Seems like most of the complaints in these reviews center on service. At a pizza place I don't know why people expect great service. This is New England, welcome to our pizza joints. I've eaten here twice now, and the pizza was elite both times: flavorful, sweet sauce (hence the name), copious toppings, and you can tell that they use really good flour in the crust. I will definitely be back. Oh, and by the way: GREAT, friendly service from a guy who appeared to be the owner. read more

Good thin crust pizza. The specialty pies were fantastic. The rustica white with spinach and garlic wAs awesome. The cheese was not a hit with the kids though. Too many tomatoes and not enough cheese. read more

Great place. Very family friendly (chalk board, cornhole, outdoor seating ect) Delicious food. Wish pizza had a little more sauce but very good. Waitress were amazing. They sell pizza by the slice read more

Great pizza, super workers. This is a great place for thin crust crispy pizza! There is a good variety of toppings and some very interesting specialty pizzas. Service has always been great. read more

We just had pizza from Sweet Tomatoes in Chatham. I have to say I am surprised at the negative reviews here on Yelp. Many seem a bit old so maybe that's part of the problem. Regarding the place itself...they have a new location on Main St. In Chatham and have added an outdoor patio area too! Tonight we got a Rustica pizza to go. It was fantastic. The crust is nice and thin. Red sauce is tasty with just the right amount of garlic. This pizza has sausage ( sliced thin ) with spinach, roasted red peppers and mozzarella cheese. It was so good. My husband, our friend and I were so thrilled to find a good pizza place here in Chatham. Sweet Tomatoes will definitely be our go to spot from now on. Can't wait to try salads and calzones too! read more

We tried their clam pizza last night. What a mistake. They use canned clams that taste rotten. It's hard to believe that in Chatham, which is known for fresh shellfish they use canned clams. They should take it off the menu. read more

Great pizza! I personally hate thick crust because I feel like I fill up on dough. This pizza has a great tasting, thin crust with fresh ingredients on top. After so much seafood it was such a treat to find this lovely pizzeria on our vacation. We sat outside and had the best meal! read more

I like this place because I thought that the staff were nice and the pizza there is pretty good! Come to this place by getting public transportation, taxi, walking or even bike there! Hopefully there should be some bike racks nearby! read more

Great pizza, fast service, casual ambience. They serve beer too which is a plus. Not a place to go if you have a large group or are expecting to be waited on. This is really pretty close to fast food but with far better quality. read more

Okay, so I've had a lot of pizza in my life...in many parts of the US. The pizza here is excellent, we got it for pickup. A bustling pizza shop, it was busy at dinner time. Great sauce and great thin crust. Beat's Upper Crust up in Boston. This is a thin crust pizza, not greek style, or thick crust, or like dominos etc. Crust had a great crunch and texture. If you don't like thin pizza, well, you won't like this. But for us it was the perfect ratio of toppings to crust. read more

Delightful pizza stop in Chatham near the end of the Old Colony Rail Trail. We enjoyed a 1/2 & 1/2 (Greek/3-Cheese) pizza and took subs to-go for the bike ride back to Yarmouth. Wonderful patio to enjoy this beautiful Cape Cod day and some amazing pizza. I can't wait to come back!! read more

We arrived at 5:25 tonight and there was only 2 people ahead of us. When our beer cans were handed to us the tops were covered in what looked like sand. I asked what was on the can and the employee said it is flour used for the pizzas with no attempt to clean them off. I was shocked that this employee did not have the sense to clean it off. I asked her to please rinse off the top and she seemed annoyed. Suddenly within 10-15 minutes after our order a surge of people came in - probably 5 or 6 tables. Our order got lost and management did not seem to care. After 50 minutes I went and asked about it and they said oh it's here and will be out in 10 minutes. No concessions or offers of a drink on the house or credit off our bill. Pizza was just average. read more

Very good pizza. Nice light summer pie. Beat option in Chatham. Customer service is really great. I would highly recommend. Good location as well read more

Best pizza I've had on the Cape. Thin crust perfection. Had pesto pizza easy on the cheese. Super fresh and tasty. Our salads were great too - Mediterranean and Greek with very good produce and well balanced dressings. Young woman at the counter was lovely and let us know our pizzas would be 30 minutes. This is a small shop - not fast food. Well worth the wait! read more

The owner of this location is extremely unprofessional and rude. I have food allergies, which many restaurants can easily accommodate without issue. When I started explaining my allergy, the owner cut me off mid sentence without even listening and was extremely rude and condescending. I always understand if a restaurant does not feel comfortable accommodating an allergy, but at least do it with respect and professionalism- this is a medical disorder, not a high maintenance demand. read more

Can't believe the low rating for this place- we stopped by on the off chance about 15 minutes before closing and ordered a pepperoni pizza to share. The girl behind the counter insisted we stay to eat in if we wanted, even though it was close to closing, as they had clearing up to. It took less than 10 minutes to arrive and it was soooooo delicious! Really thin and crispy base and delicious tomato sauce- so much so that we have already decided to return before our trip is over and to just go for cheese and tomato so nothing can distract from the yummy sauce! Would highly recommend. read more

Good pizza, if you can get one or obtain the "CORRECT PHONE NUMBER" ~ If you call information (411), as many do, for "SWEET TOMATOES PIZZA" in Chatham they connect & give you the "CROWELL RD" Chatham phone number (which is unanswered) or the "SANDWICH, MA" phone number! The actual location, "790 MAIN STREET, CHATHAM" is NOT available thru the information operator (411). After getting no answer at the "CROWELL RD" number provided & being connected to the SANDWICH, MA" location several times I asked the operator for the "MAIN STREET, CHATHAM" phone number and was told it's not in their directory.- - - Must be a lot of orders NOT picked-up at the "SANDWICH, MA" location and the "MAIN STREET CHATHAM" location must be missing-out on a lot of potential orders. read more

Insanely bad service. Like, you can't really believe somebody in a restaurant is talking to you like this. The owner/manager seems a bit imbalanced. I tried Sweet Tomatoes the other day. Seems we have a pattern here (after reading other reviews). I called ahead, got put on hold twice but finally put in my order. I sent my son to pick up the pizza. The manager told him they never got the order. So I decided to stop by myself and see what was up. The manager (owner?) barked at me and said someone had already stopped by and they didn't get our order. I said, "Well, I called it in." The guy snaps at me and said "it's not here." Full disclosure, the pizza is really good there but I'm not going back. The manager (or whomever the older guy is) is not exactly a pro at running a pizza joint. Here's the deal: you run a pizza place in a summer/tourist town so you should expect business to get sort of chaotic, you know, during the summer. Deal with it. Clearly, this guy can't. read more

very very poor customer service rude totally ignorant and abrasive rule of thumb the customer is always right! thanks for nothing, sweet tomatoes not try rotten tomatos !!! read more

Great toppings, lovely flavor, and it is served up fast. I recommend the pesto veggie pizza or one of their calzones. The crust is thin and delicious. Not the tasteless cardboard some other thin crust pizzas can have. read more

I ordered a large pizza tonight. It wasn't what I expected. Too light on the sauce and cheese as well as the toppings. Disappointed

Having read all the reviews it seems that the bad ones outnumber the good ones, that being a warning for me to stay far away from Sweet Tomatoes. Sounds like the owner is a bit off his rocker, insulting paying customers, and that seems to have rubbed off on the other employees. read more

The staff is sweet too! We went there once and had to return two days later because the margherita pizza was so perfect. It's situated a little bit apart of the main street traffic but it worth the few more minutes you have to walk. read more

If I could give this place zero stars I would. The sauce is terrible and badly distributed, cheese is frozen, the slices are all cut uneven and thin. Last time we went here, my buddy took a bite out of the pizza only to find that he had eat half of a MAGGOT - i shit you not - in the pizza. By far the worst pizza place i've been to. read more

Good pizza but getting them to deliver is like pulling teeth. They do everything they can to not have to deliver. They said they go as far as the corner store, told them we were only four houses from there but they would not do it. Oh well the Talkative Pig in south chatham has better pizza. read more

Great pizza! My wife and I came as we were staying in Chatham for the night and sat outside on the porch. It was so fun, great food, and great guys working! read more

In August this past summer I had a salad with "grilled" chicken. Absolutely THE WORST salad and chicken I've ever had! The chicken was reheated frozen crap, and the "salad" was wilted and awful. I wouldn't let my dog eat there!! read more

Great little pizza place near downtown Catham. Pepperoni by the slice was great and the atmosphere is very "mom and pop".

For any New Yorker like myself who loves a traditional thin crust pie, this is the place. Perfectly charred crust with a good ratio of sauce, cheese and ample toppings. Chunky tomato sauce with a nice balance of tart/sweet as the name suggests. Pie was ready and piping hot within the 15 minute estimate we were given. Friendly, professional staff and reasonable prices. Under $20 for a generously sized large 1/2 cheese, 1/2 mushroom/sausage, using all quality ingredients. I'm a fan! I'll be back soon! read more

I would give this place zero stars if that was possible. Last summer, we ordered two pizzas for our family by phone. My husband asked the clerk to read back the order, he did, and told him 20 minutes. He drove over, and when he arrived, was told that they never got the order. This year, we decided to give it a second chance, thinking that had to be a fluke. This time, I called. I ordered a large pizza, gave my name and asked how long it would take. They said 15 minutes. We arrived 15 minutes later, and surprise! were told that they never got our order. They immediately blamed us for "calling their other location." I checked my phone log and confirmed we had the number right. Standing in the store, you can see that they have a bunch of cordless phones. The tiny, young staff seems to be responsible for making pizza, taking orders, and ringing people up. They were apologizing to the woman next to me for forgetting her fries. The manager was beyond rude. The attitude is that they have a captive audience who won't be repeat customers anyway. We ended up going to Carmine's Pizza- the service was great and the pizza was excellent. Avoid this place if you'd actually like to eat something or be treated with any sort of respect for trying to patronize a local business. read more

The pizza and salad we ordered were good but the owner/manager was a jerk. While picking up our order, he talked rudely to customers coming in and treated his staff horribly. I'm surprised anyone would work for him. Given what we experienced, we will look for other options in Chatham! read more

One of the best white claim pizzas that I've had. Maybe I got lucky but it was fantastic.

Manager was completely unprofessional and rude... Only reason why I would return is for the food. I work in the food service industry and would never treat anyone with such disrespect. He is immature and needs to find a more suitable profession for his personality. read more

Had a great meal with the family. Pizza, meatballs, chicken cutlet sandwich. Kids wrote on the wall which they thought was great.

The pizza was awful... The sauce was nearly non-existent. I asked if there garlic was fresh or from the jar... The answer was fresh.. Which come to find out meant raw. Who eats raw garlic on Pizza? The eggplant was just about raw as well. Overall a very bad experience read more

Horrible. On a quiet night in June we ordered pizza to go. It was horrible. Nearly devoid of cheese, and just tasted terrible. We barely ate it. read more

We ordered three pizzas and ate in the restaurant. I really liked the pizzas- they are thin crust- New Haven-Wooster Street type. The rest of the family really enjoyed the pizzas as well. Staff is not very friendly. I'd give a five star for the pizza, 2 for service. read more

I hate to give any business a 1-Star review, let alone a Cape Cod business, but unfortunately this will have to be my first. My family and I ordered a large white clam and a small cheese pizza from Sweet Tomatoes on a regular Summer Tuesday night and waited for nearly twenty minutes in the restaurant for our pizzas to be ready (which were finally ready 20 minutes past their promised time). I hoped that the pizza was going to be worth the wait despite the very slow service and the mistakes that I saw being made on several other orders while I waited. Unfortunately for Sweet Tomatoes, the pizza did not. Now, in all fairness, the menu did not say that there would cheese on the white clam pizza, but I must say that it was just very odd to eat a white clam pizza without cheese (I had figured that cheese on a white clam was a given). It was strangely dry and pieces of basil literally flew off into the wind with the slightest breeze on our backyard porch while eating. Although the cheese was a little better and I understand that this pizza is Neapolitan-style pizza, I have never witnessed such thin pizza at such a high price in my entire life. The small cheese for $11 wasn't bad, but the $21 white clam is nearly incomprehensible. Sure it was pretty big, but it seemed like nothing was on it and that I was eating just the pizza crust. I suggest more staff to decrease wait times and a clear indication that there is literally nothing but a few clams, few pieces of basil, and trace amounts of olive oil on their white clam pizza. read more