From what I can tell, the only reason this place would have a sub-4-star rating is because locals…read moreare trying to keep it a secret. I found zero issue with any part of the experience and would call the meal no less than quaint and enjoyable. Theresa was a fabulous server, and very accommodating, even with the limited vegetarian options available. The food was great, though nothing extraordinary. It was simply good food--nothing more, nothing less--and that's really all anyone needs. Will definitely be recommending this place to any of my colleagues who happen to pass through the area on work trips.

My mom and I were shopping and stopped for a bite to eat…read more You have to try the potato skins, I have never had skins with that perfect crispness. I am going to dream about those potato skins. Also, for protein lovers ; I strongly recommend the Irish Boss sandwich; corn beef and sauerkraut on top of a juicy burger patty! Yum! flavorful! We sat at the bar and Phil was our waiter. Even though it started to get busy, he was super pleasant. I don't like chain restaurants, but the quality was quite enjoyable. They had the March madness games on the TV's. It was relaxing inside.

Staff unfriendly, Dining floor is nasty, sticky and filthy dirty, tables were all dirty.read more

I got to the drive through at 1:45pm and there was one car in front of me already ordering. I…read moredidn't receive my food until 2:05. The poor lady taking orders seemed to be the only one actually working. I saw a girl on her smoke break outside and another guy walking around the kitchen but only the one lady actually working. She was sweet and I felt bad for her. I got two sliders because they were out of everything else I wanted. The roast beef slider wasn't that warm and the bun was as hard as a rock. Glad the Buffalo chicken was a little more enjoyable but also had a pretty hard bun. That's all I got so pretty frustrating to wait that long. Seemed like everywhere is struggling to find quality workers!

came from a long drive and got to the hotel at 8:30 pm and ran in just as they were closing and…read morethey were kind enough to still let us order and take the pizza to go! Best pizza I've ever had and they have gluten free. very good service and I would recommend the place to anyone.

My favorite pizza place ever! This is a family-owned & family-ran facility. EVERY SINGLE employee…read moreis extremely kind and will go out of their way to ensure you have a great experience. I love the chicken ranch pizza, as well as their chicken wings. This restaurant is very clean and the owners/employees really take pride in what they do.

Absolutely love this place. I come here to work when I have half days, and every time the food is…read moregreat and the service is amazing. The vibes are chill and friendly. Great for family.

As I was headed into this Irvington strip center location, I had my eyes set on stopping into…read moreSahm's Tavern for dinner. However, as I parked I spied Sleepy Hollow Gourmet Deli & Cafe along with a Jack's Donuts. I was curious. So, I wheeled over and realized they were like conjoined culinary twins. I detoured my plans and decided to hang out at Sleepy Hollow, a delightfully named establishment (though I do wish they'd lean into the decor a bit more) for this Irvington-set restaurant. Jack's does seem to be the dominant force here. There are donuts, bagels, cookies, and even kolaches. The prices are surprisingly affordable. Drinks include hot coffee, iced coffee, lattes, boba energy, and Pepsi products. They do have both sweet and unsweetened iced tea. The menu also includes Choc-ola! The deli menu includes toasted subs (every sub has 1/4-pound of meat and you can go double for an extra price). They use Boar's Head meats. You can get chips and a soft drink to make it a combo. This strip center is always a little hit-and-miss in terms of access, however, with some nearby road construction it seems just a bit slower and I was able to find a spot that improved my accessibility. If you go to the door by the entrance, the curb has a bit of a step to it. If you go to the end of the aisle, there's a smooth and level section to make it all easily work. The interior itself is nicely laid out and easily accessible. The employees were super friendly. They also offer catering. There's a combination of higher-top tables and regular tables. Business was fairly steady, however, I had no issue finding a place to sit. I ended up ordering a chicken salad sandwich that was a healthy size and quite tasty. I grabbed a bag of chips and my usual unsweetened iced tea. Pricing was right about $13. Overall, I was quite pleased and I would easily return. Whether you're seeking donuts or a deli sandwich, Sleepy Hollow (or Jack's) is an ideal place to stop in.

I came in good spirits. I tried to engage the man and woman in the store and was greeted with short…read morehellos and stares. Ummmm...ok. I ordered my sandwich and got it without incident.....Until....... The cup of soup I ordered they didn't have enough of, so the guy said he needed to get more. I said I would wait with no problem. Seconds later he bought me out soup that I swear he added water to! It was broccoli and cheddar water! There was zero flavor and crackers didn't thicken it up! The sandwich was good. The manager did correct the issue, but overall, not a great first impression.

I have ordered delivery from the Downtown location before but this was my first time visiting any…read morelocation in person. It's very cool on the inside with vintage and Indiana-themed decor, tin ceilings, and, of course, a potbelly stove. The staff were friendly. But brother and I were very confused about the ordering process. There wasn't a lot of directional signage showing where to start and each step of the process. I watched a few other customers go through and they didn't seem like they had a problem so maybe it was just us. Next time I would probably just order online and pick it up so I could avoid the in-person ordering process altogether. I had the turkey sandwich and it was pretty good. I would say definitely a step up from your typical sub sandwich chain in terms of flavor and toppings options. I tried the chili mac as well. The chili is definitely à la Wendy's but I enjoyed it. The mac and cheese was good as well. I'd probably get either on its own but not together again. I also tried the Potbelly/Zapp's collab chips, the Hot Pepper flavor. They were good but are definitely not for everyone. When I visited, most of their fountain soda options were out of order so I settled on a no sugar added Pineapple Passionfruit juice/soda which was actually pretty good. We'll definitely be back - especially to try out their milkshakes!

Some of the best sammiches in the city!! Love both locations, they're accommodating & the food is…read morefresh

Great sandwiches Philly Cheesesteaks for 9 on our crew today! They all loved them! Made fresh and…read moretastes great.

We were dining nearby and smelled those delicious cheeseburgers cooking. We both grew up in…read moreColumbus and remembered those sandwiches from childhood. Ordered two burgers to go just for a taste test. It was about a twenty minute wait but they were as good as I remembered. Yum.

Food was good, but very greasy. Service was quick and cost was affordable! Will go back!read more

Fantastic. Great and fast service even when busy. It's nice to have sandwich choices in town and…read morethis is a good one.

So glad they opened in Colombus. The service and food were great. Friendly and quick service. What…read moreI expected and more.