Been going since 2009 and Is absolutely our favorite. The owner is great and always so kind! read more

Sushi Cafe - Sushi Cafe is my Favorite sushi spot ever! I often switch my orders up but my favorite roll is the Volcano roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Came here on a Monday during lunch. We were the only ones here. I have been to probably 100 sushi spots easily all over the country. I will not be back here. The tempura in the shrimp tempura roll was actually breadcrumbs. Not panko even. The sushi was just okay. It was mostly filler items than actual Fish. The dumpling sauce was exceptionally salty. The location is clean. We also ordered a coke from a can which was flat. And the next one they brought was also flat. Must be kept in the heat? They also had probably 70 pre made eel sauce, chipotle mayo, and soy sauce made for 50 cents. Personally I think that's kind of gross to have them sitting in pasto containers for who knows how long. Overall won't be back read more

I have come here a couple times, and I've had a great experience always, except this one. I have never tasted a Red Dragon roll so good before coming here. All of their rolls are always delicious! But the service seemed to be the problem. It took us an hour to receive our meal. The table across from us ended up paying the bill, leaving, and packing their food to go. The restaurant wasn't as busy for a Friday night. There were only two servers and that seemed to be the problem. Overall, I love coming here for their delicious rolls! But the experience definitely could have been better. read more

Sushi Cafe - 38. Red Dragon Roll 39. Fire Dragon Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Fantastic Love the atmosphere, Fresh food. Delicious Amazing Great for dates Love love the art. So great vibes read more

Nice lunch spot. Very good Raman and good sushi. Friendly staff and easy to find location.

I was in the neighborhood and came in to grab a quick lunch. The restaurant has nice decor and the service was quick. I got a chirashi which was pretty good. The sashimi was fresh and tasty. It's $25 so don't expect a super fancy chirashi with ingredients like uni and salmon roe. It has salmon, tuna, fluke, tamago, shrimp, and imitation crab sticks. It got the job done and I would come back again next time I'm in the area. read more

Sushi Cafe - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Great service, delicious rolls and sashimi, wonderful live music. I would definitely come back again! read more

Sushi Cafe - 46. Hot Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Overall this place is so cute. The ambience is not typical of a sushi restaurant but is very nice and I loved it. The pork gyoza were some of the best we have had. I loved the sushi rolls I ordeeed (shrimp with spicy mayo and a tuna roll). They weren't too big which I appreciate. Only complaint was The kids ordered their usual chicken yaki udon and they liked the chicken but the sauce had an overall taste of cinnamon sweetness they did not like. Other orders were yellowtail sashimi and salmon avocado rolls, cucumber rolls, seaweed salad and miso soup. It's BYOB which is great too. read more

Terrific. A wide menu and good service. Always fresh. Music sometimes on Thursdays. Been there several times. Very consistent. Thanks. read more

The best food. Every Thursday is great!! Kani Sunrise or Christmas roll and Bumblebee read more

Sushi Cafe - Clean plate - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

What is happening? Ordered two rolls for myself and salmon teriyaki ($19) for the kids See photo of rolls and video because I just don't get how someone would allow such a sad excuse for a sushi roll be served out of any "sushi" establishment: loosely wrapped, dinky and just sad The actual inside was fine in terms of taste but c'mon..... thee second I picked me up the wrap was falling apart and the inside noticeably filled poorly. Plenty of other options nearby for a better value: Sushi Laco is tons better. The rice dish was prepared just fine and taste was good but not a $19 dish by any means. Verdict: Overpriced with no intention behind the execution read more

Sushi Cafe - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE... we had different rolls... all were awful. terrible sushi! they also messed up our order... the wasabi was wet and the soy sauce was diluted. The fish tasted like poor quality. read more

My boyfriend and I ordered three rolls from Sushi Cafe for delivery one weekend night from Grubhub and waited around 45-55 minutes for the order to arrive (as estimated). We were excited when the sushi arrived through contactless delivery and immediately dug in. Needless to say, the sushi was pretty darn good. We ordered the salmon roll, spicy tuna roll, and the Tokyo Roll. The salmon and tuna fish in the sushi tasted fresh and soft and super yummy along with the avocado. The rolls were pretty decently priced and we thoroughly enjoyed our sushi meal. We will definitely be ordering from this place again in the near future and possibly trying other rolls! read more

Sushi Cafe - Salmon roll , spicy tuna roll , and Tokyo Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

I got the yaki udon with chicken for $20 and it was definitely not worth $20. Was very average. The gyoza was also just ok. Food wasn't bad but also wasn't worth the steep price read more

My experience ordering a pick-up through their website: I read about a free appetizer offer for online orders, so I went on their website and ordered 3 rolls, 2 shumai appetizers, and a Gyoza, plus an extra Gyoza as the free appetizer. I noted "4 people" to ensure enough sauces and chopsticks. When my husband brought the order home, the bag was soaked from leaking sauces, they gave us only ONE pair of chopsticks for four people, and the free appetizer was missing. I called, but the lady was dismissive, and no one followed up as promised. Avoid this place--first and last time ordering from them. read more

Tasty, well packaged, fair prices, beautiful decor. The restaurant is not as visible from the street. Friendly service. Ordered the spider roll, tuna roll and a spicy tuna roll. Would come back. read more

Way too much rice. We ordered a bunch of rolls for a quick dinner. It was cheap (6ish a roll) but the ratio of fish to rice was way off. I don't mind eating a smaller sized roll with less rice but that was not the case! I wouldn't order from here again. Sushi laco is way better! read more

Sushi Cafe - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Very cool ambiance, great food and fast service! Fun date night place or good place to bring a decent sized group. Will be going back!

I ordered a bento box with Salmon Teriyaki for lunch. It comes with Salmon fried with broccoli, 4 pieces of California rolls, 2 fried dumplings and salad ( I ordered salad instead of miso soup for the side, then I ended up having too much salad for lunch ). The price $13.99 is fair. The salmon is very fresh, but the rest items are nothing good. Maybe they shall improve the quality of rice, it's too sticky and sour. read more

i got food poisoning at this place after eating chicken and vegetables on Dec 19. The food poisoning was confirmed & treated by physicIan. I am still recovering from this horrible illness. read more

I first ate here 5 years ago when I moved here and was extremely disappointed with the mediocre sushi. I decided to give them another chance and I stand by my opinion. The rolls are mediocre and continues to be rice heavy and the fish is tiny. Not worth the money. Will continue to go out of my way to West Orange for sushi. read more

Sushi Cafe - a tray of sushi and chopsticks - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Sushi Cafe is a great sushi restaurant and their staff is phenomenal. I recommend all to come to this restaurant.

We did takeout Sunday night. The sushi was just ok-nothing bad, but nothing great. I would best describe it as American type sushi. The issue I had was the tempura. It was not tempura, but rather panko fried shrimp & vegetables & much heavier. Tempura is a type of batter & its unfair& wrong to say that when it's not. What a waste of $12. read more

Sushi Cafe - Thursday AYCE - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

This was my first stop at Sushi Cafe! I thought I walked into a piece of Japan when I entered... beautiful decor, great vibes, and excellent service. Andrew helped us navigate the menu and made great suggestions. Their prices are fair and lunch specials cannot be beat. I rarely ever give 5 stars, but this place deserves it. (Don't believe me... check my other reviews). read more

Sushi Cafe - Sushi bar and seating! - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Have ordered lunch from here a few times already and I'm obsessed with their sushi. It is fresh, tasteful and filling. My favorites are the Monster roll, Lucky roll and the spicy tuna roll. I have also had their spicy ramen and that was a disappointment. It tasted worst than the ramen you can buy at the supermarket 3 for a dollar. Besides that I would really recommend them for the sushi. Best sushi in the area! read more

Sushi Cafe - Volcano roll and spicy tuna - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

We had a very good dinner. Loved the seaweed salad and Kano salad for appetizer. Had 3 rolls, all good. I found the spicy scallops a little too spicy for me but not my boyfriend, he loves it spicy. Can't go wrong. Service very nice too read more

See all

The food was great and it was so great for my daughters birthday it was a great experience

Came here for lunch. After their lunch special. I didn't even notice and I order two rolls. Haha. I was stuffed and didn't need to be. I am glad I came here for lunch. It is a very cheap option for pretty good sushi. $6.99 for two rolls lunch special 11:30-3:00. $10 minimum on cards. Sat at the sushi bar. Ordered a miso soup and a green salad. The miso soup had great flavors! Just the right amount of salt. There was a perfect amount of scallions but barely any tofu or seaweed. I barely cared though because the broth was super good. The green salad was great as well. The ginger dressing was not too overpowering and enough was provided for the whole salad. Now onto the sushi. It was made really fast! Eight pieces is one roll. Lovely, you barely find a place that does eight pieces. I ordered the Tokyo and Philadelphia roll. They both were good just lacked flavor. All the flavors just meshed into one, rather than tasting everything that's in it. It was fresh but just one note. The low sodium soy sauce is extremely low sodium. Tastes like they mix it with water. When you pour it into the dish it's super light. The lightest soy sauce I've ever seen. Barely any salt. Even though the sushi was one note, I am definitely making this place my go-to-sushi-lunch spot because it's fast, cheap, and the food is good. I am excited to come back and try their special rolls. The people next to me ordered the Trick or Treat roll which looked finger licking good. read more

See all

The most delish sushi in this area. Spicy tuna rolls are awesome and the Goyza (dumplings) are amazing Wish they stayed open a bit later but maybe these are pandemic hours. They always get my order right and I usually have a couple extra requests. If you are looking for sushi in this area go with Sushi Cafe. read more

Very Consistent and creative rolls. The 38 Special is my favorite. Went with family and everyone enjoyed. Eel sashimi, Bulgogi Don, several different rolls, shumai, gyoza all delicious. Accommodated a special request for two of the rolls. Always enjoy it. read more

Really good ordered take out for the first time really fresh this is our new sushi place ! read more

Sushi Cafe - a plate of sushi on a table - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

perfect!!! i love the California rolls and shrimp califorina rolls and avocado roll it is such a good combo for to go the staff is so kind and friendlyand me and my family love going there, 10/10 read more

Even one star is too nice to give, but unfortunately there is no option or less. Horrible food, horrible service. The waiters have no clue about customer service...our experience kept getting worse minute by minute. This was our second time - we will we won't be returning. read more

I have been going to Sushi Cafe for 15 years! Paul's sushi and sashimi is a household favorite!! Sashimi is absolutely fresh and delicious. We are obsessed with special rice, fire cracker roll and fire dragon roll. Don't miss opportunity to indulge in the freshest sushi in the area. read more

Sushi Cafe - 33. Flower Roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

This is a tastefully renovated sushi cafe with a friendly staff and BYOB policy. The sushi is fresh, the prices are reasonable, and Sushi Cafe supports live music on weekends. There's a lot to like about this place, check it out! read more

Sushi Cafe - Sushi cafe with live music, nice! - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Wish Yelp allowed 1/2 stars or allowed rating on separate topics like food, ambience, service. I think 3 1/2 would be my rating... to start this is an unusual Japanese restaurant, nothing wrong with that, it just took us aback a bit at first. Staff are mostly 20-something white guys dressed like they're serving burgers at a surf shop (including 1/2 the guys working the sushi bar) t shirts with cartoon logos, baseball caps...but all good...they were all friendly. Big Beatles posters with glitter on one wall, rice paper panels on the other...a little overly bright lighting. TVs at the sushi bar. I guess I should have expected something less traditional when I came for the live music. Pretty low prices. Menu could have had more vegetarian options, but was okay. They didn't have an ice bucket for wine & refilled water glasses with a gallon jug of Poland Spring...???.... We came a distance from home because a band we like (The Koots) was playing here, but we might come back when we're in the area. read more

See all

I love this new location! It's close and décor is beautiful and more modern & better parking lot vs. the old location. The food is still as good as the old location. Definitely cannot beat the value. All the rolls are good and fresh. I usually split the sushi boat with my niece and it's awesome. The only one thing for improvement is sometimes the rolls are a little loose. If that's tightened up a bit, it would be all good. I definitely recommend this place. It's one of my fave restaurants around the west Essex area. read more

Myth debunked: you DO NOT have to go into all the way into the city to find delicious Sushi! Come to this cute cafe for an amazing meal at a fantastic price. I ordered a Shrimp Tempura roll & a Cucumber roll as part of the Two-Roll Lunch Special. My boyfriend ordered the Chicken Teriyaki Bento lunch special. The waitress asked if we wanted our Miso Soups, which were complimentary with our lunch orders. (I love that she asked first, because I don't like soup & I always feel embarrassed to waste it!) Check out my pictures, because this lunch was a feast for the tummy AND the eyes! My boyfriend's Bento was overflowing with delicious food. He really enjoyed the chicken teriyaki & the dumplings. My two rolls were so fresh -- the shrimp tempura was still warm, & the texture was delicious next to the soft, fluffy sticky rice. My only complaint is that the rolls (especially the Cucumber roll) could've been a little bit tighter, because some of the filling fell out as I picked them up. The sauce on top of the tempura roll was to die for, & there was enough on the plate to use for dipping! My two rolls were beautifully presented, even at 1:30pm on a Wednesday afternoon! All in all, we spent just a hair over $20 for a great lunch. Even the decor was traditional, with tables and a sushi bar ... and they even had 90s alternative music playing softly in the background! It's like they knew I was coming :) The main menu looks promising, so I'll have to come back for dinner sometime. Thumbs up for this little sushi powerhouse! read more

Sushi Cafe - Two-roll lunch special: Shrimp Tempura (left) and Cucumber (right). Delicious! - Sushi Bars Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

See all

Yelp asked me to consider the pandemic before I posted. My complaint has nothing to do with food but has everything to do with service. On 5/27/21 I come into the restaurant to order food. First time customer, long time sushi lover. As I'm about to order another customer comes in after me and a server/waiter/employee asks if my order can wait while they person after me is served his take out order first. I was in the restaurant first for at least 10 minutes. I don't think that's fair. I'm placing a complaint for mgmt to see. I never tasted the food. I'm appalled. I left the establishment. As I approached my vehicle the customer who was waited on ahead of came to me and apologized and stated "they must be smoking too much pot " and agreed that my order should've been taken ahead of his take out pick up. My hope is that the customer service is improved upon. Sadly I'll never return to verify. Good luck. read more

Paul is the best! Tell him your favorite fish and he will customize a roll for you. So good! My favorite sushi place! New favorite rolls include the Volcano Roll and the Fire Dragon roll read more