Great new place at the beach with gelato! Strawberry Nutella shake is delicious. Lots of fun…read moreflavors to choose from and different ice cream creations to try!

We tried this place on a week night in late September. They were open at 8:00 pm which was…read moreconvenient with most dessert venues already closed. We didn't try any of the gelato but the cake desserts were fantastic. Had a tiramisu and limoncello cake.

Staff is friendly and quick with your ice cream And I will…read moretell you the chocolate chocolate thunder is AMAZINGLY DELICIOUS Thank you

I love this ice cream store when we are at Rehoboth! They have over 20+ assortments of flavors! I…read moretried the buttery salted caramel and cake batter cookie dough! They both were very creamy! The salted caramel was perfect with the creamy sweet taste! And the dough from cake battered cookie dough ice cream had a slight sweet and salted taste! This place never disappoints after a hot day on the beach! The service was great, always friendly serving the ice cream!

So I tried a different ice cream shop and loved it, but they were closed on Monday so we tried…read moreArchie's as an alternative and boy oh boy am I glad I did. I'm not sure which of the two is my favorite, but you can't go wrong at Archie's. They have super unique flavors and one scoop is HUGE! So you get what you pay for and more in my opinion. I highly recommend them and I had great customer service! I can't wait to come back and get some more next time I'm vacationing in Rehoboth! Just a few ideas of their flavors: Twix, snickers, Oreo and more! Def give it a try, you won't be disappointed.

I was on the Rehoboth Beach boardwalk and I was in the mood for some ice cream so I decided to give…read moreArchie's a try. Taking this into consideration, I ordered a small soft vanilla ice cream on a cake cone. Knowing that, the ice cream was pretty good. To explain, it was creamy, sweet, and rich. However, the cone was just a pre-packaged cone that was a little stale. Furthermore, the price was steep. To make clear, it cost $6.50 for a small ice cream and they didn't even use homemade cones. In summation, Archie's is a fine place for some ice cream, but it's nothing special.

Delicious local ice cream! We were here on vacation and saw a few Bonkey's near where we were…read morestaying. I couldn't believe how many options there were and the pricing. It was absolutely delicious. I got the pick 4 scoops - not that I needed it - but it was nice to try all the different flavors. There's sometimes a long line, just shows how good it is, but the wait wasn't too bad. There were some outdoor chairs but it was a nice summer night so we just hung out by our car. Would definitely go back here again when we visit!

Stopped here for an after dinner ice cream. Lots of different flavors to choice. Definitely…read morerecommend checking this place out. Service was quick and friendly.

As the Beatles sang: Lovely Rita, nothing can come between us…read more Why aren't you located closer to our home? The mixture of gelato and Italian ice is unbeatable!

They were able to handle a large crowd at once, very good service, clean restaurant even thought…read morethey were super busy

Had to stop by since this is the new ice cream place in town, and we were FAR from disappointed…read more Ice cream is my jam, and I will be visiting every night I'm at the beach the rest of the summer FOR SURE!! We first saw the line out the door and down the steps Sunday evening, but we swung in Tuesday afternoon and there was only one couple ahead of us. Service was quick and friendly. The flavors here are homemade and lack nothing! Awesome combinations and even better creative names! My youngest got the cotton candy twist, middle child got a cookie dough on a cone (classic), oldest got the dirt milkshake. Think of the dirt cup desserts, it was an Oreo ice cream with gummie worms-she loves this stuff. Can't recall what my husband got because when I saw the badger sundae on the TV screen I couldn't contain my excitement. (I do wish the tv screen rotated images slightly slower so I could read everything) Originally I was torn between all these amazing sounding flavors, and figured I'd do a two scooper with two flavors, but this badger sundae caught my eye and it was game on! Badger Sundae = This $&@! Just Got Serious ice cream layered with Hot fudge and toffee pieces- OMGeeeee, all things lovable!!! Topped with whipped cream of course, and you better believe I didn't share! (Well barely) This $&@! Just Got Serious ice cream is their Award-winning, smooth salted caramel ice cream brimming with rich sea salt fudge and salted cashews. I can not wait to return and try something else. I urge you to stop in & dare you not to love these flavors. They also had freezers with to go ice cream cakes and vegan options! Get your booty by the bay for ice cream!!! Oh there's also an adorable backdrop inside for great photo ops, & their sundae cup nutrition facts are hilarious as well. Only downside is seating isn't too great, there are benches outside but it's a tight fit. Although when the ice cream is this good who cares, walk it up to the boardwalk and enjoy with the sounds of waves in the background. By the Bay creamery In Bethany- you're welcome!

When you enter Bethany Beach as an ice cream shop, you are stepping into well established…read moreterritory!! But By the Bay Creamery brings creative flavor combos, location outside of the main drag of town, and no lines even at prime time. Now... being new this summer, the lines may eventually grow, but they definitely are adding a new flavor to the town! Located across the street from Pirates Mini Golf, they add a sweet treat to the end of your putting! The inside is decorated with a cool photo wall, colorful menus, and a scrolling menu with photos of uncommon options. We opted for single scoops: - Munchie Madness - cake batter ice cream with a gooey caramel ripple, Oreos, m&ms, and peanut butter cups - Mint Avalanche - mint ice cream with Andes mint pieces and grasshopper cookie crunch - Smore to Love - graham cracker ice cream with ripples of gooey marshmallow and melty chocolate layers The waffle cones are so fresh that they give you a plastic cone diaper to catch any drippage. They will let you try any and all flavor before you decide and the service is super fast to get your scoops right into your hands!

The deep dark chocolate with raspberry is the best I've had !!!…read moreThe girls at the counter are friendly and fun Enjoy

With 100+ flavors to choose from, it was so hard to decide! There are lots of unique, specialty…read moreflavors at Starkey's compared to the other ice cream shops on the boardwalk , but it isn't handmade like Archie's or National Ice Cream shop. It's great to have the option to choose 2 flavors for the single scoop. I enjoyed the Brown Bourbon Truffle Ice Cream paired with Coffee Oreo. During the daytime it's not that busy, but at night it can get packed. There was a 10 min line on Sunday. Staff was nice and kindly let me sample a few flavors. Recommend trying a new flavor!

All I got was a large frozen Mexican Mocha..... The staff is…read morefriendly and quick with drinks and food, the shop was nice and cozy I'll be back while I'm in town Thank you keep up the great work

Went back this morning with my partner. I had a bagel with hummus, onion and tomato. My partner…read morehad English Muffin with egg and cheese. The food was prepared quickly and was delicious. The coffee was great again today snd I heard the iced tea was also very good. Friendly staff. Comfortable place to sit. If you are looking to purchase coffee beans, I counted 12 varieties available for sale.