Good bagels with a vibe we have been around forever. Excellent quality with just enough originality that they have their own style.

Took close to 30 minutes to get two bagels and two coffees to go. We saw our drinks idling on the counter and inquired if they were ours only to be told that our drinks were still in the queue. Asked again ten minutes later and yes, they were our drinks. Saw employees rushing back and forth inside; two collided into each other while delivering orders. One employee made an announcement that they were short-staffed. Seemed chaotic. read more

These are the best bagels I have ever had! I am so picky about my bagels after having the privilege of eating here growing up. They did unfortunately raise the prices after covid and at times the staff is not super welcoming, but the food is worth it and the wait is never too long. My favorite thing to get here is the lox cream cheese. read more

The best bagel shop north of Bagel Oasis in Seattle. Great selection and service, quality ingredients, nice vibe.

Great bagels. We got a breakfast bagel with egg and cheese. I wish they offered bacon or sausage on it also but we were happy with what we ordered. They were flavorful and crispy on the outside and perfectly chewy. Our main complaint is that the service was poor. They didn't take cash due to COVID-19 which I understand, but the guy helping us was kind of rude and snappy when I didn't see their sign. Finally, when the girl put our order on the table and called my name, she just walked away from me after I said thanks. This is why I deducted 1 star. The owners really needs to train their employees on customer service and friendliness. read more

I love me a fresh bagel and The Bagelry has so many options to choose from! I ran in for a quick lunch for a bagel sandwich and it was so good! They sure do get a lunch rush, but they took care of everyone quickly and have a super friendly staff! Bagel sandwich included chips and a slice of pickle, and got a drink separately. My favorite part was that they offer sprouts on your sandwich (for extra) - so good. I'll definitely be back for more! read more

See all

Delicious bagels & sandwiches! I love the rosemary salt bagel & the feta dill cream cheese. Typically fast service, love to stop when I'm close by! read more

TL;DR: If you use a coupon for a free bagel, they won't cut it for you, won't give you a knife, will make you pay for cream cheese as a separate transaction, will give you a plastic spoon to smear it on yourself, and will probably make you feel bad for using a coupon. I don't usually write negative reviews, but after a really awful experience at The Bagelry on Sunday, May 1, 2016 at about 10 a.m., I would like to share my poor experience. My friend and I were about to leave town to head down to Seattle. The friend we were staying with had the Big Blue Book, which is a coupon book for local businesses around Bellingham. The free bagel with no strings attached at The Bagelry caught our attention, and my friend raved about how wonderful the owner was and how he had a strong tie to the community. The line was pretty short but moved very slowly. When I was greeted by someone behind the counter, I requested a garlic bagel with cream cheese. They gave me at ticket, and I proceeded to the cashier. I didn't know that this was a cash only spot, and I only had $2 cash on me. I wasn't going to use the ATM when I was just about to leave town. I informed the cashier that I had a coupon and was prepared to pay the difference for the cream cheese with my $2. She immediately corrected me and said that I wasn't able to do that and could only get a plain bagel. This took me back a bit; wouldn't The Bagelry want to make money off of the upsells? After talking with the her a bit more, she agreed to let me pay for cream cheese as a side item in a separate transaction and gave me a plain unsliced bagel. I asked if I could get a garlic one like what I had requested at the beginning, so she grabbed one of those and wasn't very nice about it. When I looked in the bag, I found it was unsliced and asked if they could please slice it for me. A couple people came over to the cash register and told me they were unable to cut it for me and that the coupon only covered a bagel, and not the cutting? Great, so I asked for a knife and discovered there were no knives available. I had to use my hands to rip the bagel in half, which was very messy and didn't work out very well. The plain cream cheese on the side was a tiny scoop that was about $1.50 (I couldn't afford the $2.07 for the flavored cream cheese scoop). They gave me a plastic spoon to spread the cream cheese, which also did not work very well. They were very unfriendly to me, and the experience was honestly a bit humiliating. I use coupons as a way to discover new places and return if I have a good experience, but I wish I just went somewhere else so I didn't have to go through all that. I interacted with at least three different employees, all of which were not very nice or understanding. My friend said that if the owner had been at The Bagelry that morning, this very poor customer experience would not have happened. read more

The Bagelry - 5/1/16- 10 a.m. They were rude to me for using a coupon, refused to cut the bagel, and didn't have any knives, so I had to rip it. - Bagels Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

I've been going to the Bagelry since I moved to Bellingham in the late 90's. It was then - and still is - pretty much the best bagel you can get in the tri-county region (if not beyond). Just walking into the place you can smell the yummy goodness of whatever they are baking that day. My favorite is the sourdough and the garlic. They don't toast their bagels, which used to bug me but now I understand why: a good bagel just doesn't need to be toasted. If you really want a warm bagel, ask for whatever's fresh out of the oven. Their cream cheese is also to-die-for, and the coffee's good too. What bugs me about the Bagelry is that they still, after all these years, are a cash-only business. While I admire their dedication to this concept, the fact is it's 2014 and the overwhelming majority of people use debit cards for most transactions. Yes, it would cost the Bagelry a small fee to process these transactions; but I do wonder how much more business they would generate if they accepted cards. (Yes, yes, I know there's a cash machine on the premises but it also charges a pretty hefty fee.) Speaking of money, their prices are pretty high. I just don't think it needs to cost that much to get a bagel with a scrambled egg and coffee. We often go elsewhere for breakfast because we can get more food for less money. But the fact is, if you want a really good bagel, there is only one place to go and that's why the Bagelry is still king in Bellingham. UPDATE! I'm pleased to report that the Bagelry is now offering TOASTED bagels, and this is worth a full star upgrade from me. Well done, Bagelry people, well done! The toasted bagel fans of the world thank you! read more

I'm a big fan of the Bagelry whenever I'm in Bellingham! I often bring their bagels for trainings I'm holding, and they're always a big hit! If I'm lucky enough to have some time before a meeting, I like to come here myself and enjoy a bagel and a latte. They make a great latte and the ambiance of the restaurant is cool with all the bustle of patrons and yummy smells. I've only ever tried the garlic bagel with Italian cream cheese. It's just so so so so so good.....However, I've been meaning to branch out and give the others a try! The Bagelry is doing it right, that's for sure! read more

See all

If you're craving a bagel, look no further! The Bagelry has a wide selection of flavors and their bagels are fresh, chewy, and soft, and just the right size for a filling breakfast or lunch. We tried the whipped garlic-feta-dill cream cheese and it worked wonderfully on all the savory bagels we got. The bialy was unique and a particular favorite, closely followed by the everything and sourdough. I topped mine off with some lox at home for an extra fancy breakfast. read more

The Bagelry - Poppyseed, garlic, and onion bagels - Bagels Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

Really lovely bagels. I think even my hyper-picky friends from New York or Montreal would like them.

Holy hell! The bagels slap and the cream cheese is whipped to perfection! Occasionally the employees have to deal with horrible folks and do so with grace. Keep up the good work y'all read more

I had the lox with cream cheese on a toasted sesame seed bagel. The toppings were tasty, but the bagel itself was pretty tough - a mouth workout. Same for my husband's. Would probably pass this spot up next time. read more

Bagels can be OK, but tend to be inconsistent in flavor from too salty to totally bland. While the cream cheese spreads are good, the bagels just don't seem to have the necessary consistent love in their preparation. Service is decent, but the bagels are smaller and less flavorful than the best bagels in Seattle and just less flavorful compared to Vancouver. Not sure why, but the blueberry bagels were a big disappointment with lackluster flavor. Wonder if they used some kind of canned blueberries or what went wrong. The challah bread looks very interesting, but did not try it. Parking options decent. read more

We stopped in this cute town where The Bagelry is located on the way to Seattle from Vancouver. I ordered a plain bagel with butter, along with several breakfast sandwiches. The butter costed more than the bagel and when I inquired about it, the manager rudely told me I can go home and get my own butter. Since the kids were hungry, we completed the order. However, the bagels were doughy but also tasted stale. Don't waste your time or money. There are plenty of other options on the street. read more

Best place for fresh bagels! Their bagels are the perfect consistency. Their lox and cream cheese is wonderful. The servers are really nice, and their shop promotes a lot of the local businesses. You can also get their spreads to go. I love picking up a tub of their cream cheese (salmon and their jalepeno) and having it for a few days-the quality stays. read more

It really sucks that this is the only bagel place in town. The bagels are good but their service is dreadful. There's always a long line and the orders seem to take forever. The employees also seem to be annoyed with the customers, I don't get it. The customer service is just bad. read more

The bagels were okay, but the service was awful. We tried the curbside pickup and were told online that our order would be ready around 10:24 we checked in at 10:20 and didn't get our food until 10:57. I watched a bunch of people order and receive their food in the time I was waiting. On top of that I'm pretty sure they had our bagels ready at 10:24 and just never brought them because they were cold and stale by the time I got them. I was very excited to try this place but I was also very disappointed. Maybe it's an inexperienced staff? Not sure. But if they can't keep up with the curbside orders than they shouldn't be taking up such rare parking spots downtown like they do. read more

So sad that this place has such a low rating - I absolutely love it! Was worried when I came based on the reviews but I was in Bellingham for the day and was craving a bagel so I thought I would just give it a try despite what I read. I was SO impressed!! I'm not vegan but I am trying to cut down on dairy so when I saw that they had vegan spreads I was ecstatic. I got a sourdough bagel with their plain vegan spread and got a plain bagel with the vegan scallion spread and both were amazing. The bagels were fresh, toasted perfectly, and had the perfect bagel to cream cheese ratio. The staff was super sweet and the bagels were ready nearly instantly after I ordered which I wasn't expecting based off of a lot of the reviews. It may be because I was there close to closing so they weren't very busy but still, super fast for me. Wish I lived in the area, would definitely be a regular! read more

The bagels here are as good as it gets. NYC included. The COVID restrictions seem to anger some; but I don't mind waiting outside. As long as I get those fantastic bagels. read more

Bagels are good for a small town. Nothing to write home about but a noble effort outside of the northeast. Unfortunately they don't take cash and only visa or MasterCard at that. Staff is hit or miss. Can be friendly or very unfriendly. Been coming since 2002 but experiences are getting more and more lackluster. Oh well. Need to eat better anyway. Some better customer service would go far here. Just ordered and tried paying with cash (denied covid?), then card (denied Amex not accepted) and then some nice girl behind me offered to pay. I was so bummed by this and just left. I'm done for a while. Don't want to see this place go because it's kinda a bellingham institution but it needs to get over itself or become like boundary bay after all the other micro brews popped up. read more

It was ok, more like Meh. The Bagel I got- the bottom of it wasn't that great, so just ate the top of it. and drank down my Pepsi, The muffin I had was ok as well, not the best muffin I've tried. Karin went with some Omelet which IMO it didnt look to tasty to me so glad I didn't get a Omelet lol. The place seemed to look clean IMO,so unlike some others who have posted I didnt see any dirty tables or whatever. Just a warning though- this place for some reason DOES NOT ACCEPT CREDIT/DEBIT CARDS! They only take cash and (LOL) checks! (like who carries checks anymore?) I highly doubt I would recommend this place, I doubt we will come back to it! read more

See all

These are really good bagels and maybe the best north of Seattle. The sesame bagels are the best and service is usually very good. Finding parking is hit or miss depending on the time, but there is typically a lot of street parking in the general area. read more

I have been a patron of the bakery for 30 years and I'm especially proud to say that I've been ordering online from them a couple times a month during this pandemic. They have a great system of curbside pick up on the bagels are delicious. read more

Delicious bagels served by friendly people. I'm not a bagel eating person normally and have taken my time getting to the Bagelry. For months, people have been raving about the place. I get it. If you're in the mood for fresh made bagels and spreads, this is the place to go. With so many options, it can be difficult to know what to order. Fear not. Employees can help by making recommendations. I had an everything bagel with vegetable spread and a pesto cheese omelette. Absolutely delicious. I didn't have coffee, but it smelled wonderful. It's a relaxing atmosphere, which is perfect for a grumpy morning person such as myself. A friend treated me to breakfast my first visit. Often times, I think food tastes better when someone else pays for it. My theory is that this place is going to be good even if I pay for it myself. read more

First of all, my dislike of the Bagelry has nothing to do with the bagels as they are the best in all of Bellingham. My issue is with the service. No one who works at the Bagelry EVER appears to be in a hurry and they put a lot more time and energy into the conversations they have with each other than the ones they have with their customers. Save yourselves the hassle and go to Avenue Bread instead which is just a few doors down from the Bagelry. The service is excellent there and the food delicious. read more

They do have decent bagels but I struggled with the rude staff and unorganized service.

Great customer service. I really enjoy the bagels I get from here. I always wish they had a cheese bagel of some sort but overall decent bagels. Love the whipped cream cheese. read more

Always dependable for a real bagel. Nice selection of bagels and cream cheese. I am a fan of the Everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. I usually pickup a half dozen to go along with a small cream cheese. Staff is super friendly and very helpful. You will also find a small selection of cheese and meats (can't call it Charcuterie... Just your typical deli meats). The space is large and clean with a nice view of Railroad Avenue (great for people watching). There are outside tables and chairs. Be advised they close early (currently 3pm Sunday and 4pm all other days). Also, no credit or debit cards are accepted (there is an ATM in the seating area. A sign advertises soups and omelettes (I have tried neither). Oh, don't skip the desserts! Today's visit reveled some awesome metal artwork on display... A quick and easy breakfast or early afternoon pick-me-up.... read more

The Bagelry - Metal artwork on dusplay - Bagels Near Me - Bellingham, Washington

See all

I had a breakfast special and a latte. They were out of rosemary salt bagels so I ordered raisin. I ordered the eggs scrambled because the last several times there I've ordered the eggs fried, over medium, and they always came too raw and runny. So I thought, "How can one mess up scrambled eggs?" I also let the order-taker know this would be an order, for here, not to-go. She responded by asking if this order would be for here or to go. Really. So...20 minutes after ordering I was served eggs with absolutely no taste, very dry, hard, and rubbery tiny bits--nothing light or fluffy about them. The latte had a scratchy texture and over-extracted taste. The bagel was fine. Also of note: As I sat and waited for my order, an employee stood behind the counter (right beside my table) and drank from an espresso drink he had just made and ate food, while on duty. I am not a picky eater, but I did not have a great experience. I've been a fairly regular Bagelry customer for decades, but I'm not sure when/if I'll go back. read more

I decided to break my diet and have a bagel glad I did very fresh and tasty made very fast like disappointed they didn't have avocado but they DID HAVE BOARS HEAD MEATS yaya! Big plus where I'm concerned so still a win read more

See all

I've been pretty disappointed with this place for quite a while. It really irks me I can't get a real breakfast sandwich here - - that bacon is evil and can't be put on the breakfast menu. They don't seem to care about customers or feedback - -So I'm thankful for the new place in town. read more

No bacon? What the hell. Ordered a "breakfast sandwich" and it was just egg and cheese. It's not a breakfast sandwich with no bacon, absolutely ridiculous, no bacon on the whole menu... read more

How I heard of this place: When we were little, my dad would wake up early on Sunday mornings and head downtown to buy us a baker's dozen fresh, hot bagels from the best bagel-factory ever. Each Sunday morning we would jump out of bed and rush to the kitchen to savor the new and yummy flavors he would choose. After decades of coming back to The Bagelry at every chance we got, we finally stayed to dine in and could get some photos before devouring our meals! Type of cuisine: Bagels galore! "There is nothing like a good bagel, and at The Bagelry, we proudly produce the best bagels in the Northwest. The bagels at The Bagelry are made in the time-honored tradition that is hard to find today even in New York. With no preservatives or additives, The Bagelry's bagels taste like the bagels that our grandparents loved!" Ambiance: Cute. Quirky. Large, yet unpretentious. Simple and warm. Family-friendly. Spacious and smells like a dream...of fresh bread! What I ordered: I enjoyed an 8-ounce mocha ($2.40) and my husband ordered the 16-ounce mocha ($3.00). My bagel was the classic, Plain with a Jalapeño Cream Cheese ($2.45) while my husband chose the Pesto & Ricotta omelette with a buttered plain bagel. We also shared one day-old Blackbottom Cupcake ($2.45) at the recommendation of a customer in front of us in line, and the cashier! What I loved: BAGEL! Bagel! Bagel! Why I loved it: Have I said how much I love their bagels? Soft, yet dense on the inside, crisped to golden perfection on the outside. Lightly sour, perfectly bready. Cost: Low ($1.15 - $7.35 per bagel sandwich) read more

Noticed I only had 15 minutes to order before they closed and I was 5 minutes away. All I wanted wad a bagel and a cup of coffee so I call in takeout order and the person on the phone acted like they didn't want to take my order. I asked do you take orders for pickup they said "we encourage online ordering and besides we're closing in 15 minutes" (exactly the reason I called in) okay so make me feel like I'm a pain in your heel because you wanna go home (I hung up). I used to love this place, we used to ride the bus from north county when we were kids just for the bagels. I came here a few weeks ago had no problem ordering at the window, was super stoked, came back again and they had a line down the street, gave it a 3rd try and received crappy service on the phone. Bummer, I'll have a hard time returning. Gave them 3 stars because they do have killer bagels read more

First time there yesterday. Had lox bagel sandwich that I took home to eat, and thought I was going to break a tooth the bagel was so hard and unyielding. I had also ordered at least a dozen different bagels to go, and I checked them when I got home to see if they were all hard and they basically were! I actually consider them inedible due to the hardness. Guess I'll be feeding the crows with the dozen I bought. Very disappointing. read more

Best bagels in Whatcom County (probably the best in the Puget Sound Northwest Interior. I'm something of a bagel snob, so I don't heap praise on many bagel shops. Bagels from the Bagelry in downtown Bellingham are always fresh and it's not unusual to find them still warm. They prepare their own smears and their takeout counter is quite efficient. read more

Food tastes OK but service is really bad. I ordered a bagel with cream cheese to go and it took 16 minutes to prepare. Employees wandering around everywhere but looking for busy jobs other than actually preparing food or helping the customers. read more

I went to Vancouver BC for the weekend during Dine Out Vancouver and somehow the Bagelry in Bham became the best meal of the trip. Perfect bagels with a lot of chew and tons of cream cheese options. Also sampled the lox on rosemary salt bagel. SO TASTY. We stopped for coffee before this and the place was way too pretentious. Bagelry is where it's at. Nothing snooty, just perfect bagels and a bunch of space! read more