On July 23, 2026, I took my 2025 Hyundai Santa Fe Hybrid to Stephens Automotive for an oil change at 20,283 miles. Less than 48 hours later, 250 miles into a family trip to Wisconsin Dells with my three children, the engine failed from oil starvation.
The Hyundai dealership in Madison, WI provided a written diagnosis: an O-ring failed to seat properly during the oil change Stephens performed, causing oil to leak from the engine. On top of that, diagnostic records show Stephens' service triggered two engine codes at 20,286 miles (3 miles post-service) that were cleared before the car was given back to me. No one mentioned it.
My family was stranded for days. Over $7,000 in damages: towing, hotel stays, Uber, and non-refundable flight tickets I had to buy to get my children home for a custody schedule.
The shop initially acknowledged the situation and confirmed they carry garage liability insurance. Then the tone changed. Eric Stephens refused to share insurance information, told me "There is no claim here," and texted me to stop contacting him and take it up legally. A certified demand letter went unanswered.
I have filed complaints with the Iowa Attorney General, the BBB, and Polk County Small Claims Court.
Stephens performed the service. The dealership confirmed their work caused the failure. They refuse all responsibility. I would not bring my vehicle here. read more