Great diner experience - good food, fair prices, great service! So few restaurants in the area…read moreseem to make it long term...sure hope this place makes it, so I try to stop in whenever I can. Keep up the good work!!

Hungry and on a budget??? Head over to Sylvan Shores Diner, breakfast is my favorite with many…read moregrandmothers famous dishes. Eggs anyway you want, delicious pancakes, endless cups of coffee by an efficient wait staff, bacon, and sausage. My go to is the meat lovers skillet with a side of biscuits and gravy!! Can't wait to get back there to dive into one of those great meals. Bright blue building just south of the Sylvan lake in Rome City IN.

We had a pepperoni and sausage pizza delivered on a Friday evening. Pizza arrived hot in the time…read moreframe they quoted. We like the pizza from Pepperoni's better than anyone else's in the area. Delivery to our home is an added bonus!

Food was amazing! Arrived right at open and phones were already ringing off the hook. I knew I made…read morethe right decision when the woman behind the counter went above and beyond to make us feel welcomed. I drive past this place often and finally decided to pop in when the snow was getting bad. I ordered the chicken spinach deluxe pizza and it was so cheesy and delicious, the seasonings on top were a really great touch. My partner got the slammer sandwich, toasted to absolute perfection! He said it was fresh and savory with a nice touch of spice from the pepperoncini. This place was off the hook! Will 10/10 be returning.

The food and sandwiches are great. The banana nut muffins…read moreare fantastic. Fresh and ready to eat with a fresh cup of coffee. Thursday soup of the day is chicken and dumplings are out of this world. You have to try it.

Arrived around 1:15pm on A Tuesday. Place was around 75% full. Didn't realize they closed at 2pm…read more We chose a seat. A waitress came over and wiped our table down because it was a little dirty. She then took our drink order. When she came back with our drinks we were ready to order. I ordered the Taco Salad special with no beans or guacamole, and a side of Beef Vegetable soup. My friend ordered the BLT. We got to look around while we waited. There's a lot of antiques on the wall. Along with art and photographs. Nice atmosphere. Our order arrived around 15 minutes later. The soup was excellent! Taco salad was on par for taco salad. My friend said his BLT was good, and boy did he scarf it down! The prices were reasonable and the staff was friendly. I commented I really liked the soup when paying and was told they've been making it for over 40 years. Well, don't change it!

This review is for the food only. My wife really liked her chicken tenders and tots. The tots…read morewere crisp and crunchy with a meaty middle. The chicken tenders were tender and moist. The outside had a nice crunch and seasoning - very tasty! The side of Mac & cheese was very creamy. You get lots of delicious cheese sauce. You might find yourself mopping up the bottom of the cup lol. The sauce is a bit bland despite all the cheese ooze. I added black pepper frequently and put the Mac & cheese over the top. The wings were really good. There was ten large wings in the order. They were fried with a nice crisp but not crunchy. The chicken was cooked perfectly. The wings was bathed in a bourbon BBQ sauce. I think it was just poured on versus being baked on. The sauce had a very mild BBQ taste with just a bit of spicy heat. The sauce did have a hint of bourbon style flavors but not have predominant. There was plenty of sauce in the bottom of the dish to add additional flavor to the large wing.

This place really is a gem. Great atmosphere- great food and super service. Our band, "Above the…read moreFold", plays here and it's one of the most enjoyable places to hang out. Keep up the great job ! Justin and his crew really know how to do it right at this place.

Decent fish sandwich but $1 just to add a little fillet cup of tartar sauce !? Not to mention $2 to…read moreuse your debit card. Wow. This place is having problems if they are nickel and dime'ing the customer.

The service was great. Friendly staff! We enjoyed the new enclosed area for ordering and waiting…read more The fish is outstanding! The grilled chicken sandwich was perfect!

This evening (4/10/26) we went without a reservation, but they were nice enough to seat us at 5:15…read morein anticipation of their 6:30 reserves. Service was marverlous and the food excellent! We were warm in the outside room and well taken care of. Mr. Phenomenal

Walked in expecting a small Town pub feel and got exactly…read morethat!!! I loved the feel and vibe and the food was yummmmyyyyyyy.... Our server was amazing and super friendly!! Definitely a spot for us to come back and visit!

This place is just fun. It's a bar and restaurant on the water; what else do I need to say?…read more We took the pontoon boat and tied up. We ate on the deck and tossed some scraps to the carp that wait for generous diners. Surprisingly, the food was really good! I had the mushroom burger which tasted like it came from a high end burger joint. I also had the fried shrimp with tater tots. No complaints here. We ordered a few beers and were impressed with the selections. The servers were nice and friendly and seemed very happy to be working there. This place exceeded expectations and we will be back.

Great Restaurant and great food on witmer lake. Amazing service!…read moreWe always sit on the deck and feed the ducks and turtles.

Food = fantastic. I thought the pizza was really good…read more Service = okay. Our server came over a few times to check on us, but wasn't entirely friendly. Ambiance = diner vibes. I could see it getting loud in there for sure. Thankfully we went at a time during middle of day/week to where there wasn't hardly anyone in there.

Came in for the first time on a Saturday around one. The dinning room was empty. We walked down a…read morehallway and there we found employees. We didn't know if we were to order at the counter or a table. Employee said table. We sat down and noticed that the table top looked unclean and greasy, like it had been wiped with a dirty cloth. We changed tables. Not much better. The server was nice, but not too informative. She said they were out of Pasta, Meatballs, and no olives. We are not from here so we assumed they had a busy Friday night. The server went on to say that it was not busy at all on Friday night and that Saturday was turning out just as slow. We were not told of the lunch specials. They were not on the menu. So we ordered the Pizza Forum Special pizza. The Pizza came fairly quickly, and was fabulous! The crust was perfect, and the toppings were fairly generous. The only thing was I don't think there was ham on the Pizza as stated in the menu. Out of that too? But it was still a very good pizza!!! We will give them another try when we go back to Kendallville. Hopefully they'll have all the menu items.

Be aware of a young chunky girl with brown hair she tried to lie to me and tell me that she could…read morenot cancel the sale on the gas pump with my credit card I told her I would call the police if she did not do it and I will never be back here again. I always came here there was such friendly people now there's not! This happened February 18, 2025 at 10:45 PM.

Very good gas station. You can't really expect high hopes for a gas station unless your at Love's,…read morebut it was clean, in stock. And the workers looked clean and nice. The bathrooms were pretty clean. So it was a pretty good gas station.

Arrived around 3:30pm. Decided to go inside and order so I could look over the menu. It wasn't…read morebusy. One table full. My friend and I were immediately greeted and asked what we would like to order. We both ordered the same thing. Popcorn shrimp and six hushpuppies. The wait wasn't long. No more than 5 minutes and we were out the door heading home. We arrived home and dug in! All of it was good! Nothing leftover. The place looked pretty clean and the price was $6.40 out the door for 6 hushpuppies and popcorn shrimp. That's a deal!

The hush puppies where spot on but the fish was unacceptable and I normally don't get trash pieces…read moreand if I got one or two in a pack of eight I would have just dealt but this was 8 of 8 pieces where tiny overcooked no meat was unreal, like it shows a lack of caring because whoever made this knew it wasn't acceptable