ice cream. That was the only time I had ever been there with a wait that long with slow ice cream. Overall this is defiantly the place to go when you want ice cream and you are in the area. read more

This ice cream stop has landed itself a permanent place on the "LBI To-Do List". The service was great, and the ice cream was even better. The line is long at times, but if you stay on line you won't be disappointed! We stayed walking distance from it (corner of Bay Ave and Kentford ave) which was even better. Great Prices, too! My only complaint would be the whipped cream, which tasted aerosol can-y, but I'm not one to judge by taste of whipped cream. My family also decided we wanted to rent a four person bike (surrey) for the hour. Was a little pricey, yet worth it. The bicycle was in perfect condition, didn't squeak or have any rust. Will definitely be back to rent! read more

Forgot something at home? The Boardwalk has every beach item you could think of for rent -bikes, buggies, umbrellas, and more! We rented a huge umbrella at a reasonable daily rate (also available 3-day and weekly rentals). In addition to rentals, the store also stocked beach toys, sunscreen, towels, and a huge selection of fresh made coffees and ice creams! read more

I was quote a price to put a bike together and was charged a different price when I went to pay for it. Not a way to do business!!

The owner kept us waiting for an hour and a half claiming the 6 person bicycle would be right back, it never came back. We ended up having a horrible experience here. Do yourself a favor and rent somewhere else the owner has no manners or customer service skills. Good luck running a business like that. read more

Lovely Place and Great Service! Couldn't have asked for a better place to go! The shop has an array of Unique flavors too - the Swedish fish style ice flavor went down great! Prices are also a lot better than most on the island - a great spot to just get ice cream without breaking the bank! read more