We had a great time! Wait was minimal, maybe 5 minutes. Even though there's always a line, the lady…read morebehind the counter took the time to answer my questions before placing our order. Our son loves their Italian ice so much - he gets it each time. The kids sundae was the perfect size and can be made with both soft and hard ice creams. They have a large tree in the back that often the children flock to and play different games - it's nice to have somewhere to run around at there. It makes you feel like you're not on route 9. If it's raining, they have a tented area with glistening string lights, which can make for a romantic night out with the kids too. This was a great experience and have always had helpful employees!

Delicious ice cream, the choc-a-lot and cookies and creme were both great. Good portion sizes and…read morethe waffle cone tasted fresh. There's tables around to the side, but it's on sand so if you drop your ice cream like two people did while we were there, you get a nice layer of sand on it. They also have pup cups with a small treat in it. Took off a star because while the woman who took our order was friendly, the one who shouted around the side when our order was ready was not. She was highly annoyed about everything. You get a 4% discount if you pay cash.

We came here for ice cream. For the ice cream alone, this would be 3 stars. But with the food (we…read moredidn't order any, but it looked really good), the outdoor area, and the mini-golf course, the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. The ice cream was okay. It's limited to about a dozen flavors between hard and soft. The hard ice cream flavors (we got hard ice cream this time) were more traditional, the soft ice cream flavors were more creative and interesting. Prices were about the same for similar sizes, though, but $4 and change for a small dish seemed slightly above average compared to the same amount elsewhere. Then again, there's nothing else that close to this place with whom to be competitive. Spoons aren't available here unless you order ice cream. The spoons are plastic, looking more like they're designed for iced tea or milkshakes, with long, slender, flimsy handles, and only teaspoon-sized for scooping. That's fine for a shake or soft ice cream, but they were a bit too flimsy for digging into hard ice cream. The flavors could have been a little stronger too, though the stuff in the special flavors (e.g., the Moose Tracks), made up for it. This is a fine place to go if you're looking for a meal with ice cream, or mini-golf plus food or drink. Then again, there's nothing else like it for many miles in any direction.

I love a mom and pop ice cream shop with great service and gigantic servings. We both ordered small…read moretwist with extra rainbow sprinkles and our server committed to the bit. Not only did she cover the ice cream, she gave me an extra cup of sprinkles! We also played mini golf and the course is very well manicured and a great level of challenge. I appreciated that it had real obstacles (versus just flat pictures of them). I would definitely come back here if I was in the area again!

Best little slice of nostalgia. Old style walkup window…read more Great soft serve ice cream. Kids all over the place loving life. Super crowded. Bring cash!

Pros: - the most soft serve flavors in the area…read more- willing to stack flavors - great sundaes - cute seating area - staff is nice - open until 9 pm most evenings Cons: - no hard serve ice cream - items not as described, in particular, the "slush float" (a traditional root beer float is ice cream on the bottom and soda poured on top) is 90% slushie and 10% ice cream put on the top - ice cream began melting prior to receiving it (temp 65° outside) - slow service - parking lot is not safe as the lines are not maintained by line guides Tips: - cash only business We chose Humpty Dumpty due to good experiences previously. We had some challenges on our visit to include slow service and line formation was confusing and awkward as we were in one line going into the drive traffic. We originally ordered a medium soft serve cone and a slush float which was made backwards from the traditional float where the ice cream is placed on the bottom and is usually the equivalent of two scoops of ice cream and then the liquid, so in this instance slush. We received 90% slush and a dollop of ice cream on the top. It was really a major disappointment. Especially, because the slush is $2.50 and a slush "float" is $4.75. That was NOT at $2.75 worth of ice cream. Unfortunately, it was so bad i had to wait in line a second time because my son refused to consume it. When I got to the window, I explained that a float traditionally has the ice cream on the bottom, but this was met with lack of empathy and me paying for another item. The slush "float" was thrown out and the clerk knew it was getting thrown out, but we happily paid full price for our disappointment. I've never heard of a float having the ice cream on the top and wanted to make sure to add this to the review to avoid you having disappointment as well. I'm not doing well at the terms and lingo for this business. I ordered a medium ice cream in a dish to go. I've never seen an ice cream be overflowing like a cone in a dish. Had the medium ice cream melted, it would be everywhere and definitely did not fit the dish size. There is a small seating area to the side, but please be careful, the parking lot is not well lit and people will come in at 15 mph and not yield to pedestrians. I don't think we'll be back this season. Maybe next year we can try again. This years staff isn't vibing with our expectations.

Quick service good quality Very creamy soft serve…read moreOn street parking. Have been back 2x a good food good service reasonable price

I went to the village scoop a couple weeks back for the first time in a year! I got a Twix flurry…read moreand it was sooooo good

This is the only place I've come across that does chocolate flavor bursts!! I wish more places had…read morethese. The chocolate raspberry was good but the person who made it needs a bit more practice. Nice service. Lots of seating.

I was there yesterday , my treat after my Doc. apt on Sunday …read more I was probably a little disoriented from the test. I'm not sure if i said Vanilla soft on a cone. The young girl kept asking me while i was trying to talk , WHAT KIND. I finally said sorry i didn't realize i didn't say what flavor. She was rude and when i went to my car with my cone she stared at me still taking about about me. I could read lips. Rude, i've been coming to JJ's since the 80's my Dad took us. I left the parking lot before i finished my cone because she was still looking at me. Find better help please. I work in customer service as account manager for over 30 years , she needs training. On how to be kind. 5stars for the owner 1 star for service that day.

Awesome trading post store. Has something for everyone. Awesome fishing selection downstairs…read more Nice staff. Good sandwiches. Fair pricing. Only issue is deli closed a lot of the time

We loved it! We stopped for ice cream on a Saturday evening - there wasn't a long line and we…read morewere served quickly (it probably took us longer to decide what to order!). One of us ordered a sundae that wasn't on the menu - no problem! They made it up just like that, and it tasted great.

The absolute highlight of my trip to Lake George. The staff were so lovely and will let you sample…read moremultiple flavors, and the serving sizes for both the scooped and soft serve ice cream are very generous on top of them already being very well priced. It's really the best store with the best options, best prices, and friendliest service out of any of the stores I stopped by in Lake George Village. Really a gem. Also, the coconut ice cream is a 100/10!!!

Such a huge variety of flavors - everyone loved their choices. And the workers are great - perfect…read morecustomer service, with big smiles! And good value for the money, too - the single scoops were well-filled, not skimpy.

Martha's is one of our must stop places in the Northeast. This was probably my 6th time at…read moreMartha's. They always have many flavor options. The price is great and the sizes are mammoth. Service is typically excellent and friendly. They have some tables and chairs outside which has a canopy so you're covered, rain or shine. I used their restroom for the first time and that is even well-maintained. Wish we lived closer but it's probably good for my health that we don't

We needed a little lunch before we had a little ice cream. We ordered the poutine but had to…read morereturn it to the window upon noticing that we had cold , large chunks of cheese curds on top of our gravy and fries. The girl at the counter remade them for us ( with a touch of attitude) but we definitely should have just ordered something else. We always have visited Martha's any time we're at the lake...but starting to rethink the next visit LOL. The prices have definitely gone up! We paid $22 for one medium twist cone with dip and a small twist cone with dip.

Great place with great menu/ choices. Staff was very friendly and efficient. Adding a few more…read morethought because Yelp makes you.

Good ice cream, lots of different options and the prices are reasonable. They don't skimp on the…read morewhipped cream either! The girl who waited on us was very pleasant.

Consistently great service and massive sandwiches, homemade roast beef and hero rolls!read more

The best of the best Italian meals to go and subs. Served with a smile and maybe a little kidding…read morearound. Every time I'm in Cobbleskill, I stop by to pick up something to bring home for me and my son. It's also a seasonal flower shop! I also bought Lasagne with sausage to go and meatballs. The sauce with the meals is to die for. As you can see in a sub, there is plenty of meat