This is listed as Amish, but it isn't as authentic as the one in Eckerty. However, it is a great diner. They have a buffet, although you are allowed to order off of a menu. The buffet is the obvious choice, though. The buffet itself is extraordinary. On Friday, you can usually have frog legs, and that is a treat. There is also a vry good shrimp and rice dish usaully there, and fried fish, along with other entrees. I've usually seen about four different vegetable sides, but the green beans have meat in them, so if you want meaty veggies, you're in luck. There is usually corn and some greens. There are plenty of sides to choose from. The salad bar is very good. A lot of options. Caesar dressing isn't one of the four or five available ones in the containers, but they do have Caesar and other dressings in packets. The desserts are not that great, although they do have some very good soft serve ice cream. The blueberry pie is that mush in a packet. Here is where you can tell it isn't really authentic Amish, but it is still a very good restaurant. The service is good and friendly. They dress Amish, but it is more Americanized than real Amish places. I do recommend it. It's pretty expensive, but worth the price. You are treated to a good view of the lake, if they let you have a window table, but those are often taken. The other tables sit out in the open, and I never feel comfortable that way, but if that doesn't bother you, you'll be fine. There are expensive store items to buy, too. I never tried them. things like soap, candles, the usual restaurant store items. It's almost always very crowded. Often, there is a long line. The food is very good, and it is a popular place. Restrooms are dirty and sometimes out of order, which is why I don't give this five stars. I hope that they address this some day. read more

We were in Logootee yesterday and decided to try Stoll's. If you didn't know it's an Amish buffet. They do have breakfast but we were there for lunch. Service was friendly and polite. The views of the West Boggs Lake were nice. Water was very green but beautiful. Food was delicious Fried Chicken, Roast Beef, Tenderloin, Mashed potatoes and gravy, corn, green beans, stuffing, noodles, carrots, homemade bread/rolls and if you're into it they had chicken livers/ gizzards. The salad bar had a solid fresh selection of items. The desserts were tasty as well. Ice Cream and Pies. We got Pecan and Peanut Butter pies and they were fantastic. So good we forgot to take pictures. A nice place to stop by if you're passing through or visiting the Boggs camp ground. Could have been a 5 with more options but that is really the only drawback. Go visit for yourself!! read more

Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant - Buffet Plate - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Loogootee, Indiana

See all

Best Fried Chicken & chicken n dumplings/ topped with a variety of pies included with buffet! Nice view of Boggs Lake while dining! read more

This Amish Buffet restaurant is a favorite of mine. The food is good and plentiful, it is self-serve but the used dishes are removed promptly. Dessert is included in the pricing at $17.95 p/p. The dining room is simple, with a nice view of the water reservoir. read more

Coming from a kid who lives in Indy. I hit this spot anytime I'm down south. Best home cooked food you'll have with an unbeatable view of the lake. Can't say enough good things about this place. read more

We went for lunch and enjoyed the experience. The food was great and the view from our table was cool! read more

See all

I really enjoyed the home cooked foods on the buffet great flavor, the employees kept everything filled nicely! The view was beautiful right out the window was the lake seen a few fisherman today! read more

Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant - Dining area - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Loogootee, Indiana

See all

I've only taken a piece of pie out and didn't dine in. Pros: friendly, homey, inexpensive, easy parking, big dining hall. Cons: pie filling was watery, there were flies in the dining hall, restroom isn't clean and somewhat smells read more

Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Loogootee, Indiana

Fresh salad bar with vegetables, meats, baked bread and rolls, and dessert included. Waterfront restaurant in a beautiful and scenic countryside setting. Excellent service with a smile. Never had to ask for a refill of our tea. read more

Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Loogootee, Indiana

See all

Food is good but when crowded you will plan on waiting a little while Good food. ... ,,,,,!'..,.,...

I have been to this Amish Buffet a couple of times and I enjoy the scenery and the people. It can be slightly crowded at times but it's more of a tight knitted town with middle aged to older men and women which gives a more peaceful, calm vibe. The service is always amazing with the constant small talk yet remaining small not bothersome along with constant refills. The food isn't bad! The fried chicken and livers, mashed potatoes, Brussel sprouts and the desserts were all very tasty with a large variety. I drove an hour and 20 minutes which should tell you something about my recommendation. Again, look at that VIEW. There is also a golf course next door so you can play a round after eating. read more

See all

Go out of your way for this place seriously it's a nice place for a date with the misses or a good place to have a good bite and get away for an hour or two read more

While we have dined here in the past, we tried to dine at the breakfast buffet this morning. We arrived at 9:00 AM. The signs posted on the door say hours are 8:00 AM- 8:00 PM. I also checked the website and it says open 8:00 AM. THIS IS NOT THE CASE!!! We arrived with our party and there were no cars parked in the lot except closer in back/side of the building. VERY DISAPPOINTED WITH COMMUNICATION OF HOURS!! Will NOT be back!!!! read more

Stoll's lakeview is one of the buffet in southern Indiana. Their pies are the best just make sure you leave room for it.

This buffet was worth the 100+ miles to get there. The Amish people are so friendly and cook delicious food! We were there on Saturday which turns out to be the best day to go.... the roast beef was melt-in- your-mouth phenomenally delicious! But then so was the fried chicken, noodles, green beans, salad bar including beets(yum). I enjoyed the best bread ever, too, with delicious apple butter Had to go back for more of that! It's hard to save room for dessert but you must try everything! The cherry pie had popping fresh cherries. The chocolate cream pie was delicious. The cookies were some of the best I've ever had. The scenery at the restaurant is so pretty. There are picnic tables and shelters. But there are no docks for the boats so you'd be best off driving there. It's definitely worth the trip. The service was unbeatable... they were all so helpful and great. read more

Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant - View from Stolls - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Loogootee, Indiana

We were getting bored with the eating establishments we have been frequenting and were looking for a new place to eat. Believe me, Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant is not what we were looking for. The restaurant is billed as an Amish restaurant, which is usually very good, but almost everything we tried was barely edible. The chicken livers and gizzards (which was precisely what we drove forty miles to have), were so dry and hard we could hardly choke them down. Everything else we tried wasn't much better. For a buffet they have a pitifully small selection. The only redeeming quality was the beautiful view of the lake. If you just want to sit and relax you might enjoy your visit, but if you're hungry don't waste your time or gas. read more

We've lived in Indiana for 2 years & just found out about Stoll's. We had company, from out of town, and we took them out to lunch. The buffet was excellent. Everything from salads to fried chicken, mashed potatoes & cream gravy, were outstanding! And, the rolls!!! Oh my! We took a dozen home with us, they were so great. We will definitely come back!! The view of the water is very pretty and we're from Seattle, where we had water views almost every where, so, seeing a body of water was a bonus for us! read more

Very good home cooked meal. Lots of options to choose from. Baked breads, main entrees and vegetables all very good. Desserts were one of the best parts of the meal. read more

This is a long standing Resturant on Boggs Lake. It has a large parking lot and a nice little walking path down along the water where you can enjoy the beautiful landscaping and views of the water. This place is known for their Amish style cooking. They offer breakfast, lunch and dinner buffet. I was here for breakfast and enjoyed it. They have the usual scrambled eggs, biscuits, hash browns, sausage gravy, bacon, sausage links, pancakes with warm maple syrup, French toast made with homemade bread as well as a few other items. Overall a great place to come and get a good breakfast if you are in the area. read more

Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant - tables and chairs - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Loogootee, Indiana

See all

I give it 4 stars for food. Tastes great! The noodles are my favorite. However it doesn't look like they are social distancing the tables and the majority of people do not wear masks when they go wait in the 10 person deep line to get food. That's unacceptable. read more

Food is good. But do you really think the Buffett is a good idea in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic? I thought buffets were suspended read more

Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant - people sitting at tables - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Loogootee, Indiana

Nice view of lake while you eat! Food is decent and restaurant is clean and has pies and other things for sale.

Been a while since we've been there. I took my wife for a meal. Food quality has went downhill, mediocre even. Service was also mediocre. Waitress waited until we were ready to leave before asking about drink refills. She was more interested in talking with the other Amish girls. Instead of a refill, I asked for some good coffee. Brought me a watered down very unpalatable cup, and then charged me $2.50 for it. There really is no reason for us to go back again. Forgot to mention we were seated by the restrooms - not the most pleasant seat in the house. read more

Good food lots of it. The rib meat is falling off the bone. Very rich tasting food well made! Like the view of the lake. Servers are very friendly. read more

The staff are all excellent and the food is so good , we go to French Lick a few times a year and this is one restaurant that's worth the drive ! There fried chicken is so yummy along with everything they make ! If you leave this place hungry it's your own fault ! (Real) Ice cream and pies for deserts ! Don't forget a golf course is right next door , Lakeview Golf course . Girls can hit shops while guys golf and meet for Dinner ! read more

An absolute beautiful place to eat. Scenery on the lake is magnificent, the food is OUTSTANDING, (had breakfast and lunch). I didn't bring a camera or phone, since it's rude toward the Amish. There were no disappointments with the food. Everything made fresh and not over seasoned. I even ordered peanut butter cookies and oatmeal raisin to pick up for next day. They were warm when I got them. This place is my happy place! read more

Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant - the view from the driver's seat - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Loogootee, Indiana

I live local so it's convenient for me and my family to go there and eat and yes Martha the owner is very nice and the food is very good. I am a breakfast fan so I love the breakfast on Saturday mornings. My wife loves the dinner so my son gets the best of both worlds And recommend it's very good. Nice view. Nice environment good food good people. read more

Amish buffet with good country cooking. Enjoyed fried chicken, meatloaf, Amish noodles, macaroni and cheese, and an assortment of delicious prepared salads on the salad bar. The bread is wonderful, and an array of pies and desserts are available. In a beautiful setting, and worth a visit. read more

See all

Comfort food at its best! The buffet is small but lacks all the favorites. Don't skip the fresh bread and apple butter, it is truly the best thing in the buffet! The desserts are just what you'd expect at an Amish tan restaurant. They even have an ice cream machine for Sundaes. The restaurant is set beautifully on a lake, and we enjoyed seeing fishermen right outside the window in their boats. Oh, and the price is more than fair! read more

Excellent service. Delicious food. Comfortable ambiance with a view of the lake. One of our favorite places to eat. Always leave satisfied.

Decent buffet that currently is being played up by the staff until the pandemic is allows us to serve ourselves. Pies are okay. Salad bar has a nice assortment of toppings. Gizzards were over cooked. Meatloaf on the sweet side. Fried chicken when fresh out was delicious, the veggies over buttered but tasty and not over cooked. We did however arrive as the first wave of eaters came thru to eat. Views are extra nice. read more

Always good food and nice atmosphere. The staff is friendly and its nice to see familiar faces.

Hidden gem. Food is fresh and delicious. Atmosphere is comfortable. Reasonably priced buffet which includes desert. Staff are kind and attentive. We will definitely be back. The view of the lake is relaxing and we got to enjoy the wildlife. read more

Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant - Loved the turtles - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Loogootee, Indiana

A couple of my friends and I decided to head south for some shopping. One of my friends had been to Stoll's and suggested for lunch during our trip. All three of us left full and very satisfied with our meal. The view was gorgeous as we pulled into the parking lot with the restaurant sitting along the 620 acre West Boggs Lake. The friendly hostess seated us along the windows so we could appreciate the relaxing lake view during lunch. All of the staff were extremely attentive, professional and provided excellent service. Stoll's is an authentic Amish buffet serving stick-to-your-ribs entrees since 1983. The buffet is split with made-from-scratch salads on the right side and entrees on the left. The breads and desserts are in a separate area. I usually pass on Fried Chicken but since this is one of the entrees their famous for I had to try. I wasn't disappointed as the crust was crispy but still tender as if steamed after frying. The lettuce salad was fresh and crisp with a nice selection of other salads. The side dishes I had were good, but not exceptional, fresh and seasoned well. The green beans were tender but not overcooked and the bread dressing was rather bland for my taste. I didn't have an opportunity to sample the ham, pork loin, noodles or the two home-made soups. My friends loved the fried chicken, noodles, buttery mashed potatoes and gravy with sliced bread. My friend even ordered a loaf of sliced white bread to go. Several desserts are also available to go as well and can be seen in the bakery case at the checkout counter. I'm not sure why but none of us opted for the home-made desserts. So unlike me!! but I knew we still had shops to go. Our server mentioned coconut cream pie, apple crumb, pecan, cobblers and bread pudding. I did hear folks rave about the cobbler and the little ones were loving the ice cream cones. All-in-all, the service was terrific, prices were affordable for the buffet, the food was tasty and plentiful with a gorgeous lake view. I'd be happy to return if in the area and especially to try the desserts on my next visit. read more

See all

Traveling over memorial weekend and found Stolls on yelp. Great reviews, lake front, Amish restaurant in Amish land, and really not many options in loogootee. I'm not in general a fan of buffets but I was starving!!! We walked in and the views of the lake are stunning from every seat. The restaurant itself is rather worn out, old chairs, carpet, people :/ The usual buffet items, small salad bar, fried chicken which was quite good, chicken noodles, green beans, corn ect...The desserts were the star for sure, all homemade and fresh but in an odd little room separate from main buffet, weird. All in all fresh food for a buffet and did I mention the views?! Would come back for cocktails on the lake but alas Amish country, no booze on this buffet. read more

Stoll's Lakeview Restaurant - Nice view - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Loogootee, Indiana

It was 50 dollars for my mom and I to eat there everything was basically out of a can the mashed potato's were runny ( like cauliflower with water ), carrots cold, corn and green beans both canned, limited deserts, and way over priced for food that was not worth the money. It labels itself as authentic Amish I do not believe that to be true. If you go, go for the view not the food read more

We were visiting friends in the area and chose this option for our lunch. Generally, I'm not a huge fan of buffets, as I've found the food to be mediocre, but Stoll's was quite good indeed!! The fried chicken was amazing, and as a bonus they had livers and gizzards on the buffet. The meatloaf was decent...probably a 3 out of 5 stars on the meatloaf. The salad bar, while small, had all the necessary items. The pies (included with the buffet) were absolutely stellar!! The chicken was absolutely 5 star fried chicken, as was the service. Everything else I'd call a 3 or 4, so we'll go with an overall 4 star review. BTW, as has already been mentioned, the views are wonderful! read more

Went out for my Mamaw's birthday back in February with a small group& the food was great, and seating was placed well

The food is just okay. Dinner is $16 so 20 with drink and tax. This was the most bland buffet I've ever had. Unforgivable is an "Amish" buffet with store bought margarine, kroger ranch dressing and non-dairy whip topping on the pie. The ham came in chunks with very little salt or sweetness, just boring. The beef was very plain round steak. The chicken tenders were average. The mash potatoes and gravy, green beans and stuffing have no flavor. I tried both the chocolate and peanut butter pie but again very weak flavor just sweet. Service was average and the place is clean but for $20 a person I have had much better. read more

Great buffet with good home-cooked food! The chicken leg I ate had as much meat as a breast. I couldn't believe it.