I sampled the chocolate as well as the salted caramel flavors and I will say that this ice cream is pretty good. I'm usually picky and I don't like ice cream that tastes processed. I like a homemade taste to it and even though this is like likely not homemade ice cream... It still has a decent taste to it. I would definitely be back if they added malt as an option. read more

Came by on the whim after seeing a movie at Eagle Luxe and we were not disappointed! The service was quick and friendly! The staff was patient with us as we tried out a few flavors. To tell you the truth, I can't remember what flavors we got but one of them was chocolate-y and the other was a creamy strawberry. Both were fantastic flavors! That's what I remember the most. I especially liked the strawberry flavor. All in all, a delicious ice cream spot in Eagle! read more

Stella's Ice Cream - Desserts Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

A good old fashion ice cream parlor without the old fashion. I love the artisan ice cream concoctions and the fact that they use natural, locally sourced ingredients. Being able to take a pint home is really nice and the push pops for the kids is genius. I had the Police Academy which consisted of coffee flavored ice cream mixed with donuts and I ended up with more donut than ice cream and they were pretty stale tasting. Others in our party were much more satisfied with their choices and overall, this is a great place to grab some delicious ice cream. I especially liked that they offer cake cones and cookies for a base as the similar establishments where I live in Washington only offer waffle cones. They'll even turn your pick into a shake or an ice cream sandwich if you like. Stella's will be in our rotation of places to visit when we are in the Boise area and if you're in Boise and looking for a sweet treat, give them a try! Cheers. read more

Another great location and absolutely love their ice cream....this was the 1st time at this location. Inside was very clean and staff was very nice. I was so full from dinner but the family wanted to get ice cream. The nice thing about ice cream is it just fills in the cracks. They have mugs if great choices but I always go back my go to. The mint chip is so good and really hit the spot. read more

Stella's Ice Cream - Cookies and cream and salted caramel cup so delicious - Desserts Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

Vegan ice cream. Really. It is good? Hell yes it is good. I've been vegan for about six years. I've tried a lot of store bought vegan ice cream. The best until Stella's was the Ben and Jerry's with the sunflower butter. So creamy and delicious But Stella's blows the door off of Ben and Jerry's That Chocolate Oreo is pure nirvana. So damn good. Since I am vegan and I don't consume a lot of sugar and sweets, one scoop was enough to last me a month even though I probably wouldn't mind an IV drip if it was made available. Seriously. I know they're known for their other ice creams but that Chocolate Oreo was freaking amazing. Stella's has a location in Boise and one in Eagle. Check them out. By the way, my wife's milkshake was really good and she's a tough cookie to please. read more

See all

Randomly walked by and decided to try this place out. The staff were really nice and let my family and I sample all the flavors we wanted. The ice cream was really creamy and not overly sweet. All the flavors we got were all great read more

Stella's Ice Cream - Cake batter, mint chip, cookies n cream, salted caramel - Desserts Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

Stella's Ice Cream is a fantastic spot for some great local Ice Cream, and definitely one of the best creameries in the area. I've visited this location a couple of times and they've never disappointed. Order Pictured: 1 Salted Caramel Brownie Sundae I'm partial to their brownie sundaes (pictured below), and while their brownies were a bit tough the ice cream helps to soften it up a bit and overall provides a cream experience. I'm usually not a huge fan of caramel ice creams as they tend to be a bit too powerful, but Stella's salted caramel ice cream does great at providing a balanced experience where the base cream can still shine. In addition, I've had their horchata ice cream in the past and it was one of the best desserts I've ever had, offering a really rich experience that is unparalleled by any other location in the area. If you want good ice cream, Stella's is definitely the place to go! read more

Stella's Ice Cream - Salted Caramel Brownie Sundae - Desserts Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

What?!?! How did I not know they have gluten free waffle cones?!?! Oh yeah! I had red velvet gf cone w/praline & mint ice cream too... help was wonderful & my guest raved & raved about the super fresh strawberry ice cream... (& she's an ice cream-aholic so her raving is big deal!) in addition to multi gluten free waffle cone options... vegan options r avail too, so allergy friendly read more

See all

Service is always great here, friendly younger staff. Ice creams is smooth and delicious. I live bringing the kids here. They also have push pops and some banked goods you can add ice cream to. There is the normal seating for an ice cream shop here. Pro tip, It can get busy after dinner time so be aware. It's just part of attending a well attended place for dessert. read more

Discovered this little gem and loved the level of service I received from the girl who helped us. She said she was celiac and gave all sorts of reassurances and even verified ingredients in the waffle cones that I was so excited to try! She went above and beyond! Today was our second visit there and thankfully the same girl was there and she started helping us. I was disappointed when this blond girl in a black shirt swooped in trying to dominate the helping situation. It made me uncomfortable for the girl who was helping us already. I don't think that was right. Thankful for the employee with celiac who helped us and we will keep coming back ! The waffle cone is yummy! read more

Oh yummy! We love Stella's . Great place for the whole family. And a fun date night too.

I really don't like writing bad reviews, being in the service industry myself and all. However after the experience the other night I was compelled to do so after my 7 year old daughter was crying because she couldn't have 2 flavors in a single size. There should be a kids size the mini is pathetic, samples are bigger and the single is more than enough ice cream for a child however you only get one flavor. So if a child wants two different flavors they have to get a double which is way too much ice cream for me even, let alone a child. Figure out another size or be able to have two flavors for a single like any other ice cream shop. The main complaint was the lack of consideration the staff had for the situation it's not that hard to put two different flavors in a single size. We were offered the idea to get two minis however it would end up costing more than a single and for much less ice cream, this was exactly what we were told by the girls working. read more

The staff was very friendly, but I ordered a mini cup, which turned out to be about 2 Tb. for over $3. Only filled half of the very small cup. read more

Great ice cream! My daughter has a tree nut allergy and they're always accommodating - they get a new scoop and a new tub of ice cream after double checking it's nut free. read more

Customer good will can be lost and so it has been here for us after the "let's give them another chance" visit this week. This "retry" after a visit to pick up a pint - or two - a handful of months ago when we decided that although we had tried to support this local place since they opened we wouldn't go back. Here's why we felt that way then: ice cream flavors seemed indistinct one from the other, kids behind counter were friendly but always seemed too new to answer questions and also understaffed so even working as hard as they could had trouble with service (these are all management issues, btw, employees were trying). Adding in at that time a few months ago when the Central District Health pandemic mitigation rules, and Eagle is part of that District, required mask wearing inside stores the owners here didn't follow them. Whereas other businesses in this strip mall did, these owners thought customers should make their own decisions. That posture was, btw, consistent with the city of Eagle's mayor and counselors who issued public political statement calling CDH rules over reach. Yet Stella's location in Boise followed the rules because Boise's Mayor and government leadership made it clear they excepted businesses to follow them. We felt public health safety rules should be followed by all parties whether the local government "pooh-poohed" them or not and so...well 'tilt'...for us. We all vote our values with our feet and wallets as consumers. So when my husband received a Square "how did we do" inquiry from the business from our months ago visit and he answered he was disappointed to find CDH mask rules ignored he received a reply from the owner that outlined their position that people should make their own choices. So our choice was not to do business with those who didn't pitch in to follow Health District rules at the time. But new Easter flavors beckoned this week and when the deal was sweetened (no pun intended...well...maybe) with 15% off coupon by email in we went again. This time it really will be our last time. Here's why: whereas tables from opening day through the last few months were fewer to provide 'breathing room' inside, now tables have been added to have the sense of too many in the small space and the sense of 'sparkling spic and span' is gone too. The refrigeration unit where the tubs of ice cream are kept may have had temperature raised to make it easier for the staff (still too few in number as only one person was again hard at work on this sunny afternoon with several customers waiting) because our cone was near soft serve texture and the pint was bordering on soupy...for which the very nice staff person apologized as the carton was sealed with liquid running down sides. And high prices do not match the not as high quality product; after the 15% discount it was about $9.50 for a pint and a single scoop. We are consumers who have no problem with paying premium prices for premium product so it was not the price of the product but that the ice cream seemed to have a lot of air in it and was not the quality we remember enjoying at one time. Different strokes for different folks because we realize customers can enjoy different things. read more

Stella's has great ice cream and I'm glad they opened this Eagle shop to go with their original location in Nampa. While the STIL gets a lot of well-deserved notoriety, I enjoy Stella's more. I just think they produce better ice cream. It's creamy and flavorful. read more

Stella's Ice Cream - Huckleberry ice cream. Delicious. - Desserts Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

Okay I came back and the cookie bowl is so warm and the cookie is bomb. The ice cream is bomb too so I'm sorry for my review 4 years ago lol read more

I can't come here anymore. The Eagle location continues to schedule one specific worker who I absolutely cannot stand. She is so incredibly rude to all customers that are NOT teenage boys. read more

I unfortunately had to give them 3 stars as they had music blaring with intense profanity. Inappropriate in general for any establishment, but especially when there are a 3 and 5 year old trying to enjoy an ice cream cone on a Saturday evening. read more

Amazing ice cream -so smooth & creamy! The staff here are always so nice. I just wish they'd offer a t-shirt with the cool artwork seen on the Boise store. - Very cute design! read more

On a very cold and snowy January night, I found myself at Stella's getting ice cream. It was cold. I was cold. It was creamy. I was happy. Full disclosure...I don't love ice cream. Usually I eat about half of what is on my cone, then scrape it off and just eat the cone. That being said, I liked Stella's ice cream. It was really creamy, but not so rich that I felt sick after a few bites. I had the cookie dough. I liked that the cookie dough pieces were still soft. I hate when the cookie dough gets hard and you break your teeth trying to bite through. My sister got the Cookies n Cream, which definitely tasted like the flavor, but was missing big chunks of cookies. The flavor actually intensified after you swallow. For me, the best thing about Stella's was the waffle cones. I really should just order a cone next time. They have all sorts of fun flavors. They had mint, strawberry, red velvet, and espresso. They were all really good, but my favorite was the strawberry. It was really packed with strawberry flavor and was the loveliest shade of pink! My sister got her ice cream on top of a brownie. It was HUGE and tasted pretty good, but was a real bummer to eat with her plastic spoon. The brownie was a bit tough, plus the coldness of the ice cream toughened it even further. The young lady who helped us was efficient and answered our questions, but was a bit on the grumpier side. Not sure she even smiled at us? Lastly, I would strongly suggest that they label their ice cream and add descriptions! We had no idea what contents laid inside some of the options (for example, would you have guessed that Blue Moon was blue raspberry? All I could think of was beer! :) ) read more

See all

My take on the Stella's Ice Cream in Eagle is similar but not quite as good as my take on the Stella's in Nampa. I wanted a brownie sundae, but deciphering the pricing wasn't easy. And the girl that was assisting us didn't really know either. There is a price for scoops and then a price for sundae and then a price for a brownie and a price for toppings (is that 1 or more or ... ?). So, adding it all up we figured $13.50. Yikes - I thought that was excessive for a 3-scoop sundae and asked the girl to double-check my math and she agreed. And I said it out loud "so, a 3-scoop sundae is $13.50??" And she said "YES, wellll, let me ask ... " and then came back with $6.50? Triple scoop plus a brownie and toppings? I don't even know .... but that's what we got. And I can live with that price. :) The brownie part was no bueno though. It tasted bitter, maybe even burnt (it was really dark)? And it was so hard. She even heated it to soften it while I was deciding on flavors. It didn't seem warm, and then when the ice cream went on top, there was no melting and softening of that brownie. It was hard, bitter, and not good. I couldn't even cut pieces off it with those flimsy spoons. I just ate the ice cream, and the brownie went to waste. For the size of the sundae, I felt the toppings (hot fudge and nuts) were a little skimpy. And like their Nampa location there are no names to go along with the flavors. They are up on the wall though, and if you want to try something (which I did), just ask. I tried the lemon something and it was not good at all ... which is why you try before you buy. :) The ice cream is hard, and you taste more ice than cream, it's just not very creamy and it stays hard way too long ... and my strawberry wasn't very strawberryeeee. All that being said, if I were in the area and wanted some ice cream, I'd give them another shot .... but maybe stick to ice cream on a cone. read more

See all

I have a confession...I've been to Stella's three times in the past three weeks. The ice cream is so good that I just can't stay away. Every time I visit I am amazed by how rich and creamy their ice cream is. My absolute favorite flavor is the Salted Caramel - you have to try it! Stella's doesn't have the biggest selection of flavors, but everything I've tried has been great (and I sampled a lot of flavors during my first visit. The employees were very patient with me). There are a couple vegan/gluten free/dairy free options available as well, so there should be something for everyone. The flavor selections are a little different each day, so be sure to check the Stella's Facebook or Instagram story if you're curious about which flavors are available before you go in. And thankfully Stella's is still open for carryout and delivery despite COVID-19 because, clearly, I've been craving their ice cream a lot lately. read more

See all

My sister and I stopped by Stella's for desert and sister time. The inside has a modern minimalist vibe to it that I love. With one wall dedicated to what looks like their Instagram posts and customers, it was a cute addition to the simplicity of the place. Let's talk about their flavored waffle cones. Genius! That night they had mocha, mint chip, strawberry, and red velvet with samples of all. They were delicious and make a great addition to the ice cream. What I loved most was their baked goods. They were huge, delicious and CHEAP! I got a giant brownie to go with my ice cream and the brownie was only $1.50! Winner winner!!! The ice cream was creamy and had lots of favorites to choose from. I ordered cookies and cream which doesn't look like normal cookies and cream, but just as good! Check this place out for dessert with the family. It won't empty your wallet! read more

Stella's Ice Cream - Brownie with cookies and cream ice cream - Desserts Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

We went to Stella's for a birthday treat for my little sisters 10th birthday and it was great! The ice cream was creamy and so yummy! I got a brownie at the bottom of mine and it was amazing! They let us try a bunch of samples and the girls behind the counter were very sweet! I'd recommend looking at the menu before you arrive so you can have an idea of what your want! Otherwise all the options can get overwhelming! We loved Stella's and I can't wait for the next birthday! read more

Stella's Ice Cream - Desserts Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

I had their vegan/gluten free chocolate Oreo ice cream and it was outstanding! Seriously the best vegan ice cream I have ever had and packed with Oreos. Not sure how they get the consistency so smooth and silky, it tasted just like traditional ice cream! Will be back in the future read more

Delicious ice cream!! Tons of options. Love how it's all freshly made! You could really taste the difference! price was reasonable as well! read more

Stella's Ice Cream - Desserts Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

Very over priced. Ice cream is good but not comparative to cost. If you are wanting really good hard packed ice cream I would look elsewhere. D read more

Options, options, options! Stella's is super bright, clean, and has tons of yummy choices. When I went this week there were four non-dairy ice "creams", five waffle cone flavors, a dozen baked goods, and Emilee's candies! I opted for a pumpkin cheesecake and vanilla shake and it was great! I'll be back when I am craving something sweet. read more

See all

Our go to for ice cream! My only wish is they had more than 3 flavors of dairy free ice cream !

Fun little place with a nice selection of ice cream. People were friendly and prices were reasonable.

Stopped by today on a whim and glad I did. Upon entering you are pulled in by treats of cookies and brownies which were being cut as I entered. I decided on the Almond Roca ice cream. Caramel flavor from start to finish. Loved the plethora of almond and toffee bits distributed throughout the creamy base. It was delicious. Thank you to the friendly counter girls who greeted us and let me sample a couple flavors. I also appreciated that when I asked for a cone she mentioned to me that the ice cream was a little soft and recommended putting it in a cup as well. If I had one complaint it is that the flavors of the ice cream are not near the freezer case. Yes you can guess what they may be and they were helpful and told me but it would alleviate questions and maybe make the selection process go a little more quickly if it was busy. Take out the guesswork. Very happy with my visit today! read more

What a cute little ice cream shop!! I took my daughters in as a little treat, and we loved it! We were the only people there, which was nice for keeping our distance. It was right after opening and maybe 40* out, so I'm sure most people were looking for something warm. But, this was great. It smells like heavenly waffle cones when you step in. My girls kept going on about how yummy it smelled!! Ha! The youngest tried blue moon (blue raspberry) in a chocolate & sprinkle dipped cake cone, oldest had chocolate peanut butter in a chocolate & fruity pebble dipped cake cone, I tried a scoop of strawberry champagne in a cup. All the flavors were so good! I normally stay away from the artificial blue raspberry, but had to taste it while helping my 3 year old out. It was actually really pretty good! A little sour, but light. Not syrupy sweet like I expected. The chocolate peanut butter (which is also available as a vegan option) was so creamy and rich!! Then the strawberry champagne... it's the prettiest color! And tasted amazing!! I don't usually do a strawberry but honestly the color is what sold me. Ha! I'm only sad my phone died so I don't have any photos of the deliciousness!! The girls were already planning our next trip back. read more

Love the brownies, cookies and ice cream! Have not been disappointed yet! The staff are friendly when I've visited.

Stopped here on a whim with my fiancé after driving the last of our family off to the airport after a big family wedding in the area. We both love sweets, and Stella's was awesome. The sundaes are to die for! Very sweet and tough to finish, but you'll be able to fight through that because they are so awesome! read more

Such good ice cream and cute company story! They have clearly marked GF options and also some fun cone options. I got rocky road and strawberry and it was very generous scooping. They have a lot of flavors too, including some classic favorites. I recommend for a ice cream night! read more

Oh stellas, another experience where you have not let me down. I wanted to give my friends hot cocoa bombs and they have stacks of containers of them! I got a 4 pack and a cake batter push pop! My fiancé got a cookie with vanilla ice cream! The cookie was crunchy on the edges and soft on the inside. The push pop was easy to push up and I seriously love their cake batter ice cream! This location has a lot less flavors than the downtown Boise one, but that's completely understandable. My favorite ice cream shop by far in the trea read more

Stella's Ice Cream - Cake batter Push-Pop - Desserts Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

This was a mediocre ice cream shop. They didn't have the flavor of the month that they advertised on their website. Most of the flavors are just generic ice cream I could buy in the store for a fraction of the price. Unfortunately, the bathrooms were in very bad shape as well. It was a mess and hasn't been cleaned in awhile. We even notified the staff who replied that they knew but were unwilling to do anything about it. read more

They overfill the ice cream cups and it leaked everywhere. Tastes good because but need to not overfill the cups.

Had a great experience here. Service was super friendly and quick. Good flavor options! We only ordered ice cream but the cookies looked delicious. I loved the flavor "All Nighter". Will definitely visit again! read more