Great store with lots of options. Clothing gifts toys…read morejewelry etc. not your everyday items.

I stop in here multiple times a year to let my kids pick out a toy or book because they have such a…read morenice selection. This year, as my 5 year old was picking out a book, my one year old was in a baby backpack on my back and reached over and knocked a glass off of the shelf which ended up smashing on the ground. When I told the lady and offered to pay she scoffed multiple times and asked why I would bring a baby into her store. Everyone around us had their jaws dropped including the other cashiers. Gross behavior and you have permanently lost a repeat customer. I'm not sure why you'd have a toy section in a store where you don't want children. I'm almost relieved after reading other reviews on here that I'm not the only one who was stunned by her behavior.

I highly recommend Port cargo in Falmouth for a five star shopping experience Abigail the owner and…read moresales specialist at this store is professional extremely kind and helpful. The clothes throughout the store are thoughtfully handpicked, and it would be hard for anyone to leave the store empty-handed the next time anybody is in Falmouth shopping Main Street don't pass on this store. Bonus, she was extremely kind to my little dog and gave her a delicious treat.!

Visited over a year ago, loving and using everything purchased here…read more I enjoy the boutique feel, as I don't do well in massive department stores, appreciate personalized service. Still using their cute bag for the beach, a subtle reminder that this place is unique and worth visiting when on the cape. Looking forward to going back this fall!!

I completely disagree with Aretha B's post above. Yes, the shop is expensive, and yes, there are a…read morelot of tourists there. But, it's on Martha's Vineyard - everything is expensive, and it's full of tourists. So you should expect to find that at Menemsha Blues just like you would anywhere else. It is similar to Black Dog, but not as big, and not as ubiquitous. I also disagree with characterizing it as a "chain." It's a local store that has several physical locations in the area. As far as their products: the quality of everything they sell is excellent. We bought several clothing items from them, and they were worth every penny. My husband seriously considers a trip back just to buy more of the polo and button-up shirts there because he loves them so much (and you can't get most of the items on their website, which is the only slight issue I have). He routinely gets stopped while wearing their items, because people like the small fish logo and it's so unusual, and they want to know where he got it. By all means, go to Menemsha Blues, and the original store in Menemsha is quite charming. If you dislike paying for quality items or buying from a store that has several locations in the area it was founded, I guess you can skip it, but you're doing yourself a disservice.

I like this shop. I still have a polo bought 100 years ago from them. They carry great quality…read moreclothes that I like. I have seen different prices. Some high some lower. In any case, quality aint free. Love The logo and the name. All the best , Ps in San Diego with great blue sweater

Had a wonderful shopping experience the other day with Ranu. Best customer service and such an…read moreamazing collection of clothing. will definitely be shopping there again.

Buyers Beware! Their return policy will not make you a happy customer. I attempted to return a…read moredress the next day and was told I would get a store credit. They do have small signs in their store that state 'returns will gladly be accepted within 7 days - for a store credit only'! that's a lousy catch! Oh and the credit is only good at the Mashpee location. When I burn through this credit I will never shop here again. My advice to shoppers - really think about any purchase or just pass it buy. Making the customer happy is not this store's focus!

I would give zero stars if possible…read more Shop girl wanted to refuse me entry due to le petite chien. I planned to buy several items too. She gave me attitude about where his service dog vest was...uh, hello, this is the laid back Vineyard, is it not? Not really a place you need to display a service dog vest and most people are friendly to pooches anyway. I slapped his service dog card on the counter and decided to NOT spend my wad of cash at such an unfriendly unwelcoming establishment.

I always make time to shop here when I'm on Martha's Vineyard. The sales people are kind and…read morehelpful--you can expect an honest opinion or suggestions if you ask for them. They usually only carry a few sizes for each item, similar to most boutiques. Additionally, they've made the point to start carrying more plus size options, which was awesome to see. Some of my favorite clothing pieces are from this shop, so check them out!

if i could give them 0 stars i would. i just had a very uncomfortable experience here. i asked if i…read morecan try on a shirt and she said "no" laughed paused and then said "that won't fit u! that's a child shirt!" i'm actually a pretty petit woman who can fit in child's clothes. it was very awkward and uncomfortable and i'm never coming back here. we ended up having to leave and not buy what we wanted to because we were so uncomfortable.

Great place to get your Onset or Tesno outer wear! Hooded sweatshirts, tie died tanks, tied died t…read moreshirts, and sweat pants can be found here. Open year round so don't forget to Christmas shop during the colder months!

I couldn't leave Martha's Vineyard without stopping by this store! The building itself is super…read morecute, and I loved the little post that had all of the VV locations up at the front! The store is small, but bright and cheery, offering a small selection of men's and women's wear of button-up shirts, t-shirts, shorts, pants, and accessories, as well as children's wear and women's wear. I was surprised to not see as many items at this location, because I'm sure they do get a lot of tourist traffic during the main season! It was also a little difficult in finding SAs for specific items and to look for sizes. +limited styles/fits +unavailable SAs

The dude waiting on us was extremely rude! I decided to add a shirt at the last minute and this…read moresnotty dude harrumphed and complained how difficult his job was with the cashier machine. Then after bagging the the last minute shirt he refused to put the original purchase in the bag and just tossed it toward my wife. We left, and I seriously considered going back to complain but figured this review would suffice. I haven't reviewed anything in over a year - if that tells ya how much he annoyed me. Ask for a kind service member.

I always enjoy stopping by Boneyard Surf Shop during my summers on the Vineyard. Simple, laid-back…read morestyle but still fashionable -- exactly my type. Went in today and the woman working the register was super kind. She even recommended I hold onto my receipt since they do exchanges (no returns) within about 10 days. Fair enough -- that's pretty standard for the smaller island shops. Unless you're at the bigger brands like Lululemon, Faherty, or Vineyard Vines, expect exchange-only. Great service either way. Highly recommend if you're in Edgartown.

My favorite store in Edgartown. Cute and comfy clothes that sells other great brands as well. Also…read moremore affordable.