The Best Yes the best Italian restaurant in Orillia…read more Amazing food and great service. The pizza is thin and done properly. Dishes are all incredible. Excellent wine selection. Great patio for the summer and excellent atmosphere inside and out. Need to book 2 weeks in advance in the summer.

Good food, server was attentive but it was very noisy . Cody feel to restaurant…read more Had the pizza, delicious thin crust

We attended the restaurant tonight and were pleasantly surprised about the food and service. The…read morefood was excellent, tasty and well prepared. They clearly have a good chef. The prices were fare by today's standards and the service was efficient and friendly. The space is large, not crowded with tables and nicely decorated. We would definitely return.

10-12-24 Bartender/Server Cindy was great, friendly, and very attentive. The cook however was…read morehaving a terrible night, he appeared ill or "on something". Food was terrible looking, after hearing from other customers they had waited over 45 minutes for the wrong food and missing proteins, we ordered takeout from another restuarant. Sad, because we just had dinner 10-5-24 and it was very good.

**A True Hidden Gem in Orillia **…read more As we were passing through Orillia, we decided to stop into **Theo's Restaurant** for a bite to eat--and I'm so glad we did. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted and brought to our table with such genuine hospitality. The space is spotless, intimate, and beautifully styled, creating the perfect atmosphere for a cozy meal. The menu is filled with wonderful Greek and Italian options, and everything we ordered was absolutely delicious. The bruschetta was outstanding, and the veal parm was perfection. The food alone is worth the visit, but the service truly elevated the experience. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, giving us that small-town connection where we didn't feel like "just customers." We also noticed the same level of care at the tables around us--clearly, this is how they treat everyone who walks in. Theo's is definitely a place I'd stop at again on my next trip back. And for anyone who lives in Orillia, it's a wonderful spot for a family celebration, a special date night, a relaxed dinner out, or even a business meeting. **Five stars all the way. The Theo family has done an incredible job.** Anja Lavigne ( Toronto/Kwarthas )

What a great experience. Fast and friendly service. A…read morerefill brought without even asking! The pepper was full not that we used it and they give enough tzatziki sauce to swim in (not that I'd recommend trying that) We aren't positive but think it's POSSIBLE Justin Beiber was at another table here. You be the judge. Deffo would recommend.

Quick review as I was only able to try a scoop of gelato. It was a hard choice between Pistachio…read moreand Hazelnut, but decided on Hazelnut. The gelato was fresh and tasty. I will try more very soon. There is a small shelf with grocery items from Italy with some very pricy pasta. Just note this little shop is located in the back of a comic book store and has a separate entrance on Peter St.

They need to control the customers better i was in there…read moregetting a very good gelato and some idiot comes in with 4 kids REALLY all over the place it's supposed to be 2 people per family in a store

They are a Canadian owned and operated pizza chain…read more First time trying their pizza tonight. The pizza was quite good and we liked the sesame seeds on the crust.. We ordered by phone a single large 2 topper for $12.45 because we went to pick it up (pepperoni and bacon)) and added italian sausage for an extra topper costing an extra $2.75. We also wanted the cheddar cheese dip and creamy garlic dip which were $2.00 each. The man who answered the phone spoke English quite clearly and was easy to understand him. He also understood what we requested and informed us it would be 20 minutes for the pizza to be ready. The dough was good and yes it was fresh. The base sauce, cheese and pepperoni was very good but was a little lacking for bacon and the sausage. But it was definitely better than CP for value. Only costed $20.00 and went across the street to Dollarama to buy a couple of 1 Liter bottles of Pepsi. That completed our meal. We would definitely order a Red Swan pizza again if we happen to be near one. Hopefully it would be as good as fbis one was tonight.

I waited 40 mins just to have them mess up my pizza and the two cashiers the ladies looked so…read moreconfused at there job had me repeatedly say what I wanted meanwhile I was speaking loud and clearly my pizza is pretty much burnt and missing feta cheese never again will I be eating here waste of money

This restaurant checks the important boxes: great tasting and quality food, well presented,…read morepleasant ambiance with local (Toronto) artist's works, reasonable priced, pleasant and professional server (Cory). We had the halibut and stuffed chicken with yummy cheesecake.

*** Update from our previous visit ***…read more My family had been to Era 67 in late September, and had a horrendous experience. After we posted our review the owner, Brian, contacted us to discuss what happened. He then offered for us to come back and give them another shot. We accepted, and returned this past Sunday (November 10th) When we arrived, we were seated quickly in the private room. Brian extended his apologies again and thanked us for returning. Our drink order was taken and delivered in a timely manner. My husband was impressed with his Old Fashioned, and said it was well made. We placed our appetizer and dinner choices at the same time. The appetizers were a bit slow to come out, however we attributed that to it being a busy evening. No big deal for us. We had the stuffed Yorkies, and the bruschetta. Both were excellent. Our dinners took longer than expected, but again, it was a busy night. 2 of us has the braised lamb shank, 2 had the Prime Rib special, and I had the striploin. They were worth the wait!! My brother wanted to lick his plate when he finished his lamb and said it was the best he's ever had. My steak was perfectly cooked, and the prime rib was also well enjoyed. Although we didn't have much space left, we elected to try their flourless chocolate torte for dessert, 2 pieces to be shared amongst us. It was super rich, but came with a raspberry coulis to help cut it. Excellent!! All in all, our experience was a million times better than our last. For me, personally, I do wish the food came out a bit faster, but aside from that, we were all very pleased. I've given it a 4 only because of the delay in between courses. The food was still worth the wait though. I know that my family plans to return. My mother wants to try the lamb after seeing how much my father and brother enjoyed theirs. Thanks for a great night, Brian.

Tonight my wife, 2 friends and I went out to dinner. It started off fine, our waitress had to get…read moreanother girl to serve us because she was overwhelmed but about 10 minutes in we started to hear a different waitress completely berating the young girl over our table. She was so Nasty to that poor girl. Not even 5 minutes later we hear her say "I f*cking hate this Place. Everyone here is so f*cking stupid." This started to upset my wife and she wanted to say something but we didn't. For the next 30 minutes we listened to her say 7-8 more discusting things to the other works. She called a kitchen worker a r*t*rd and said the girl at the front door has no idea how to do her job. How rancid is that. There were kids around and she was yelling this shit. Our waitress Bobby was very nice and apologetic and she gave us a dessert and gift card to try to fix the situation but thy doesn't fix it. No one should have to put up with that. We were incredibly disappointed. I've owned my own business for 13 years and if I had a employee like that they'd be gone so fast they wouldn't know what hit them. The entire situation left a bad taste in our mouths.

Originally a bit hesitant about coming to this location after reading some of the reviews on Yelp…read more Service was quick & pleasant. No issues with the food or service. Got what I expected - equitable service & quality that I previously received in Pickering & Markham locations.

This place is incredible I came in just as they were getting…read moreready to close placing my order was not a problem at all I ordered the large meatatararin pizza I thought it was a little pricey But OMG it as amazing normally my wife and I can finish off a large pizza no problem But this was so filling we finished just half of it It has got to be one of best pizza I've ever had I will definitely stop in there again when I'm up here Even if I'm close in the area I'll stop in and get one to go

It's good. I have tried it twice and did not get that wow…read morethis is fantastic idea . It's pretty bland and does not scream italian . Maybe some new ideas in the kitchen would kick it up a bit

Skimps out on toppings completely. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and got 2 pepperonis per slice. Also…read morewas cut super uneven where 1 slice was a sliver. The slices on display looked like roadkill that have been sitting there since yesterday. It looks like it has seen better days in the decor as well. I felt super dirty going in there. Now onto the bathroom.. I found a needle beside the toilet. I just am super upset with Pizza Pizza in Orillia. I will go back with a video at a later date with a new experience and hope they can change this review.

Wow what can I say about this pizza pizza...well all good things. I came in expecting nothing more…read moreor less than your run of the mill pizza pizza....but I was pleasantly surprised. Jay our server welcomed us warmly into the establishment. His smile alone made the experience fantastic but then he continued to deliver a positive and surprising experience. Jay notified us of the deep fried avocados which was my first time hearing about this wonderful treat at a pizza pizza. Kudos Jay! We didn't try the avocado deep fried, a bit exotic for our taste buds but it was delightful to learn That they are an option. Speaking of learning Jay taught us about all the soda options available. Did you know they have Barq's cream soda?! This is the first time I had even heard that this was a thing. All in all the experience was 11 out of 10. Jay provides great service and I can't wait to come back. Well done gentlemen keep up the great work.