Cancel

Open app

Search

Steph and Andy's Pizza Plus

3.8 (4 reviews)
ModeratePizza

Steph and Andy's Pizza Plus Photos

You might also consider

More like Steph and Andy's Pizza Plus

Recommended Reviews - Steph and Andy's Pizza Plus

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Pizza King - Menu - Page 5 of 6

Pizza King

4.2(18 reviews)
32.5 mi
•$$

Visiting family in the area, I saw a delivery car for Pizza King. Having to drive three hours back…read morehome, I decided to stop in and see what they offered. After looking over the menu, I decided to stay basic and order a medium pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese on hand-tossed dough. (They also offer a thin crust for those who prefer that.) The wait was about 10-15 minutes maybe - not long. This isn't a dine-in place. They only have a small bench inside for waiting and room to stand as well. You can watch them hand-toss the dough for your pizza as you wait, as well as watch them assemble all the toppings too. The phone orders were pouring in while I waited for my pizza pie masterpiece. They were taking orders as fast as they could crank them out. I mentioned them being busy, and the reply was that they actually weren't as busy as normal. Wow! I'd hate to see it any more busy. These guys were working together like a well-oiled machine to produce some tasty-looking orders. My order comes out, and it's piping hot. I make my way to the vehicle where I proceeded to take pictures as my normal. Then, the taste test... It was simply heavenly! The cheese has a nice salty edge, as it should. The pepperoni is a good quality too. The sauce has a nice mild flavor, definitely not spicy as some. The dough had a nice airy texture, yet that crunch you long for every time you order a pizza. They hit it out of the park on every aspect! Way to go Pizza King!! I made it home with leftovers where it was enjoyed there too. The flavor took my husband back to a family-favorite pizza chain from his childhood. Needless to say, when back in the area to visit family, this will now be a must-stop food dive especially since we want to try other menu items. Pizza will always be on the list though! Try it for yourself! All the locals ordering it for delivery can't be wrong!! Simply delicious, Pizza King! Until next time... :-)

The biggest trash, garbage place I've ever ordered from. I called them before my order and asked if…read morethe could double cook my wings because I don't like nasty boogers wings. They said yes..wings showed up wet and fatty and boogers. I also order a cheese steak sub. It was nothing more than a tiny bit of steak-ums from Walmart and a very little bit of cheese.....disgusting. I will NEVER order from this shithole again!!!!

Photos
Pizza King - Menu - Page 6 of 6

Menu - Page 6 of 6

Pizza King
Pizza King - Menu - Page 2 of 6

See all

Menu - Page 2 of 6

Pies & Pints Pizzeria

Pies & Pints Pizzeria

4.5(638 reviews)
77.5 mi
•$$

Best garlic bread ever very good pizza very good service there is good a playground and pool table…read more are there people are very nice and the place is very nice 10/10 recommend

Never thought I would have good pizza during a trip AWAY from NY but here we are…read more Firstly, I was very grateful to be in a place with restaurants after spending a night in Sutton. This seemed like a fun place to have dinner and it is very hard to fuck up a big beer selection and pizza. Not far at all from where we were staying across the gorge in Lansing and it was nice to have another excuse to go back into the most adorable town, Fayetteville. We were seated immediately at 5 on a Friday (we are old now). There is both a very comfortable indoor area and a perfect-for-this-weather outdoor patio. Service was good, prices were very reasonable. The pizza menu is out of this world. I can't say I have ever seen such creative and unusual pizza ideas. We wanted to try a classic and their elotes pizza. I saw another Mexican-themed version with black beans (for the plumbing) but it was a compromise with GF to get the elotes (her choice) WITH black beans (for the plumbing). We also ordered something healthy (and for the plumbing): their house salad: spring mix (which I typically despise), grape tomatoes, huge croutons chunks, grated cheese, pepperoncini. Two dressing choices: I can't ever pass on a nice vinaigrette. I was not aware that grated cheese, frank grated cheese, in a salad could be so good. The dressing was fantastic. The greens were crisp. The croutons were very good but not plentiful enough, and again the cheese. The pizzas were incredible. The classic really couldn't have been better. The crust was PERFECT thickness and balance of chewy and crispy. Sauce had a flavorful tang. Cheese was, again, cheese. The elotes pizza was also sensational. Who knew that could be such a good flavor combo? So fucking good. The toppings (corn, black beans, jalapeños, think I saw a scallion or two) fell all over the place and made holding the pizza difficult (probably my fault due to addition of black beans...for the plumbing) but it was totally worth it. We did have to flag the server down but service was pretty good otherwise. Everything came out within a very reasonable amont of time. We finished the leftovers literally by the time we went to bed that night.

Photos
Pies & Pints Pizzeria
Pies & Pints Pizzeria - Classic Pie

Classic Pie

Pies & Pints Pizzeria - Char - grilled Hot Wings

See all

Char - grilled Hot Wings

Steph and Andy's Pizza Plus - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...