Our bus stopped on the way home at this amazing ice cream shop. I've driven by but this is the first time I've tried their ice cream. They carry homemade ice cream and some selections from Perry's. They also have soft serve. Everyone on the bus said this ice cream was great...from sundaes, milkshakes, soft serve with dips and hard ice cream it was unanimous. I had a great flavor I've never seen anywhere..... chocolate ice cream mixed with chocolate pieces and coconut pieces in a chocolate and nut dipped waffle cream cone. The place was packed but the service was great. read more

See all

This is the summer of exploring ice cream shops. Now that the weather's warming up I'm finding myself visiting a new shop once a week, starting with Super Cream Dairy Bar. Walking up to the order window you're greeted by a friendly cashier who's eager to take your order. You look around at their large menu before deciding on getting a scoop of their newest creation: Earl's Ice Cream. After reading the description and learning that it's named after a local farmer, your scoop is up within minutes and now you have the option to sit outdoors in the sun, under their covered patio, or indoors in the AC. If you're needing a bit more than just ice cream you can also order food off of their snacks menu which includes fries, tenders, and other finger foods! read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - Earl's Ice Cream (8/10); decadent, packed with whole peanuts, and the perfect item if you're a lover of peanuts and chocolate - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York

Super Cream Dairy Bar is a cute ice cream place that also serves some food in a cool throwback retro environment in Homer, NY. Ice cream and frozen treats are served via 2 outdoor walk up windows, while food is served in a modest indoor space off to the side, with plenty of patio seating outside, and plenty of them covered in case of rain. They have restrooms for customers in the rear of the building accessible by the indoor food area. Since the place is a dairy bar and we weren't hungry, we opted for ice cream treats rather than food. The Oreo milkshake (4.5/5) was thick and delicious, and tasted just the right amount of sweet without being excessive, although it seemed that most of the Oreo cookie pieces were distributed up near the top of the milkshake (but still great). The we saw plenty of people getting soft serve as well, so we tried the vanilla/chocolate twist soft serve (4.5/5). While I'm not the biggest fan of soft serve, it was decent quality ice cream and satisfied our sweet tooth. They use milk from local dairies, as many such places in the region do. Service (5/5) seemed to be from local high schoolers, but was quick, efficient, and friendly. They are clearly popular as there was a regular flow of local customers pouring in for treats on a nice summer evening, which is always a good sign. The world would be a better and happier place if more towns had a place like Super Cream Dairy Bar. I would return if passing through the area again, and would recommend them to others traveling north of Binghamton through the Cortland/Homer area. read more

See all

wonderful ambiance, delicious ice cream and great food. set up with a 50's overtone inside, with plenty of seating outside as well. clean, well maintained, with outgoing, friendly servers stop in for a burger or a cone, stay for the atmosphere read more

We stopped in because we're staying in the area for skiing and they're the only ice cream stand open in the winter, or so we were told. They came very highly recommended, so off we went. Not disappointed! Their hard ice cream is all homemade. They had some seasonal (valentines) flavors along with many others and also lots of sundaes. We didn't try any of the food, but they had diner type stuff. It was a cool, vintage, drive up ice cream stand with delicious stuff, yum! I had a regular banana split and shared it because it was still pretty big, again yum! The kids got medium ice cream and it was probably 4 scoops, they put it in 16 oz cups. Really generous portions. We were happy and headed back to the hotel full. read more

See all

Best ice cream around , the flavors are great and I love that they are open a lot cuz who doesn't love ice cream year round , I do And the help is great a family affair for sure Very friendly atmosphere check it you won't be disappointed read more

Ample parking and seating. Big portions. Great prices. Quality ice cream Friendly staff. read more

Super Cream Dairy has a Super large selection of fresh homemade ice creams, hard and soft. Put it in a dish or on a cone you can't go wrong. Optioned for a small which is pretty big that i split into two flavors since I couldn't decide between the Black Raspberry and the Salted Caramel Toffee. The pricing is more affordable that most ice cream locals. If I lived closer I'd probably be here every other day trying out all their flavors. This location even has a drive thru, usually don't see that for an ice cream parlor. Although I suppose if you are willing to wait at carry out walk up window, why not wait on a drive thru line. I highly recommend this location as the quality is there and are sure regardless of flavors you pick you won't be disappointed. Everyone near and far traveling into town should make this a must do pit stop to support good local business. read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York

Great ice cream, affordable and fun. We stop by here every year during our Skaneateles vacation. read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - Kids at Super Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York

They have a really good EggNog Milkshake for this winter so you should come soon. I have been here a lot and every time it was good accept for today when my mother and father got the Love You To Pieces and it was overchurned but mine was good. read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - Egg Nog Milkshake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York

I came in last evening and ordered a Mac n cheese panini because my son recommended it to me (because I love cheese ) and I was waited on by this wonderful young lady with the best smile. She agreed that it was a good suggestion. You all were so busy but she was such a sweetheart the entire time I was there. I tried to catch her name... Kelsey... Chelsea? (She had dark hair, tan, long lashes) I can't quite recall her name at the moment. But she was just such a sweetheart and she really made my day and the panini was delicious! I will definitely be back read more

Ice cream at this place is awesome! Their homemade flavors especially the orange pineapple to die for. Great place!

Everything about this place is perfect. Incredible ice cream. Highly recommend!! I had the peanut butter Oreo, it's amazing read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - Peanut butter Oreo ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York

Ice cream is pricey and is nothing special, though flurries are very good. Service is good and sheltered dining area is very nice, but food prices are outrageous and quality is meh. read more

If you want a place where you can get good ice cream AND lunch, look no further. While the vanilla in my sundae was so-so, try their maple walnut homemade ice cream for a superb treat. Dairy-free ice cream options are available, as is a vegetarian panini for lunch. There's also an ice cream flight! read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - Super Cream Dairy Bar - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York

See all

So delicious! The hard homemade ice creams are so flavorful. Chocolate peanut butter was full of large peanut butter chunks, just like you'd want. Quick service. They have a drive thru too! read more

See all

They have really good ice cream and food specials. Absolutely they have the best selection of hard ice creams. Just love this place .I always choose it to get ice cream on a hot summer day. Great family atmosphere and employees are very helpful. read more

Our family goes here all the time! Friendly service, welcoming environment with lots of seating and plenty of variety. Food and ice cream are excellent every time! read more

All the staff is very friendly and welcoming! The ice cream is the best around and great food! Check it out if you haven't

Great place. Friendly service. Ice cream and food are delicious. Plenty of room inside and out

Super indeed! This is the mansion of ice cream stands! They have SO many choices! It is so incredibly hard to decide. Their homemade ice cream, sorbets, sundaes. Everything is so good. I wish they would add sugar cones to their menu though! The soft serve is nice and creamy. I loved the orange dole whip swirled with vanilla. I haven't had a thing I didn't like! The doggie sundaes are so cute with extra peanut butter sauce in addition to the vanilla ice cream. My dog Odin was thrilled. Turn towards super cream and he starts whining for joy. I love that they have lots of spread out seating. The drive through is a fun touch too! read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - A fancy pup sundae. For the doggos that want more than just a vanilla soft serve. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York

Great ice cream. Wide variety of flavors. Friendly staff. I get eaten alive by mosquitoes while sitting on the patio every time I go there. Can't go back until they hang some bug zappers. read more

Homemade hard ice cream and plenty of flavors to choose from! Whenever I'm in the area I stop here. I've had the maple walnut and it's fantastic. Today I tried the sea salt toffee caramel in a waffle cone. I do like the maple walnut better but this was still very good. It's such a cute place if your in the area stop in. read more

See all

Unique flavors and fast service. I'm not totally blown away by the ice cream, but it's good. read more

See all

The homemade ice cream is very good. The maple walnut is among the best that I have ever had.

One of our favorite places. CLEAN. Good service and many tables inside and out to enjoy your treat. We haven't tried any food yet, we're always focused on the excellent ice cream. Hubby enjoys vanilla, which he raves about, and I like the mint chip and the coffee...all hard ice cream, made by them. SO GOOD...give them a try! read more

Ok food clean dinning area super friendly service great ice cream as usual keep up the good work read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - Dinning room - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York

This is a hometown love. It was the go-to ice cream stand growing up! They have all sorts of flavors and combinations. My best friend would drive all the way from Ithaca to "see me" but really she was coming up for Super Cream for their generous portions and killer ice cream. It used to just be seasonal but now they have a great year round location. My personal favorite from Super Cream is their flurries which have chocolate or vanilla soft ice cream with up to three candies/mix-ins. (I love mine with Skittles!) My boyfriend is a big fan of their blackberry shake. If you're rolling down Route 481 it's definitely worth a stop! read more

My husband and I always look forward to stopping for homemade ice cream when we drive through Homer. On our last stop, I ordered my usual butter pecan small cone. No sugar cones, so I had a cup. It was the worst butter pecan ice cream--no flavor and no pecans. I threw it away. read more

This place is the ABSOLUTE best soft-serve and ice cream on the planet!!!!!!!!!! My other half grew up in the area. Great quality and service and the list of flavors!!!!!!!!! Just check out the pic i posted. Cones...Sundaes...Shakes...Yogurt....soft-Serve...Home made Ice cream. DA BesT!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

See all

Ice cream had zero flavor. Texture was like whipped cream. Way to much air being put into the soft serve. Very disappointed since change in ownership. read more

Upsides: Plenty of outdoor seating - lots in the shade, too. Prices were super inexpensive for giant-sized servings. Downsides: flavors of soft serve and hard serve just weren't that tasty. Cold & creamy, but nothing special. Sprinkles were strange and melted too quickly, turning my vanilla soft serve grey. Every cone was served in a plastic sleeve! That's a huge unnecessary waste of plastic. Bottom line: I'll probably not return to this spot. read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - This is a JUNIOR size banana split! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York

See all

The best milkshake ever and the drive thru service was amazing overall a great experience.

Waiting 30 mins in the drive thru. Definitely got to big for their own good. We honked after 15 mins. We also said hello to one of the ladies walking by who just looked at us. Through our 30 minutes sitting there we must have seen 5 to 10 different employees who just looked at us and continued on what they were doing. Very upset and worst part was our puppy knew where we were and she was so upset not getting any ice cream. Never again will we go there again. read more

Ice cream is good just like the other places around. 2 stars because ownership will not honor your gift cards. Frequent customers for prior owners but once new owners wouldn't take a gift card sold at the end of prior year we had to go down the road. read more

me & my bf had grilled cheeses and they tasted like school lunch. Just two mf pieces of cheese on bread. Not bussi.

Outstanding selection of hard and soft ice cream. All kinds of dips including peanut butter. Their sprinkles are crunchy and full of flavor. None of the other ice cream stores in the area have more than five reviews. Super cream has more than 20 and I am giving them five stars for a wonderful ice cream experience read more

Been coming here since I was a kid. It gets better every year! We live up in Tully now and make the 15 minute ride down rather than eat at the stupidly expensive Scoops ice cream in Tully. read more

A summer tradition! We have been getting Ice Cream here for years and now with the remodel and expansion we love having a quick meal here too. The pesto grilled cheese is one of the best I have had. It is hard to describe but trust me it is worth a try. read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - Menu Left Side - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York

See all

Delicious ice cream. I went over the weekend and got mud pie hard ice cream in a chocolate dipped waffle cone. The girl at the counter told me the ice cream was suppose to be coffee flavor with cookie chicks inside. It tasted like chocolate ice cream, it was good but I hoped for coffee flavor. She was very nice, she added some whipped cream on mine. My husband got the Carmel turtle. The flavor was amazing. It had chocolate and Carmel in the ice cream. We ordered small ice creams but the portion was huge. The price is very reasonable. For two "small" ice creams and one waffle cone it came to less than $6. We were visiting for the weekend and looked up ice cream places in the area. I'm so glad we chose this place. If I'm ever in the area again I will make sure to make a stop here. read more

Super Cream Dairy Bar - Mud pie ice cream with chocolate dipped waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Homer, New York