Hard to give it an honest review of food, service or ambience since we found it to be closed for lunch on a day that the website said you'd be open. It was a nice drive from Appleton and we were able to find a nice lunch at the wheelhouse. Maybe another time. read more

Came here for a Friday lunch with the girls before a cabin weekend and I cannot WAIT to come back! Customer service and quality of food is unmatched!! Cannot recommend this place enough! read more

Sulten Belly - Tuscan Panini (left) , Snood Dude (right), bowl mac n cheese, chipotle turkey sandwich - American Near Me - Waupaca, Wisconsin

Waupaca,WI. I have been walking by Sulten Belly for at least a year, not aware of the good things going on in there. There is some special food to be had in this part of Wisconsin, I am a huge fan of the Green Fountain Inn and the Secret Garden just a few blocks away, and now Sulten Belly. We were greeted as we entered and given some clarity of the process so there was no confusion. I liked that we found a seat and took our time with the menu before I went to the ordering station, ordered, paid, and received a number for the table. I'm not exactly pleased with the modern method of tipping before you even see the food, but I paid cash so I could add more to the tip jar if deserved. Oh yeah, if you pay by card they tack on 4%. Bring your cash, they discourage cards. Where I live (Laguna Beach, CA) , some restaurants are the other way. They are not accepting cash and only take alternate card or digital payments. I ordered Mr. Beefy, a delicious smoked beef tenderloin panini sandwich with melted provolone cheese that really hit the spot. The beef tasted like it had been braised in wine, just wonderful for $16.50. Also excellent was the Sulten Belly Favorite Salad that was with assorted fresh greens and bacon, $13.50. The staff here were all friendly and helpful. It was a nice cozy vibe without the bright lights. I will be back. They also have premade frozen dishes available that look pretty good. read more

See all

How does one define "best"? Would I need to try every single eatery in a geographic area to base my assumptions on? While I can't confidently say this is the best joint in Wisconsin, it certainly has to be up there insofar as central Wisconsin establishments. The lasagna, being so meaty, hearty and flavorful you'd swear it came from an authentic Italian hole-in-the-wall. The pulled pork (drenched in their bbq sauce) just shines as bright as any respectful bbq place. The barbecue pastrami sandwich (go figure), was pretty insane, too. No, I haven't been to every supper club or obscure restaurant in Central Wisconsin. But having frequented "up north Wisconsin" (family owns a lake house up there) since I was 5 years old, not once could I remember a place that I felt had better food. Whenever I make the trek up from Illinois, I always stop in, as well as grab one of their frozen lasagnas or bbq chili bowls to go. That's saying something. read more

Sulten Belly - BBQ pastrami with chips and beer cheese dip - American Near Me - Waupaca, Wisconsin

Stopped at SB back in May for lunch. My 3rd or 4th time visiting and it is delightful every time. I love that they have a rotating menu in addition to their menu staples. As a vegetarian, I'm always grateful to see options that are anything but boring or lacking. The pear salad definitely delivers tons of flavor and filling ingredients, and the Mac & cheese is so comforting. It was my partners first time and he really enjoyed his sandwich too. It might be on the higher end for casual lunch pricing in Waupaca, but it is worth every penny! read more

Sulten Belly - a plate of salad and a bowl of dressing - American Near Me - Waupaca, Wisconsin

See all

Great service and Mac n cheese was fire. Recommend a few more hot sauce options but will be back 100%!

So charming! We were greeted by friendly staff (possibly owner?). LOVE the menu. Ordered walleye sandwich and a grilled cheese w arugula and tomato. Served with lovely roasted mini carrots. Both sandwiches were outstanding, excellent bread. Serving size is large. To top it off restaurant also serves wine by glass. Would definitely return. read more

See all

Food was absolutely amazing we will be back for sure again anyone who hasn't gone here needs too truly outstanding food read more

Sulten Belly - Loco Cubano - American Near Me - Waupaca, Wisconsin

The food here is so fresh and tasty! We ate here for the first time in August, while on vacation with our family. It's a cozy place with the cooking area visible, which was pretty cool. Everyone was really friendly. I love that you can tip the cooks (in beer). My husband had the WISCO - it was AMAZING!! I had the mac n cheese with a side of marinated mushrooms - equally amazing!! My son had the mac n cheese with pork belly - ditto. We will be back regularly, it's a fantastic place!! read more

Phenomenal scratch kitchen. High quality locally sourced ingredients. Obvious talent in the kitchen. And amazing service. This place checks all the boxes. If you're looking for lunch in Waupaca, you aren't going to find better. read more

Great food! Totally awesome! Mac and cheese, heavenly! You have to try it. Great staff, nice and friendly! You won't be disappointed! read more

Great good and great service. A must visit if you are in the Waupaca area! Check for times !!

My husband I stopped around 11:00 on a Saturday. My husband had the Wisco sandwich and I had the Cajun Gobbler, both sandwiches were served with chips and I chose to add the bacon cheese dip, which I highly recommend; we give both our meals a 5. Service was fantastic, we were greeting and served with a smile 5. The restaurant is decorated super nice and the cleanliness is impeccable 5!!! Thank you to all the staff! read more

I had the Sultan Belly Favorite and my wife had the Cajun Gobbler. Both were very good. Will definitely come back to try other menu items.

You had me at Arugula!!!!! Finally a place that I can get fresh food from that is not an hour drive away. Had the Cajun turkey salad and I should have bought another to take home. So fresh I'm shocked to find food this good in Waupaca. read more

Nice ambience. Great music. Superb service. Oh, and the FOOD! The macaroni and cheese alone is worth coming back for. read more

Sulten Belly - a sandwich, macaroni and cheese salad and macaroni salad - American Near Me - Waupaca, Wisconsin

Cute cafe. Can't go wrong with crispy pork belly belt or crispy chicken ranch sandwich.

Great food! We had the WISCO BELT and it was the best breakfast we ever had!! Provolone, pork belly and fried egg with roasted garlic mayo. Wow!! The service was fantastic but I must say that the prices were a bit exorbitant as two iced coffees one sandwich (that we split) and one large cookie for a total of $25?? The ambiance and rustic interiors of the place as well as the gourmet breakfast sandwich made up for the high prices; but I am not sure if I'd return. But you can tell that the staff take pride in creating beautifully well put together food. If you're looking for budget breakfast or lunch go over to Gretchens down the street but if you're looking for gourmet food items then give this place a try!! read more

Lovely style of the place but was a bit loud. They do have outside seating that is lovely so we opted for that. You can seat yourself, and when you're ready, order at the counter. You must pay yourself with an iPad system. So you pay before you get your food. They did provide a glass water bottle for us to share so that is lovely. The server was good and the other guy who checked on us was pleasant as well. The food was wonderfull and got more than expected. Plenty to satisfy and take to work for lunch. read more

I was driving between Chicago and the Upper Peninsula and needed to stop for food. I checked YELP and Sulten Belly looked pretty interesting. (On trips I try and avoid chains and love the small business entrepreneur restaurant owner) What a nice surprise. I had the Cajun Gobbler but could have tried 3-4 other menu items. Plus the sandwich came with chips and a house made chip dip that was amazing. I would love this place in the Chicago suburbs. I would visit weekly. The server was so nice too. Great experience. read more

First time trying this place and it was incredible. We're from Chicago and said this food would easily stand up to/ surpass the city standards. We ordered a little bit of everything: pear salad, BELT sandwich, the walleye sandwich, and a side of the Mac and cheese with pork belly. The service was outstanding too. Wonderful, kind people. We sat on the patio with our little pup - It was a lovely afternoon out there! Not kidding though, the food is insane. Must try!!! read more

Loved the Walter sandwich. A huge piece of fresh walleye on a beautiful ciabatta role. Awesome sandwich! Others enjoyed the panini and other soups. read more

I stopped for lunch and they exceed my expectations. Great laid back clean fresh atmosphere and decor. I ordered the Me So Beefy sandwich. It was a shredded beef sandwich with an Asian twist. It was excellent. Bun was perfectly toasted and warm. Key part of a great sandwich. The beef was hot and the slaw was crispy. There was at least 6 or 7 other items on the menu I would love to try. Great friendly service. read more

Went here for lunch today with a colleague. Awesome new lunch spot in the neighborhood. Delicious gourmet sandwich options, unreal Mac and cheese, cool decor and friendly people running the place. How am I the first to review?! read more

We stopped here for lunch as we traveled from Milwaukee to Rhinelander. What a treat! Enjoyed the high quality food and friendly service so much we made a point of stopping on our way back a week later. "The Walter" is to die for - fried Canadian walleye perfectly done. Everything we had was exceptional. Imagine traditional American food, prepared with the care and thoughtfulness of gourmet cuisine. Every component of each entree seems to receive special attention. Delicious. We hope they do well. read more