Sweetings has been open since 1889 which is as old school as you can get. They've been serving basically the same menu for close to 125 years. While waiting for our table, standing at the bar for an afternoon beer in a pewter mug, I spied an old menu on the wall in a frame. Sure enough it was almost the same as their current menu. You won't find anything fancy here. Just great quality fish, prepared simply well. And it's only open 3 and a half hours a day Monday through Friday (11:30 to 3pm). I took a yelper's advice and showed up right at 11:30 am to avoid a queue. I'm thinking the having a beer first is part of the tradition as we were still taken to the bar for about 15 minutes until our table was ready.
We started off with a crab bisque and a lobster bisque soup. I only took one photo since they looked exactly the same. However doing a side by side taste test, they were totally different. I loved both of them. The Lobster bisque had a much bolder wine flavor to it. Neither was very creamy and was more of a tomato broth. I'm guessing they use rice starch rather than cream to thicken up the bisque. I prefered the crab bisque just a little bit more than the Lobster, but my brother enjoyed the Lobster more. At only £5.50 each, if you don't mind sharing soup, I would get both and do your own tasting.
Next up was an excellent appetizer of Scallops & Bacon. I could have eaten this all day. Perfectly buttery lightly seared scallops wrapped in bacon served on a large scallop shell. It's a tried and true formula for sure and it works every time.
The daily special appetizer was not so excellent however. Crab cakes served with a very spicy Thai chili dipping sauce. Considering how simple the main menu is, a Thai flavor seemed a little out of place for the restaurant to me. But really the problem was that the crab cakes were just way too much breading, way too little crab.
For the main courses we shared the Dover Sole, the Halibut, Scampi, and the Chef's Fish Pie. The price ranges are all over the place with these dishes. The Fish pie was the most reasonable at £13.50 and the Dover Sole the other extreme of the menu at £31. The fish pie is the best I've had. Huge chunks of Salmon, Halibut, and a few other white fishes all baked in a rich tasty cream sauce, topped with mashed potatoes and browned. If I worked nearby, this would be my lunch dish for sure.
Since London is only 76 miles from Dover, I felt I had to try the Dover Sole. Sucker? Maybe. But at least I'm pretty sure I'm getting the real thing. The porterhouse of fish it's always called. All fish here can be either fried, grilled, or poached. It's best to ask your waiter, which preparation works best with what fish. He recommended poached with a side of hollandaise sauce. By request, your waiter will debone the fish for you, so while it doesn't really make for a nice presentation, I knew he would do a better job than we would. Don't expect any seasoning in this preparation, but after I just added a pinch of table salt along with a little bit of hollandaise in each bite, it was heavenly. That said, I'm not sure I wouldn't have also enjoyed any of their other more reasonably priced fish served the same way.
We had the Halibut fried. I learned on my last trip to England that it's common for the British to leave the skin on their fish when doing fish and chips. Us Americans, look at this as kind of crazy, but it's your dish. Having tried it on the last visit, I'm not a fan of the skin on. It doesn't get crunchy, but just seems like slimy fish skin in between the batter and the fish. That said, I totally forgot to ask for it without here. Actually didn't think I'd have to in such a fine restaurant. But let's just chuck this up to "Lost in Translation". It was a shame because this was a huge piece of fine Halibut, but as we flaked it away from the skin, we lost most of the tasty breading. The fried scampi were perfect however and would also be something to be ordered on a regular basis here if you are a local. They were huge and a great excuse to dip in their tartare sauce. No meal would be complete without some chips. I'm guessing that Sweetings double fries them. They had a nice crispness about them, but weren't overdone.
I can see why the other reviews here are 3 and 4 stars. It's somewhere between 4 and 5 stars for me. But since Sweetings has been open for business since the reign of Queen Victoria, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt and round it up to 5 stars. read more