Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sunshine Sam's Toy Store

    5.0 (4 reviews)
    ModerateToy Stores

    Sunshine Sam's Toy Store Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Sunshine Sam's Toy Store

    Recommended Reviews - Sunshine Sam's Toy Store

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Coll S.
    0
    54
    29

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Suzy M.
    375
    58
    75

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Sunshine Sam's Toy Store

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Toy Stores 10,096 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Just Kidding Around - The outside

    Just Kidding Around

    4.4(30 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    $$$

    This place is very lovely with a lot of nice things for kids. Only issue with this place, is that…read moreit's way too pricey. You can find a lot of the same things in othwrblocari9ne for way less then what they have it for. It's a good place to look around, but budget wise, it's not.

    Brick and mortar toy stores are increasingly struggling to keep their doors open, so it's a relief…read moreto find a really good toy store in an easily accessible area. They have a really great message and seem to be conscious of being inclusive. They have books from different cultures (I found a really good one about Ganesh, an important Hindu God), a Black Lives Matter sign in the window, and the customer service is top notch. I arrived a few minutes before opening and was willing to wait, but the woman working inside saw me and immediately unlocked the door. She was very friendly not just with me but with the kids in the store. It's such a warm, bright and friendly environment. You can find so many things here including toys, books, large items like ice cream making stands and rocking horses, costumes, legos, puzzles, art and other creation making kits, stuffed animals. It's nicely set up, bright and welcoming. The prices are also reasonable. They provide wrapping and choice of ribbon color as well. They continually change what they have in stock and stay relevant with the seasons and holidays. So if you're looking for a gift for your child or someone else's, I highly recommend supporting this business.

    Photos
    Just Kidding Around - Part of the inside of the store. It's nice and big

    Part of the inside of the store. It's nice and big

    Just Kidding Around
    Just Kidding Around - Jkatoys.com

    See all

    Jkatoys.com

    Fortress of Solitude - Comic page ( HANDLED ) let's make it TWO !

    Fortress of Solitude

    4.2(28 reviews)
    6.8 mi
    $

    This is definitely one of the coolest comic bookstores I have ever been in. A HUGE selection of…read morecomics and action figures. It was clean, friendly, and very well organized. The atmosphere was very welcoming and friendly, which is always something I, as a woman, am always concerned about it these sort of places.

    Their customer service is not there, rushed to be off the phone, barely had knowledge on the…read moreinformation asked about, didn't want to accommodate the customer or try to resolve or give the right information to the customer to be able to make better informed decisions, instead it was more like, "you can figure it out, catch him when you see him" instead of trying to get my information to contact me in the future , didn't give me time, dates or person to speak to regarding the comics, trades and buys. Literally said "this is too much, we don't buy or trade, goodbye" just because she didn't have the information about the "worker" that handles the buys and trades so she rather just be rude and rush me off the phone! Customer service is key to company's like this that rely on the customers support to keep their business and the comic book industry going, there's no place for disrespectful staff that don't want to even TRY to come to a solution or help out a fellow comic customer. I DO NO RECOMMEND GOING TO THIS SHOP FOR BUYS/TRADES/SELLS. Instead Midtown comics, new world manga, time warp comics; ALL in Jersey only 20 min for this location.

    Photos
    Fortress of Solitude - The MechaGodzilla vinyl I purchased.

    The MechaGodzilla vinyl I purchased.

    Fortress of Solitude - The comic books I picked up!

    The comic books I picked up!

    Fortress of Solitude

    See all

    Paradox Comics

    Paradox Comics

    4.8(32 reviews)
    5.2 mi
    $$

    Paradox Comics is a small shop that gets a lot done. It shares a storefront with a restaurant and…read moremetered parking is available on the street. Interior is not large, but they use the available space well. Paradox has a wall of new pull books and many shortboxes of back issues. Above these shortboxes are a fair selection of toys and collectables. Behind the counter are Pop Vinyl's, variant comic covers, and wall books. They also sell some sports cards and collectable card games. Employee was helpful and knowledgeable. This is a good small shop that has just about everything you would want out of a local comic shop.

    Kaboom! Pow! Bang!…read more Thank you Paradox comics for always being there when we need you! Holy Miracles Batman! The awesome Paradox staff has helped us find #1 back issues that have been decades old and still in mint condition. Shazam! The marvelous staff has stocked the shelves with the newest figures, nostalgic figures and also some jaw dropping collectible figures. Hulk Smash! Monstrous prices during their yearly anniversary sale! Great Hera! Paradox welcomes all, children, boys and girls, adults, collectors, nerds, fans and newbies. Up, up and away! Paradox staff steps up in cosplay during the free comic book day (1st Saturday of May) and entertains the kids and fans standing on line. We have brought our nephews and nieces and they loved taking pictures with the staff in costume. Merciful Minerva! Something for everyone from, DC, Marvel, Star Wars, Star Trek to Aliens and Anime! Titans Go! If you are lookin for comics, figures, gifts or browsing. You will not be disappointed. #thankyouthursday2021

    Photos
    Paradox Comics - Paradox Comics!

    Paradox Comics!

    Paradox Comics - Paradox comics!

    Paradox comics!

    Paradox Comics - Paradox

    See all

    Paradox

    Toy Division - Maileg collection

    Toy Division

    4.4(7 reviews)
    8.5 mi

    We've spent well over $1000 at this place over the last few years. They don't have anything I…read morecouldn't get online, but we love to support local businesses. It's cute in there and the quality of product is great. Today, I was there with my potty-training 3 year old and 6 year old, shopping for a couple of birthday presents. The 3 year old needed to potty. The employees told us that they didn't have a bathroom. I said, "I come here all the time. I know you have a bathroom. I've used it." They unapologetically stated that the owner told them no bathroom use for customers. I was confused. They were matter-of-fact and insistent that this is the policy of the owner. I said, "This is a shop for little kids. You don't let kids use the bathroom?" They insisted no- that it was the policy of the owner. If this is true (I can't image they were lying to me), I just can't support the place. My three year old peed her pants while we were still in there. I spent the last $130 I will ever spend at Toy Division. Now I'll make the drive to Montclair to shop local for kids toys.

    Short version: I haven't visited the store yet myself, but their customer service is incredible…read more Long version: I recently received a beautiful gift from Toy Division, and when I fully unboxed up the item later I saw that it was unfortunately damaged to the point that I couldn't have used it. (To be clear - it was not Toy Division's fault at all, definitely an issue with the item manufacturer, and it would not have been visible until you removed the item from its packaging.) I didn't want to bother the gift giver with it so I figured I would check with Toy Division just in case they could help, but honestly I'd already mentally chalked it up to an unfixable bummer and was prepared to move on. To my surprise I got an email response within a few hours, and after a brief and very helpful email exchange with Indira, I had a brand-new replacement item coming my way directly from the manufacturer! I'm so, so happy that I'll be able to use this lovely present, and I'm equally thrilled with the friendliness, speed, and effectiveness of the Toy Division team. Thank you so much Indira for turning a bummer of a situation into a delightful one!

    Photos
    Toy Division
    Toy Division
    Toy Division

    See all

    Sunshine Sam's Toy Store - toys - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...